Occipital nerve stimulation in medically intractable, chronic cluster headache. The ICON study: rationale and protocol of a randomised trial.

BACKGROUND: About 10% of cluster headache patients have the chronic form. At least 10% of this chronic group is intractable to or cannot tolerate medical treatment. Open pilot studies suggest that occipital nerve stimulation (ONS) might offer effective prevention in these patients. Controlled neuromodulation studies in treatments inducing paraesthesias have a general problem in blinding. We have introduced a new design in pain neuromodulation by which we think we can overcome this problem. METHODS/DESIGN: We propose a prospective, randomised, double-blind, parallel-group international clinical study in medically intractable, chronic cluster headache patients of high- versus low-amplitude ONS. Primary outcome measure is the mean number of attacks over the last four weeks. After a study period of six months there is an open extension phase of six months. Alongside the randomised trial an economic evaluation study is performed. DISCUSSION: The ICON study will show if ONS is an effective preventive therapy for patients suffering medically intractable chronic cluster headache and if there is a difference between high- and low-amplitude stimulation. The innovative design of the study will, for the first time, assess efficacy of ONS in a blinded way.

Safety and efficacy of occipital nerve stimulation for attack prevention in medically intractable chronic cluster headache (ICON): a randomised, double-blind, multicentre, phase 3, electrical dose-controlled trial.

BACKGROUND: Occipital nerve stimulation (ONS) has shown promising results in small uncontrolled trials in patients with medically intractable chronic cluster headache (MICCH). We aimed to establish whether ONS could serve as an effective treatment for patients with MICCH. METHODS: The ONS in MICCH (ICON) study is an investigator-initiated, international, multicentre, randomised, double-blind, phase 3, electrical dose-controlled clinical trial. The study took place at four hospitals in the Netherlands, one hospital in Belgium, one in Germany, and one in Hungary. After 12 weeks' baseline observation, patients with MICCH, at least four attacks per week, and history of being non-responsive to at least three standard preventive drugs, were randomly allocated (at a 1:1 ratio using a computer-generated permuted block) to 24 weeks of occipital nerve stimulation at either 100% or 30% of the individually determined range between paraesthesia threshold and near-discomfort (double-blind study phase). Because ONS causes paraesthesia, preventing masked comparison versus placebo, we compared high-intensity versus low-intensity ONS, which are hypothesised to cause similar paraesthesia, but with different efficacy. In weeks 25-48, participants received individually optimised open-label ONS. The primary outcome was the weekly mean attack frequency in weeks 21-24 compared with baseline across all patients and, if a decrease was shown, to show a group-wise difference. The trial is closed to recruitment (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01151631). FINDINGS: Patients were enrolled between Oct 12, 2010, and Dec 3, 2017. We enrolled 150 patients and randomly assigned 131 (87%) to treatment; 65 (50%) patients to 100% ONS and 66 (50%) to 30% ONS. One of the 66 patients assigned to 30% ONS was not implanted and was therefore excluded from the intention-to-treat analysis. Because the weekly mean attack frequencies at baseline were skewed (median 15·75; IQR 9·44 to 24·75) we used log transformation to analyse the data and medians to present the results. Median weekly mean attack frequencies in the total population decreased from baseline to 7·38 (2·50 to 18·50; p<0·0001) in weeks 21-24, a median change of -5·21 (-11·18 to -0·19; p<0·0001) attacks per week. In the 100% ONS stimulation group, mean attack frequency decreased from 17·58 (9·83 to 29·33) at baseline to 9·50 (3·00 to 21·25) at 21-24 weeks (median change from baseline -4·08, -11·92 to -0·25), and for the 30% ONS stimulation group, mean attack frequency decreased from 15·00 (9·25 to 22·33) to 6·75 (1·50 to 16·50; -6·50, -10·83 to -0·08). The difference in median weekly mean attack frequency between groups at the end of the masked phase in weeks 21-24 was -2·42 (95% CI -5·17 to 3·33). In the masked study phase, 129 adverse events occurred with 100% ONS and 95 occurred with 30% ONS. None of the adverse events was unexpected but 17 with 100% ONS and eight with 30% ONS were labelled as serious, given they required brief hospital admission for minor hardware-related issues. The most common adverse events were local pain, impaired wound healing, neck stiffness, and hardware damage. INTERPRETATION: In patients with MICCH, both 100% ONS intensity and 30% ONS intensity substantially reduced attack frequency and were safe and well tolerated. Future research should focus on optimising stimulation protocols and disentangling the underlying mechanism of action. FUNDING: The Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research, the Dutch Ministry of Health, the NutsOhra Foundation from the Dutch Health Insurance Companies, and Medtronic.

