The influence of histocompatibility on graft rejection and graft survival within a single center population of heart transplant recipients.

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: We report a consecutive single center series of 261 patients who received first orthotopic heart transplants from 1986 to 1997. The 1- and 5-year graft survivals were 78 and 68%. The influence of histocompatibility was investigated by comparing graft survival and numbers of treated rejection episodes with HLA-A, -B, and -DR mismatches over different time periods. FINDINGS: Recipients with six mismatches for HLA-A+-B+-DR combined (13.4%) had reduced survival at 7 years (47%) when compared with other recipients (64%). In the first year of transplant, recipients with four HLA-A+-B mismatches had significantly reduced actuarial graft survival (P=0.03) with the greatest influence apparent at 6 months [0-3 mismatches (n=193) 85% versus 4 mismatches (n=68) 69%; P=0.005, OR=2.1]. For 182 recipients with functioning hearts at 1 year, the number of rejection episodes treated within this time was strongly influenced by HLA-DR mismatch [0 DR mismatch (n=15) mean 1.2 rejection episodes versus 1 DR mismatch (n=76) mean 2.7 rejection episodes versus 2 DR mismatches (n=91) mean 3.8 rejection episodes P=0.0002]. Of these 182 transplants, recipients who had more than four treated rejection episodes during the first year had a significantly reduced 7- year survival [<5 rejection episodes (n=133) 85% versus more than four rejection episodes (n=49) 66%; P=0.02, OR=3.4], as did those with two HLA-DR mismatches [0+1 mismatch (n=91) 87% versus 2 mismatches (n=91) 70%; P<0.05, OR=2.4]. INTERPRETATION: We show that graft loss in the first 6 months of transplant is significantly influenced by four HLA-A+-B mismatches. HLA-DR mismatch significantly increases the number of rejection episodes within the first year, without influencing graft survival. After 12 months both >4 rejection episodes in the first year and two HLA-DR mismatches are markers for late graft loss. We postulate that immunological graft loss in the first 6 months is dominated by the direct allorecognition pathway driven by HLA-DR mismatch. This mechanism is later lost or suppressed. Our data highlight HLA-DR mismatch as a marker for late graft loss and we show an advantage to avoiding transplanting hearts with six HLA-A+-B+-DR mismatches and to minimizing HLA-DR mismatches whenever possible.