Termination of Transcription of Short Noncoding RNAs by RNA Polymerase II.

The RNA polymerase II transcription cycle is often divided into three major stages: initiation, elongation, and termination. Research over the last decade has blurred these divisions and emphasized the tightly regulated transitions that occur as RNA polymerase II synthesizes a transcript from start to finish. Transcription termination, the process that marks the end of transcription elongation, is regulated by proteins that interact with the polymerase, nascent transcript, and/or chromatin template. The failure to terminate transcription can cause accumulation of aberrant transcripts and interfere with transcription at downstream genes. Here, we review the mechanism, regulation, and physiological impact of a termination pathway that targets small noncoding transcripts produced by RNA polymerase II. We emphasize the Nrd1-Nab3-Sen1 pathway in yeast, in which the process has been extensively studied. The importance of understanding small RNA termination pathways is underscored by the need to control noncoding transcription in eukaryotic genomes.

Nab3 nuclear granule accumulation is driven by respiratory capacity.

Numerous biological processes involve proteins capable of transiently assembling into subcellular compartments necessary for cellular functions. One process is the RNA polymerase II transcription cycle which involves initiation, elongation, co-transcriptional modification of nascent RNA, and termination. The essential yeast transcription termination factor Nab3 is required for termination of small non-coding RNAs and accumulates into a compact nuclear granule upon glucose removal. Nab3 nuclear granule accumulation varies in penetrance across yeast strains and a higher Nab3 granule accumulation phenotype is associated with petite strains, suggesting a possible ATP-dependent mechanism for granule disassembly. Here, we demonstrate the uncoupling of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation by drug treatment or deletions of nuclear-encoded ATP synthase subunit genes were sufficient to increase Nab3 granule accumulation and led to an inability to proliferate during prolonged glucose deprivation, which requires respiration. Additionally, by enriching for respiration competent cells from a petite-prone strain, we generated a low granule-accumulating strain from a relatively high one, providing another link between respiratory competency and Nab3 granules. Consistent with the resulting idea that ATP is involved in granule accumulation, the addition of extracellular ATP to semi-permeabilized cells was sufficient to reduce Nab3 granule accumulation. Deleting the SKY1 gene, which encodes a kinase that phosphorylates nuclear SR repeat-containing proteins and is involved in efficient stress granule disassembly, also resulted in increased granule accumulation. This observation implicates Sky1 in Nab3 granule biogenesis. Taken together, these findings suggest there is normally an equilibrium between termination factor granule assembly and disassembly mediated by ATP-requiring nuclear machinery.

Variable penetrance of Nab3 granule accumulation quantified by a new tool for high-throughput single-cell granule analysis.

Reorganization of cellular proteins into subcellular compartments, such as the concentration of RNA-binding proteins into cytoplasmic stress granules and P-bodies, is a well-recognized, widely studied physiological process currently under intense investigation. One example of this is the induction of the yeast Nab3 transcription termination factor to rearrange from its pan-nucleoplasmic distribution to a granule at the nuclear periphery in response to nutrient limitation. Recent work in many cell types has shown that protein condensation in the nucleus is functionally important for transcription initiation, RNA processing, and termination. However, little is known about how subnuclear compartments form. Here, we have quantitatively analyzed this dynamic process in living yeast using a high-throughput computational tool and fluorescence microscopy. This analysis revealed that Nab3 granule accumulation varies in penetrance across yeast strains. A concentrated single granule is formed from at least a quarter of the nuclear Nab3 drawn from the rest of the nucleus. Levels of granule accumulation were inversely correlated with a growth defect in the absence of glucose. Importantly, the basis for some of the variation in penetrance was attributable to a defect in mitochondrial function. This publicly available computational tool provides a rigorous, reproducible, and unbiased examination of Nab3 granule accumulation that should be widely applicable to a variety of fluorescent images. Thousands of live cells can be readily examined enabling rigorous statistical verification of significance. With it, we describe a new feature of inducible subnuclear compartment formation for RNA-binding transcription factors and an important determinant of granule biogenesis.

