Synthesis and Properties of RNA Modified with Thioamide Internucleoside Linkage.

Recent success of RNA therapeutics has reinvigorated interest in chemical modifications of RNA. As exemplified by the phosphorothioates, modifications of sugar-phosphate backbone have been remarkably impactful but relatively underexplored in therapeutic RNAs. The present study reports synthesis, thermal stability, and RNA interference activity of RNAs modified with thioamide linkages. Compared to the previously studied amide-modified RNA, thioamide linkages strongly destabilized a short self-complementary RNA model duplex. However, in short interfering RNAs amides and thioamides had a similar effect on duplex stability and target RNA cleavage activity and specificity. Hence, the thioamide may be added to the toolbox of chemical biologist as a useful backbone modification well tolerated by the RNA interference machinery.

Conformational Morphing by a DNA Analogue Featuring 7-Deazapurines and 5-Halogenpyrimidines and the Origins of Adenine-Tract Geometry.

Several efforts are currently directed at the creation and cellular implementation of alternative genetic systems composed of pairing components that are orthogonal to the natural dA/dT and dG/dC base pairs. In an alternative approach, Watson-Crick-type pairing is conserved, but one or all of the four letters of the A, C, G, and T alphabet are substituted by modified components. Thus, all four nucleobases were altered to create halogenated deazanucleic acid (DZA): dA was replaced by 7-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine (dzA), dG by 7-deaza-2'-deoxyguanosine (dzG), dC by 5-fluoro-2'-deoxycytidine (FdC), and dT by 5-chloro-2'-deoxyuridine (CldU). This base-pairing system was previously shown to retain function in Escherichia coli. Here, we analyze the stability, hydration, structure, and dynamics of a DZA Dickerson-Drew Dodecamer (DDD) of sequence 5'-FdC-dzG-FdC-dzG-dzA-dzA-CldU-CldU-FdC-dzG-FdC-dzG-3'. Contrary to similar stabilities of DDD and DZA-DDD, osmotic stressing revealed a dramatic loss of hydration for the DZA-DDD relative to that for the DDD. The parent DDD 5'-d(CGCGAATTCGCG)-3' features an A-tract, a run of adenosines uninterrupted by a TpA step, and exhibits a hallmark narrow minor groove. Crystal structures─in the presence of RNase H─and MD simulations show increased conformational plasticity ("morphing") of DZA-DDD relative to that of the DDD. The narrow dzA-tract minor groove in one structure widens to resemble that in canonical B-DNA in a second structure. These changes reflect an indirect consequence of altered DZA major groove electrostatics (less negatively polarized compared to that in DNA) and hydration (reduced compared to that in DNA). Therefore, chemical modifications outside the minor groove that lead to collapse of major groove electrostatics and hydration can modulate A-tract geometry.

Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acid Controls Dynamic Conformations of RNA Bulges.

RNA folding is driven by the formation of double-helical segments interspaced by loops of unpaired nucleotides. Among the latter, bulges formed by one or several unpaired nucleotides are one of the most common structural motifs that play an important role in stabilizing RNA-RNA, RNA-protein, and RNA-small molecule interactions. Single-nucleotide bulges can fold in alternative structures where the unpaired nucleobase is either looped-out (flexible) in a solvent or stacked-in (intercalated) between the base pairs. In the present study, we discovered that triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) had unusually high affinity for single-purine-nucleotide bulges in double-helical RNA. Depending on the PNA's sequence, the triplex formation shifted the equilibrium between looped-out and stacked-in conformations. The ability to control the dynamic equilibria of RNA's structure will be an important tool for studying structure-function relationships in RNA biology and may have potential in novel therapeutic approaches targeting disease-related RNAs.

Nucleobase and Linker Modification for Triple-Helical Recognition of Pyrimidines in RNA Using Peptide Nucleic Acids.

