Evaluation of linear accelerator radiosurgical techniques using biophysical parameters (NTCP and TCP).

PURPOSE: Several irradiation techniques are compared with regard to normal tissue complication probability and tumor control probability. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Normal tissue complication probability is calculated using a model based on the "critical element architecture." The probability of controlling an inhomogeneously irradiated tumor is calculated using a model that takes into account the heterogeneity of tumors (different radiosensitivity of clonogens within the tumor and the varying number of clonogens among patients with the same kind of tumor). The ratio of tumor control probability to normal tissue complication probability (therapeutic gain factor) at different levels of dose has been used as a score for the analysis of various irradiation techniques. RESULTS: The best irradiation techniques depends on many factors: irradiation genometry, irradiation field size, choice of the reference isodose, and it is dictated by the pathology of the lesions (noninfiltrating radioresistant tumors, infiltrating radioresistant tumors, noninfiltrating radiosensitive tumors, infiltrating radiosensitive tumors, arterovenous malformations). For the irradiation of the artero-venous malformations it is proposed to insert on the supplemental collimator a flattening filter to reduce the probability of inducing a poorly syncronized obliterative effect. CONCLUSION: We propose that for each kind of pathology to be treated radiosurgically, a proper irradiation strategy should be used.

From radiotherapy to stereotactic radiosurgery: physical and dosimetrical considerations.

The aim of this presentation is to analyse the mechanical and dosimetrical parameters of the linear accelerator used in stereotactic radiosurgery. The use of the thimble and Markus chambers, TL and film in small field dosimetry are investigated. To determine the optimal irradiation technique and dose distribution, the dose volume to healthy tissue is considered.

Dosimetric considerations on multiple arc stereotaxic radiotherapy.

The aim of this paper is to present the physical and dosimetrical features of the stereotaxic radiosurgical method already published by the authors. This method concentrates the dose into the stereotaxic target volume, placed at the isocenter of a 4 MV X-ray beam. Computer calculations showed that: 9-17 arcs provide almost spherical dose distributions; the optimal photon beam quality is about 4-6 MV. The angle between adjacent rotation planes is 20-40 degrees and the arcs are 100-160 degrees wide. In this way the dose to healthy tissue is minimized. The dose distribution was experimentally verified both by ionometric and photodensitometric methods. The procedure for dose calculation at isocenter of fields as small as required by the radiotherapist, has been investigated.

Analysis of dosimetric measurements in linac radiosurgery calibration.

The aim of this paper is to analyse the dosimetric parameters of a linear accelerator used in radiosurgery treatments. The influence of these parameters on the resulting dose distribution are basic for delivering the predefined dose to the vascular or oncological target volume. Several dosimetric methods have been used to define the output factors for small fields. The thimble and the Markus chambers, TLD and film dosimetry are investigated; all these dosimetric systems give reliable and almost similar results if used in the correct way. In the determination of tissue maximum ratio (TMR) the response curves obtained by ionometric and film dosimetry were investigated. For TMR determination the use of the Markus chamber and the correction factors to be applied as a result of the small dimension of the field were also investigated.

Quality assurance in conformal radiotherapy: DYNARAD consensus report on practice guidelines.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Conformal radiotherapy has only recently been widely implemented. Although not all aspects have yet been adequately proven, it is generally recognized that maintaining a high degree of precision throughout the process is critical to the treatment outcome while the focus for quality assurance and quality improvement will need to concentrate more on human factors, procedures, communication, organization and training. A general consensus document on quality assurance guidelines for institutions that deliver conformal radiotherapy treatments to patients has been elaborated within the framework of the DYNARAD/BIOMED concerted action on conformal radiotherapy. The present paper aims to highlight those issues that were identified as of specific importance to conformal radiotherapy. The work reported here further details this guidance by direct correlation with the issues involved in the special case of conformal radiotherapy. METHODS: The DYNARAD document has been drafted in the form of a desktop guide comprising six sets of guidelines and is based on the ESTRO advisory report on 'Quality Assurance in Radiotherapy'. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: The document has been endorsed by the DYNARAD group of institutions. As such it can form the basis for further discussions and enter into the subsequent phase of expanding its consensus basis.