A fluorescent assay for the genetic dissection of the RNA polymerase II termination machinery.

RNA polymerase II is a highly processive enzyme that synthesizes mRNAs and some non-protein coding RNAs. Termination of transcription, which entails release of the transcript and disengagement of the polymerase, requires an active process. In yeast, there are at least two multi-protein complexes needed for termination of transcription, depending upon which class of RNAs are being acted upon. In general, the two classes are relatively short non-coding RNAs (e.g. snoRNAs) and relatively long mRNAs, although there are exceptions. Here, a procedure is described in which defective termination can be detected in living cells, resulting in a method that allows strains with mutations in termination factors or cis-acting sequences, to be identified and recovered. The strategy employs a reporter plasmid with a galactose inducible promoter driving transcription of green fluorescent protein which yields highly fluorescent cells. When a test terminator is inserted between the promoter and the fluorescent protein reading frame, cells fail to fluoresce. Mutant strains that have lost termination capability, so called terminator-override mutants, gain expression of the fluorescent protein and can be collected by fluorescence activated cell sorting. The strategy is robust since acquisition of fluorescence is a positive trait that has a low probability of happening adventitiously. Live mutant cells can easily be cloned from the population of positive candidates. Flow sorting is a sensitive, high-throughput detection step capable of discovering spontaneous mutations in yeast with high fidelity.

Decapping goes nuclear.

In this issue of Molecular Cell, Brannan et al. (2012) propose a novel function for RNA-decapping and transcription termination in aborting "divergent" promoter-proximal elongation complexes.

Yeast Nab3 protein contains a self-assembly domain found in human heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein-C (hnRNP-C) that is necessary for transcription termination.

Nab3 is an RNA-binding protein whose function is important for terminating transcription by RNA polymerase II. It co-assembles with Nrd1, and the resulting heterodimer of these heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein-C (hnRNP)-like proteins interacts with the nascent transcript and RNA polymerase II. Previous genetic analysis showed that a short carboxyl-terminal region of Nab3 is functionally important for termination and is located far from the Nab3 RNA recognition domain in the primary sequence. The domain is structurally homologous to hnRNP-C from higher organisms. Here we provide biochemical evidence that this short region is sufficient to enable self-assembly of Nab3 into a tetrameric form in a manner similar to the cognate region of human hnRNP-C. Within this region, there is a stretch of low complexity protein sequence (16 glutamines) adjacent to a putative α-helix that potentiates the ability of the conserved region to self-assemble. The glutamine stretch and the final 18 amino acids of Nab3 are both important for termination in living yeast cells. The findings herein describe an additional avenue by which these hnRNP-like proteins can polymerize on target transcripts. This process is independent of, but acts in concert with, the interactions of the proteins with RNA and RNA polymerase and extends the relationship of Nab3 as a functional orthologue of a higher eukaryotic hnRNP.

A network of interdependent molecular interactions describes a higher order Nrd1-Nab3 complex involved in yeast transcription termination.

Nab3 and Nrd1 are yeast heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein (hnRNP)-like proteins that heterodimerize and bind RNA. Genetic and biochemical evidence reveals that they are integral to the termination of transcription of short non-coding RNAs by RNA polymerase II. Here we define a Nab3 mutation (nab3Δ134) that removes an essential part of the protein's C terminus but nevertheless can rescue, in trans, the phenotype resulting from a mutation in the RNA recognition motif of Nab3. This low complexity region of Nab3 appears intrinsically unstructured and can form a hydrogel in vitro. These data support a model in which multiple Nrd1-Nab3 heterodimers polymerize onto substrate RNA to effect termination, allowing complementation of one mutant Nab3 molecule by another lacking a different function. The self-association property of Nab3 adds to the previously documented interactions between these hnRNP-like proteins, RNA polymerase II, and the nascent transcript, leading to a network of nucleoprotein interactions that define a higher order Nrd1-Nab3 complex. This was underscored from the synthetic phenotypes of yeast strains with pairwise combinations of Nrd1 and Nab3 mutations known to affect their distinct biochemical activities. The mutations included a Nab3 self-association defect, a Nab3-Nrd1 heterodimerization defect, a Nrd1-polymerase II binding defect, and an Nab3-RNA recognition motif mutation. Although no single mutation was lethal, cells with any two mutations were not viable for four such pairings, and a fifth displayed a synthetic growth defect. These data strengthen the idea that a multiplicity of interactions is needed to assemble a higher order Nrd1-Nab3 complex that coats specific nascent RNAs in preparation for termination.