Triple-helical recognition of any sequence of double-stranded RNA requires high affinity Hoogsteen hydrogen binding to pyrimidine interruptions of polypurine tracts. Because pyrimidines have only one hydrogen bond donor/acceptor on Hoogsteen face, their triple-helical recognition is a formidable problem. The present study explored various five-membered heterocycles and linkers that connect nucleobases to backbone of peptide nucleic acid (PNA) to optimize formation of X•C-G and Y•U-A triplets. Molecular modeling and biophysical (UV melting and isothermal titration calorimetry) results revealed a complex interplay between the heterocyclic nucleobase and linker to PNA backbone. While the five-membered heterocycles did not improve pyrimidine recognition, increasing the linker length by four atoms provided promising gains in binding affinity and selectivity. The results suggest that further optimization of heterocyclic bases with extended linkers to PNA backbone may be a promising approach to triple-helical recognition of RNA.

Improved Triplex-Forming Isoorotamide PNA Nucleobases for A-U Recognition of RNA Duplexes.

Four new isoorotamide (Io)-containing PNA nucleobases have been designed for A-U recognition of double helical RNA. New PNA monomers were prepared efficiently and incorporated into PNA nonamers for binding A-U in a PNA:RNA2 triplex. Isothermal titration calorimetry and UV thermal melting experiments revealed slightly improved binding affinity for singly modified PNA compared to known A-binding nucleobases. Molecular dynamics simulations provided further insights into binding of Io bases in the triple helix. Together, the data revealed interesting insights into binding modes including the notion that three Hoogsteen hydrogen bonds are unnecessary for strong selective binding of an extended nucleobase. Cationic monomer Io8 additionally gave the highest affinity observed for an A-binding nucleobase to date. These results will help inform future nucleobase design toward the goal of recognizing any sequence of double helical RNA.

Chemical Modifications of CRISPR RNAs to Improve Gene-Editing Activity and Specificity.

CRISPR (clustered, regularly interspaced, short palindromic repeats) has become a cutting-edge research method and holds great potential to revolutionize biotechnology and medicine. However, like other nucleic acid technologies, CRISPR will greatly benefit from chemical innovation to improve activity and specificity for critical in vivo applications. Chemists have started optimizing various components of the CRISPR system; the present Perspective focuses on chemical modifications of CRISPR RNAs (crRNAs). As with other nucleic acid-based technologies, early efforts focused on well-established sugar and backbone modifications (2'-deoxy, 2'-F, 2'-OMe, and phosphorothioates). Some more significant alterations of crRNAs have been done using bicyclic (locked) riboses and phosphate backbone replacements (phosphonoacetates and amides); however, the range of chemical innovation applied to crRNAs remains limited to modifications that have been successful in RNA interference and antisense technologies. The encouraging results given by these tried-and-true modifications suggest that, going forward, chemists should take a bolder approach─research must aim to investigate what chemistry will have the most impact on maturing CRISPR as therapeutic and other in vivo technologies. With an eye to the future, this Perspective argues that the complexity of CRISPR presents rich unprecedented opportunities for chemists to synergize advances in synthetic methodology and structural biochemistry to rationally optimize crRNA-protein interactions.

Fluorobenzene Nucleobase Analogues for Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids.

2,4-Difluorotoluene is a nonpolar isostere of thymidine that has been used as a powerful mechanistic probe to study the role of hydrogen bonding in nucleic acid recognition and interactions with polymerases. In the present study, we evaluated five fluorinated benzenes as nucleobase analogues in peptide nucleic acids designed for triple helical recognition of double helical RNA. We found that analogues having para and ortho fluorine substitution patterns (as in 2,4-difluorotoluene) selectively stabilized Hoogsteen triplets with U-A base pairs. The results were consistent with attractive electrostatic interactions akin to non-canonical F to H-N and C-H to N hydrogen bonding. The fluorinated nucleobases were not able to stabilize Hoogsteen-like triplets with pyrimidines in either G-C or A-U base pairs. Our results illustrate the ability of fluorine to engage in non-canonical base pairing and provide insights into triple helical recognition of RNA.

Enzymatic Beacons for Specific Sensing of Dilute Nucleic Acid.