Effect of spinal cord stimulation in Type I complex regional pain syndrome with 2 rare severe cutaneous manifestations.

The authors present the case of a 49-year-old female patient with complex regional pain syndrome-Type I (CRPSI) who was suffering from nonhealing wounds and giant bullae, which dramatically improved after spinal cord stimulation (SCS). The scientific literature concerning severe cutaneous manifestations of CRPS-I and their treatment is reviewed. Nonhealing wounds and bullae are rare manifestations of CRPS-I that are extremely difficult to treat. Immediate improvement of both wounds and bullae after SCS, such as in this case, has not been reported previously in literature. Considering the rapidly progressive nature of these severe skin manifestations, immediate treatment, possibly with SCS, is mandatory.

Upregulation of the GABA-transporter GAT-1 in the spinal cord contributes to pain behaviour in experimental neuropathy.

Sciatic nerve ligation in rats (chronic constriction injury (CCI)) induces signs and symptoms that mimic human conditions of neuropathy. The central mechanisms that have been implicated in the pathogenesis of neuropathic pain include increased neuronal excitability, possibly a consequence of decreased availability of spinal GABA. GABA availability is regulated by the presence of the GABA-transporters (GATs). This study investigates the dorsal horn expression of the transporter GAT-1 and its functional involvement towards pain behaviour in the CCI model. Male Lewis rats (total n=37) were subjected to CCI or to a sham procedure. A sub-group of animals was treated with the GAT-1 antagonist NO-711. Behavioural testing was performed pre-surgery and at 7 days post-surgery. Testing included evaluation of mechanical allodynia using Von Frey filaments, thermal allodynia with a hot-plate test and observational testing of spontaneous pain behaviour. Subsequently, spinal protein expression of GAT-1 was assessed by Western blotting. Animals were sacrificed 7 days following surgery. CCI markedly increased mechanical and thermal allodynia and spontaneous pain behaviour after 7 days, while the sham procedure did not. GAT-1 was increased in spinal cord homogenates compared contralateral to the ligation side after 7 days. NO-711 treatment significantly reduced all tested pain behaviour. These data provide evidence for possible functional involvement of GAT-1 in the development of experimental neuropathic pain. The latter can be derived from observed analgesic effects of early treatment with NO-711, a selective GAT-1 inhibitor. The obtained insights support the clinical employment of GAT-1 inhibitors to treat neuropathic pain.

The restore rechargeable, implantable neurostimulator: handling and clinical results of a multicenter study.

