RESUMEN
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to assess the impact of treatment with dexamethasone, remdesivir or both on neurological complications in acute coronavirus diease 2019 (COVID-19). METHODS: We used observational data from the International Severe Acute and emerging Respiratory Infection Consortium World Health Organization (WHO) Clinical Characterization Protocol, United Kingdom. Hospital inpatients aged ≥18 years with laboratory-confirmed severe acute respiratory syndrome-coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection admitted between January 31, 2020, and June 29, 2021, were included. Treatment allocation was non-blinded and performed by reporting clinicians. A propensity scoring methodology was used to minimize confounding. Treatment with remdesivir, dexamethasone, or both was assessed against the standard of care. The primary outcome was a neurological complication occurring at the point of death, discharge, or resolution of the COVID-19 clinical episode. RESULTS: Out of 89,297 hospital inpatients, 64,088 had severe COVID-19 and 25,209 had non-hypoxic COVID-19. Neurological complications developed in 4.8% and 4.5%, respectively. In both groups, neurological complications were associated with increased mortality, intensive care unit (ICU) admission, worse self-care on discharge, and time to recovery. In patients with severe COVID-19, treatment with dexamethasone (n = 21,129), remdesivir (n = 1,428), and both combined (n = 10,846) were associated with a lower frequency of neurological complications: OR = 0.76 (95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.69-0.83), OR = 0.69 (95% CI = 0.51-0.90), and OR = 0.54 (95% CI = 0.47-0.61), respectively. In patients with non-hypoxic COVID-19, dexamethasone (n = 2,580) was associated with less neurological complications (OR = 0.78, 95% CI = 0.62-0.97), whereas the dexamethasone/remdesivir combination (n = 460) showed a similar trend (OR = 0.63, 95% CI = 0.31-1.15). INTERPRETATION: Treatment with dexamethasone, remdesivir, or both in patients hospitalized with COVID-19 was associated with a lower frequency of neurological complications in an additive manner, such that the greatest benefit was observed in patients who received both drugs together. ANN NEUROL 2023;93:88-102.
Asunto(s)
Alanina , Antivirales , Tratamiento Farmacológico de COVID-19 , COVID-19 , Dexametasona , Adolescente , Adulto , Humanos , Alanina/uso terapéutico , Antivirales/efectos adversos , COVID-19/complicaciones , Dexametasona/uso terapéutico , SARS-CoV-2RESUMEN
Rare events are events which occur with low frequencies. These often arise in clinical trials or cohort studies where the data are arranged in binary contingency tables. In this article, we investigate the estimation of effect heterogeneity for the risk-ratio parameter in meta-analysis of rare events studies through two likelihood-based nonparametric mixture approaches: an arm-based and a contrast-based model. Maximum likelihood estimation is achieved using the EM algorithm. Special attention is given to the choice of initial values. Inspired by the classification likelihood, a strategy is implemented which repeatably uses random allocation of the studies to the mixture components as choice of initial values. The likelihoods under the contrast-based and arm-based approaches are compared and differences are highlighted. We use simulations to assess the performance of these two methods. Under the design of sampling studies with nested treatment groups, the results show that the nonparametric mixture model based on the contrast-based approach is more appropriate in terms of model selection criteria such as AIC and BIC. Under the arm-based design the results from the arm-based model performs well although in some cases it is also outperformed by the contrast-based model. Comparisons of the estimators are provided in terms of bias and mean squared error. Also included in the comparison is the mixed Poisson regression model as well as the classical DerSimonian-Laird model (using the Mantel-Haenszel estimator for the common effect). Using simulation, estimating effect heterogeneity in the case of the contrast-based method appears to behave better than the compared methods although differences become negligible for large within-study sample sizes. We illustrate the methodologies using several meta-analytic data sets in medicine.
