Size-Controlled Synthesis of Gold Nanoparticles Tethering Antimicrobial Peptides with Potent Broad-Spectrum Antimicrobial and Antibiofilm Activities.

New antimicrobials are urgently needed to combat the rising global health concern of antibiotic resistance. Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are one of the leading candidates as new antimicrobials since they target bacterial membranes and are therefore less prone to bacterial resistance. However, poor enzymatic stability, high production costs, and toxicity are drawbacks that limit their clinical use. Conjugation of AMPs to gold nanoparticles (NPs) may help to improve enzymatic stability and, thus, their overall antimicrobial efficiency. We did a one-pot synthesis of size-controlled (10 nm) gold NPs selectively conjugated to lipopeptides and determined their antibacterial activity. The conjugates exhibited potent (0.13-1.25 µM) antimicrobial activity against clinical isolates, including Gram-positive methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) ATCC33593, Gram-negative Escherichia coli (E. coli) CTX-M-14, multidrug-resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa LESB58 and Acinetobacter baumannii ATCC19606, and showed promising activity (90% inhibition of initial biofilms and 80% reduction of preformed biofilms) against S. aureus and E. coli DH5α biofilms at low micromolar concentrations. The conjugates were stable in rat serum and not toxic to representative mammalian cell lines in vitro (≤64 µM) and in vivo (≤100 µM).

Accessing the Thiol Toolbox: Synthesis and Structure-Activity Studies on Fluoro-Thiol Conjugated Antimicrobial Peptides.

The para-fluoro-thiol reaction (PFTR) is a modern name for the much older concept of a nucleophilic aromatic substitution reaction in which the para-position fluorine of a perfluorinated benzene moiety is substituted by a thiol. As a rapid and mild reaction, the PFTR is a useful technique for the post-synthetic modification of macromolecules like peptides on the solid phase. This reaction is of great potential since it allows for peptide chemists to access the vast catalogue of commercially available thiols with diverse structures to conjugate to peptides, which may impart favorable biological activity, particularly in antimicrobial sequences. This work covers the generation of a library of antimicrobial peptides by modifying a relatively inactive tetrapeptide with thiols of various structures using the PFTR to grant antimicrobial potency to the core sequence. In general, nucleophilic substitution of the peptide scaffold by hydrophobic thiols like cyclohexanethiol and octanethiol imparted the greatest antimicrobial activity over that of hydrophilic thiols bearing carboxylic acid or sugar moieties, which were ineffectual at improving the antimicrobial activity. The general trend here follows expected structure-activity relationship outcomes like that of changing the acyl group of lipopeptide antibiotics and is encouraging for the use of this reaction for structural modifications of antimicrobial sequences further.

Development of truncated Battacin antimicrobials featuring novel N-terminal fatty acids with an excellent safety profile.

Octapeptin B5 peptides containing a novel fatty acids have been found to have enhanced antibacterial activity against Staphylococcus aureus and also have an excellent safety profile. Cyclic lipopeptides such as the polymyxins and battacin are potent antibacterial agents. It has been shown that truncated, non-linear, versions of these agents (e.g. octapeptin B5) can retain the activity of the more complex cyclic compounds. In this work the synthesis of Octapeptin B5 peptides containing a range of novel fatty acids is reported. Many of these lipopeptides have been found to have enhanced antibacterial activity against Staphylococcus aureus compared to Octapeptin B5 whilst also having an excellent safety profile in haemolytic and cytotoxicity assays.

Structural characterization of a PCP-R didomain from an archaeal nonribosomal peptide synthetase reveals novel interdomain interactions.

