Rescuing the function of mutant p53.

One protein--p53--plays nemesis to most cancers by condemning damaged cells to death or quarantining them for repair. But the activity of p53 relies on its intact native conformation, which can be lost following mutation of a single nucleotide. With thousands of such mutations identified in patients, how can a future cancer drug buttress this fragile protein structure and restore the cell's natural defence?

Solution structure of a protein denatured state and folding intermediate.

The most controversial area in protein folding concerns its earliest stages. Questions such as whether there are genuine folding intermediates, and whether the events at the earliest stages are just rearrangements of the denatured state or progress from populated transition states, remain unresolved. The problem is that there is a lack of experimental high-resolution structural information about early folding intermediates and denatured states under conditions that favour folding because competent states spontaneously fold rapidly. Here we have solved directly the solution structure of a true denatured state by nuclear magnetic resonance under conditions that would normally favour folding, and directly studied its equilibrium and kinetic behaviour. We engineered a mutant of Drosophila melanogaster Engrailed homeodomain that folds and unfolds reversibly just by changing ionic strength. At high ionic strength, the mutant L16A is an ultra-fast folding native protein, just like the wild-type protein; however, at physiological ionic strength it is denatured. The denatured state is a well-ordered folding intermediate, poised to fold by docking helices and breaking some non-native interactions. It unfolds relatively progressively with increasingly denaturing conditions, and so superficially resembles a denatured state with properties that vary with conditions. Such ill-defined unfolding is a common feature of early folding intermediate states and accounts for why there are so many controversies about intermediates versus compact denatured states in protein folding.

The accessory subunit of mitochondrial DNA polymerase gamma determines the DNA content of mitochondrial nucleoids in human cultured cells.

The accessory subunit of mitochondrial DNA polymerase gamma, POLGbeta, functions as a processivity factor in vitro. Here we show POLGbeta has additional roles in mitochondrial DNA metabolism. Mitochondrial DNA is arranged in nucleoprotein complexes, or nucleoids, which often contain multiple copies of the mitochondrial genome. Gene-silencing of POLGbeta increased nucleoid numbers, whereas over-expression of POLGbeta reduced the number and increased the size of mitochondrial nucleoids. Both increased and decreased expression of POLGbeta altered nucleoid structure and precipitated a marked decrease in 7S DNA molecules, which form short displacement-loops on mitochondrial DNA. Recombinant POLGbeta preferentially bound to plasmids with a short displacement-loop, in contrast to POLGalpha. These findings support the view that the mitochondrial D-loop acts as a protein recruitment centre, and suggest POLGbeta is a key factor in the organization of mitochondrial DNA in multigenomic nucleoprotein complexes.

Time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer study shows a compact denatured state of the B domain of protein A.

The B domain of protein A (BDPA), a three-helix bundle of 60 residues, folds via a nucleation-condensation mechanism in apparent two-state kinetics. We have applied a time-resolved FRET (tr-FRET) approach to characterize the ensembles of BDPA during chemical denaturation. The distribution of the distance between residues 22 and 55, which are close and separated by helices 2 and 3 in the native state, was determined by global analysis of the time-resolved fluorescence decay curves of the probes. Narrow distributions were observed when the protein was equilibrated in guanidinium chloride (GdmCl) concentrations below 1.5 M (native state, N) and above the transition zone at 2.6-3.0 M GdmCl (denatured state, D). Considerably broader distributions were found around the transition point (2.0 M GdmCl) or much higher GdmCl concentrations (>3.0 M). Comparative global analysis of the tr-FRET data showed a compact denatured state of the protein, characterized by narrow distribution and relatively small mean distance between residues 22 and 55 that was observed at mild denaturing conditions (<3 M GdmCl). This experiment supports the two-state folding mechanism of BDPA and indicates the existence of effective nonlocal, probably hydrophobic, intramolecular interactions that stabilize a pretty uniform ensemble of compact denatured molecules at intermediate denaturing conditions.

