The "Origin-of-Life Reactor" and Reduction of CO2 by H2 in Inorganic Precipitates.

It has been suggested that inorganic membranes were forerunners of organic membranes at the origin of life. Such membranes, interposed between alkaline fluid in submarine vents and the more acidic Hadean ocean, were thought to house inorganic molecular machines. H+ flowed down the pH gradient (ΔpH) from ocean to vent through the molecular machines to drive metabolic reactions for early life. A set of experiments was performed by Herschy et al. (J Mol Evol 79:213-227, 2014) who followed earlier work to construct inorganic precipitate membranes which, they argued, would be transected by a ΔpH. They supposed that inorganic molecular machines might assemble by chance in the precipitate membranes, and be capable of using the ΔpH to drive unfavourable reduction of CO2 by H2 to formate and formaldehyde. Indeed, these workers detected both of these compounds in their origin-of-life reaction vessel and contend this was proof of principle for their hypothesis. However, it is shown here by a straightforward calculation that the formate produced was only that which reached on approach to equilibrium without any driving force from ΔpH. We conclude that the reaction was facilitated by isotropic catalysts in the precipitate membrane but not by an anisotropic ΔpH-driven molecular machine.

Natural pH Gradients in Hydrothermal Alkali Vents Were Unlikely to Have Played a Role in the Origin of Life.

The hypothesis that a natural pH gradient across inorganic membranes lying between the ocean and fluid issuing from hydrothermal alkali vents provided energy to drive chemical reactions during the origin of life has an attractive parallel with chemiosmotic ATP synthesis in present-day organisms. However, arguments raised in this review suggest that such natural pH gradients are unlikely to have played a part in life's origin. There is as yet no evidence for thin inorganic membranes holding sharp pH gradients in modern hydrothermal alkali vents at Lost City near the Mid-Atlantic Ridge. Proposed models of non-protein forms of the H(+)-pyrophosphate synthase that could have functioned as a molecular machine utilizing the energy of a natural pH gradient are unsatisfactory. Some hypothetical designs of non-protein motors utilizing a natural pH gradient to drive redox reactions are plausible but complex, and such motors are deemed unlikely to have assembled by chance in prebiotic times. Small molecular motors comprising a few hundred atoms would have been unable to function in the relatively thick (>1 µm) inorganic membranes that have hitherto been used as descriptive models for the natural pH gradient hypothesis. Alternative hypotheses for the evolution of chemiosmotic systems following the emergence of error-prone gene replication and translation are more likely to be correct.

A review of the binding-change mechanism for proton-translocating transhydrogenase.

Proton-translocating transhydrogenase is found in the inner membranes of animal mitochondria, and in the cytoplasmic membranes of many bacteria. It catalyses hydride transfer from NADH to NADP(+) coupled to inward proton translocation. Evidence is reviewed suggesting the enzyme operates by a "binding-change" mechanism. Experiments with Escherichia coli transhydrogenase indicate the enzyme is driven between "open" and "occluded" states by protonation and deprotonation reactions associated with proton translocation. In the open states NADP(+)/NADPH can rapidly associate with, or dissociate from, the enzyme, and hydride transfer is prevented. In the occluded states bound NADP(+)/NADPH cannot dissociate, and hydride transfer is allowed. Crystal structures of a complex of the nucleotide-binding components of Rhodospirillum rubrum transhydrogenase show how hydride transfer is enabled and disabled at appropriate steps in catalysis, and how release of NADP(+)/NADPH is restricted in the occluded state. Thermodynamic and kinetic studies indicate that the equilibrium constant for hydride transfer on the enzyme is elevated as a consequence of the tight binding of NADPH relative to NADP(+). The protonation site in the translocation pathway must face the outside if NADP(+) is bound, the inside if NADPH is bound. Chemical shift changes detected by NMR may show where alterations in protein conformation resulting from NADP(+) reduction are initiated. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: 17th European Bioenergetics Conference (EBEC 2012).

The specificity of proton-translocating transhydrogenase for nicotinamide nucleotides.