Linear accelerator radiosurgery of cerebral arteriovenous malformations.

A technique for linear accelerator radiosurgery has been used in clinical practice since 1982. The technique is based on multiple intersecting arc irradiations focused on a stereotactic target. From November 1984 to October 1988, 97 patients with cerebral arteriovenous malformations have been treated. Seventy-nine patients suffered one or more than one hemorrhage. Four patients had progressive neurological symptoms. In 14 patients, epilepsy was the principal complaint. Stereotactic localization was performed by stereotactic angiography. Lesion dimensions varied from 4 to 40 mm in diameter. Doses from 18.7 to 40 Gy were delivered in one or two sessions. Mean follow-up is 17.1 months (from 1 to 49). Four instances of minor rebleeding were observed after treatment; 3 patients complained of transient neurological deterioration. Of 56 patients who were followed longer than 1 year, 50 underwent 12-month follow-up angiography. In 26 patients complete obliteration of the malformation was demonstrated (52%), in 12 patients subtotal obliteration was obtained (24%), in 11 patients the obliteration was evident but not significant (22%), and in 1 patient the AVM was unchanged. Other angiographic features in incompletely obliterated cases were a significant reduction of flow velocity through the malformation together with a reduction in diameter of both feeding arteries and draining veins.

Linear accelerator radiosurgery of cerebral arteriovenous malformations: an update.

One hundred eighty patients affected by cerebral arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) underwent radiosurgical treatment in our department. One hundred fifty-three patients have been treated with complete irradiation of the entire AVM nidus. In 27 patients (with large and/or three-dimensional irregular target volumes), only part of the nidus was covered with a dose adequate for obliteration. Follow-up ranged from 88 to 1 months (mean, 43.1 mo). Angiographic control was performed at 12, 24, and 36 months until complete obliteration was attained. The complete obliteration rate was 46% at 1 year and 80% at 2 years. We observed 15 hemorrhages after treatment, and five patients died from them. No bleeding took place after complete angiographic obliteration. The aim of this study is to evaluate the effect of irradiation on bleeding risk after radiosurgery and before complete obliteration. Inclusive parameters of patients considered at risk were as follows: 1) all patients in the time lapse between irradiation and demonstrated complete angiographic obliteration; 2) all patients in the time lapse between irradiation and definitive treatment either by surgery or embolization; and 3) all patients in the time lapse between irradiation and death. These groups include all irradiated patients who still had incompletely obliterated AVMs. They were stratified starting from 0 time (the date of radiosurgery), and the hemorrhages were evaluated every 6 months. In totally irradiated cases, the bleeding risk decreased from 4.8% in the first 6 months after radiosurgery to 0% starting from the 12th month of the follow-up.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

External stereotactic irradiation by linear accelerator.

Stereotactic radiotherapy has two advantages: (a) the possibility of giving high radiation doses to small but spatially well-defined target volumes and (b) the presence of a stepped dose gradient between the target volume and the surrounding healthy tissues. To utilize these advantages, the authors built a new stereotactic head frame by which the intracranial target is fixed to the rotational isocenter of a 4-MV linear accelerator. The collimator openings are selected according to the volume and the three-dimensional configuration of the target, and the radiation dose is based on the radiosensitivity of the lesion. After the patient is fixed to the frame, the radiation source and the patient are rotated so that the target is irradiated through infinite portals distributed over the convexity of the skull. It is thereby possible to obtain very high radiation doses centered into the target with a stepped dose gradient. The preliminary radiodosimetric tests and the operative technique are described. The advantages of this technique compared to interstitial radiotherapy and Leksell's radiosurgery are emphasized. This noninvasive procedure has been used to treat a series of intracranial tumors.