Catalysis of amide proton exchange by the molecular chaperones GroEL and SecB.

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange of 39 amide protons of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens ribonuclease (barnase) was analyzed by two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance in the presence of micromolar concentrations of the molecular chaperones GroEL and SecB. Both chaperones bound to native barnase under physiological conditions and catalyzed exchange of deeply buried amide protons with solvent. Such exchange required complete unfolding of barnase, which occurred in the complex with the chaperones. Subsequent collapse of unfolded barnase to the exchange-protected folding intermediate was markedly slowed in the presence of GroEL or SecB. Thus, both chaperones have the potential to correct misfolding in proteins by annealing.

Hydrogen exchange at equilibrium: a short cut for analysing protein-folding pathways?

Hydrogen exchange is an attractive method for observing small populations of partly unfolded states of proteins at equilibrium. It has been suggested that these represent folding intermediates so that hydrogen exchange can offer a short cut for studying protein-folding pathways. This cannot work in theory because it is not possible to tell whether they are intermediates or side reactions. Experimental studies of barnase and chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 show that there is no obvious relationship between hydrogen exchange at equilibrium and their folding pathways.

Structure-function-rescue: the diverse nature of common p53 cancer mutants.

The tumor suppressor protein p53 is inactivated by mutation in about half of all human cancers. Most mutations are located in the DNA-binding domain of the protein. It is, therefore, important to understand the structure of p53 and how it responds to mutation, so as to predict the phenotypic response and cancer prognosis. In this review, we present recent structural and systematic functional data that elucidate the molecular basis of how p53 is inactivated by different types of cancer mutation. Intriguingly, common cancer mutants exhibit a variety of distinct local structural changes, while the overall structural scaffold is largely preserved. The diverse structural and energetic response to mutation determines: (i) the folding state of a particular mutant under physiological conditions; (ii) its affinity for the various p53 target DNA sequences; and (iii) its protein-protein interactions both within the p53 tetramer and with a multitude of regulatory proteins. Further, the structural details of individual mutants provide the basis for the design of specific and generic drugs for cancer therapy purposes. In combination with studies on second-site suppressor mutations, it appears that some mutants are ideal rescue candidates, whereas for others simple pharmacological rescue by small molecule drugs may not be successful.

Nucleation mechanisms in protein folding.

Experiment and theory are converging on the importance of nucleation mechanisms in protein folding. These mechanisms do not use classic nuclei, which are well formed elements of structure present in ground states, but they use diffuse, extended regions, which are observed in transition states.

Characterizing transition states in protein folding: an essential step in the puzzle.

Transition states in protein folding are being analyzed experimentally and by computer simulation to reveal the sequence of events in the folding and unfolding of proteins at high resolution. Results of this analysis have enabled the reconstruction of folding pathways in vitro and open the prospect of analyzing pathways in vivo.

Oxidative refolding chromatography: folding of the scorpion toxin Cn5.

We have made an immobilized and reusable molecular chaperone system for oxidative refolding chromatography. Its three components-GroEL minichaperone (191-345), which can prevent protein aggregation; DsbA, which catalyzes the shuffling and oxidative formation of disulfide bonds; and peptidyl-prolyl isomerase-were immobilized on an agarose gel. The gel was applied to the refolding of denatured and reduced scorpion toxin Cn5. The 66-residue toxin, which has four disulfide bridges and a cis peptidyl-proline bond, had not previously been refolded in reasonable yield. We recovered an 87% yield of protein with 100% biological activity.

Stability and function: two constraints in the evolution of barstar and other proteins.