BACKGROUND: Spinal cord stimulation is an effective therapy for chronic, neuropathic pain refractory to medication. Use of a rechargeable neurostimulation system (Restore, Medtronic Inc) could provide greater longevity in the treatment of complex pain. However, patients' ability to successfully recharge a neurostimulation system has not yet been demonstrated. PRIMARY OBJECTIVE: Ability of patients to recharge the neurostimulator. SECONDARY OBJECTIVES: Patient and physician satisfaction with the system, pain relief, quality of life, functional status, adverse events. METHODS: Prospective, open-label, multicenter, European study in patients with long-term refractory neuropathic pain. Recharging ability was assessed 1-month postimplant. Patient and physician satisfaction, pain relief, quality of life, and functional status were assessed at scheduled follow-up visits through 12 months. Adverse events were monitored throughout. RESULTS: Primary end point: 100% of patients (n=41) successfully recharged the neurostimulator. Secondary end points at 1 month: 78.6% of patients found recharging easy. At 12 months: physicians were satisfied with the system for 92.7% of patients; pain intensity decreased significantly (P<0.001); mean self-reported pain relief was 62%; 80.5% of patients had more than 50% pain relief; quality of life and functional status improved significantly (P<0.001); 98% of patients would recommend spinal cord stimulation to others. Overall, 41 device-related complications (23 patients) were observed. CONCLUSIONS: Twelve-month experience indicates that the rechargeable neurostimulation system (Restore) was easy to use, with 100% of patients able to recharge successfully. Patient and physician satisfaction was high, with significant improvements in pain, quality of life, and functional status. Complications were comparable to prior experience with this therapy.

Monopolar versus bipolar high frequency stimulation in the rat subthalamic nucleus: differences in histological damage.

The aim of the present study was to determine the effects of monopolar and bipolar high frequency stimulation (HFS) on histological damage and current flow using a commonly applied stimulus amplitude (300 microA). Bipolar HFS resulted in a large amount of histological damage whereas with monopolar HFS no damage was observed except for the electrode trajectory. Oscilloscopic readings confirmed that this was due to the application of twice as much current to the target with bipolar HFS. Our results demonstrate that there are differences in tissue damage dependent of polarity. In order to create a better comparison to the clinical condition, we suggest that the present rodent models for studying the effect of chronic HFS require further adjustment. This can be achieved by decreasing the present current densities to a level comparable to the human situation.

Efficacy of intrathecal baclofen therapy in children with intractable spastic cerebral palsy: a randomised controlled trial.

BACKGROUND: Intractable spasticity can be treated effectively with continuous infusion of intrathecal baclofen. Because evidence for its use in the treatment of children with spastic cerebral palsy is lacking, we conducted a randomised controlled trial. AIMS: To test whether continuous infusion of intrathecal baclofen is effective in comparison with standard treatment only. METHODS: Seventeen children, aged 13.2 (SD 2.8) years, with intractable spastic cerebral palsy were randomised to receive a Synchromed pump for continuous infusion of intrathecal baclofen after either 1 month (CITB group) or 6 months (Control group). Primary outcomes were the 6-month-change scores on the 0-10 visual analogue scale for individually formulated problems and the caregiver assistance scale of the Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory self-care domain. One of the secondary outcome measures was health related quality of life as measured with the Child Health Questionnaire-PF50. RESULTS: Nine children were randomly assigned to the CITB group and eight to the Control group. The visual analogue scale for individual problems improved with 4.0 (SD 1.7) in the CITB group and changed with -0.2 (SD 1.3) in the Control group (p=0.001). Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory scores did not change significantly. The Child Health Questionnaire-PF50 6-month-change score significantly differed in favour of the CITB group for the domains of bodily pain/discomfort (p=0.014), mental health (p=0.045), psychosocial status (p=0.027) and parents' personal time limitation (p=0.043). CONCLUSION: The results of this randomised controlled trial establish continuous infusion of intrathecal baclofen to be effective in carefully selected children with problems caused by intractable spastic cerebral palsy.

Safety and one-year efficacy of intrathecal baclofen therapy in children with intractable spastic cerebral palsy.