Enzymatic beacons, or E-beacons, are 1 : 1 bioconjugates of the nanoluciferase enzyme linked covalently at its C-terminus to hairpin forming ssDNA equipped with a dark quencher. We prepared E-beacons biocatalytically using HhC, the promiscuous Hedgehog C-terminal protein-cholesterol ligase. HhC attached nanoluciferase site-specifically to mono-sterylated hairpin oligonucleotides, called steramers. Three E-beacon dark quenchers were evaluated: Iowa Black, Onyx-A, and dabcyl. Each quencher enabled sensitive, sequence-specific nucleic acid detection through enhanced E-beacon bioluminescence upon target hybridization. We assembled prototype dabcyl-quenched E-beacons specific for SARS-CoV-2. Targeting the E484 codon of the virus Spike protein, E-beacons (80×10-12  M) reported wild-type SARS-CoV-2 nucleic acid at ≥1×10-9  M by increased bioluminescence of 8-fold. E-beacon prepared for the SARS-CoV-2 E484K variant functioned with similar sensitivity. Both E-beacons could discriminate their target from the E484Q mutation of the SARS-CoV-2 Kappa variant. Along with mismatch specificity, E-beacons are two to three orders of magnitude more sensitive than synthetic molecular beacons.

Cellular uptake of 2-aminopyridine-modified peptide nucleic acids conjugated with cell-penetrating peptides.

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) have been extensively used to deliver peptide nucleic acid (PNA) in cells. We have previously found that replacement of cytosine in triplex-forming PNAs with 2-aminopyridine (M) not only enhanced RNA binding, but also improved cellular uptake of PNAs. In this study, we used confocal fluorescence microscopy to evaluate the ability of CPPs to further improve cellular uptake of M-modified PNAs. We found that PNAs conjugated with Tat and octa-arginine peptides were effectively taken up in MCF7 cells when supplied in cell media at 1 µM. Remarkably, M-modified PNA without any CPP conjugation also showed strong uptake when the concentration was increased to 5 µM. Majority of PNA conjugates remained localized in distinct cytoplasmic vesicles, as judged by dot-like fluorescence patterns. However, M-modified PNAs conjugated with Tat, octa-arginine, and even a simple tri-lysine peptide also showed dispersed fluorescence in cytoplasm and were taken up in nuclei where they localized in larger vesicles, most likely nucleoli. Endosomolytic peptides or chemicals (chloroquine and CaCl2 ) did not release the conjugates from cytosolic vesicles, which suggested that the PNAs were not entrapped in endosomes. We hypothesize that M-modified PNAs escape endosomes and accumulate in cellular compartments rich in RNA, such as nucleoli, stress granules, and P-bodies.

The 2-Aminopyridine Nucleobase Improves Triple-Helical Recognition of RNA and DNA When Used Instead of Pseudoisocytosine in Peptide Nucleic Acids.

Pseudoisocytosine (J), a neutral analogue of protonated cytosine, is currently the gold standard modified nucleobase in peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) for the formation of J·G-C triplets that are stable at physiological pH. This study shows that triple-helical recognition of RNA and DNA is significantly improved by using 2-aminopyridine (M) instead of J. The positively charged M forms 3-fold stronger M+·G-C triplets than J with uncompromised sequence selectivity. Replacement of six Js with Ms in a PNA 9-mer increased its binding affinity by ∼2 orders of magnitude. M-modified PNAs prefer binding double-stranded RNA over DNA and disfavor off-target binding to single-stranded nucleic acids. Taken together, the results show that M is a promising modified nucleobase that significantly improves triplex-forming PNAs and may provide breakthrough developments for therapeutic and biotechnology applications.

Amide-Modified RNA: Using Protein Backbone to Modulate Function of Short Interfering RNAs.