BACKGROUND: Barstar is the intracellular inhibitor of barnase, an extracellular RNAse of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens. The dissociation constant of the barnase-barstar complex is 10(-14) M with an association rate constant between barnase and barstar of 3.7 x 10(8) s-1 M-1. The rapid association arises in part from the clustering of four acidic residues (Asp35, Asp39, Glu76 and Glu80) on the barnase-binding surface of barstar. The negatively charged barnase-binding surface of barstar effectively 'steers' the inhibitor towards the positively charged active site of barnase. RESULTS: Mutating any one of the four acidic side chains of barstar to an alanine results in an approximately two-fold decrease in the association rate constant, while the dissociation rate constant increases from five orders of magnitude for Asp39-->Ala, to no significant change for Glu80-->Ala. The stability of barstar is increased by all four mutations, the increase ranging from 0.3 kcal mol-1 for Asp35-->Ala or Asp39-->Ala, to 2.1 kcal mol-1 for Glu80-->Ala. CONCLUSIONS: The evolutionary pressure on barstar for rapid binding of barnase is so strong that glutamate is preferred over alanine at position 80, even though it does not directly interact with barnase in the complex and significantly destabilizes the inhibitor structure. This, and other examples from the literature, suggest that proteins evolve primarily to optimize their function in vivo, with relatively little evolutionary pressure to increase stability above a certain threshold, thus allowing greater latitude in the evolution of enzyme activity.

Quantitative analysis of residual folding and DNA binding in mutant p53 core domain: definition of mutant states for rescue in cancer therapy.

The tumour suppressor p53 is mutated in half of all human cancers, most frequently with missense substitutions in its core domain. We present a new assessment of the mutation database based on quantitative folding and DNA-binding studies of the isolated core domain. Our data identify five distinct mutant classes that correlate with four well-defined regions of the core domain structure. On extrapolation to 37 degrees C the wild-type protein has a stability of 3.0 kcal/mol. This also emerges as an oncogenic threshold: all beta-sandwich mutants destabilized by this amount (50% denatured) are expected to promote cancer. Other weakly destabilizing mutations are restricted to loop 3 in the DNA-binding region. Drugs that stabilize mutant p53 folding have the potential to reactivate apoptotic signalling pathways in tumour cells either by transactivation-dependent or independent pathways. Using an affinity ligand as a proof of principle we have recovered the thermodynamic stability of the hotspot G245S. With reference states for the five mutant classes as a guide, future therapeutic strategies may similarly stabilize partially structured or binding states of mutant p53 that restore limited p53 pathways to tumour suppression.

Protein engineering and the study of structure--function relationships in receptors.

Protein engineering is a powerful tool for studying relationships between receptor structure and function--providing that it is used and interpreted appropriately. Site-directed mutagenesis, deletion mutagenesis and construction of chimaeric proteins have all been used to characterize receptors. In this review, Walter Ward, David Timms and Alan Fersht describe the application of protein engineering, illustrating important concepts with experimental data. They explain that detailed study of function requires careful dissection of mechanistic steps. Care must also be taken when selecting replacement residues; mutation should not cause delocalized structural reorganization or else the true significance of functional change will remain unclear.

Refolding of barnase in the presence of GroE.

The refolding of barnase in the presence of GroEL has been monitored on the millisecond to seconds time scale using stopped-flow kinetics. GroEL binds rapidly and tightly to the denatured enzyme with a second-order rate constant of greater than 1.3 x 10(8) s-1 M-1 and slows down greatly the rate of barnase refolding. However, addition of ever increasing concentrations of GroEL does not prevent barnase refolding completely, as would be expected from mass action if folding of barnase could proceed only in free solution. At saturating concentrations of GroEL, barnase refolds with a half-life of 30 s, compared with 50 ms for refolding of free enzyme. The rate-determining step in the refolding of free barnase is the reaction of a "late" folding intermediate. A mutant of barnase that fold more slowly (Ser-->Ala91), refolds at a correspondingly lower rate when bound to GroEL, suggesting that formation of the fully folded state may be rate limiting for folding on GroEL. For the slow-folding Ser-->Ala91 mutant, the rate-determining refolding step has a half-life of 180 ms. In sequential mixing experiments, a delay was introduced to allow the Ser-->Ala91 mutant to refold for 30 ms before being mixed with GroEL. This reduces by 50% the amount of mutant barnase initially bound by GroEL. As only 11% of this mutant barnase is fully refolded from the late intermediate in 30 ms, there is preferential binding of an earlier refolding state to GroEL. We show by single mixing experiments that binding, not hydrolysis, of ATP reduces the lag in regain of barnase activity seen with GroEL alone. In the presence of high concentrations of ATP and GroEL the rate constant for refolding of barnase approaches that found in their absence, probably because ATP reduces the affinity of GroEL for refolding barnase, such that bound barnase is released and refolds unhindered. The addition of exceedingly small quantities of GroES in the presence of excess GroEL and a moderate amount of ATP also has a marked effect on the barnase refolding rate constant, suggesting that GroES may have higher affinity for the barnase: GroEL complex than for GroEL.

