Early animal evolution: emerging views from comparative biology and geology.

The Cambrian appearance of fossils representing diverse phyla has long inspired hypotheses about possible genetic or environmental catalysts of early animal evolution. Only recently, however, have data begun to emerge that can resolve the sequence of genetic and morphological innovations, environmental events, and ecological interactions that collectively shaped Cambrian evolution. Assembly of the modern genetic tool kit for development and the initial divergence of major animal clades occurred during the Proterozoic Eon. Crown group morphologies diversified in the Cambrian through changes in the genetic regulatory networks that organize animal ontogeny. Cambrian radiation may have been triggered by environmental perturbation near the Proterozoic-Cambrian boundary and subsequently amplified by ecological interactions within reorganized ecosystems.

Control of a genetic regulatory network by a selector gene.

The formation of many complex structures is controlled by a special class of transcription factors encoded by selector genes. It is shown that SCALLOPED, the DNA binding component of the selector protein complex for the Drosophila wing field, binds to and directly regulates the cis-regulatory elements of many individual target genes within the genetic regulatory network controlling wing development. Furthermore, combinations of binding sites for SCALLOPED and transcriptional effectors of signaling pathways are necessary and sufficient to specify wing-specific responses to different signaling pathways. The obligate integration of selector and signaling protein inputs on cis-regulatory DNA may be a general mechanism by which selector proteins control extensive genetic regulatory networks during development.

Pattern formation and eyespot determination in butterfly wings.

Butterfly wings display pattern elements of many types and colors. To identify the molecular processes underlying the generation of these patterns, several butterfly cognates of Drosophila appendage patterning genes have been cloned and their expression patterns have been analyzed. Butterfly wing patterns are organized by two spatial coordinate systems. One system specifies positional information with respect to the entire wing field and is conserved between fruit flies and butterflies. A second system, superimposed on the general system and involving several of the same genes, operates within each wing subdivision to elaborate discrete pattern elements. Eyespots, which form from discrete developmental organizers, are marked by Distal-less gene expression. These circular pattern elements appear to be generated by a process similar to, and perhaps evolved from, proximodistal pattern formation in insect appendages.

Recruitment of a hedgehog regulatory circuit in butterfly eyespot evolution.

The origin of new morphological characters is a long-standing problem in evolutionary biology. Novelties arise through changes in development, but the nature of these changes is largely unknown. In butterflies, eyespots have evolved as new pattern elements that develop from special organizers called foci. Formation of these foci is associated with novel expression patterns of the Hedgehog signaling protein, its receptor Patched, the transcription factor Cubitus interruptus, and the engrailed target gene that break the conserved compartmental restrictions on this regulatory circuit in insect wings. Redeployment of preexisting regulatory circuits may be a general mechanism underlying the evolution of novelties.

The role of the Distal-less gene in the development and evolution of insect limbs.

BACKGROUND: Arthropod diversity is apparent in the variations in limb number, type, and position along the body axis. Among the insects, for example, butterflies and moths (Lepidoptera) develop larval abdominal and caudal appendages ('prolegs'), whereas flies (Diptera) do not. Comparative studies of the expression and regulation during development of limb-patterning genes, such as Distal-less (Dll), may provide insights into arthropod evolution. RESULTS: We report the cloning of a Dll homolog from the butterfly Precis coenia, and present data showing that it is expressed in all developing limbs (except the mandible), including the prolegs; the relationship between Dll and wingless expression observed in Drosophila is conserved in Precis among all limbs. However, Dll is deployed in distinct spatial and temporal patterns within each limb type. CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest that Dll function, suppressed in the abdomen early in insect evolution, has been derepressed in Lepidoptera, and also suggest that there is a common mechanism underlying the formation of all insect appendages. The limb-type-specific patterns of Dll expression (and its exclusion from the mandible) indicate that regulation of Dll expression may be critical to limb morphology, and are inconsistent with Dll functioning in a simple distal-to-proximal concentration gradient.

Expression pattern of a butterfly achaete-scute homolog reveals the homology of butterfly wing scales and insect sensory bristles.