Nonribosomal peptide synthetases (NRPSs) are multimodular enzymes that produce a wide range of bioactive peptides, such as siderophores, toxins, and antibacterial and insecticidal agents. NRPSs are dynamic proteins characterized by extensive interdomain communications as a consequence of their assembly-line mode of synthesis. Hence, crystal structures of multidomain fragments of NRPSs have aided in elucidating crucial interdomain interactions that occur during different steps of the NRPS catalytic cycle. One crucial yet unexplored interaction is that between the reductase (R) domain and the peptide carrier protein (PCP) domain. R domains are members of the short-chain dehydrogenase/reductase family and function as termination domains that catalyze the reductive release of the final peptide product from the terminal PCP domain of the NRPS. Here, we report the crystal structure of an archaeal NRPS PCP-R didomain construct. This is the first NRPS R domain structure to be determined together with the upstream PCP domain and is also the first structure of an archaeal NRPS to be reported. The structure reveals that a novel helix-turn-helix motif, found in NRPS R domains but not in other short-chain dehydrogenase/reductase family members, plays a major role in the interface between the PCP and R domains. The information derived from the described PCP-R interface will aid in gaining further mechanistic insights into the peptide termination reaction catalyzed by the R domain and may have implications in engineering NRPSs to synthesize novel peptide products.

Toward cheaper light harvesting systems: Using earth-abundant metal oxide nanoparticles in self-assembled peptide-porphyrin nanofibers.

Cheap artificial light harvesting systems, which competently harvest solar energy and promote efficient energy transfer, are highly sought after in the renewable sector. We report the synthesis of self-assembled peptide-porphyrin fibers (SJ 6) fabricated with iron(III) oxide (Fe3 O4 ) nanoparticles as feasible electron acceptors. Charge-complementarity between the negatively charged peptide (20E) and the protonated Zn-tetraphenyl porphyrin (ZnTPyP) led to an ordered assembly of the ZnTPyP molecules, enabling efficient light harvesting. X-ray diffraction data indicates a more ordered structure in SJ 6 compared to 20E and ZnTPyP. The incorporation of Fe3 O4 nanoparticles into SJ 6 showed significant fluorescence quenching, indicating efficient electron flow from the donor to the acceptor. The SJ 6-nFe3 O4 system performed the light reaction of photosynthesis as confirmed by the reduction of 1 mM NAD+ to 0.180 mM NADH upon exposure to visible light (Xe lamp λ > 420 nm) for 1 h. The photochemical regeneration of NADH using the SJ 6-nFe3 O4 system was coupled to glutamate dehydrogenase-catalyzed conversion of α-ketoglutarate to L-glutamate. These results confirm the successful synthesis of an artificial light harvesting peptide-porphyrin system with Fe3 O4 nanoparticles as promising low-cost electron separators.

Mechanistic insight into functionally different human islet polypeptide (hIAPP) amyloid: the intrinsic role of the C-terminal structural motifs.

Targeting amyloidosis requires high-resolution insight into the underlying mechanisms of amyloid aggregation. The sequence-specific intrinsic properties of a peptide or protein largely govern the amyloidogenic propensity. Thus, it is essential to delineate the structural motifs that define the subsequent downstream amyloidogenic cascade of events. Additionally, it is important to understand the role played by extrinsic factors, such as temperature or sample agitation, in modulating the overall energy barrier that prompts divergent nucleation events. Consequently, these changes can affect the fibrillation kinetics, resulting in structurally and functionally distinct amyloidogenic conformers associated with disease pathogenesis. Here, we have focused on human Islet Polypeptide (hIAPP) amyloidogenesis for the full-length peptide along with its N- and C-terminal fragments, under different temperatures and sample agitation conditions. This helped us to gain a comprehensive understanding of the intrinsic role of specific functional epitopes in the primary structure of the peptide that regulates amyloidogenesis and subsequent cytotoxicity. Intriguingly, our study involving an array of biophysical experiments and ex vivo data suggests a direct influence of external changes on the C-terminal fibrillating sequence. Furthermore, the observations indicate a possible collaborative role of this segment in nucleating hIAPP amyloidogenesis in a physiological scenario, thus making it a potential target for future therapeutic interventions.

Carbon Monoxide is an Inhibitor of HIF Prolyl Hydroxylase Domain 2.

Hypoxia-inducible factor prolyl hydroxylase domain 2 (PHD2) is an important oxygen sensor in animals. By using the CO-releasing molecule-2 (CORM-2) as an in situ CO donor, we demonstrate that CO is an inhibitor of PHD2. This report provides further evidence about the emerging role of CO in oxygen sensing and homeostasis.

Cyclic Tetrapeptides from Nature and Design: A Review of Synthetic Methodologies, Structure, and Function.