BACKGROUND: Prospective studies that address both efficacy and safety of continuous infusion of intrathecal baclofen (CITB) in children with spastic cerebral palsy (CP), and that use outcome measures beyond muscle tone are lacking. AIMS: To study the efficacy at 12 months and safety up to 24 months after start of CITB in children with intractable spastic CP. METHODS: Nine girls and eight boys, aged 13.7 years (SD 2.9), received a SynchroMed pump for CITB. We prospectively recorded effects and adverse events at regular follow-up visits up to 24 months. Outcome measures included the 0-10 visual analogue scale (VAS) for individual problems, Gross Motor Function Measure (GMFM) and health related quality of life as measured with the Child Health Questionnaire-PF50. RESULTS: CITB for 12 months significantly improved the VAS for individual problems with 4.7 (SD 2.0; p=0.000), VAS for ease of care with 5.2 (SD 2.1; p=0.000), VAS for pain with 5.4 (SD 2.7; p=0.002); GMFM sitting dimension with 3.3 (range -4.0 to 22.0; p=0.022), GMFM goal dimension with 4.0 (range 0.0-26.0; p=0.007); and Child Health Questionnaire-PF50 domains of bodily pain/discomfort with 25.6 (SD 35.9; p=0.016) and mental health with 9.8 (SD 11.3; p=0.007). During a mean follow-up of 18.4 months (range 12-24), we recorded 80 adverse events. Eight adverse events were serious, but not life-threatening. CONCLUSIONS: CITB was effective at 12 months and safe up to 24 months for carefully selected children with intractable spastic CP. CITB relieved pain, facilitated ease of care and improved mental health. The majority of children could extend their activities and participation.

Intrathecal baclofen in children with spastic cerebral palsy: a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled, dose-finding study.

Intrathecal baclofen (ITB) therapy can be very effective in the treatment of intractable spasticity, but its effectiveness and safety have not yet been thoroughly studied in children with cerebral palsy (CP). The aims of this double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled, dose-finding study were to select children eligible for continuous ITB infusion, to assess the effective ITB bolus dose, and to evaluate the effects, side effects, and complications. Outcome measures included the original Ashworth scale and the Visual Analogue Scale for individually formulated problems. We studied nine females and eight males, aged between 7 and 16 years (mean age 13y 2mo [SD 2y 9mo]). Twelve children had spastic CP and five had spastic-dyskinetic CP. One child was classified on the Gross Motor Function Classification System at Level III, two at Level I V, and 14 at Level V. The test treatment worked successfully for all 17 children with an effective ITB bolus dose of 12.5 microg in one, 20 microg in another, 25 microg in 10, and 50 microg in five children. ITB significantly reduced muscle tone, diminished pain, and facilitated ease of care. The placebo did not have these effects. Nine side effects of ITB were registered, including slight lethargy in seven children. Fourteen children had symptoms of lowered cerebrospinal fluid pressure. We conclude that ITB bolus administration is effective and safe for carefully selected children with intractable spastic CP.

Differential effects of subthalamic nucleus stimulation in advanced Parkinson disease on reaction time performance.

The aim of the present study was to assess the effect of bilateral subthalamic nucleus (STN) stimulation and dopaminergic medication on speed of mental processing and motor function. Thirty-nine patients suffering from advanced Parkinson disease (PD) were operated on. Motor function and reaction time (RT) performance [simple RT (SRT) and complex RT (CRT)] were evaluated under four experimental conditions with stimulation (stim) and medication (med) on and off: stim-on/med-on, stim-on/med-off, stim-off/med-off and stim-off/med-on. In the last condition, the patients received either low medication (usual dose) or high medication (suprathreshold dose). STN stimulation improved the motor performance in the SRT and CRT tasks. Furthermore, STN deep brain stimulation (DBS) also improved response preparation as shown by the significant improvement of the RT performance in the SRT task. This effect of STN DBS on the RT performance in the SRT task was greater as compared with the CRT task. This is due to the more complex information processing that is required in the CRT task as compared to the SRT task. These data suggest that treatment of STN hyperactivity by DBS improves motor function, confirming earlier reports, but has a differential effect on cognitive functions. The STN seems to be an important modulator of cognitive processing and STN DBS can differentially affect motor and associative circuits.

The development of a quality system for neuromodulation in the Netherlands.

