Time for Re-Evaluating the Human Carcinogenicity of Ethylenedithiocarbamate Fungicides? A Systematic Review.

BACKGROUND: In January 2021, the European Union ended the license of Mancozeb, the bestselling ethylenedithiocarbamate (EBDC) fungicide, because of some properties typical of human carcinogens. This decision contrasts the IARC classification of EBDC fungicides (Group 3, not classifiable as to human carcinogenicity). A systematic review of the scientific literature was conducted to explore the current evidence. METHODS: Human and experimental studies of cancer and exposure to EBDC fungicides (Mancozeb, Maneb, Zineb, and others) and ethylene thiourea (ETU), their major metabolite, published in English as of December 2021, were retrieved using PubMed, the list of references of the relevant reports, and grey literature. RESULTS: The epidemiological evidence of EBDC carcinogenicity is inadequate, with two studies each suggesting an association with melanoma and brain cancer and inconsistent findings for thyroid cancer. Experimental animal studies point at thyroid cancer in rats and liver cancer in mice, while multiple organs were affected following the long-term oral administration of Mancozeb. The mechanism of thyroid carcinogenesis in rats has also been shown to occur in humans. Genotoxic effects have been reported. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this systematic review suggest inadequate evidence for the carcinogenicity of EBDC fungicides from human studies and sufficient evidence from animal studies, with positive results on three out of ten key characteristics of carcinogens applying to humans as well. An IARC re-evaluation of the human carcinogenicity of EBDC fungicides is warranted.

Sample Preparation Methods for Metal Containing Pesticides in Food and Environmental Samples.

Metal-containing pesticides are used in many areas for purposes such as harvest efficiency and keeping pests away from the vegetable environment. Metal-containing pesticides are in the form of dithiocarbamate complexes and are named differently according to the type of metal they contain and are used for different purposes. Since the presence of these pesticides even at residue level threatens human and environmental health, their determination at trace level is important. In this review, studies on the determination of metal-containing dithiocarbamate pesticides in different matrices are discussed. This review on the analysis of dithiocarbamate pesticides with different techniques will shed light on the studies to be carried out for the determination of these pesticides one by one in different matrices.

Multicolor visual screening of total dithiocarbamate pesticides in foods based on sulfydryl-mediated growth of gold nanobipyramids.

Dithiocarbamates (DTCs) pesticides were extensively used as fungicides in a variety of crops during their growth, storage and shipment. The DTCs residue in foods will seriously harm human health. In this study, a novel multicolor colorimetric sensor was developed for visual screening of total DTCs (total of ziram, thiram and zineb) based on sulfhydryl-mediated growth of gold nanobipyramids (AuNBPs). We demonstrated that DTCs can absorb on AuNBPs seed's surface via the formation of Au-S bonds and thus impede the 8-hydroxyquinoline (8-HQ)-promoted AuNBPs growth, which generates DTCs concentration-corresponding color changes. The developed sensor has vivid color changes, short analysis time, higher sensitivity and excellent specificity. It can be used to detect as low as 50 nM of total DTCs by bare eye observation and 17-18 nM of total DTCs by UV-visible spectrometry. By using the multicolor sensor, we have successfully screened total DTCs in apple and black tea by bare eye observation, and detected total DTCs in apple and black tea by UV-visible spectrometry with a recovery of 90%-104% and a relative standard deviation (RSD, n = 5) < 5%. The results obtained with our method consisted well with those obtained with high-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS/MS), verifying that our method had good accuracy and reliability. Especially, the visual detection limit of our method is much lower than the maximum residue limit of total DTCs in vegetable and fruits. All above features make our sensor a promising method for rapid on-site screening of total DTCs in vegetable and fruits by only bare eye observation.

ROS-dependent Bax/Bcl2 and caspase 3 pathway-mediated apoptosis induced by zineb in human keratinocyte cells.

There are a large number of agricultural workers who are exposed to pesticides through skin and inhalation. The best approach to identify altered molecular pathways during dermal exposure to pesticides is relevant to risk-associated concern about skin safety. In this study, we investigated the cytotoxic effect of zineb, a fungicide, in human keratinocyte (HaCaT) cells. HaCaT cells were treated with zineb (1-40 µg/mL) for 24 hours. Cellular and molecular mechanisms of cell toxicity were investigated through MTT and neutral red-uptake assays. Zineb reduced viability of HaCaT cells and induced apoptosis in a concentration-dependent manner. Zineb increased levels of Bax and caspase 3 and inhibited the level of Bcl2, which subsequently induced apoptosis via the Bax/Bcl2 and caspase pathway. Therefore, zineb could have induced apoptosis through the mitochondrial pathway in HaCaT cells. Our study suggests that zineb is cytotoxic to HaCaT cells via the induction of apoptosis and oxidative stress in vitro.