Comparison of conformal radiation therapy techniques within the dynamic radiotherapy project 'Dynarad'.

The objective of the dynamic radiotherapy project 'Dynarad' within the European Community has been to compare and grade treatment techniques that are currently applied or being developed at the participating institutions. Cervical cancer was selected as the tumour site on the grounds that the involved organs at risk, mainly the rectum and the bladder, are very close to the tumour and partly located inside the internal target volume. In this work, a solid phantom simulating the pelvic anatomy was used by institutions in Belgium, France, Greece, Holland, Italy, Sweden and the United Kingdom. The results were evaluated using both biological and physical criteria. The main purpose of this parallel evaluation is to test the value of biological and physical evaluations in comparing treatment techniques. It is demonstrated that the biological objective functions allow a much higher conformality and a more clinically relevant scoring of the outcome. Often external beam treatment techniques have to be combined with intracavitary therapy to give clinically acceptable results. However, recent developments can reduce or even eliminate this need by delivering more conformal dose distributions using intensity modulated external dose delivery. In these cases the reliability of the patient set-up procedure becomes critical for the effectiveness of the treatment.

A retrospective analysis concerning physical aspects and clinical dosimetry in radiosurgery.

The authors have reviewed their experience with treatments of small intracranial lesions by unconventionally fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy using a 4 MV photon beam. Treatment is carried out by multiple non coplanar arc irradiation obtained rotating the target, while kept at the isocentre of a Linac, around a vertical axis. The outmost concentration of the dose within the target volume enables consistent reduction of the amount of the absorbed dose by critical structures of the intact brain. They analyse the dose distribution and the method to optimise the choice of the therapeutic dose. Finally, some radiobiological considerations are presented.

Stereotactic radiosurgery of intracranial tumors in childhood.

The Authors have developed an original stereotactic technique by which the radiation dose erogated by a 4 MV linear accelerator is focused into the target volume with a steep dose gradient at its borders. The technique has been employed in a series of 30 patients affected by deep seated brain tumors and AVMs. The paper deals with the preliminary results obtained in a series of 10 patients in pediatric age.

Linear accelerator radiosurgery of cerebral arteriovenous malformations: current status.

228 patients affected by cerebral arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) underwent linear accelerator radiosurgery. Follow-up ranges from 1 to 100 months (mean 42 months). Complete angiographic obliteration was achieved in 47% of treated patients at one year and 80% at 2 years. 17 haemorrhages were observed after treatment and 6 patients died from them. No bleeding took place after complete angiographic obliteration. 11 patients suffered for radionecrosis. In 6 patients complete recovery was obtained with corticoid medication. The aim of this study is to present our results and to evaluate the effect of irradiation on the risk of bleeding after radiosurgery. Patients were considered at risk in the time lapse after irradiation and before angiographic obliteration or other definitive treatment or death. Patients were followed from the date of radiosurgery and the number of haemorrhages were recorded every six months. In our series the bleeding risk in patients harbouring incompletely obliterated AVMs decreases from 8% in the first year after radiosurgery to 0% starting from the 24th month of the follow-up.

[Postoperative pain in pediatric patients]. / Il dolore post-operatorio nel paziente pediatrico.

Surgery is an unpleasant experience which is always related to a period of pain. In the pediatric patient this results in an important effective and metabolic-neuroendocrine manifestation. After a short review of the methods recently used to evaluate pain-qualitatively as well as quantitatively, we focused on the different techniques and drugs which can be used by the anesthesiologist to achieve an adequate control of the pain symptoms. The aim is to provide devices which can be used for different groups of age in order to guarantee the maximum efficacy in pain control with the least side effect and invasiveness.

[Inhomogeneity of electron beam dose distribution]. / Considerazioni sulle disomogeneità nella distribuzione di dose dei fasci di elettroni.