Small cyclic peptides possess a wide range of biological properties and unique structures that make them attractive to scientists working in a range of areas from medicinal to materials chemistry. However, cyclic tetrapeptides (CTPs), which are important members of this family, are notoriously difficult to synthesize. Various synthetic methodologies have been developed that enable access to natural product CTPs and their rationally designed synthetic analogues having novel molecular structures. These methodologies include the use of reversible protecting groups such as pseudoprolines that restrict conformational freedom, ring contraction strategies, on-resin cyclization approaches, and optimization of coupling reagents and reaction conditions such as temperature and dilution factors. Several fundamental studies have documented the impacts of amino acid configurations, N-alkylation, and steric bulk on both synthetic success and ensuing conformations. Carefully executed retrosynthetic ring dissection and the unique structural features of the linear precursor sequences that result from the ring dissection are crucial for the success of the cyclization step. Other factors that influence the outcome of the cyclization step include reaction temperature, solvent, reagents used as well as dilution levels. The purpose of this review is to highlight the current state of affairs on naturally occurring and rationally designed cyclic tetrapeptides, including strategies investigated for their syntheses in the literature, the conformations adopted by these molecules, and specific examples of their function. Using selected examples from the literature, an in-depth discussion of the synthetic techniques and reaction parameters applied for the successful syntheses of 12-, 13-, and 14-membered natural product CTPs and their novel analogues are presented, with particular focus on the cyclization step. Selected examples of the three-dimensional structures of cyclic tetrapeptides studied by NMR, and X-ray crystallography are also included.

Cyclic peptides bearing the d-Phe-2-Abz turn motif: Structural characterization and antimicrobial potential.

The effect on secondary structure and antimicrobial activity of introducing different cyclic constraints in linear ß-hairpin antimicrobial peptides has been investigated with the intention of generating cyclic ß sheets as promising antimicrobials with improved therapeutic potential. The linear peptides were cyclized head to tail either directly or after the addition of either a second turn motif or a disulfide bridge. The propensity of these peptides to adopt a cyclic ß-sheet structure has been correlated to their antibacterial activity. All cyclic peptides showed enhanced activity, compared with their linear counterparts against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus. Scanning electron microscopy and transmission electron microscopy studies showed that this family kills bacteria through membrane lysis. The peptide that showed the best efficacy against all strains (exhibiting nanomolar activity), while retaining low haemolysis, bears two symmetrical, homochiral d-phe-2-Abz-d-ala turns and adopted a flexible structure. Its twin peptide that bears heterochiral turns (one with d-ala and one with L-Ala) showed reduced antibacterial activity and higher percentage of haemolysis. Circular dichroism and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy indicate that heterochirality in the two turns leads to oligomerization of the peptide at higher concentrations, stabilizing the ß-sheet secondary structure. More rigid secondary structure is associated with lower activity against bacteria and loss of selectivity.

Covalently Immobilized Battacin Lipopeptide Gels with Activity against Bacterial Biofilms.

Novel antibiotic treatments are in increasing demand to tackle life-threatening infections from bacterial pathogens. In this study, we report the use of a potent battacin lipopeptide as an antimicrobial gel to inhibit planktonic and mature biofilms of S. aureus and P. aeruginosa. The antimicrobial gels were made by covalently linking the N-terminal cysteine containing lipopeptide (GZ3.163) onto the polyethylene glycol polymer matrix and initiating gelation using thiol-ene click chemistry. The gels were prepared both in methanol and in water and were characterised using rheology, Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Antibacterial and antibiofilm analyses revealed that the gels prepared in methanol have better antibacterial and antibiofilm activity. Additionally, a minimum peptide content of 0.5 wt% (relative to polymer content) is required to successfully inhibit the planktonic bacterial growth and disperse mature biofilms of P. aeruginosa and S. aureus. The antibacterial activity of these lipopeptide gels is mediated by a contact kill mechanism of action. The gels are non-haemolytic against mouse red blood cells and are non-cytotoxic against human dermal fibroblasts. Findings from this study show that battacin lipopeptide gels have the potential to be developed as novel topical antibacterial agents to combat skin infections, particularly caused by S. aureus.

Synthesis and Antibacterial Analysis of Analogues of the Marine Alkaloid Pseudoceratidine.