A genetic screen for terminator function in yeast identifies a role for a new functional domain in termination factor Nab3.

The yeast IMD2 gene encodes an enzyme involved in GTP synthesis. Its expression is controlled by guanine nucleotides through a set of alternate start sites and an intervening transcriptional terminator. In the off state, transcription results in a short non-coding RNA that starts upstream of the gene. Transcription terminates via the Nrd1-Nab3-Sen1 complex and is degraded by the nuclear exosome. Using a sensitive terminator read-through assay, we identified trans-acting Terminator Override (TOV) genes that operate this terminator. Four genes were identified: the RNA polymerase II phosphatase SSU72, the RNA polymerase II binding protein PCF11, the TRAMP subunit TRF4 and the hnRNP-like, NAB3. The TOV phenotype can be explained by the loss of function of these gene products as described in models in which termination and RNA degradation are coupled to the phosphorylation state of RNA polymerase II's repeat domain. The most interesting mutations were those found in NAB3, which led to the finding that the removal of merely three carboxy-terminal amino acids compromised Nab3's function. This region of previously unknown function is distant from the protein's well-known RNA binding and Nrd1 binding domains. Structural homology modeling suggests this Nab3 'tail' forms an α-helical multimerization domain that helps assemble it onto an RNA substrate.

Metabolic regulation of IMD2 transcription and an unusual DNA element that generates short transcripts.

Transcriptional regulation of IMD2 in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) is governed by the concentration of intracellular guanine nucleotide pools. The mechanism by which pool size is measured and transduced to the transcriptional apparatus is unknown. Here we show that DNA sequences surrounding the IMD2 initiation site constitute a repressive element (RE) involved in guanine regulation that contains a novel transcription-blocking activity. When this regulatory region is placed downstream of a heterologous promoter, short poly(A)(+) transcripts are generated. The element is orientation dependent, and sequences within the normally transcribed and nontranscribed regions of the element are required for its activity. The promoter-proximal short RNAs are unstable and serve as substrates for the nuclear exosome. These findings support a model in which intergenic short transcripts emanating from upstream of the IMD2 promoter are terminated by a polyadenylation/terminator-like signal embedded within the IMD2 transcription start site.

Recent advances in understanding RNA polymerase II structure and function.

More than 50 years after the identification of RNA polymerase II, the enzyme responsible for the transcription of most eukaryotic genes, studies have continued to reveal fresh aspects of its structure and regulation. New technologies, coupled with years of development of a vast catalog of RNA polymerase II accessory proteins and activities, have led to new revelations about the transcription process. The maturation of cryo-electron microscopy as a tool for unraveling the detailed structure of large molecular machines has provided numerous structures of the enzyme and its accessory factors. Advances in biophysical methods have enabled the observation of a single polymerase's behavior, distinct from work on aggregate population averages. Other recent work has revealed new properties and activities of the general initiation factors that RNA polymerase II employs to accurately initiate transcription, as well as chromatin proteins that control RNA polymerase II's firing frequency, and elongation factors that facilitate the enzyme's departure from the promoter and which control sequential steps and obstacles that must be navigated by elongating RNA polymerase II. There has also been a growing appreciation of the physical properties conferred upon many of these proteins by regions of each polypeptide that are of low primary sequence complexity and that are often intrinsically disordered. This peculiar feature of a surprisingly large number of proteins enables a disordered region of the protein to morph into a stable structure and creates an opportunity for pathway participants to dynamically partition into subcompartments of the nucleus. These subcompartments host designated portions of the chemical reactions that lead to mRNA synthesis. This article highlights a selection of recent findings that reveal some of the resolved workings of RNA polymerase II and its ensemble of supporting factors.