RNA-based technologies to control gene expression, such as RNA interference (RNAi) and CRISPR-Cas9, have become powerful tools in molecular biology and genomics. The exciting potential that RNAi and CRISPR-Cas9 may also become new therapeutic approaches has reinvigorated interest in chemically modifying RNA to improve its properties for in vivo applications. Chemical modifications can improve enzymatic stability, in vivo delivery, cellular uptake, and sequence specificity as well as minimize off-target activity of short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) and CRISPR associated RNAs. While numerous good solutions for improving stability toward enzymatic degradation have emerged, optimization of the latter functional properties remains challenging. In this Account, we discuss synthesis, structure, and biological activity of novel nonionic analogues of RNA that have the phosphodiester backbone replaced by amide linkages (AM1). Our long-term goal is to use the amide backbone to improve the stability and specificity of siRNAs and other functional RNAs. Our work in this area was motivated by early discoveries that nonionic backbone modifications, including AM1, did not disturb the overall structure or thermal stability of RNA duplexes. We hypothesized that the reduced negative charge and hydrophobic nature of the AM1 backbone modification might be useful in optimizing functional applications through enhanced cellular uptake, and might suppress unwanted off-target effects of siRNAs. NMR and X-ray crystallography studies showed that AM1 was an excellent mimic of phosphodiester linkages in RNA. The local conformational changes caused by the amide linkages were easily accommodated by small adjustments in RNA's conformation. Further, the amide carbonyl group assumed an orientation that is similar to one of the nonbridging P-O bonds, which may enable amide/phosphate mimicry by conserving hydrogen bonding interactions. The crystal structure of a short amide-modified DNA-RNA hybrid in complex with RNase H indicated that the amide N-H could also act as an H-bond donor to stabilize RNA-protein interactions, which is an interaction mode not available to phosphate groups. Functional assays established that amides were well tolerated at internal positions in both strands of siRNAs. Surprisingly, amide modifications in the middle of the guide strand and at the 5'-end of the passenger strand increased RNAi activity compared to unmodified siRNA. Most importantly, an amide linkage between the first and second nucleosides of the passenger strand completely abolished its undesired off-target activity while enhancing the desired RNAi activity. These results suggest that RNAi may tolerate more substantial modifications of siRNAs than the chemistries tried so far. The findings are also important and timely because they demonstrate that amide modifications may reduce off-target activity of siRNAs, which remains an important roadblock for clinical use of RNAi. Taken together, our work suggests that amide linkages have underappreciated potential to optimize the biological and pharmacological properties of RNA. Expanded use of amide linkages in RNA to enhance CRISPR and other technologies requiring chemically stable, functional mimics of noncoding RNAs is expected.

Extended Peptide Nucleic Acid Nucleobases Based on Isoorotic Acid for the Recognition of A-U Base Pairs in Double-Stranded RNA.

Peptide nucleic acids (PNA) with extended isoorotamide containing nucleobases (Io ) were designed for binding A-U base pairs in double-stranded RNA. Isothermal titration calorimetry and UV thermal melting experiments revealed improved affinity for A-U using the Io scaffold in PNA. PNAs having four sequential Io extended nucleobases maintained high binding affinity.

Chemical approaches to discover the full potential of peptide nucleic acids in biomedical applications.

Peptide nucleic acid (PNA) is arguably one of the most successful DNA mimics, despite a most dramatic departure from the native structure of DNA. The present review summarizes 30 years of research on PNA's chemistry, optimization of structure and function, applications as probes and diagnostics, and attempts to develop new PNA therapeutics. The discussion starts with a brief review of PNA's binding modes and structural features, followed by the most impactful chemical modifications, PNA enabled assays and diagnostics, and discussion of the current state of development of PNA therapeutics. While many modifications have improved on PNA's binding affinity and specificity, solubility and other biophysical properties, the original PNA is still most frequently used in diagnostic and other in vitro applications. Development of therapeutics and other in vivo applications of PNA has notably lagged behind and is still limited by insufficient bioavailability and difficulties with tissue specific delivery. Relatively high doses are required to overcome poor cellular uptake and endosomal entrapment, which increases the risk of toxicity. These limitations remain unsolved problems waiting for innovative chemistry and biology to unlock the full potential of PNA in biomedical applications.

Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids with Extended Backbones.