Asunto(s)
Metaanálisis como Asunto , Humanos , Simulación por Computador , Funciones de Verosimilitud , Oportunidad Relativa , Tamaño de la MuestraRESUMEN
In screening large populations a diagnostic test is frequently used repeatedly. An example is screening for bowel cancer using the fecal occult blood test (FOBT) on several occasions such as at 3 or 6 days. The question that is addressed here is how often should we repeat a diagnostic test when screening for a specific medical condition. Sensitivity is often used as a performance measure of a diagnostic test and is considered here for the individual application of the diagnostic test as well as for the overall screening procedure. The latter can involve an increasingly large number of repeated applications, but how many are sufficient? We demonstrate the issues involved in answering this question using real data on bowel cancer at St Vincents Hospital in Sydney. As data are only available for those testing positive at least once, an appropriate modeling technique is developed on the basis of the zero-truncated binomial distribution which allows for population heterogeneity. The latter is modeled using discrete nonparametric maximum likelihood. If we wish to achieve an overall sensitivity of 90%, the FOBT should be repeated for 2 weeks instead of the 1 week that was used at the time of the survey. A simulation study also shows consistency in the sense that bias and standard deviation for the estimated sensitivity decrease with an increasing number of repeated occasions as well as with increasing sample size.
Asunto(s)
Neoplasias Colorrectales , Humanos , Neoplasias Colorrectales/diagnóstico , Sangre Oculta , Tamaño de la Muestra , Pruebas Diagnósticas de Rutina , Tamizaje Masivo/métodosRESUMEN
While the number of detected Monkeypox infections are widely available, an understanding of the extent of undetected cases is urgently needed for an effective tackling of its spread. The aim of this study is to estimate the true number of Monkeypox (detected and undetected) infections in most affected countries. The question being asked is: How many cases have actually occurred? We propose a lower bound estimator for the true number of Monkeypox cases. The estimator is data-driven and can be easily computed from the cumulative distributions of weekly cases. We focused on the ratio of the total estimated cases to the observed cases on July 31, 2022: The proportion of undetected cases was relevant in all countries, with countries whose estimated true number of infections could be more than three times the observed one. We provided a practical contribution to the understanding of the current Monkeypox wave and reliable estimates on how many undetected cases are going around in several countries, where the epidemic spreads differently.
Asunto(s)
Epidemias , Mpox , Humanos , Mpox/diagnóstico , Mpox/epidemiología , Brotes de Enfermedades , Monkeypox virusRESUMEN
Contact-tracing is one of the most effective tools in infectious disease outbreak control. A capture-recapture approach based upon ratio regression is suggested to estimate the completeness of case detection. Ratio regression has been recently developed as flexible tool for count data modeling and has proved to be successful in the capture-recapture setting. The methodology is applied here to Covid-19 contact tracing data from Thailand. A simple weighted straight line approach is used which includes the Poisson and geometric distribution as special cases. For the case study data of contact tracing for Thailand, a completeness of 83% could be found with a 95% confidence interval of 74%-93%.
Asunto(s)
COVID-19 , Humanos , COVID-19/epidemiología , Trazado de Contacto , Brotes de Enfermedades , Distribuciones EstadísticasRESUMEN
One-inflation in zero-truncated count data has recently found considerable attention. There are currently two views in the literature. In the first approach, the untruncated model is considered as one-inflated whereas in the second approach the truncated model is viewed as one-inflated. Here, we show that both models have identical model spaces as well as identical maximum likelihoods. Consequences of population size estimation are illuminated, and the findings are illustrated at hand of two case studies.
Asunto(s)
Modelos Estadísticos , Probabilidad , Densidad de Población , Distribución de PoissonRESUMEN
In meta-analysis, the conventional two-stage approach computes an effect estimate for each study in the first stage and proceeds with the analysis of effect estimates in the second stage. For counts of events as outcome, the risk ratio is often the effect measure of choice. However, if the meta-analysis includes many studies with no events the conventional method breaks down. As an alternative one-stage approach, a Poisson regression model and a conditional binomial model can be considered where no event studies do not cause problems. The conditional binomial model excludes double-zero studies, whereas this is seemingly not the case for the Poisson regression approach. However, we show here that both models lead to the same likelihood inference and double-zero studies (in contrast to single-zero studies) do not contribute in either case to the likelihood.