The gene encoding the fragile X RNA-binding protein is controlled by nuclear respiratory factor 2 and the CREB family of transcription factors.

FMR1 encodes an RNA-binding protein whose absence results in fragile X mental retardation. In most patients, the FMR1 gene is cytosine-methylated and transcriptionally inactive. NRF-1 and Sp1 are known to bind and stimulate the active, but not the methylated/silenced, FMR1 promoter. Prior analysis has implicated a CRE site in regulation of FMR1 in neural cells but the role of this site is controversial. We now show that a phospho-CREB/ATF family member is bound to this site in vivo. We also find that the histone acetyltransferases CBP and p300 are associated with active FMR1 but are lost at the hypoacetylated fragile X allele. Surprisingly, FMR1 is not cAMP-inducible and resides in a newly recognized subclass of CREB-regulated genes. We have also elucidated a role for NRF-2 as a regulator of FMR1 in vivo through a previously unrecognized and highly conserved recognition site in FMR1. NRF-1 and NRF-2 act additively while NRF-2 synergizes with CREB/ATF at FMR1's promoter. These data add FMR1 to the collection of genes controlled by both NRF-1 and NRF-2 and disfavor its membership in the immediate early response group of genes.

Nab3's localization to a nuclear granule in response to nutrient deprivation is determined by its essential prion-like domain.

Ribonucleoprotein (RNP) granules are higher order assemblies of RNA, RNA-binding proteins, and other proteins, that regulate the transcriptome and protect RNAs from environmental challenge. There is a diverse range of RNP granules, many cytoplasmic, which provide various levels of regulation of RNA metabolism. Here we present evidence that the yeast transcription termination factor, Nab3, is targeted to intranuclear granules in response to glucose starvation by Nab3's proline/glutamine-rich, prion-like domain (PrLD) which can assemble into amyloid in vitro. Localization to the granule is reversible and sensitive to the chemical probe 1,6 hexanediol suggesting condensation is driven by phase separation. Nab3's RNA recognition motif is also required for localization as seen for other PrLD-containing RNA-binding proteins that phase separate. Although the PrLD is necessary, it is not sufficient to localize to the granule. A heterologous PrLD that functionally replaces Nab3's essential PrLD, directed localization to the nuclear granule, however a chimeric Nab3 molecule with a heterologous PrLD that cannot restore termination function or viability, does not form granules. The Nab3 nuclear granule shows properties similar to well characterized cytoplasmic compartments formed by phase separation, suggesting that, as seen for other elements of the transcription machinery, termination factor condensation is functionally important.

Compositional complexity of rods and rings.

Rods and rings (RRs) are large linear- or circular-shaped structures typically described as polymers of IMPDH (inosine monophosphate dehydrogenase). They have been observed across a wide variety of cell types and species and can be induced to form by inhibitors of IMPDH. RRs are thought to play a role in the regulation of de novo guanine nucleotide synthesis; however, the function and regulation of RRs is poorly understood. Here we show that the regulatory GTPase, ARL2, a subset of its binding partners, and several resident proteins at the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) also localize to RRs. We also have identified two new inducers of RR formation: AICAR and glucose deprivation. We demonstrate that RRs can be disassembled if guanine nucleotides can be generated by salvage synthesis regardless of the inducer. Finally, we show that there is an ordered addition of components as RRs mature, with IMPDH first forming aggregates, followed by ARL2, and only later calnexin, a marker of the ER. These findings suggest that RRs are considerably more complex than previously thought and that the function(s) of RRs may include involvement of a regulatory GTPase, its effectors, and potentially contacts with intracellular membranes.

The hnRNP-like Nab3 termination factor can employ heterologous prion-like domains in place of its own essential low complexity domain.