In an effort to gain more understanding on the structure activity relationship of pseudoceratidine 1, a di-bromo pyrrole spermidine alkaloid derived from the marine sponge Pseudoceratina purpurea that has been shown to exhibit potent biofouling, anti-fungal, antibacterial, and anti-malarial activities, a large series of 65 compounds that incorporated several aspects of structural variation has been synthesised through an efficient, divergent method that allowed for a number of analogues to be generated from common precursors. Subsequently, all analogues were assessed for their antibacterial activity against both Gram-positive (Staphylococcus aureus) and Gram-negative (Escherichia coli) bacteria. Overall, several compounds exhibited comparable or better activity than that of pseudoceratidine 1, and it was found that this class of compounds is generally more effective against Gram-positive than Gram-negative bacteria. Furthermore, altering several structural features allowed for the establishment of a comprehensive structure activity relationship (SAR), where it was concluded that several structural features are critical for potent anti-bacterial activity, including di-halogenation (preferable bromine, but chlorine is also effective) on the pyrrole ring, two pyrrolic units in the structure and with one or more secondary amines in the chain adjoining these units, with longer chains giving rise to better activities.

A Multitargeted Approach: Organorhodium Anticancer Agent Based on Vorinostat as a Potent Histone Deacetylase Inhibitor.

The combination of more than one bioactive moiety in a multitargeted anticancer agent may result in synergistic activity of its components. Using this concept, bioorganometallic compounds were designed to feature a metal center, a 2-pyridinecarbothioamide (PCA), and a hydroxamic acid, which is found in the anticancer drug vorinostat (SAHA). The organometallics showed inhibitory activity in the nanomolar range against histone deacetylases (HDACs) as the key target for SAHA. In particular, the Rh complex was a potent inhibitor of HDAC6 over HDAC1 and HDAC8. Whereas this complex was highly cytotoxic in human cancer cells, it showed low toxicity in hemolysis studies and zebrafish, demonstrating the role of the metal center. For this complex a slightly reduced expression of vascular endothelial growth factor receptor 2 (VEGFR2) was established, which was upregulated by SAHA. This finding indicates that the new organometallics display different modes of action than their bioactive components.

Design, Synthesis, Antibacterial Potential, and Structural Characterization of N-Acylated Derivatives of the Human Autophagy 16 Polypeptide.

A synthetic antimicrobial peptide library based on the human autophagy 16 polypeptide has been developed. Designed acetylated peptides bearing lipids of different chain lengths resulted in peptides with enhanced potency compared to the parent Atg16. A 21-residue fragment of Atg16 conjugated to 4-methylhexanoic acid (K30) emerged as the most potent antibacterial, with negligible hemolysis. Several studies, including microscopy, dye leakage, and ITC, were conducted to gain insight into the antibacterial mechanism of action of the peptide. Visual inspection using both SEM and TEM revealed the membranolytic effect of the peptide on bacterial cells. The selectivity of the peptide against bacterial cell membranes was also proven using dye leakage assays. ITC analysis revealed the exothermic nature of the binding interaction of the peptide to D8PG micelles. The three-dimensional solution NMR structure of K30 in complex with dioctanoylphosphatidylglycerol (D8PG) micelles revealed that the peptide adopts a helix-loop-helix structure in the presence of anionic membrane lipids mimicking bacterial membranes. Intermolecular NOEs between the peptide and lipid deciphered the location of the peptide in the bound state, which was subsequently supported by the paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) NMR experiment. Collectively, these results describe the structure-function relationship of the peptide in the bacterial membrane.

Battacin-Inspired Ultrashort Peptides: Nanostructure Analysis and Antimicrobial Activity.