Ethylene bisdithiocarbamate pesticides Maneb and Mancozeb cause metal overload in human colon cells.

Previous studies in our laboratory have shown that ethylene bisdithiocarbamate (EBDC) fungicides Maneb and Mancozeb are equipotent gastrointestinal toxicants that produce cell loss and metal accumulation within HT-29 and Caco2 colon cells. Nabam, MnCl2, CuCl2 and ZnCl2 exposure produced no loss of viability up to 200 µM and increases in metal levels were noted but not to the same extent as Maneb and Mancozeb. EBDC exposure caused increases in copper levels (20-200 µM). Maneb and Mancozeb treatment also caused increases in manganese and zinc concentrations (20-200 µM). Nabam plus MnCl2 and Nabam and MnCl2 plus ZnCl2 caused decreases in viability and increases in metal levels comparable to Maneb and Mancozeb. Decreases in the ratio of reduced glutathione to glutathione disulfide were observed with Maneb and Mancozeb (20-200 µM). Maneb and Mancozeb treatment results in intracellular metal accumulation leading to the oxidative stress. The metal moiety and the organic portion of EBDCs contribute to toxicity.

Dithiocarbamate fungicides increase intracellular Zn(2+) levels by increasing influx of Zn(2+) in rat thymic lymphocytes.

Dithiocarbamate fungicides are used as alternative antifouling agents to highly toxic organotin antifouling agents, such as tri-n-butyltin and triphenyltin. There are some concerns regarding their environmental and health risks. It has been shown that tri-n-butyltin increases intracellular Zn(2+) levels of mammalian lymphocytes. Therefore, we examined the effects of dithiocarbamate fungicides (Ziram, Thiram, and Zineb) on rat thymic lymphocytes using a flow-cytometric technique to elucidate how these fungicides affect intracellular Zn(2+) levels. We further determined whether the agents increase intracellular Zn(2+) and/or Ca(2+), because both Zn(2+) and Ca(2+) are intracellular signals in lymphocytes, and excessive increases in their intracellular concentrations can have adverse effects. Dithiocarbamate fungicides increased intracellular Zn(2+) levels, without affecting intracellular Ca(2+) levels. Ziram was the most potent compound, increasing intracellular Zn(2+) levels via Zn(2+) influx. Ziram (1µM) greatly decreased the cellular nonprotein thiol content, and Zn(2+) chelators attenuated the Ziram-induced decrease. Ziram increased the population of annexin V-positive cells in a Zn(2+)-dependent manner. Therefore, we propose that dithiocarbamate fungicides induce Zn(2+) influx, resulting in an excessive elevation of intracellular Zn(2+) levels, leading to the induction of apoptosis. This study gives a basic insight into the mechanisms of dithiocarbamate fungicide-induced adverse events.

Modulation of antioxidant defense system by the dithiocarbamate fungicides Maneb and Zineb in Chinese hamster V79 cells and the role of N-acetyl-L-cysteine.

Oxidative stress is one of the major factors leading to Maneb- and Zineb-induced disorders. The aim of this in vitro study was to examine (i) the potency of Maneb and Zineb to induce changes in antioxidant enzyme activities in Chinese hamster fibroblasts V79 cells and (ii) the role of N-acetyl-L-cysteine (NAC) in the preventing their action. Maneb increased mitochondrial superoxide dismutase (SOD2) activity but failed to affect the activity of cytoplasmic superoxide dismutase (SOD1), whereas Zineb did not change the activity of any of superoxide dismutases. The activity of catalase (CAT) was reduced only by Zineb. The activity of both glutathione peroxidases (non-Se-GPx, Se-GPx) and glutathione reductase (GR) was decreased after exposure to these agents. After NAC pre-treatment Maneb increased the activity of GR, whereas the activity of non-Se-GPx was decreased as compared to that in NAC-treated cells. On the other hand, the activity of both SODs and CAT was decreased. Zineb decreased the activity of both GPxs and SOD2 with a concomitant increase in CAT activity comparing to NAC-treated cells. The results obtained thus suggest that Zineb acts by another mechanism, than Maneb does, and that one of the mechanisms of NAC protection against Maneb or Zineb-induced effects in V79 cells is its impact on enzymatic defense. Activity of GR, SOD2, and GPxs are the most affected enzymes.