BACKGROUND: Lepidopteran wing scales are the individual units of wing color patterns and were a key innovation during Lepidopteran evolution. On the basis of developmental and morphological evidence, it has been proposed that the sensory bristles of the insect peripheral nervous system and the wing scales of Lepidoptera are homologous structures. In order to determine if the developmental pathways leading to Drosophila sensory bristle and butterfly scale formation use similar genetic circuitry, we cloned, from the butterfly Precis coenia, a homolog of the Drosophila achaete-scute (AS-C) genes--which encode transcription factors that promote neural precursor formation--and examined its expression pattern during development. RESULTS: During embryonic and larval development, the expression pattern of the AS-C homolog, ASH1, forecasted neural precursor formation. ASH1 was expressed both in embryonic proneural clusters--within which an individual cell retained ASH1 expression, enlarged, segregated, and became a neural precursor--and in larval wing discs in putative sensory mother cells. ASH1 was also expressed in pupal wings, however, in evenly spaced rows of enlarged cells that had segregated from the underlying epidermis but, rather than give rise to neural structures, each cell contributed to an individual scale. CONCLUSIONS: ASH1 appears to perform multiple functions throughout butterfly development, apparently promoting the initial events of selection and formation of both neural and scale precursor cells. The similarity in the cellular and molecular processes of scale and neural precursor formation suggests that the spatial regulation of an AS-C gene was modified during Lepidopteran evolution to promote scale cell formation.

Drosophila wing melanin patterns form by vein-dependent elaboration of enzymatic prepatterns.

BACKGROUND: Animal melanin patterns are involved in diverse aspects of their ecology, from thermoregulation to mimicry. Many theoretical models have simulated pigment patterning, but little is known about the developmental mechanisms of color pattern formation. In Drosophila melanogaster, several genes are known to be necessary for cuticular melanization, but the involvement of these genes in melanin pattern evolution is unknown. We have taken a genetic approach to elucidate the developmental mechanisms underlying melanin pattern formation in various drosophilids. RESULTS: We show that, in D. melanogaster, tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) and dopa decarboxylase (DDC) are required for melanin synthesis. Ectopic expression of TH, but not DDC, alone was sufficient to cause ectopic melanin patterns in the wing. Thus, changes in the level of expression of a single gene can result in a new level of melanization. The ontogeny of this ectopic melanization resembled that found in Drosophila species bearing wing melanin patterns and in D. melanogaster ebony mutants. Importantly, we discovered that in D. melanogaster and three other Drosophila species these wing melanin patterns are dependent upon and shaped by the circulation patterns of hemolymph in the wing veins. CONCLUSIONS: Complex wing melanin patterns are determined by two distinct developmental mechanisms. Spatial prepatterns of enzymatic activity are established late in wing development. Then, in newly eclosed adults, melanin precursors gradually diffuse out from wing veins and are oxidized into dark brown or black melanin. Both the prepatterning and hemolymph-supplied components of this system can change during evolution to produce color pattern diversity.

The generation and diversification of butterfly eyespot color patterns.

BACKGROUND: A fundamental challenge of evolutionary and developmental biology is understanding how new characters arise and change. The recently derived eyespots on butterfly wings vary extensively in number and pattern between species and play important roles in predator avoidance. Eyespots form through the activity of inductive organizers (foci) at the center of developing eyespot fields. Foci are the proposed source of a morphogen, the levels of which determine the color of surrounding wing scale cells. However, it is unknown how reception of the focal signal translates into rings of different-colored scales, nor how different color schemes arise in different species. RESULTS: We have identified several transcription factors, including butterfly homologs of the Drosophila Engrailed/Invected and Spalt proteins, that are deployed in concentric territories corresponding to the future rings of pigmented scales that compose the adult eyespot. We have isolated a new Bicyclus anynana wing pattern mutant, Goldeneye, in which the scales of one inner color ring become the color of a different ring. These changes correlate with shifts in transcription factor expression, suggesting that Goldeneye affects an early regulatory step in eyespot color patterning. In different butterfly species, the same transcription factors are expressed in eyespot fields, but in different relative spatial domains that correlate with divergent eyespot color schemes. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that signaling from the focus induces nested rings of regulatory gene expression that subsequently control the final color pattern. Furthermore, the remarkably plastic regulatory interactions downstream of focal signaling have facilitated the evolution of eyespot diversity.