Asunto(s)
Modelos Estadísticos , Proyectos de Investigación , Humanos , Oportunidad Relativa , Distribución de Poisson , ProbabilidadRESUMEN
Despite its critical role in containing outbreaks, the efficacy of contact tracing, measured as the sensitivity of case detection, remains an elusive metric. We estimated the sensitivity of contact tracing by applying unilist capture-recapture methods on data from the 2018-2020 outbreak of Ebola virus disease in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. To compute sensitivity, we applied different distributional assumptions to the zero-truncated count data to estimate the number of unobserved case-patients with any contacts and infected contacts. Geometric distributions were the best-fitting models. Our results indicate that contact tracing efforts identified almost all (n = 792, 99%) of case-patients with any contacts but only half (n = 207, 48%) of case-patients with infected contacts, suggesting that contact tracing efforts performed well at identifying contacts during the listing stage but performed poorly during the contact follow-up stage. We discuss extensions to our work and potential applications for the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.
Asunto(s)
Ebolavirus , Fiebre Hemorrágica Ebola , Trazado de Contacto , República Democrática del Congo/epidemiología , Brotes de Enfermedades , Fiebre Hemorrágica Ebola/epidemiología , HumanosRESUMEN
OBJECTIVE: Previous studies suggested that recombinant human IGF-1 (rhIGF-1) administration affects carbohydrate and lipid metabolism in healthy people and in people with diabetes. This study aimed to determine the effects of rhIGF-1/rhIGF binding protein-3 (rhIGFBP-3) administration on glucose homeostasis and lipid metabolism in healthy recreational athletes. DESIGN AND SETTING: Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled rhIGF-1/rhIGFBP-3 administration study at Southampton General Hospital, UK. PARTICIPANTS: 56 recreational athletes (30 men, 26 women). METHODS: Participants were randomly assigned to receive placebo, low-dose rhIGF-1/rhIGFBP-3 (30 mg/day) or high-dose rhIGF-1/rhIGFBP-3 (60 mg/day) for 28 days. The following variables were measured before and immediately after the treatment period: fasting lipids, glucose, insulin, C-peptide and glycated haemoglobin. The homeostatic model assessment (HOMA-IR) was used to estimate insulin sensitivity and indirect calorimetry to assess substrate oxidation rates. The general linear model approach was used to compare treatment group changes with the placebo group. RESULTS: Compared with the placebo group, there was a significant reduction in fasting triglycerides in participants treated with high-dose rhIGF-1/rhIGFBP-3 (p = .030), but not in the low-dose group (p = .390). In women, but not in men, there were significant increases in total cholesterol (p = .003), HDL cholesterol (p = .001) and LDL cholesterol (p = .008). These lipid changes were associated with reduced fasting insulin (p = .010), C-peptide (p = .001) and HOMA-IR (p = .018) in women and reduced C-peptide (p = .046) in men. CONCLUSIONS: rhIGF-1/rhIGFBP-3 administration for 28 days reduced insulin concentration, improved insulin sensitivity and had significant effects on lipid profile including decreased fasting triglycerides.
Asunto(s)
Atletas , Proteínas Portadoras , Proteína 3 de Unión a Factor de Crecimiento Similar a la Insulina , Factor I del Crecimiento Similar a la Insulina , Metabolismo de los Hidratos de Carbono , Método Doble Ciego , Femenino , Humanos , Insulina , Proteína 3 de Unión a Factor de Crecimiento Similar a la Insulina/farmacología , Factor I del Crecimiento Similar a la Insulina/farmacología , Metabolismo de los Lípidos , Masculino , Proteínas Recombinantes/farmacologíaRESUMEN
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Increasingly populations are both overweight/obese and consume alcohol. The risk of liver disease from the combination of these factors is unclear. We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis to address this important gap in evidence. Protocol registered with PROSPERO(CRD42016046508). METHODS: We performed electronic searches of Ovid Medline, Embase Classic + Embase, until 17th June 2020 for cohort studies of adults without pre-existing liver disease. Primary outcome was morbidity/mortality from chronic liver disease. Exposures were alcohol consumption categorised as within or above UK recommended limits (14 units/112 g per week) and BMI categorised as normal, overweight or obese. Non-drinkers were excluded. A Poisson regression log-linear model was used to test for statistical interaction between alcohol and BMI and to conduct a one-stage meta-analysis. RESULTS: Searches identified 3129 studies-16 were eligible. Of these, nine cohorts (1,121,514 participants) had data available and were included in the analysis. The Poisson model showed no significant statistical interaction between alcohol consumption and BMI on the risk of chronic liver disease. Compared to normal weight participants drinking alcohol within UK recommended limits, relative risk of chronic liver disease in overweight participants drinking above limits was 3.32 (95% CI 2.88 to 3.83) and relative risk in obese participants drinking above limits was 5.39 (95% CI 4.62 to 6.29). CONCLUSIONS: This meta-analysis demonstrated a significantly increased risk of chronic liver disease in participants who were both overweight/obese and consumed alcohol above UK recommended limits. This evidence should inform advice given to patients and risk stratification by healthcare professionals.
