Impact of implementing electronic clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis, control and treatment of cardiovascular risk factors: A pre-post controlled study.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the impact of computerized clinical practice guidelines on the management, diagnosis, treatment, control, and follow-up of the main cardiovascular risk factors: hypertension, hypercholesterolaemia, and type 2 diabetes mellitus. DESIGN: Pre-post controlled study. SETTING: Catalonia, autonomous community located in north-eastern Spain. PARTICIPANTS: Individuals aged 35-74 years assigned to general practitioners of the Catalan Health Institute. INTERVENTION: The intervention group consisted of individuals whose general practitioners had accessed the computerized clinical practice guidelines at least twice a day, while the control group consisted of individuals whose general practitioner had never accessed the computerized clinical practice guidelines platform. MAIN OUTCOMES: The Chi-squared test was used to detect significant differences in the follow-up, control, and treatment variables for all three disorders (hypertension, hypercholesterolaemia, and type 2 diabetes mellitus) between individuals assigned to users and non-users of the computerized clinical practice guidelines, respectively. RESULTS: A total of 189,067 patients were included in this study, with a mean age of 56 years (standard deviation 12), and 55.5% of whom were women. Significant differences were observed in hypertension management, treatment and control; type 2 diabetes mellitus management, treatment and diagnoses, and the management and control of hypercholesterolaemia in both sexes. CONCLUSIONS: Computerized clinical practice guidelines are an effective tool for the control and follow-up of patients diagnosed with hypertension, type 2 diabetes mellitus, and hypercholesterolaemia. The usefulness of computerized clinical practice guidelines to diagnose and adequately treat individuals with these disorders remains unclear.

Impact of the implementation of electronic guidelines for cardiovascular prevention in primary care: study protocol.

BACKGROUND: The electronic medical records software of the Catalan Institute of Health has recently incorporated an electronic version of clinical practice guidelines (e-CPGs). This study aims to assess the impact of the implementation of e-CPGs on the diagnosis, treatment, control and management of hypercholesterolaemia, diabetes mellitus type 2 and hypertension. METHODS: Eligible study participants are those aged 35-74 years assigned to family practitioners (FPs) of the Catalan Institute of Health. Routinely collected data from electronic primary care registries covering 80% of the Catalan population will be analysed using two approaches: (1) a cross-sectional study to describe the characteristics of the sample before e-CPG implementation; (2) a controlled before-and-after study with 1-year follow-up to ascertain the effect of e-CPG implementation. Patients of FPs who regularly use the e-CPGs will constitute the intervention group; the control group will comprise patients assigned to FPs not regularly using the e-CPG. The outcomes are: (1) suspected and confirmed diagnoses, (2) control of clinical variables, (3) requests for tests and (4) proportions of patients with adequate drug prescriptions. RESULTS: This protocol should represent a reproducible process to assess the impact of the implementation of e-CPGs. We anticipate reporting results in late 2013. CONCLUSION: This project will assess the effectiveness of e-CPGs to improve clinical decisions and healthcare procedures in the three disorders analysed. The results will shed light on the use of evidence-based medicine to improve clinical practice of FPs.

[Efficacy of an intensive prevention programme of coronary heart disease: 5 year follow-up outcomes]. / Eficacia de un programa intensivo de prevención secundaria de cardiopatía isquémica tras 5 años de intervención.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Most evidence on the efficacy of intensive preventive programs of secondary prevention of coronary diseases comes from Anglo-Saxon countries and effectiveness remains controversial. We have scarce information about the efficacy of these types of programs in Spain. In the present analysis we show the results of the ICAR (Intervención en la Comunidad de Alto Riesgo coronario) study, aimed to analyze the efficacy of an intensive preventive program primary care based in reducing the cardiovascular recurrences and mortality in patients with coronary heart disease. PATIENTS AND METHOD: We designed a randomized clinical trial, multicenter and community based, which included 23 health care areas in Catalonia, Spain. We followed for 5 years 2 cohorts of patients with coronary heart disease, aged 30-80 years. The intervention group was quarterly examined by their general practitioner, who adjusted treatments to control their cardiovascular risk factors thoroughly and reinforced life style behaviours. In order to do that, patient's weight and blood pressure were determined in each visit and laboratory test carried out twice a year. Patients in the control group received the usual care. In order to analyze the effect of the intervention cardiovascular recurrences and mortality were registered. RESULTS: We included 983 patients. Mean (standard deviation) age was 64 (10) and 74.5% were men. During the follow-up 235 patients suffered some non-fatal cardiovascular recurrence (109 vs 126 in the control and intervention group, respectively; p = 0.84), and 45 died from cardiovascular recurrences (23 vs 22, respectively; p = 0.57). Adjusted hazard ratio of cardiovascular event and total mortality, for the intervention group were 1.01 (95% confidence interval, 0.74-1.39), and 0.92 (95% confidence interval, 0.54-1.56), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The implementation of an intensive secondary prevention program based on periodical reminds to patients with stable coronary heart disease to attend their general practitioners did not reduce either the cardiovascular recurrences or mortality at 5 years as compared with usual care.

