Trends in OSHA Compliance Monitoring Data 1979-2011: Statistical Modeling of Ancillary Information across 77 Chemicals.

OBJECTIVES: The Integrated Management Information System (IMIS) is the largest multi-industry source of exposure measurements available in North America. However, many have suspected that the criteria through which worksites are selected for inspection are related to exposure levels. We investigated associations between exposure levels and ancillary variables in IMIS in order to understand the predictors of high exposure within an enforcement context. METHODS: We analyzed the association between nine variables (reason for inspection, establishment size, total amount of penalty, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) plan, OSHA region, union status, inspection scope, year, and industry) and exposure levels in IMIS using multimodel inference for 77 agents. For each agent, we used two different types of models: (i) logistic models were used for the odds ratio (OR) of exposure being above the threshold limit value (TLV) and (ii) linear models were used for exposure concentrations restricted to detected results to estimate percent increase in exposure level, i.e. relative index of exposure (RIE). Meta-analytic methods were used to combine results for each variable across agents. RESULTS: A total of 511,047 exposure measurements were modeled for logistic models and 299,791 for linear models. Higher exposures were measured during follow-up inspections than planned inspections [meta-OR = 1.61, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.44-1.81; meta-RIE = 1.06, 95% CI: 1.03-1.09]. Lower exposures were observed for measurements collected under state OSHA plans compared to measurements collected under federal OSHA (meta-OR = 0.82, 95% CI: 0.73-0.92; meta-RIE = 0.86, 95% CI: 0.81-0.91). A 'high' total historical amount of penalty relative to none was associated with higher exposures (meta-OR = 1.54, 95% CI: 1.40-1.71; meta-RIE = 1.18, 95% CI: 1.13-1.23). CONCLUSIONS: The relationships observed between exposure levels and ancillary variables across a vast majority of agents suggest that certain elements of OSHA's process of selecting worksites for inspection influence the exposure levels that OSHA inspectors encounter. Nonetheless, given the paucity of other sources of exposure data and the lack of a more demonstrably representative data source, our study considers the use of IMIS data for the estimation of exposures in the broader universe of worksites in the USA.

Exposure Determinants in the French Database COLCHIC (1987-2019): Statistical Modeling across 77 Chemicals.

OBJECTIVES: The COLCHIC database contains workplace exposure results of chemical samples collected by the French prevention network since 1987. We aimed to investigate potential associations between exposure levels and ancillary variables in COLCHIC across a broad range of chemical agents in order to provide insight into how to best interpret and exploit the information in this national database. METHODS: We selected personal and area measurements in COLCHIC and collected outside respiratory personal protective equipment (PPE), restricted to chemical agents that had at least 1000 samples available. We used Tobit models to estimate associations between exposure concentrations and sample year, sampling duration, PPE, workforce size, collective protective equipment, origin of request, and reason for request for each chemical agent for the period 1987-2019. Models for period 2002-2019 also included type of process (open/closed) and exposure frequency. We used separate models for each combination of agent, period, and personal or area samples. We then applied Bayesian meta-analytical methods to assess average effects and effect heterogeneity of exposure factors across agents. RESULTS: COLCHIC contained 720 282 exposure results (62% personal and 38% area samples) to 77 agents, including 346 766 results for the more recent period 2002-2019 (67% personal and 33% area samples). Sample year and duration, PPE, and process type had the strongest and most consistent associations with exposure levels across agents. Personal and area exposure levels decreased yearly (6% for the entire period and 9% since 2002), and 30-min samples were approximately twice as high as 240-min samples. Workers wearing PPE were exposed to levels 1.7 times higher on average than those without PPE for both area and personal samples. Personal exposure levels associated with enclosed or semi-enclosed processes were approximately 20-30% lower compared with open processes. The associations for the other exposure variables were weaker and more inconsistent between agents. Between-agent heterogeneity of estimated effects, based on 80% prediction intervals, was lowest for sampling duration, time trends, and the presence of PPE. CONCLUSIONS: Sampling duration, time trends, and the presence of PPE are important factors to take into account when analyzing COLCHIC and had similar associations with exposure levels across agents. Other variables generally showed weaker associations or variable effects. These results will be used to adjust exposure estimates for the French working population from measurements stored in COLCHIC.