Asunto(s)
Hepatopatías , Sobrepeso , Adulto , Consumo de Bebidas Alcohólicas/efectos adversos , Consumo de Bebidas Alcohólicas/epidemiología , Índice de Masa Corporal , Estudios de Cohortes , Humanos , Hepatopatías/epidemiología , Obesidad/complicaciones , Obesidad/epidemiología , Sobrepeso/epidemiologíaRESUMEN
Capture-recapture studies have attracted a lot of attention over the past few decades, especially in applied disciplines where a direct estimate for the size of a population of interest is not available. Epidemiology, ecology, public health, and biodiversity are just a few examples. The estimation of the number of unseen units has been a challenge for theoretical statisticians, and considerable progress has been made in providing lower bound estimators for the population size. In fact, it is well known that consistent estimators for this cannot be provided in the very general case. Considering a case where capture-recapture studies are summarized by a frequency of frequencies distribution, we derive a simple upper bound of the population size based on the cumulative distribution function. We introduce two estimators of this bound, without any specific parametric assumption on the distribution of the observed frequency counts. The behavior of the proposed estimators is investigated using several benchmark datasets and a large-scale simulation experiment based on the scheme discussed by Pledger.
Asunto(s)
Ecología , Modelos Estadísticos , Simulación por Computador , Densidad de PoblaciónRESUMEN
This paper is motivated by the GH-2000 biomarker test, though the discussion is applicable to other diagnostic tests. The GH-2000 biomarker test has been developed as a powerful technique to detect growth hormone misuse by athletes, based on the GH-2000 score. Decision limits on the GH-2000 score have been developed and incorporated into the guidelines of the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA). These decision limits are constructed, however, under the assumption that the GH-2000 score follows a normal distribution. As it is difficult to affirm the normality of a distribution based on a finite sample, nonparametric decision limits, readily available in the statistical literature, are viable alternatives. In this paper, we compare the normal distribution-based and nonparametric decision limits. We show that the decision limit based on the normal distribution may deviate significantly from the nominal confidence level 1-α or nominal FPR γ when the distribution of the GH-2000 score departs only slightly from the normal distribution. While a nonparametric decision limit does not assume any specific distribution of the GH-2000 score and always guarantees the nominal confidence level and FPR, it requires a much larger sample size than the normal distribution-based decision limit. Due to the stringent FPR of the GH-2000 biomarker test used by WADA, the sample sizes currently available are much too small, and it will take many years of testing to have the minimum sample size required, in order to use the nonparametric decision limits. Large sample theory about the normal distribution-based and nonparametric decision limits is also developed in this paper to help understanding their behaviours when the sample size is large.
Asunto(s)
Doping en los Deportes , Hormona del Crecimiento , Humanos , Factor I del Crecimiento Similar a la Insulina , Distribución Normal , Detección de Abuso de SustanciasRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Adolescent pregnancy is an important health and social issue that affects both individual and social well-being. However, deriving a national estimate is challenging in a country with multiple incomplete national databases especially the abortion statistics. The objective of this study was to estimate the adolescent pregnancy rates in Thailand using capture-recapture method. METHODS: An application of capture-recapture method was conducted using two cross-sectional databases (i.e., the national birth registration and the Ministry of Public Health standard health databases) and one hospital-based data source from medical record reviews. A 3-sources capture-recapture with log-linear model was applied to estimate adolescent pregnancy rates. RESULTS: A total number of 741,084, 290,922 and 25,478 records were respectively identified from the birth registrations, standard health databases and hospital-based survey data during 2008 to 2013. The estimated adolescent pregnancy rates /1000 adolescent women (95% confidence intervals (CI)) ranged from 56.3 (49.4, 66.9) to 70.3 (60.3, 76.6). The estimated rates were about 12-31% higher than adolescent birth rates reported by the Thailand Public Health Statistics. CONCLUSIONS: With the capture-recapture method, more accurate adolescent pregnancy rates were estimated. This method should be able to apply to any setting with similar context.