Peptide nucleic acid (PNA) forms a triple helix with double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) stabilized by a hydrogen-bonding zipper formed by PNA's backbone amides (N-H) interacting with RNA phosphate oxygens. This hydrogen-bonding pattern is enabled by the matching ∼5.7 Šspacing (typical for A-form dsRNA) between PNA's backbone amides and RNA phosphate oxygens. We hypothesized that extending the PNA's backbone by one -CH2 - group might bring the distance between PNA amide groups closer to 7 Å, which is favourable for hydrogen bonding to the B-form dsDNA phosphate oxygens. Extension of the PNA backbone was expected to selectively stabilize PNA-DNA triplexes compared to PNA-RNA. To test this hypothesis, we synthesized triplex-forming PNAs that had the pseudopeptide backbones extended by an additional -CH2 - group in three different positions. Isothermal titration calorimetry measurements of the binding affinity of these extended PNA analogues for the matched dsDNA and dsRNA showed that, contrary to our structural reasoning, extending the PNA backbone at any position had a strong negative effect on triplex stability. Our results suggest that PNAs might have an inherent preference for A-form-like conformations when binding double-stranded nucleic acids. It appears that the original six-atom-long PNA backbone is an almost perfect fit for binding to A-form nucleic acids.

Synthesis and Biological Activity of Short Interfering RNAs Having Several Consecutive Amide Internucleoside Linkages.

The success of RNA interference (RNAi) as a research tool and potential therapeutic approach has reinvigorated interest in chemical modifications of RNA. Replacement of the negatively charged phosphates with neutral amides may be expected to improve bioavailability and cellular uptake of small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) critical for in vivo applications. In this study, we introduced up to seven consecutive amide linkages at the 3'-end of the guide strand of an siRNA duplex. Modified guide strands having four consecutive amide linkages retained high RNAi activity when paired with a passenger strand having one amide modification between its first and second nucleosides at the 5'-end. Further increase in the number of modifications decreased the RNAi activity; however, siRNAs with six and seven amide linkages still showed useful target silencing. While an siRNA duplex having nine amide linkages retained some silencing activity, the partial reduction of the negative charge did not enable passive uptake in HeLa cells. Our results suggest that further chemical modifications, in addition to amide linkages, are needed to enable cellular uptake of siRNAs in the absence of transfection agents.

Sequence-selective recognition of double-stranded RNA and enhanced cellular uptake of cationic nucleobase and backbone-modified peptide nucleic acids.

Sequence-selective recognition of complex RNAs in live cells could find broad applications in biology, biomedical research, and biotechnology. However, specific recognition of structured RNA is challenging, and generally applicable and effective methods are lacking. Recently, we found that peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) were unusually well-suited ligands for recognition of double-stranded RNAs. Herein, we report that 2-aminopyridine (M) modified PNAs and their conjugates with lysine and arginine tripeptides form strong (Ka = 9.4 to 17 × 107 M-1) and sequence-selective triple helices with RNA hairpins at physiological pH and salt concentration. The affinity of PNA-peptide conjugates for the matched RNA hairpins was unusually high compared to the much lower affinity for DNA hairpins of the same sequence (Ka = 0.05 to 1.1 × 107 M-1). The binding of double-stranded RNA by M-modified PNA-peptide conjugates was a relatively fast process (kon = 2.9 × 104 M-1 sec-1) compared to the notoriously slow triple helix formation by oligodeoxynucleotides (kon ∼ 103 M-1 sec-1). M-modified PNA-peptide conjugates were not cytotoxic and were efficiently delivered in the cytosol of HEK293 cells at 10 µM. Surprisingly, M-modified PNAs without peptide conjugation were also taken up by HEK293 cells, which, to the best of our knowledge, is the first example of heterocyclic base modification that enhances the cellular uptake of PNA. Our results suggest that M-modified PNA-peptide conjugates are promising probes for sequence-selective recognition of double-stranded RNA in live cells and other biological systems.

Synthetic, Structural, and RNA Binding Studies on 2-Aminopyridine-Modified Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids.