Ectopic gene expression and homeotic transformations in arthropods using recombinant Sindbis viruses.

BACKGROUND: The morphological diversity of arthropods makes them attractive subjects for studying the evolution of developmental mechanisms. Comparative analyses suggest that arthropod diversity has arisen largely as a result of changes in expression patterns of genes that control development. Direct analysis of how a particular gene functions in a given species during development is hindered by the lack of broadly applicable techniques for manipulating gene expression. RESULTS: We report that the Arbovirus Sindbis can be used to deliver high levels of gene expression in vivo in a number of non-host arthropod species without causing cytopathic effects in infected cells or impairing development. Using recombinant Sindbis virus, we investigated the function of the homeotic gene Ultrabithorax in the development of butterfly wings and beetle embryos. Ectopic Ultrabithorax expression in butterfly forewing imaginal discs was sufficient to cause the transformation of characteristic forewing properties in the adult, including scale morphology and pigmentation, to those of the hindwing. Expression of Ultrabithorax in beetle embryos outside of its endogenous expression domain affected normal development of the body wall cuticle and appendages. CONCLUSIONS: The homeotic genes have long been thought to play an important role in the diversification of arthropod appendages. Using recombinant Sindbis virus, we were able to investigate homeotic gene function in non-model arthropod species. We found that Ultrabithorax is sufficient to confer hindwing identity in butterflies and alter normal development of anterior structures in beetles. Recombinant Sindbis virus has broad potential as a tool for analyzing how the function of developmental genes has changed during the diversification of arthropods.

Expression of an endogenous asialoglycoprotein receptor in a human intestinal epithelial cell line, Caco-2.

We have previously shown that rat asialoglycoprotein receptor expressed in the intestine and liver differ in mRNA size, cell surface distribution, and ratio of compositional protein subunits. In this study, we examined a well characterized intestinal epithelial cell line, Caco-2, as a potential model for studying endogenous receptor in a polarized cell line. Both subunits H1 and H2 of human asialoglycoprotein receptor were detected in Caco-2 cells by Western blots using subunit-specific antisera raised against the hepatic receptor. Antigenic receptor level in fully differentiated Caco-2 cells was approx. 1/3 to 1/2 the level of hepatic HepG2 cells H1 was the dominant subunit in both cell lines. The apparent size of H1 and H2 in Caco-2 cells was not the same as that in HepG2 cells, due to differences in N-linked glycosylation. Consistent with this finding, Northern blot analysis showed that receptor mRNA in the two cell types was of identical size. In pulse-chase experiments H1 was first detected as a 'high-mannose' precursor (40 kDa) in Caco-2 cells that was converted to mature H1 (43 kDa) with a half-life of approx. 60 min. Antigenic levels of H1 and H2 in undifferentiated Caco-2 cells were low, but increased rapidly during cell differentiation, reaching a peak level at 7 days after confluence. Immunocytochemical staining and domain-selective cell surface biotinylation assays showed that the ASGP-R was predominantly localized in the basolateral domain. The receptor in Caco-2 cells was capable of mediating specific uptake and degradation of [125I]asialoorosomucoid. The ligand uptake capacity of the basolateral surface of was approx. 10-fold higher than the apical. These characteristics (H1 subunit and basolateral predominance) of the receptor in Caco-2 cells, resembles the hepatic receptor. We conclude that Caco-2 cells endogenously express in ectopic hepatic-type functional asialoglycoprotein receptor.

Conservation of a DNA-binding site in the largest subunit of eukaryotic RNA polymerase II.

Using a monoclonal antibody to a DNA-binding site of calf RNA polymerase II, we found that this site occurs on the largest subunit and is structurally similar in RNA polymerase II of widely divergent eukaryotes. In immuno-blotting of electrophoretically separated subunits, the monoclonal antibody recognized a determinant on the largest polypeptide of all RNA eukaryotic polymerase II forms tested, with a preference for the IIA enzyme subunit of 215 X 10(3) Mr over the partially proteolyzed 180 X 10(3) Mr form. This site is conserved on human, chicken, Drosophila, wheat germ and yeast RNA polymerase II, all of which reacted strongly with the monoclonal antibody. These results contrasted with those obtained with polyclonal antibodies to non-functional determinants of the calf enzyme. The reactivity of the polyclonal antibody with eukaryotic RNA polymerase II steadily decreased with increasing evolutionary distance from the original antigen; the yeast enzyme showed no cross-reactivity. These results suggest that a basic functional feature of eukaryotic RNA polymerase II has been strongly conserved and support the view that divergence of RNA polymerase II has taken place mainly in other, perhaps regulatory, sites of the enzyme.