Asunto(s)
Embarazo en Adolescencia/estadística & datos numéricos , Adolescente , Estudios Transversales , Bases de Datos Factuales , Femenino , Humanos , Embarazo , Índice de Embarazo , Proyectos de Investigación , Tailandia/epidemiología , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
In the last decades, considerable attention has been paid to the collection of antimicrobial resistance data, with the aim of monitoring non-wild-type isolates. This monitoring is performed based on minimum inhibition concentration (MIC) values, which are collected through dilution experiments. We present a semi-parametric mixture model to estimate the entire MIC density on the continuous scale. The parametric first component is extended with a non-parametric second component and a new back-fitting algorithm, based on the Vertex Exchange Method, is proposed. Our data example shows how to estimate the MIC density for Escherichia coli tested for ampicillin and how to use this estimate for model-based classification. A simulation study was performed, showing the promising behavior of the new method, both in terms of density estimation as well as classification.
Asunto(s)
Ampicilina/farmacología , Antibacterianos/farmacología , Farmacorresistencia Bacteriana , Escherichia coli/efectos de los fármacos , Pruebas de Sensibilidad Microbiana/métodos , Escherichia coli/aislamiento & purificaciónRESUMEN
Statistical inference for analyzing the results from several independent studies on the same quantity of interest has been investigated frequently in recent decades. Typically, any meta-analytic inference requires that the quantity of interest is available from each study together with an estimate of its variability. The current work is motivated by a meta-analysis on comparing two treatments (thoracoscopic and open) of congenital lung malformations in young children. Quantities of interest include continuous end-points such as length of operation or number of chest tube days. As studies only report mean values (and no standard errors or confidence intervals), the question arises how meta-analytic inference can be developed. We suggest two methods to estimate study-specific variances in such a meta-analysis, where only sample means and sample sizes are available in the treatment arms. A general likelihood ratio test is derived for testing equality of variances in two groups. By means of simulation studies, the bias and estimated standard error of the overall mean difference from both methodologies are evaluated and compared with two existing approaches: complete study analysis only and partial variance information. The performance of the test is evaluated in terms of type I error. Additionally, we illustrate these methods in the meta-analysis on comparing thoracoscopic and open surgery for congenital lung malformations and in a meta-analysis on the change in renal function after kidney donation. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Asunto(s)
Interpretación Estadística de Datos , Metaanálisis como Asunto , Tubos Torácicos/estadística & datos numéricos , Preescolar , Humanos , Pulmón/anomalías , Pulmón/cirugía , Tempo Operativo , Estadística como Asunto , Factores de TiempoRESUMEN
Capture-recapture methods are used to estimate the size of a population of interest which is only partially observed. In such studies, each member of the population carries a count of the number of times it has been identified during the observational period. In real-life applications, only positive counts are recorded, and we get a truncated at zero-observed distribution. We need to use the truncated count distribution to estimate the number of unobserved units. We consider ratios of neighboring count probabilities, estimated by ratios of observed frequencies, regardless of whether we have a zero-truncated or an untruncated distribution. Rocchetti et al. (2011) have shown that, for densities in the Katz family, these ratios can be modeled by a regression approach, and Rocchetti et al. (2014) have specialized the approach to the beta-binomial distribution. Once the regression model has been estimated, the unobserved frequency of zero counts can be simply derived. The guiding principle is that it is often easier to find an appropriate regression model than a proper model for the count distribution. However, a full analysis of the connection between the regression model and the associated count distribution has been missing. In this manuscript, we fill the gap and show that the regression model approach leads, under general conditions, to a valid count distribution; we also consider a wider class of regression models, based on fractional polynomials. The proposed approach is illustrated by analyzing various empirical applications, and by means of a simulation study.