Determinación de etilentiourea en acelgas tratadas con Zineb: Efecto del calor húmedo por ebullición / Determination of ethylenethiourea in chard treated with Zineb: Effect of wet heat by boiling

El Zineb es un plaguicida perteneciente a la familia de los etilenbisditiocarbamatos (EBDC) ampliamente utilizado en la provincia de Jujuy (Argentina). La toxicidad de este fungicida está dada por la etilentiourea (ETU) que es el principal producto de su degradación. La ETU tiene efectos mutagénicos, teratogénicos y cancerígenos en animales. La EPA la clasifica como probable cancerígeno humano. El objetivo del trabajo fue determinar la transformación del Zineb a ETU en acelgas cultivadas en Jujuy, por efecto del calor húmedo por tratamiento térmico. El método se basó en la extracción de la ETU con agua y su posterior reextracción con diclorometano a pH alcalino. El extracto se purificó por cromatografía en columna de alúmina y la ETU se cuantificó por HPLC con un detector UV-Visible a 232 nm. Para cumplir con el objetivo planteado se realizó un cultivo experimental de acelgas a las que se aplicó el fungicida Zineb, el cual luego se cuantificó a diferentes periodos de tiempo. La ETU se cuantificó con y sin aplicación de calor húmedo. La concentración de ETU en las acelgas sometidas a tratamiento térmico fue de 8,07 mg/kg y transcurridos 30 días disminuyó a 0,05 mg/kg, lo que representa una disminución de más del 99 % respecto a la concentración inicial. Simultáneamente, se determinó la concentración de Zineb en las acelgas y se obtuvo, inicialmente, 44 mg/kg y luego de 36 días la concentración de Zineb disminuyó a 3,83 mg/kg, lo que representa una disminución del 91 % respecto a la concentración del plaguicida al inicio. La detección de ETU en acelgas sometidas a tratamientos térmicos confirma la transformación del fungicida Zineb a un producto de degradación clasificado según el IARC en el grupo 3. Esto pone en discusión la reglamentación Argentina vigente, por cuanto al finalizar los tiempos de carencia no se evalúan la presencia de metabolitos o productos de degradación potencialmente tóxicos.

Zineb is a pesticide belonging to the family of ethylenebisdithiocarbamates (EBDC) widely used in the province of Jujuy, Argentina. The toxicity of this fungicide is given by the ethylenethiourea (ETU) which is the main product of degradation. The ETU has mutagenic, teratogenic and carcinogenic effects in animals. The EPA classifies it as a probable human carcinogen. The aim of the study was to determine the transformation of Zineb to ETU in cultivated chards in Jujuy, by treatment with humid heat. The method is based on extraction of ETU with water and subsequent extraction of the aqueous phase with dichloromethane. The extract was cleaned by alumina column chromatography and the ETU was quantified by HPLC with a UV-Visible detector at 232 nm. An experimental cultivation of chards was carried out and the Zineb fungicide was applied and then quantified at different time periods. The ETU was quantified with and without application of moist heat. The concentration of ETU in heat treated chards was 8.07 mg/kg and after 30 days decreased to 0.05 mg/kg, representing a decrease of more than 99 % over the initial concentration. Simultaneously, Zineb concentration in chard was initially determined as 44 mg/kg and, 36 days later, the Zineb concentration decreased to 3.83 mg/kg, representing a 91% decrease with respect to the concentration of the pesticide at the beginning. Detection of ETU in chards subjected to heat treatment confirms the transformation of the fungicide Zineb to a degradation product classified by the IARC as group 3. This puts into discussion the current Argentine regulations since, at the end of the deficiency times the presence of potentially toxic metabolites or degradation products is not evaluated.

The effect ofin vitro andin vivo ethylenbis dithiocarbamate fungicides on NMDA receptors in rat brain membranes.

To determine whether the ethlenbisdithiocarbamate fungicides, zineb, manzeb and maneb affect the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor in rat brain membranes, we performed a binding assay using [(3)H]MK-801, a noncompetitive NMDA receptor antagonist. Displacement studies were conducted using well washed membranes to exclude the effect of endogenous acidic amino acids on the binding of [(3)H]MK-801. In both the presence or absence of added glutamate and glycine in the assay buffer, the dose-response curve indicated that zineb enhanced the binding in a concentration range of 100-500 µM. However, the displacement curves indicated that manzeb and maneb inhibited the binding in a concentration range of 10-500 µM. The addition of 50 µM glutamate and glycine to the assay medium increased binding by 5-20% above the control in a concentration range of 0.1-100 µM.No rats injected with zineb, manzeb, maneb (100 mg/kg, ip) showed any characteristic toxic signs or any significant weight changes within 24 hrs. Estimation of [(3)H]MK-801 binding to unwashed membranes from intoxicated rat brains revealed no marked change in Bmax or Kd values for 24 hrs following fungicide administration.