Impact of implementing electronic clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis, control and treatment of cardiovascular risk factors: A pre-post controlled study / Impacto de la implementación de las guías de práctica clínica electrónicas en el diagnóstico, control y tratamiento de los factores de riesgo cardiovascular: un estudio pre-post controlado

Objective: To evaluate the impact of computerized clinical practice guidelines on the management, diagnosis, treatment, control, and follow-up of the main cardiovascular risk factors: hypertension, hypercholesterolaemia, and type 2 diabetes mellitus. Design: Pre-post controlled study. Setting: Catalonia, autonomous community located in north-eastern Spain. Participants: Individuals aged 35-74 years assigned to general practitioners of the Catalan Health Institute. Intervention: The intervention group consisted of individuals whose general practitioners had accessed the computerized clinical practice guidelines at least twice a day, while the control group consisted of individuals whose general practitioner had never accessed the computerized clinical practice guidelines platform Main outcomes: The Chi-squared test was used to detect significant differences in the follow-up, control, and treatment variables for all three disorders (hypertension, hypercholesterolaemia, and type 2 diabetes mellitus) between individuals assigned to users and non-users of the computerized clinical practice guidelines, respectively. Results: A total of 189,067 patients were included in this study, with a mean age of 56 years (standard deviation 12), and 55.5% of whom were women. Significant differences were observed in hypertension management, treatment and control; type 2 diabetes mellitus management, treatment and diagnoses, and the management and control of hypercholesterolaemia in both sexes. Conclusions: Computerized clinical practice guidelines are an effective tool for the control and follow-up of patients diagnosed with hypertension, type 2 diabetes mellitus, and hypercholesterolaemia. The usefulness of computerized clinical practice guidelines to diagnose and adequately treat individuals with these disorders remains unclear (AU)

Objetivo: Evaluar el impacto de las guías de práctica clínica electrónicas en el manejo, diagnóstico, tratamiento, control y seguimiento de los factores de riesgo cardiovascular mayores: hipertensión, hipercolesterolemia, diabetes mellitus tipo 2. Diseño: Estudio pre-post controlado. Emplazamiento: Cataluña, comunidad autónoma situada al noreste de España. Participantes: Individuos de 35-74 años asignados a médicos de familia del Institut Català de la Salut. Intervención: El grupo de intervención estaba formado por pacientes asignados a médicos de familia que accedían al menos 2 veces al día a las guías de práctica clínica electrónicas. El grupo de control estaba formado por las personas asignadas a médicos de familia que nunca habían accedido. Medidas de resultado: Se realizaron pruebas de ji al cuadrado para detectar diferencias significativas en el seguimiento, control y tratamiento de la hipertensión, hipercolesterolemia y diabetes mellitus tipo 2 entre los individuos asignados al grupo de usuarios y los no usuarios de las guías. Resultados: Se incluyeron 189.067 individuos, con una edad media de 56 años (desviación estándar 12), de los cuales el 55,5% eran mujeres. Se encontraron diferencias estadísticamente significativas en el manejo, tratamiento y control de la hipertensión; en el manejo, tratamiento y diagnóstico de la diabetes mellitus tipo 2, y en el manejo y control de la hipercolesterolemia en ambos sexos. Conclusiones: Las guías de práctica clínica electrónicas son una herramienta efectiva para el control y seguimiento de los pacientes con hipertensión, hipercolesterolemia y diabetes mellitus tipo 2. La utilidad de las guías de práctica clínica electrónicas en el diagnóstico y adecuación del tratamiento sigue en discusión (AU)