In its forward direction, transhydrogenase couples the reduction of NADP(+) by NADH to the outward translocation of protons across the membrane of bacteria and animal mitochondria. The enzyme has three components: dI and dIII protrude from the membrane and dII spans the membrane. Hydride transfer takes place between nucleotides bound to dI and dIII. Studies on the kinetics of a lag phase at the onset of a "cyclic reaction" catalysed by complexes of the dI and dIII components of transhydrogenase from Rhodospirillum rubrum, and on the kinetics of fluorescence changes associated with nucleotide binding, reveal two features. Firstly, the binding of NADP(+) and NADPH to dIII is extremely slow, and is probably limited by the conversion of the occluded to the open state of the complex. Secondly, dIII can also bind NAD(+) and NADH. Extrapolating to the intact enzyme this binding to the "wrong" site could lead to slip: proton translocation without change in the nucleotide redox state, which would have important consequences for bacterial and mitochondrial metabolism.

X-ray absorption studies of Zn(2+)-binding sites in Escherichia coli transhydrogenase and its betaH91K mutant.

Transhydrogenase couples hydride transfer between NADH and NADP(+) to proton translocation across a membrane. The binding of Zn(2+) to the enzyme was shown previously to inhibit steps associated with proton transfer. Using Zn K-edge X-ray absorption fine structure (XAFS), we report here on the local structure of Zn(2+) bound to Escherichia coli transhydrogenase. Experiments were performed on wild-type enzyme and a mutant in which betaHis91 was replaced by Lys (betaH91K). This well-conserved His residue, located in the membrane-spanning domain of the protein, has been suggested to function in proton transfer, and to act as a ligand of the inhibitory Zn(2+). The XAFS analysis has identified a Zn(2+)-binding cluster formed by one Cys, two His, and one Asp/Glu residue, arranged in a tetrahedral geometry. The structure of the site is consistent with the notion that Zn(2+) inhibits proton translocation by competing with H(+) binding to the His residues. The same cluster of residues with very similar bond lengths best fits the spectra of wild-type transhydrogenase and betaH91K. Evidently, betaHis91 is not directly involved in Zn(2+) binding. The locus of betaHis91 and that of the Zn-binding site, although both on (or close to) the proton-transfer pathway of transhydrogenase, are spatially separate.

Inhibition of proton-transfer steps in transhydrogenase by transition metal ions.

Transhydrogenase couples proton translocation across a bacterial or mitochondrial membrane to the redox reaction between NAD(H) and NADP(H). Purified intact transhydrogenase from Escherichia coli was prepared, and its His tag removed. The forward and reverse transhydrogenation reactions catalysed by the enzyme were inhibited by certain metal ions but a "cyclic reaction" was stimulated. Of metal ions tested they were effective in the order Pb(2+)>Cu(2+)>Zn(2+)=Cd(2+)>Ni(2+)>Co(2+). The results suggest that the metal ions affect transhydrogenase by binding to a site in the proton-transfer pathway. Attenuated total-reflectance Fourier-transform infrared difference spectroscopy indicated the involvement of His and Asp/Glu residues in the Zn(2+)-binding site(s). A mutant in which betaHis91 in the membrane-spanning domain of transhydrogenase was replaced by Lys had enzyme activities resembling those of wild-type enzyme treated with Zn(2+). Effects of the metal ion on the mutant were much diminished but still evident. Signals in Zn(2+)-induced FTIR difference spectra of the betaHis91Lys mutant were also attributable to changes in His and Asp/Glu residues but were much smaller than those in wild-type spectra. The results support the view that betaHis91 and nearby Asp or Glu residues participate in the proton-transfer pathway of transhydrogenase.

Mutations in transhydrogenase change the fluorescence emission state of TRP72 from 1La to 1Lb.

The dI component of Rhodospirillum rubrum transhydrogenase has a single Trp residue (Trp(72)), which has distinctive optical properties, including short-wavelength fluorescence emission with clear vibrational fine structure, and long-lived, well-resolved phosphorescence emission. We have made a set of mutant dI proteins in which residues contacting Trp(72) are conservatively substituted. The room-temperature fluorescence-emission spectra of our three Met(97) mutants are blue shifted by approximately 4 nm, giving them a shorter-wavelength emission than any other protein described in the literature, including azurin from Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Fluorescence spectra in low-temperature glasses show equivalent well-resolved vibrational bands in wild-type and the mutant dI proteins, and in azurin. Substitution of Met(97) in dI changes the relative intensities of some of these vibrational bands. The analysis supports the view that fluorescence from the Met(97) mutants arises predominantly from the (1)L(b) excited singlet state of Trp(72), whereas (1)L(a) is the predominant emitting state in wild-type dI. It is suggested that the sulfur atom of Met(97) promotes greater stabilization of (1)L(a) than either (1)L(b) or the ground state. The phosphorescence spectra of Met(97) mutants are also blue-shifted, indicating that the sulfur atom decreases the transition energy between the (3)L(a) state of the Trp and the ground state.