Strategy for analysing the co-operativity of intramolecular interactions in peptides and proteins.

Double mutant cycles enable the measurement of pairwise interactions in proteins. This method is extended for mutations at any number of positions in the protein. This provides a way for determining the context dependence of pairwise interactions on other neighbouring residues.

Co-operative interactions during protein folding.

The theory for measuring co-operativity between interactions in proteins by protein engineering experiments is developed by introducing a procedure for analysing increasing orders of synergy in a protein with increasing numbers of residues. The (pairwise) interaction energy (delta 2Gint) between two side-chains may be measured experimentally by a double-mutant cycle consisting of the wild-type protein, the two single mutants and the double mutant. This procedure may be extended to three residues to give a value for delta 3Gint for a triple-mutant cube, and to higher orders using multi-dimensional mutant space. We now show that delta 3Gint is the excess energy of adding all three chains compared with the sum of all the pairwise values of delta 2Gint for each of the constituent double-mutant cycles and the sum of all the single addition energies. This physical interpretation extends to higher orders of mutation. delta nGint (i.e. the interaction energy for n residues), thus, reveals the layers of synergy in interactions as a protein is built up. This procedure is applied to measuring changes in synergy during the refolding of barnase for the triad of salt-linked residues Asp8, Asp12 and Arg110, which are mutated to alanine residues. The value of delta 3Gint in the folded structure is 0.77(+/- 0.06) kcal mol-1 (i.e. the triad is 0.77 kcal mol-1 more stable than expected from the sum of the individual pairwise interactions and single contributions). The value of delta 3Gint is still significant in the transition state for unfolding (0.60(+/- 0.07) kcal mol-1) and in the folding intermediate (0.60(+/- 0.13 kcal mol-1)). These results show that synergistic interactions exist in barnase, in its transition state for unfolding and in a refolding intermediate. A direct measurement of the change of co-operativity between the folded state and the transition state for unfolding shows a decrease of 0.17(+/- 0.04) kcal mol-1, suggesting that the initial stages of protein unfolding may be accompanied by some loosening of structure in parts that still interact. The similar extent of co-operativity in the transition state for unfolding and the intermediate in refolding suggests that the intermediate is homogeneous, at least in the region of the salt-linked triad, as heterogeneity would lower the co-operativity.

Dissection of an enzyme by protein engineering. The N and C-terminal fragments of barnase form a native-like complex with restored enzymic activity.

A method is described for producing fragments of a protein suitable for studies of protein folding. The codon for a single methionine residue is introduced into the cloned gene of barnase, and the gene product cleaved with cyanogen bromide. The site of mutation was chosen to be at the surface of the protein in a region connecting segments of secondary structure in the native enzyme. The alpha + beta protein was mutated from Val36----Met, and split into two fragments, B(1-36) containing the alpha-helical regions and B(37-110), the beta-sheet. The fragments were purified by ion exchange chromatography. Neither retains catalytic activity. Fluorescence, circular dichroism, and 1H nuclear magnetic resonance data indicate that their structures are each close to that of random-coil peptides. The two fragments associate to form a tight complex (Kd = 0.2 to 0.6 microM), which displays spectroscopic properties similar to those of the uncleaved protein. The catalytic activity is restored in the complex with a value for Km similar to that for native enzyme but with kcat reduced about three- to fourfold. The second-order rate constant for association on mixing fragments in the concentration range 2.5 to 7.5 microM is 1 x 10(5) s-1 M-1.