Eficacia de un programa intensivo de prevención secundaria de cardiopatía isquémica tras 5 años de intervención / Efficacy of an intensive prevention programme of coronary heart disease: 5 year follow-up outcomes

Fundamento y objetivo: Los resultados sobre la eficacia de los programas multifactoriales de prevención secundaria de cardiopatía isquémica son contradictorios. En el presente artículo mostramos los resultados a 5 años de un ensayo clínico diseñado para conocer la eficacia de un programa preventivo en la reducción de recurrencias cardiovasculares y la mortalidad, en pacientes con enfermedad coronaria estable. Pacientes y método: Se trata de un ensayo clínico multicéntrico con asignación aleatoria de la intervención, en el que participaron 23 áreas básicas de salud de Cataluña. Se incluyó a pacientes con enfermedad coronaria estable de 30 a 80 años. Los pacientes del grupo de intervención acudieron a visitas trimestrales con el médico de familia, mientras que el grupo de control recibió los cuidados habituales. La intervención consistió en realizar mediciones de presión arterial y peso, así como analíticas semestrales para evaluar el control de los factores de riesgo. En el grupo de intervención se realizaba un refuerzo sobre estilos de vida saludable, se ajustaba la medicación que recibían los pacientes y se les entregaba material educativo de refuerzo. Para analizar el efecto de la intervención se registraron las recurrencias cardiovasculares y la mortalidad durante el seguimiento en ambos grupos. Resultados: Se incluyó a 983 pacientes, cuya media (desviación estándar) de edad fue de 64 (10) años. Un total de 235 presentó alguna recurrencia cardiovascular no mortal (109 en el grupo de control frente a 126 en el grupo de intervención; p = 0,84) y 45 murieron por un acontecimiento cardiovascular (23 frente a 22, respectivamente; p = 0,57). El cociente de riesgo ajustado de presentar un acontecimiento cardiovascular para el grupo de intervención respecto al control fue de 1,01 (intervalo de confianza del 95%, 0,74-1,39) y el de mortalidad total, de 0,92 (intervalo de confianza del 95%, 0,54-1,56). Conclusiones: La implantación de un programa intensivo de prevención secundaria basado en recordatorios periódicos a los pacientes con enfermedad coronaria estable para consultar con sus médicos de atención primaria no se acompaña de una disminución del número de recurrencias cardiovasculares ni de la mortalidad total, comparada con los cuidados habituales, tras 5 años de seguimiento

Background and objective: Most evidence on the efficacy of intensive preventive programs of secondary prevention of coronary diseases comes from Anglo-Saxon countries and effectiveness remains controversial. We have scarce information about the efficacy of these types of programs in Spain. In the present analysis we show the results of the ICAR (Intervención en la Comunidad de Alto Riesgo coronario) study, aimed to analyze the efficacy of an intensive preventive program primary care based in reducing the cardiovascular recurrences and mortality in patients with coronary heart disease. Patients and method: We designed a randomized clinical trial, multicenter and community based, which included 23 health care areas in Catalonia, Spain. We followed for 5 years 2 cohorts of patients with coronary heart disease, aged 30-80 years. The intervention group was quarterly examined by their general practitioner, who adjusted treatments to control their cardiovascular risk factors thoroughly and reinforced life style behaviours. In order to do that, patient's weight and blood pressure were determined in each visit and laboratory test carried out twice a year. Patients in the control group received the usual care. In order to analyze the effect of the intervention cardiovascular recurrences and mortality were registered. Results: We included 983 patients. Mean (standard deviation) age was 64 (10) and 74.5% were men. During the follow-up 235 patients suffered some non-fatal cardiovascular recurrence (109 vs 126 in the control and intervention group, respectively; p = 0.84), and 45 died from cardiovascular recurrences (23 vs 22, respectively; p = 0.57). Adjusted hazard ratio of cardiovascular event and total mortality, for the intervention group were 1.01 (95% confidence interval, 0.74-1.39), and 0.92 (95% confidence interval, 0.54-1.56), respectively. Conclusions: The implementation of an intensive secondary prevention program based on periodical reminds to patients with stable coronary heart disease to attend their general practitioners did not reduce either the cardiovascular recurrences or mortality at 5 years as compared with usual care