We present here a descriptive article on the development of a national quality system for neuromodulatory techniques in the Netherlands. In 1994, due to reimbursement difficulties in the Netherlands, a Neuromodulation Working Group (WGN) undertook an initiative to develop a national quality system for neuromodulation. It was believed that with official recognition of neuromodulation as a therapy by the health authorities in the Netherlands, a quality system for monitoring would then follow. To that purpose an observational study was performed. Integration of this entire primary process (from intake to control phase) was based upon an inventory of the practices of the most experienced medical specialists practicing neuromodulation in the Netherlands. Based on the study data, nine quality indicators were identified that would allow monitoring of the quality of care to patients in the Netherlands. The study resulted in a positive feedback to the National Health Insurance Board and the Ministry of Health in the Netherlands. Neuromodulation for chronic pain and disabling spasticity is now recognized and fully reimbursed within the limits of the newly developed quality system. We therefore conclude that developed quality systems can provide a basis for medical specialists to cooperate around groups of patients or diseases. These quality systems can facilitate implementation and innovation within the health care system. The role of medical specialists and their will to cooperate is essential.

Neuropathic limb pain and spinal cord stimulation: results of the dutch prospective study.

Baseline and 12-month follow-up data from a prospective controlled study on patients treated with SCS for neuropathic limb pain (NLP) are analyzed critically. The outcome on pain, use of medication, and quality of life are reported and compared with the literature. Patients enrolled from April 1999 to December 2001 were part of a quality system study by the Dutch Working Group on Neuromodulation. In two years, more than 400 patients were admitted for several indications of chronic neuropathic pain. Failed back surgery syndrome (FBSS) and complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) were the largest cohorts. FBSS was defined as persistent limb pain with/or without concomitant minor back pain after prior surgery for a slipped lumbar disc or spinal instability. SCS was a last resort therapy. Two criteria were used for eligibility: a SCL-90 score below 225 and a mean visual analog score (VAS) of four days according to Jensen of ≥ 5. One hundred sixty nine patients were registered for FBSS. Thirty four did not fulfill the eligibility criteria, and 135 received several questionnaires for baseline evaluation. Thirty patients did not have successful trial stimulation (< 50% pain relief), leaving 105 patients for implantation. The mean scores of the baseline evaluation were: SCL 137 (SD 28.3) and VAS 7.3 (SD 1.2), McGill pain questionnaire (MPQ) total PRI: 22.4 (9.4), Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) total score: 19.4 (SD10.1), ROLAND disability (RD) 16.9 (SD 3.5) and EUROQOL (EQ-5D) 55.2 (SD 14.5) (simple linear index). Medication quantification scale at intake was 11.5 (SD 7.9). 56.2% of the patients used one or more narcotic drugs at intake. 82% of the patients did not have a paid job at the time of inclusion. 61% of the patients lost their job due to their medical problems. Scores at 12-m follow-up were VAS 3.0 (SD 2.4), MPQ 10.8 (SD 8), SIP 11.7 (SD 9.4), EQ-5D 38.2 (SD 19.2) and RD 12.4 (SD 4.8). The difference between baseline and 12-m follow-up is statistically significant for all measures. We conclude that the outcome measures indicate that SCS significantly reduces pain and enhances quality of life in patients having NLP not responding to other adjuvant therapy. Recommendations are proposed to make studies more comparable.

Developing a national continuous quality improvement system for neuromodulation treatment in The Netherlands.

BACKGROUND: Because neuromodulation was not included in the national health insurance system, the Dutch Neuromodulation Group (DNG) developed national standards and a continuous quality improvement (CQI) system for consistency in application of neuromodulation techniques and in the quality of outcomes. DEVELOPING THE NATIONAL QUALITY IMPROVEMENT SYSTEM: A stepwise approach was used in which the following ten steps were taken: (1) selected participating medical specialists and their centers, (2) described the treatment protocol, (3) collected data in a national database, (4) organized feedback sessions for the DNG, (5) formulated quality indicators, (6) adjusted the process of treatment, (7) formalized the structure of the DNG, (8) defined responsibilities, (9) established procedures for future development, and (10) made agreements with payers. DISCUSSION: Making reimbursement for expensive health care interventions contingent on a national CQI system created a powerful financial incentive to continuously provide effective care in an efficient manner.