Peptides can serve as versatile therapeutics with a highly modular structure and tunable biophysical properties. In particular, the efficacy of peptide antibiotics against drug-resistant pathogens is of great promise, as few new classes of antibiotics are being developed to overcome the ever-increasing bacterial resistance to contemporary drugs. This work reports biophysical and antimicrobial studies of a designed library of ultrashort peptides that self-assemble into hydrogels at concentrations as low as 0.5% w/v in buffered saline, as confirmed by rheology. The hydrogels are constituted by ß-sheet-rich nanofibril networks, as determined by biophysical techniques including spectroscopy (attenuated total reflectance Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and Congo red binding assay), short- and wide-angle X-ray scattering, and electron microscopy. Both peptide solutions and self-assembled hydrogels show potent antimicrobial activity against S. aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa by membrane lysis. These peptides also displayed selectivity toward bacterial cells over human dermal fibroblasts in vitro, as determined from Live/Dead, scanning electron microscopy, and coculture assays. This work reports an antimicrobial self-assembling motif of only three residues comprising an aromatically acylated cationic d-Dab/Lys amino acid, a second cationic residue, and naphthylalanine that heavily influences the self-assembly of these peptides into hydrogels. The variations in the antimicrobial activity and self-assembly properties between analogues may have implications in future studies on the correlation between self-assembly and biological activity in ultrashort peptides.

Solution structure of linear battacin lipopeptides - the effect of lengthening fatty acid chain.

In recent years, lipopeptides have received attention for their enhanced antimicrobial activity, especially against multi-drug resistant (MDR) pathogens. We have previously reported that the bacterial soil extracted, novel cyclic lipopeptide, battacin, and its synthetic analogues have enhanced antimicrobial activity against various Gram negative, Gram positive and fungal pathogens. In particular, the modification of the hydrophobic fatty acid chain and molecular structure has improved its activity. We have used small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and circular dichroism (CD) to characterise the low resolution structure of battacin lipopeptides containing covalently bonded fatty acid chains and the one without it. In the absence of fatty acids or with short fatty acid chain, the peptides adopted an extended random coil structure that is best described barbell-like shape, while fatty acids that are sufficiently long induced an aggregation into a ∼4.0 nm diameter core shell sphere. While the kinked structure found within this barbell shape may have a role in antimicrobial activities, the self-assembly of the battacin analogue with the longest fatty acid chain may have a correlation to the declined antibacterial activities.

A review on anti-tuberculosis peptides: Impact of peptide structure on anti-tuberculosis activity.

Antibiotic resistance is a major public health problem globally. Particularly concerning amongst drug-resistant human pathogens is Mycobacterium tuberculosis that causes the deadly infectious tuberculosis (TB) disease. Significant issues associated with current treatment options for drug-resistant TB and the high rate of mortality from the disease makes the development of novel treatment options against this pathogen an urgent need. Antimicrobial peptides are part of innate immunity in all forms of life and could provide a potential solution against drug-resistant TB. This review is a critical analysis of antimicrobial peptides that are reported to be active against the M tuberculosis complex exclusively. However, activity on non-TB strains such as Mycobacterium avium and Mycobacterium intracellulare, whenever available, have been included at appropriate sections for these anti-TB peptides. Natural and synthetic antimicrobial peptides of diverse sequences, along with their chemical structures, are presented, discussed, and correlated to their observed antimycobacterial activities. Critical analyses of the structure allied to the anti-mycobacterial activity have allowed us to draw important conclusions and ideas for research and development on these promising molecules to realise their full potential. Even though the review is focussed on peptides, we have briefly summarised the structures and potency of the various small molecule drugs that are available and under development, for TB treatment.

Molecular Weight and Charge Density Effects of Guanidinylated Biodegradable Polycarbonates on Antimicrobial Activity and Selectivity.

Six guanidine functionalized aliphatic biodegradable polycarbonates with varying molecular weights and charge densities were synthesized via postsynthesis modification of alkyne containing polycarbonates using Cu(I)-catalyzed azide-alkyne cycloaddition (CuAAC) click chemistry. The concept of passive diluting group was to modify the cationic charge density of the polycarbonate without changing its hydrophilicity. Within the molecular weight range from 8000 to 30000 g mol-1, these guanidine polycarbonates exhibited broad-spectrum biocidal activity with low toxicity to red blood cells (RBCs). The lowest molecular weight homopolymer sample (PG-8k-100) showed the best antimicrobial activity (MIC = 40 µg/mL against Escherichia coli and MIC = 20 µg/mL against Staphylococcus epidermidis) and least RBC toxicity (0.6% hemolysis at MIC). Within the three guanidine charge densities from 20% to 70%, the low to medium dilution samples (PG-8k-7030 and PG-8k-5050) had no obvious loss in antimicrobial activities compared to the nondiluted control sample PG-8k-100. However, upon further dilution, PG-8k-2080 gave the lowest antimicrobial activity.