From pattern to gene, from gene to pattern.

Our understanding of animal development has been revolutionized by genetic approaches to the identification and isolation of pattern-regulating genes. In the past several years, fundamental embryological concepts such as morphogenetic fields, compartments, and organizers have been defined at a molecular level and visualized in developing animals. Here, I will discuss how the focus on the regulation and function of genes with dramatic effects on pattern formation, primarily by through the analysis of gene expression patterns as surrogates of physical pattern elements, has elucidated gene hierarchies that control developmental pathways.

Three-color immunofluorescence imaging of Drosophila embryos by laser scanning confocal microscopy.

We present a simple means for triple-labeling biological specimens by immunofluorescence using a laser scanning confocal microscope for imaging with a krypton/argon laser as a light source. Three separate images of fluorescein-, lissamine rhodamine- and cyanine-5-labeled antibodies are collected and subsequently merged to form the triple-labeled image, which is displayed at full-image resolution (24 bit) on a second image processing system. The technique is illustrated using immunofluorescence localization of three segmentation proteins in Drosophila embryos.

Comparison of the purity and efficacy of affinity purified avian antivenoms with commercial equine crotalid antivenoms.

Antivenoms were raised in laying hens by repeated immunizations with detoxified crotalid snake venoms and purified from egg yolks by affinity chromatography. While the affinity purified avian antivenoms were essentially pure IgG, commercial equine (Wyeth) and W.H.O. international reference antivenoms (Trimeresurus flavoviridis) contained several non-immunoglobulin contaminants. In standard mouse protection assays, the purified avian Crotalus atrox and T. flavoviridis antivenoms were 6.3 and 2.0 times as potent, respectively, as these equine antivenoms in neutralizing venom lethality. The purity, efficacy, and ease of manufacture of avian antivenoms, and their inability to fix mammalian complement, make them an attractive alternative to equine and other mammalian antivenoms.

Rattlesnake and scorpion antivenoms from the egg yolks of immunized hens.

Antivenoms used to treat poisonous bites and stings are usually derived from horse sera. Consequently, they contain horse immunoglobulins, which frequently cause complement mediated side effects, and other proteins that can cause serum sickness and, occasionally, anaphylactic shock. Here we describe a new, avian source of antivenoms that precludes these complications, and an efficient and gentle means for preparing antivenoms composed solely of venom-specific antibodies. We demonstrate that antivenoms purified from the egg yolks of laying hens immunized with Crotalus atrox rattlesnake venom and Leiurus quinquestriatus hebraeus scorpion venom neutralize the lethal effects of these venoms in vivo. Antivenoms purified from chicken eggs may be pharmaceutically safer and more economical to produce than current horse antivenoms.

Homeotic genes and the evolution of arthropods and chordates.

Clusters of homeotic genes sculpt the morphology of animal body plans and body parts. Different body patterns may evolve through changes in homeotic gene number, regulation or function. Recent evidence suggests that homeotic gene clusters were duplicated early in vertebrate evolution, but the generation of arthropod and tetrapod diversity has largely involved regulatory changes in the expression of conserved arrays of homeotic genes and the evolution of interactions between homeotic proteins and the genes they regulate.

Zebra patterns in fly embryos: activation of stripes or repression of interstripes?

Like Gould's zebra, the striped embryo can be viewed as a pattern of both interstripe repression and stripe activation. A growing body of evidence suggests that both processes are at work in regulating pair-rule gene expression. Certain genes, such as ftz, are largely negatively regulated in the interstripes through proximal upstream elements by the striped expression of other pair-rule genes, while others, such as hairy and eve, are largely regulated through distal upstream elements by the aperiodic gap genes (Figure 7). Different gap proteins control different subsets of stripes and interstripes. Combinations of gap proteins regulate transcription by binding to far upstream elements that contain different numbers and types of binding sites.