Glutamine, alanine or glycine repeats inserted into the loop of a protein have minimal effects on stability and folding rates.

Natural proteins can contain flexible regions in their polypeptide chain. We have investigated the effects of glycine, alanine and glutamine repeats on the stability and folding of a protein by inserting stretches of 7 to 13 residues into a suitable position in a model system, the chymotrypsin inhibitor-2 (CI2). This folds by residues (1-40) docking with residues (41-64) to form a folding nucleus. The peptides GQ4GM, GQ6GM, GQ8GM, GQ10GM, GA2SA4SA2GM and G3SG4SG3M were inserted after residue 40. The stability of the mutant proteins changes only weakly with chain length and nature of insertion, suggesting that the presence of unstructured polypeptide chains in a protein does not have a great energetic penalty. This has implications in catalysis, for example, where floppy regions have been noted in active sites, and in DNA transcription where activators, transcription factors and intermediary proteins all show long repeats of glycine/serine and/or glutamine, which are thought to be important for function. We find that the rate of folding is very insensitive to the length of the linker. The changes in rate are close to those predicted from polymer theory for the loss of configuration entropy on closing a loop. This implies that all the diffusion steps are relatively rapid.

Energetics of protein-protein interactions: analysis of the barnase-barstar interface by single mutations and double mutant cycles.

The interaction of barnase, an extracellular RNase of Bacillus amylolique-faciens, with its intracellular inhibitor barstar is a suitable paradigm for protein-protein interactions, since the structures of both the free and the complexed proteins are available at high resolution. The contributions of residues from both proteins to the energetics of kinetics and thermodynamics of binding were measured by double mutant cycle analysis. Such cycles reveal whether the contributions from a pair of residues are additive, or the effects of mutations are coupled. The aim of the study was to determine which of the interactions are co-operative. Double mutant cycles were constructed between a subset of five barnase and seven barstar residues, which were shown by structural and mutagenesis studies to be important in stabilising the complex. The coupling energy between two residues was found to decrease with the distance between them. Generally, residues separated by less than 7 A interact co-operatively. At greater separations, the effects of mutation are additive, and the energetics of the interactions are independent of each other. The highest coupling energies are found between pairs of charged residues (1.6 to 7 kcal mol-1). Three of the six most important interactions detected by double mutant cycle analysis (with coupling energies of more than 3.0 kcal mol-1) had not been noted previously from examination of the crystal structure. The effects of mutation on the kinetics of association are all additive, apart from charged residues located at distances of up to 10 A apart, which are co-operative. This can be explained by the fact that the transition state for association occurs before most interactions are formed.

Folding of barnase in the presence of the molecular chaperone SecB.

SecB is a molecular chaperone dedicated to interact exclusively with proteins destined for translocation across membranes. We find that SecB interacts with barnase during its folding in a similar manner to its interaction with GroEL. On mixing acid-denatured barnase with SecB in a stopped-flow spectrofluorimeter under conditions that favour refolding, we observe a series of fluorescence changes, corresponding to the binding of the denatured protein and the subsequent refolding of multiply and singly bound forms. The different phases were assigned using a combination of kinetics and mutant proteins. The refolding of barnase when bound to SecB is strongly retarded but never blocked. Multiply bound barnase is less tightly bound and refolds with a higher rate constant than singly bound barnase. Up to 4 mol of denatured barnase bind to 1 mol of tetrameric SecB.