A hybrid of the transhydrogenases from Rhodospirillum rubrum and Mycobacterium tuberculosis catalyses rapid hydride transfer but not the complete, proton-translocating reaction.

All transhydrogenases appear to have three components: dI, which binds NAD(H), and dIII, which binds NADP(H), protrude from the membrane, and dII spans the membrane. However, the polypeptide composition of the enzymes varies amongst species. The transhydrogenases of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and of Rhodospirillum rubrum have three polypeptides. Sequence analysis indicates that an ancestral three-polypeptide enzyme evolved into transhydrogenases with either two polypeptides (such as the Escherichia coli enzyme) or one polypeptide (such as the mitochondrial enzyme). The fusion steps in each case probably led to the development of an additional transmembrane helix. A hybrid transhydrogenase was constructed from the dI component of the M. tuberculosis enzyme and the dII and dIII components of the R. rubrum enzyme. The hybrid catalyses cyclic transhydrogenation but not the proton-translocating, reverse reaction. This shows that nucleotide-binding/release at the NAD(H) site, and hydride transfer, are fully functional but that events associated with NADP(H) binding/release are compromised. It is concluded that sequence mismatch in the hybrid prevents a conformational change between dI and dIII which is essential for the step accompanying proton translocation.

Ancient Living Organisms Escaping from, or Imprisoned in, the Vents?

We have recently criticised the natural pH gradient hypothesis which purports to explain how the difference in pH between fluid issuing from ancient alkali vents and the more acidic Hadean ocean could have driven molecular machines that catalyse reactions that are useful in prebiotic and autotrophic chemistry. In this article, we temporarily suspend our earlier criticism while we consider difficulties for primitive organisms to have managed their energy supply and to have left the vents and become free-living. We point out that it may have been impossible for organisms to have acquired membrane-located proton (or sodium ion) pumps to replace the natural pH gradient, and independently to have driven essential molecular machines such as the ATP synthase. The volumes of the ocean and of the vent fluids were too large for a membrane-located pump to have generated a significant ion concentration gradient. Our arguments apply to three of the four concurrent models employed by the proponents of the natural pH gradient hypothesis. A fourth model is exempt from these arguments but has other intrinsic difficulties that we briefly consider. We conclude that ancient organisms utilising a natural pH gradient would have been imprisoned in the vents, unable to escape and become free-living.

Critical Role of Water Molecules in Proton Translocation by the Membrane-Bound Transhydrogenase.

The nicotinamide nucleotide transhydrogenase (TH) is an integral membrane enzyme that uses the proton-motive force to drive hydride transfer from NADH to NADP+ in bacteria and eukaryotes. Here we solved a 2.2-Å crystal structure of the TH transmembrane domain (Thermus thermophilus) at pH 6.5. This structure exhibits conformational changes of helix positions from a previous structure solved at pH 8.5, and reveals internal water molecules interacting with residues implicated in proton translocation. Together with molecular dynamics simulations, we show that transient water flows across a narrow pore and a hydrophobic "dry" region in the middle of the membrane channel, with key residues His42α2 (chain A) being protonated and Thr214ß (chain B) displaying a conformational change, respectively, to gate the channel access to both cytoplasmic and periplasmic chambers. Mutation of Thr214ß to Ala deactivated the enzyme. These data provide new insights into the gating mechanism of proton translocation in TH.

Nucleotide binding affinities of the intact proton-translocating transhydrogenase from Escherichia coli.

Transhydrogenase (E.C. 1.6.1.1) couples the redox reaction between NAD(H) and NADP(H) to the transport of protons across a membrane. The enzyme is composed of three components. The dI and dIII components, which house the binding site for NAD(H) and NADP(H), respectively, are peripheral to the membrane, and dII spans the membrane. We have estimated dissociation constants (K(d) values) for NADPH (0.87 microM), NADP(+) (16 microM), NADH (50 microM), and NAD(+) (100-500 microM) for intact, detergent-dispersed transhydrogenase from Escherichia coli using micro-calorimetry. This is the first complete set of dissociation constants of the physiological nucleotides for any intact transhydrogenase. The K(d) values for NAD(+) and NADH are similar to those previously reported with isolated dI, but the K(d) values for NADP(+) and NADPH are much larger than those previously reported with isolated dIII. There is negative co-operativity between the binding sites of the intact, detergent-dispersed transhydrogenase when both nucleotides are reduced or both are oxidized.