Asunto(s)
Modelos Biológicos , Modelos Estadísticos , Densidad de Población , Análisis de Regresión , Algoritmos , Simulación por Computador , Interpretación Estadística de Datos , Personas con Mala Vivienda/estadística & datos numéricos , Humanos , Neoplasias Intestinales/diagnóstico , Distribuciones EstadísticasRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: The GH-2000 score has been developed as a powerful and unique technique for the detection of growth hormone misuse by sportsmen and women. The score depends upon the measurement of two growth hormone (GH) sensitive markers, insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) and the amino-terminal pro-peptide of type III collagen (P-III-NP). With the collection and establishment of an increasingly large database it has become apparent that the score shows a positive age effect in the male athlete population, which could potentially place older male athletes at a disadvantage. METHODS: We have used results from residual analysis of the general linear model to show that the residual of the GH-2000 score when regressed on the mean-age centred age is an appropriate way to proceed to correct this bias. As six GH-2000 scores are possible depending on the assays used for determining IGF-I and P-III-NP, methodology had to be explored for including six different age effects into a unique residual. Meta-analytic techniques have been utilized to find a summary age effect. RESULTS: The age-adjusted GH-2000 score, a form of residual, has similar mean and variance as the original GH-2000 score and, hence, the developed decision limits show negligible change when compared to the decision limits based on the original score. We also show that any further scale-transformation will not change the adjusted score. Hence the suggested adjustment is optimal for the given data. The summary age effect is homogeneous across the six scores, and so the generic adjustment of the GH-2000 score formula is justified. CONCLUSIONS: A final revised GH-2000 score formula is provided which is independent of the age of the athlete under consideration.
Asunto(s)
Atletas , Biometría/métodos , Doping en los Deportes/estadística & datos numéricos , Hormona de Crecimiento Humana/administración & dosificación , Deportes , Detección de Abuso de Sustancias/métodos , Adulto , Factores de Edad , Algoritmos , Anabolizantes/administración & dosificación , Doping en los Deportes/prevención & control , Femenino , Humanos , Factor I del Crecimiento Similar a la Insulina/análisis , Modelos Lineales , Masculino , Modelos Teóricos , Fragmentos de Péptidos/análisis , Procolágeno/análisis , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Recent studies of the quality of in-hospital care have used the Quality of Interaction Schedule (QuIS) to rate interactions observed between staff and inpatients in a variety of ward conditions. The QuIS was developed and evaluated in nursing and residential care. We set out to develop methodology for summarising information from inter-rater reliability studies of the QuIS in the acute hospital setting. METHODS: Staff-inpatient interactions were rated by trained staff observing care delivered during two-hour observation periods. Anticipating the possibility of the quality of care varying depending on ward conditions, we selected wards and times of day to reflect the variety of daytime care delivered to patients. We estimated inter-rater reliability using weighted kappa, κ w , combined over observation periods to produce an overall, summary estimate, [Formula: see text]. Weighting schemes putting different emphasis on the severity of misclassification between QuIS categories were compared, as were different methods of combining observation period specific estimates. RESULTS: Estimated [Formula: see text] did not vary greatly depending on the weighting scheme employed, but we found simple averaging of estimates across observation periods to produce a higher value of inter-rater reliability due to over-weighting observation periods with fewest interactions. CONCLUSIONS: We recommend that researchers evaluating the inter-rater reliability of the QuIS by observing staff-inpatient interactions during observation periods representing the variety of ward conditions in which care takes place, should summarise inter-rater reliability by κ w , weighted according to our scheme A4. Observation period specific estimates should be combined into an overall, single summary statistic [Formula: see text], using a random effects approach, with [Formula: see text], to be interpreted as the mean of the distribution of κ w across the variety of ward conditions. We draw attention to issues in the analysis and interpretation of inter-rater reliability studies incorporating distinct phases of data collection that may generalise more widely.
Asunto(s)
Relaciones Profesional-Paciente , Garantía de la Calidad de Atención de Salud/métodos , Algoritmos , Interpretación Estadística de Datos , Humanos , Pacientes Internos , Cuerpo Médico , Reproducibilidad de los ResultadosRESUMEN
The purpose of this note is to contribute some general points on a recent paper by Ledberg and Wennberg (BMC Med Res Meth 14:58, 2014) which need to be rectified. They advocate the capture-removal estimator. First, we will discuss drawbacks of this estimator in comparison to the Lincoln-Petersen estimator. Second, we show that their evaluation of the Chao estimator is flawed. We conclude that some statements in Ledberg and Wennberg with respect to Chao's estimator and removal estimation need to be taken with great caution.