The development of new RNA-binding ligands is attracting increasing interest in fundamental science and the pharmaceutical industry. The goal of this study was to improve the RNA binding properties of triplex-forming peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) by further increasing the pKa of 2-aminopyridine (M). Protonation of M was the key for enabling triplex formation at physiological pH in earlier studies. Substitution on M by an electron-donating 4-methoxy substituent resulted in slight destabilization of the PNA-dsRNA triplex, contrary to the expected stabilization due to more favorable protonation. To explain this unexpected result, the first NMR structural studies were performed on an M-modified PNA-dsRNA triplex which, combined with computational modeling identified unfavorable steric and electrostatic repulsion between the 4-methoxy group of M and the oxygen of the carbonyl group connecting the adjacent nucleobase to PNA backbone. The structural studies also provided insights into hydrogen-bonding interactions that might be responsible for the high affinity and unusual RNA-binding preference of PNAs.

Synthesis and RNA-Binding Properties of Extended Nucleobases for Triplex-Forming Peptide Nucleic Acids.

Triple-helix formation, using Hoogsteen hydrogen bonding of triplex-forming oligonucleotides, represents an attractive method for sequence-specific recognition of double-stranded nucleic acids. However, practical applications using triple-helix-forming oligonucleotides and their analogues are limited to long homopurine sequences. The key problem for recognition of pyrimidines is that they present only one hydrogen-bond acceptor or donor group in the major groove. Herein, we report our first attempt to overcome this problem by using peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) modified with extended nucleobases that form three hydrogen bonds along the entire Hoogsteen edge of the Watson-Crick base pair. New nucleobase triples (five) were designed, and their hydrogen bonding feasibility was confirmed by ab initio calculations. PNA monomers carrying the modified nucleobases were synthesized and incorporated in short model PNA sequences. Isothermal titration calorimetry showed that these nucleobases had a modest binding affinity for their double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) targets. Finally, molecular modeling of the modified triples in PNA-dsRNA helix suggested that the modest binding affinity was caused by subtle structural deviations from ideal hydrogen-bonding arrangements or disrupted π-stacking of the extended nucleobase scaffolds.

Amide linkages mimic phosphates in RNA interactions with proteins and are well tolerated in the guide strand of short interfering RNAs.

While the use of RNA interference (RNAi) in molecular biology and functional genomics is a well-established technology, in vivo applications of synthetic short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) require chemical modifications. We recently found that amides as non-ionic replacements for phosphodiesters may be useful modifications for optimization of siRNAs. Herein, we report a comprehensive study of systematic replacement of a single phosphate with an amide linkage throughout the guide strand of siRNAs. The results show that amides are surprisingly well tolerated in the seed and central regions of the guide strand and increase the silencing activity when placed between nucleosides 10 and 12, at the catalytic site of Argonaute. A potential explanation is provided by the first crystal structure of an amide-modified RNA-DNA with Bacillus halodurans RNase H1. The structure reveals how small changes in both RNA and protein conformation allow the amide to establish hydrogen bonding interactions with the protein. Molecular dynamics simulations suggest that these alternative binding modes may compensate for interactions lost due to the absence of a phosphodiester moiety. Our results suggest that an amide can mimic important hydrogen bonding interactions with proteins required for RNAi activity and may be a promising modification for optimization of biological properties of siRNAs.

2-Methoxypyridine as a Thymidine Mimic in Watson-Crick Base Pairs of DNA and PNA: Synthesis, Thermal Stability, and NMR Structural Studies.

The development of nucleic acid base-pair analogues that use new modes of molecular recognition is important both for fundamental research and practical applications. The goal of this study was to evaluate 2-methoxypyridine as a cationic thymidine mimic in the A-T base pair. The hypothesis was that including protonation in the Watson-Crick base pairing scheme would enhance the thermal stability of the DNA double helix without compromising the sequence selectivity. DNA and peptide nucleic acid (PNA) sequences containing the new 2-methoxypyridine nucleobase (P) were synthesized and studied by using UV thermal melting and NMR spectroscopy. Introduction of P nucleobase caused a loss of thermal stability of ≈10 °C in DNA-DNA duplexes and ≈20 °C in PNA-DNA duplexes over a range of mildly acidic to neutral pH. Despite the decrease in thermal stability, the NMR structural studies showed that P-A formed the expected protonated base pair at pH 4.3. Our study demonstrates the feasibility of cationic unnatural base pairs; however, future optimization of such analogues will be required.