Many RNA-binding proteins possess domains with a biased amino acid content. A common property of these low complexity domains (LCDs) is that they assemble into an ordered amyloid form, juxtaposing RNA recognition motifs in a subcellular compartment in which RNA metabolism is focused. Yeast Nab3 is one such protein that contains RNA-binding domains and a low complexity, glutamine/proline-rich, prion-like domain that can self-assemble. Nab3 also contains a region of structural homology to human hnRNP-C that resembles a leucine zipper which can oligomerize. Here we show that the LCD and the human hnRNP-C homology domains of Nab3 were experimentally separable, as cells were viable with either segment, but not when both were missing. In exploiting the lethality of deleting these regions of Nab3, we were able to test if heterologous prion-like domains known to assemble into amyloid, could substitute for the native sequence. Those from the hnRNP-like protein Hrp1, the canonical prion Sup35, or the epsin-related protein Ent2, could rescue viability and enable the new Nab3 chimeric protein to support transcription termination. Other low complexity domains from RNA-binding, termination-related proteins or a yeast prion, could not. As well, an unbiased genetic selection revealed a new protein sequence that could rescue the loss of Nab3's essential domain via multimerization. This new sequence and Sup35's prion domain could also rescue the lethal loss of Hrp1's prion-like domain when substituted for it. This suggests there are different cross-functional classes of amyloid-forming LCDs and that appending merely any assembly-competent LCD to Nab3 does not restore function or rescue viability. The analysis has revealed the functional complexity of LCDs and provides a means by which the differing classes of LCD can be dissected and understood.

Determinants of Amyloid Formation for the Yeast Termination Factor Nab3.

Low complexity protein sequences are often intrinsically unstructured and many have the potential to polymerize into amyloid aggregates including filaments and hydrogels. RNA-binding proteins are unusually enriched in such sequences raising the question as to what function these domains serve in RNA metabolism. One such yeast protein, Nab3, is an 802 amino acid termination factor that contains an RNA recognition motif and a glutamine/proline rich domain adjacent to a region with structural similarity to a human hnRNP. A portion of the C-terminal glutamine/proline-rich domain assembles into filaments that organize into a hydrogel. Here we analyze the determinants of filament formation of the isolated low complexity domain as well as examine the polymerization properties of full-length Nab3. We found that the C-terminal region with structural homology to hnRNP-C is not required for assembly, nor is an adjacent stretch of 16 glutamines. However, reducing the overall glutamine composition of this 134-amino acid segment from 32% to 14% destroys its polymerization ability. Importantly, full-length wildtype Nab3 also formed filaments with a characteristic cross-ß structure which was dependent upon the glutamine/proline-rich region. When full length Nab3 with reduced glutamine content in its low complexity domain was exchanged for wildtype Nab3, cells were not viable. This suggests that polymerization of Nab3 is normally required for its function. In an extension of this idea, we show that the low complexity domain of another yeast termination factor, Pcf11, polymerizes into amyloid fibers and a hydrogel. These findings suggest that, like many other RNA binding proteins, termination factors share a common biophysical trait that may be important for their function.

Recent advances in understanding transcription termination by RNA polymerase II.

Transcription termination is a fundamental process in which RNA polymerase ceases RNA chain extension and dissociates from the chromatin template, thereby defining the end of the transcription unit. Our understanding of the biological role and functional importance of termination by RNA polymerase II and the range of processes in which it is involved has grown significantly in recent years. A large set of nucleic acid-binding proteins and enzymes have been identified as part of the termination machinery. A greater appreciation for the coupling of termination to RNA processing and metabolism has been recognized. In addition to serving as an essential step at the end of the transcription cycle, termination is involved in the regulation of a broad range of cellular processes. More recently, a role for termination in pervasive transcription, non-coding RNA regulation, genetic stability, chromatin remodeling, the immune response, and disease has come to the fore. Interesting mechanistic questions remain, but the last several years have resulted in significant insights into termination and an increasing recognition of its biological importance.

Amyloid-like assembly of the low complexity domain of yeast Nab3.