Acyclic peptides incorporating the d-Phe-2-Abz turn motif: Investigations on antimicrobial activity and propensity to adopt ß-hairpin conformations.

Three linear peptides incorporating d-Phe-2-Abz as the turn motif are reported. Peptide 1, a hydrophobic ß-hairpin, served as a proof of principle for the design strategy with both NMR and CD spectra strongly suggesting a ß-hairpin conformation. Peptides 2 and 3, designed as amphipathic antimicrobials, exhibited broad spectrum antimicrobial activity, with potency in the nanomolar range against Staphylococcus aureus. Both compounds possess a high degree of selectivity, proving non-haemolytic at concentrations 500 to 800 times higher than their respective minimal inhibitory concentrations (MICs) against S. aureus. Peptide 2 induced cell membrane and cell wall disintegration in both S. aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa as observed by transmission electron microscopy. Peptide 2 also demonstrated moderate antifungal activity against Candida albicans with an MIC of 50 µM. Synergism was observed with sub-MIC levels of amphotericin B (AmB), leading to nanomolar MICs against C. albicans for peptide 2. Based on circular dichroism spectra, both peptides 2 and 3 appear to exist as a mixture of conformers with the ß-hairpin as a minor conformer in aqueous solution, and a slight increase in hairpin population in 50% trifluoroethanol, which was more pronounced for peptide 3. NMR spectra of peptide 2 in a 1:1 CD3 CN/H2 O mixture and 30 mM deuterated sodium dodecyl sulfate showed evidence of an extended backbone conformation of the ß-strand residues. However, inter-strand rotating frame Overhauser effects (ROE) could not be detected and a loosely defined divergent hairpin structure resulted from ROE structure calculation in CD3 CN/H2 O. The loosely defined hairpin conformation is most likely a result of the electrostatic repulsions between cationic strand residues which also probably contribute towards maintaining low haemolytic activity.

Recent Developments in Antimicrobial-Peptide-Conjugated Gold Nanoparticles.

The escalation of multidrug-resistant pathogens has created a dire need to develop novel ways of addressing this global therapeutic challenge. Because of their antimicrobial activities, the combination of antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and nanoparticles is a promising tool with which to kill drug-resistant pathogens. In recent years, several studies using AMP-nanoparticle conjugates, especially metallic nanoparticles, as potential antimicrobial agents against drug-resistant pathogens have been published. Among these, antimicrobial-peptide-conjugated gold nanoparticles (AMP-AuNPs) are particularly attractive because of the nontoxic nature of gold and the possibility of fine-tuning the AMP-NP conjugation chemistry. The following review discusses recent developments in the synthesis and antimicrobial activity studies of AMP-AuNPs. The classification of AMPs, their mechanisms of action, methods used for functionalizing AuNPs with AMPs, and the antimicrobial activities of the conjugates are discussed.

A review on comparative mechanistic studies of antimicrobial peptides against archaea.

Archaea was until recently considered as a third domain of life in addition to bacteria and eukarya but recent studies support the existence of only two superphyla (bacteria and archaea). The fundamental differences between archaeal, bacterial, and eukaryal cells are probably the main reasons for the comparatively lower susceptibility of archaeal strains to current antimicrobial agents. The possible emerging pathogenicity of archaea and the role of archaeal methanogens in methane emissions, a potent greenhouse gas, has led many researchers to examine the sensitivity patterns of archaea and make attempts to find agents that have significant anti-archaeal activity. Even though antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are well known with several published reviews concerning their mode of action against bacteria and eukarya, to our knowledge, to date no reviews are available that focus on the action of these peptides against archaea. Herein, we present a review on all the peptides that have been tested against archaea. In addition, in an attempt to shed more light on possible future work that needs to be performed we have included a brief overview of the chemical characteristics, spectrum of activity, and the known mechanism of action of each of these peptides against bacteria and/or fungi. We also discuss the nature of and key physiological differences between Archaea, Bacteria, and Eukarya that are relevant to the development of anti-archaeal peptides. Despite our relatively limited knowledge about archaea, available data suggest that AMPs have an even broader spectrum of activity than currently recognized.