A conformational change in the isolated NADP(H)-binding component (dIII) of transhydrogenase induced by low pH: a reflection of events during proton translocation by the complete enzyme?

Transhydrogenase couples the reduction of NADP(+) by NADH to inward proton translocation across the bacterial (or mitochondrial) membrane. Conformational changes in the NADP(H)-binding component of the enzyme (dIII) are central to the coupling mechanism. In the "open" state, NADP(H) bound to dIII can readily exchange with nucleotides in the solvent but hydride transfer [to/from NAD(H) bound to dI] is prevented. In the "occluded" state, bound NADP(H) cannot exchange with solvent nucleotides but the hydride transfer reaction is permitted. It was previously found that the conformational state of isolated, recombinant dIII is pH dependent. At neutral pH, the protein adopts a conformation resembling the occluded state, and at low pH, it adopts a conformation resembling the open state. The crystal structure of dIII indicates that the loop E "lid" might be largely responsible for the very high affinity of the protein for NADP(H). In this paper we show, using fluorescence resonance energy transfer, that the distance between the apex of loop E of isolated dIII, and the core of the protein, increases when the solution pH is lowered. This is consistent with the view that the lid is retracted to permit NADPH release during turnover of the complete enzyme.

Zinc ions selectively inhibit steps associated with binding and release of NADP(H) during turnover of proton-translocating transhydrogenase.

Transhydrogenase couples the redox reaction between NAD(H) and NADP(H) to proton translocation across a membrane. In membrane vesicles from Escherichia coli and Rhodospirillum rubrum, the transhydrogenase reaction (measured in the direction driving inward proton translocation) was inhibited by Zn(2+) and Cd(2+). However, depending on pH, the metal ions either had no effect on, or stimulated, "cyclic" transhydrogenation. They must, therefore, interfere specifically with steps involving binding/release of NADP(+)/NADPH: the steps thought to be associated with proton translocation. It is suggested that Zn(2+) and Cd(2+) bind in the proton-transfer pathway and block inter-conversion of states responsible for changing NADP(+)/NADPH binding energy.

Review and Hypothesis. New insights into the reaction mechanism of transhydrogenase: Swivelling the dIII component may gate the proton channel.

The membrane protein transhydrogenase in animal mitochondria and bacteria couples reduction of NADP⁺ by NADH to proton translocation. Recent X-ray data on Thermus thermophilus transhydrogenase indicate a significant difference in the orientations of the two dIII components of the enzyme dimer (Leung et al., 2015). The character of the orientation change, and a review of information on the kinetics and thermodynamics of transhydrogenase, indicate that dIII swivelling might assist in the control of proton gating by the redox state of bound NADP⁺/NADPH during enzyme turnover.

Proton translocation by transhydrogenase.

Transhydrogenase, in animal mitochondria and bacteria, couples hydride transfer between NADH and NADP(+) to proton translocation across a membrane. Within the protein, the redox reaction occurs at some distance from the proton translocation pathway and coupling is achieved through conformational changes. In an 'open' conformation of transhydrogenase, in which substrate nucleotides bind and product nucleotides dissociate, the dihydronicotinamide and nicotinamide rings are held apart to block hydride transfer; in an 'occluded' conformation, they are moved into apposition to permit the redox chemistry. In the two monomers of transhydrogenase, there is a reciprocating, out-of-phase alternation of these conformations during turnover.

Structures of the dI2dIII1 complex of proton-translocating transhydrogenase with bound, inactive analogues of NADH and NADPH reveal active site geometries.