The radiation therapy employing high energy electron beams took place in superficial or near-superficial target volume treatments. The author describes the dose distribution in the patient whose body is not homogeneous for the presence of bone structures or air cavities that may involve localised perturbations of the dose distributions. Several methods have been developed to obtain the correct dose distribution including the influence of depth, field size and energy. The author describes how the dose distribution changes when the body contour at the beam entrance is bent and oblique. Artificial inhomogeneity like compensators, bolus and adjacent electron beam field may give unexpected small overdose areas.

A method for the quantitative evaluation of SAR distribution in deep regional hyperthermia.

The Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) distribution pattern visualization by a matrix of E-field light-emitting sensors has demonstrated to be a useful tool to evaluate the characteristics of the applicators used in deep regional hyperthermia and to perform a quality assurance programme. A method to quantify the SAR from photographs of the sensor array--the so-called 'Power Stepping Technique'--has already been proposed. This paper presents a new approach to the quantitative determination of the SAR profiles in a liquid phantom exposed to electromagnetic fields from the Sigma-60 applicator (BSD-2000 system for deep regional hyperthermia). The method is based on the construction of a 'calibration curve' modelling the light-output of an E-field sensor as a function of the supplied voltage and on the use of a reference light source to 'normalize' the light-output readings from the photos of the sensor array, in order to minimize the errors introduced by the non-uniformity of the photographic process. Once the calibration curve is obtained, it is possible, with only one photo, to obtain the quantitative SAR distribution in the operating conditions. For this reason, this method is suitable for equipment characterization and also for the control of the repeatability of power deposition in time.

New technique for three-dimensional linear accelerator radiosurgery.

A new method for external stereotactic focal irradiation of three-dimensional irregular target volumes is proposed. In this method the target is irradiated by a linear accelerator set in various angular positions around the isocenter. During the irradiation the target is translated in a direction perpendicular to the beam. By controlling the velocity of the translation it is possible to modify the configuration of therapeutic isodoses so as to make them follow the borders of the target.

Linear accelerator radiosurgery of three-dimensional irregular targets.

Current radiosurgical techniques allow concentration of radiation from external sources into spherical targets. Nonspherical target volumes require a modification of the irradiation technique. Moreover, isodose shaping is sometimes necessary to spare nearby important radiosensitive structures. To meet these prerequisites we have introduced some technical refinements: (1) computer-controlled rectilinear translations of the target in combination with different angular positions of the source and (2) computer-controlled rotations of the target around a vertical axis in combination with different angular positions of the source. The first solution has proven efficient for treating irregular targets, while the second one was employed for focusing the radiation dose inside volumes obtained by rotation of ellipses.

Development of a second generation stereotactic apparatus for linear accelerator radiosurgery.

Linear accelerator radiosurgery technique is based on a multiple intersecting arc irradiations procedure. The coincidence of the axis of two rotation movements (of gantry and treatment couch) into the isocenter is critical for focusing irradiation. In October 1989, our linear accelerator was changed and the stereotactic apparatus had to be adapted to the new machine. After multiple mechanical tests of the new machine, the stereotactic head frame was fixed to the roller bearing allowing rotation of the couch. The new apparatus is described.

Low-grade astrocytomas: treatment with unconventionally fractionated external beam stereotactic radiation therapy.

Fourteen patients with nonoperable low-grade astrocytomas were treated with unconventionally fractionated stereotactic radiation therapy. The target volume was defined with computed tomography (CT) performed under stereotactic conditions. The treatment was carried out with a technique producing multiple noncoplanar arc irradiation, with the center of the target volume placed at the isocenter of the linear accelerator. A total dose of 16-50 Gy was administered in either one fraction or two fractions 8 days apart. The concentration of dose within the target volume allowed reduction of dose absorbed by adjacent critical structures of the intact brain. Patients were followed up for 11-48 months. Twelve of 14 patients had a partial or complete response to treatment, as demonstrated by CT. Stereotactic radiation therapy appears to be effective in the control of small radioresistant cerebral neoplasms, without damaging surrounding healthy tissues.