Termination of transcription of short non-coding RNAs is carried out in yeast by the Nab3-Nrd1-Sen1 complex. Nab3 and Nrd1 are hnRNP-like proteins that dimerize and bind RNA with sequence specificity. We show here that an essential region of Nab3 that is predicted to be prion-like based upon its sequence bias, formed amyloid-like filaments. A similar region from Nrd1 also assembled into filaments in vitro. The purified Nab3 domain formed a macroscopic gel whose lattice organization was observed by X-ray fiber diffraction. Filaments were resistant to dissociation in anionic detergent, bound the fluorescent dye thioflavin T, and showed a ß-sheet rich structure by circular dichroism spectroscopy, similar to human amyloid ß which served as a reference amyloid. A version of the Nab3 domain with a mutation that impairs its termination function, also formed fibers as observed by electron microscopy. Using a protein fragment interaction assay, the purified Nab3 domain was seen to interact with itself in living yeast. A similar observation was made for full length Nab3. These results suggest that the Nab3 and Nrd1 RNA-binding proteins can attain a complex polymeric form and raise the possibility that this property is important for organizing their functional state during termination. These findings are congruent with recent work showing that RNA binding proteins with low complexity domains form a dynamic subcellular matrix in which RNA metabolism takes place but can also aberrantly yield pathological aggregated particles.

Properties of an intergenic terminator and start site switch that regulate IMD2 transcription in yeast.

The IMD2 gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is regulated by intracellular guanine nucleotides. Regulation is exerted through the choice of alternative transcription start sites that results in synthesis of either an unstable short transcript terminating upstream of the start codon or a full-length productive IMD2 mRNA. Start site selection is dictated by the intracellular guanine nucleotide levels. Here we have mapped the polyadenylation sites of the upstream, unstable short transcripts that form a heterogeneous family of RNAs of approximately 200 nucleotides. The switch from the upstream to downstream start sites required the Rpb9 subunit of RNA polymerase II. The enzyme's ability to locate the downstream initiation site decreased exponentially as the start was moved downstream from the TATA box. This suggests that RNA polymerase II's pincer grip is important as it slides on DNA in search of a start site. Exosome degradation of the upstream transcripts was highly dependent upon the distance between the terminator and promoter. Similarly, termination was dependent upon the Sen1 helicase when close to the promoter. These findings extend the emerging concept that distinct modes of termination by RNA polymerase II exist and that the distance of the terminator from the promoter, as well as its sequence, is important for the pathway chosen.

Dissection of the molecular basis of mycophenolate resistance in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

IMP dehydrogenase (IMPDH) is required for the de novo synthesis of guanine nucleotides. While most invertebrates have one IMPDH gene and humans and mice have two, Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains four, IMD1-IMD4. Although Imd2 is 92% identical to Imd3, it is the only S. cerevisiae IMPDH that is resistant to mycophenolic acid in vitro and is the only one of the four that supports drug-resistant growth. Thus, S. cerevisiae is unique in possessing two classes of IMPDH enzymes with very different drug susceptibilities. The mycophenolate-sensitive growth phenotype has become an important genetic tool in yeast, particularly as an indicator for mutations in the transcription elongation machinery. Here we exploit the distinct drug sensitivity of these two closely related IMPDH genes to identify the naturally occurring determinants of drug-resistant growth. Using chimeric IMD2-IMD3 genes in a strain null for IMD genes, we show that one of the 39 amino acid differences between these enzymes is responsible for much of its drug resistance. The IMP dehydrogenase activity of purified chimeric Imd3 containing the Imd2 residue at position 253 was eight-fold more resistant than native Imd3. The reciprocal change in Imd2 resulted in a 23-fold loss of resistance. Hence, acquisition of a hydroxyl side-chain at 523 is sufficient to confer a drug-resistant phenotype upon this organism. We identified the major determinant of the functional distinction between IMD genes in this yeast and suggest that selective pressure on this species forced divergence of one member of this gene family toward drug resistance.