Transhydrogenase couples the redox reaction between NADH and NADP+ to proton translocation across a membrane. The enzyme comprises three components; dI binds NAD(H), dIII binds NADP(H), and dII spans the membrane. The 1,4,5,6-tetrahydro analogue of NADH (designated H2NADH) bound to isolated dI from Rhodospirillum rubrum transhydrogenase with similar affinity to the physiological nucleotide. Binding of either NADH or H2NADH led to closure of the dI mobile loop. The 1,4,5,6-tetrahydro analogue of NADPH (H2NADPH) bound very tightly to isolated R. rubrum dIII, but the rate constant for dissociation was greater than that for NADPH. The replacement of NADP+ on dIII either with H2NADPH or with NADPH caused a similar set of chemical shift alterations, signifying an equivalent conformational change. Despite similar binding properties to the natural nucleotides, neither H2NADH nor H2NADPH could serve as a hydride donor in transhydrogenation reactions. Mixtures of dI and dIII form dI2dIII1 complexes. The nucleotide charge distribution of complexes loaded either with H2NADH and NADP+ or with NAD+ and H2NADPH should more closely mimic the ground states for forward and reverse hydride transfer, respectively, than previously studied dead-end species. Crystal structures of such complexes at 2.6 and 2.3 A resolution are described. A transition state for hydride transfer between dihydronicotinamide and nicotinamide derivatives determined in ab initio quantum mechanical calculations resembles the organization of nucleotides in the transhydrogenase active site in the crystal structure. Molecular dynamics simulations of the enzyme indicate that the (dihydro)nicotinamide rings remain close to a ground state for hydride transfer throughout a 1.4 ns trajectory.

Substitution of tyrosine 146 in the dI component of proton-translocating transhydrogenase leads to reversible dissociation of the active dimer into inactive monomers.

Transhydrogenase couples the redox reaction between NADH and NADP+ to proton translocation across a membrane. The protein has three components: dI binds NADH, dIII binds NADP+, and dII spans the membrane. Transhydrogenase is a "dimer" of two dI-dII-dIII "monomers"; x-ray structures suggested that the two catalytic sites alternate during turnover. Invariant Tyr146 in recombinant dI of Rhodospirillum rubrum transhydrogenase was substituted with Phe and Ala (proteins designated dI.Y146F and dI.Y146A, respectively). Analytical ultracentrifuge experiments and differential scanning calorimetry show that dI.Y146A more readily dissociates into monomers than wild-type dI. Analytical ultracentrifuge and Trp fluorescence experiments indicate that the dI.Y146A monomers bind NADH much more weakly than dimers. Wild-type dI and dI.Y146F reconstituted activity to dI-depleted membranes with similar characteristics. However, dI.Y146A reconstituted activity in its dimeric form but not in its monomeric form, this despite monomers retaining their native fold and binding to the dI-depleted membranes. It is suggested that transhydrogenase reconstructed with monomers of dI.Y146A is catalytically compromised, at least partly as a consequence of the lowered affinity for NADH, and this results from lost interactions between the nucleotide binding site and the protein beta-hairpin upon dissociation of the dI dimer. The importance of these interactions and their coupling to dI domain rotation in the mechanism of action of transhydrogenase is emphasized. Two peaks in the 1H NMR spectrum of wild-type dI are broadened in dI.Y146A and are tentatively assigned to S-methyl groups of Met resonances in the beta-hairpin, consistent with the segmental mobility of this feature in the structure.

Molecular recognition between protein and nicotinamide dinucleotide in intact, proton-translocating transhydrogenase studied by ATR-FTIR Spectroscopy.

Nicotinamide dinucleotide binding to transhydrogenase purified from Escherichia coli was investigated by attenuated total reflectance-Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy. Detergent-free transhydrogenase was deposited as a thin film on an ATR prism, and spectra were recorded during perfusion with buffers in the presence and absence of dinucleotide (NADP(+), NADPH, NAD(+), or NADH) in both H(2)O and D(2)O media. IR spectral changes were attributable to the bound dinucleotides and to changes in the protein itself. The dissociation constant of NADPH was estimated to be approximately 5 muM from a titration of the magnitude of the IR changes against the nucleotide concentration. IR spectra of related model compounds were used to assign principle bands of the dinucleotides. This information was combined with IR data on amino acids and with protein crystallographic data to identify interactions between specific parts of the dinucleotides and their binding sites in the protein. Several IR bands of bound nucleotide were sharpened and/or shifted relative to those in aqueous solution, reflecting a restriction to motion and a change in environment upon binding. Alterations in the protein secondary structure indicated by amide I/II changes were distinctly different for NADP(H) and for NAD(H) binding. The data suggest that NADP(H) binding leads to perturbation of a deeply buried part of the polypeptide backbone and to protonation of a carboxylic acid residue.