Immune versus natural selection: antibody aldolases with enzymic rates but broader scope.

Structural and mechanistic studies show that when the selection criteria of the immune system are changed, catalytic antibodies that have the efficiency of natural enzymes evolve, but the catalytic antibodies are much more accepting of a wide range of substrates. The catalytic antibodies were prepared by reactive immunization, a process whereby the selection criteria of the immune system are changed from simple binding to chemical reactivity. This process yielded aldolase catalytic antibodies that approximated the rate acceleration of the natural enzyme used in glycolysis. Unlike the natural enzyme, however, the antibody aldolases catalyzed a variety of aldol reactions and decarboxylations. The crystal structure of one of these antibodies identified the reactive lysine residue that was selected in the immunization process. This lysine is deeply buried in a hydrophobic pocket at the base of the binding site, thereby accounting for its perturbed pKa.

Amino acid sequences and hapten binding of catalytic and noncatalytic antibodies against N(alpha)-(5'-phosphopyridoxyl)-L-lysine.

Upon immunization with a transition-state analog, only a minority of the hapten-binding antibodies will possess catalytic activity, which will vary in efficacy and substrate specificity. Here, the amino acid sequences of the variable domains of two pyridoxal-5'-phosphate-dependent catalytic and five noncatalytic hapten-binding antibodies raised by immunization with protein-conjugated N(alpha)-(5'-phosphopyridoxyl)-L-lysine (Gramatikova, S., Christen, P., 1997. J. Biol. Chem. 272, 9779-9784) were determined by sequencing their cDNAs. The analysis revealed that the light chains of this set of antibodies were closely related (pairwise identity 65-80%), whereas the heavy chains could be traced back to two different but related groups (intergroup identity 50-54%). The majority of the antibodies proved not to be clonally related, a finding which correlates with their differences in enantiomeric selectivity in ligand binding and reaction specificity. Only one noncatalytic antibody was found to be clonally related with a catalytic antibody, the sequence identity being >95% in both the V(H) and V(L) domains. The complementarity-determining regions were invariably abundant in tyrosine residues. Nitration of three to four tyrosine residues with tetranitromethane abolished hapten binding and catalytic activity. Partial protection by pyridoxal-5'-phosphate against inactivation suggested the presence of functionally important tyrosine residues in the binding sites of the antibodies.

The pyridoxal-5'-phosphate-dependent catalytic antibody 15A9: its efficiency and stereospecificity in catalysing the exchange of the alpha-protons of glycine.

13C-NMR has been used to follow the exchange of the alpha-protons of [2-(13)C]glycine in the presence of pyridoxal-5'-phosphate and the catalytic antibody 15A9. In the presence of antibody 15A9 the 1st order exchange rates for the rapidly exchanged proton of [2-(13)C]glycine were only 25 and 150 times slower than those observed with tryptophan synthase (EC 4.2.1.20) and serine hydroxymethyltransferase (EC 2.1.2.1). The catalytic antibody increases the 1st order exchange rates of the alpha-protons of [2-(13)C]glycine by at least three orders of magnitude. We propose that this increase is largely due to an entropic mechanism which results from binding the glycine-pyridoxal-5'-phosphate Schiff base. The 1st and 2nd order exchange rates of the pro-2S proton have been determined but we were only able to determine the 2nd order exchange rate for the pro-2R proton of glycine. In the presence of 50 mM glycine the antibody preferentially catalyses the exchange of the pro-2S proton of glycine. The stereospecificity of the 2nd order exchange reaction was quantified and we discuss mechanisms which could account for the observed stereospecificity.

Pyridoxal-5'-phosphate-dependent catalytic antibodies.

Cofactors--i.e., metal ions and coenzymes--extend the catalytic scope of enzymes and might have been among the first biological catalysts. They may be expected to efficiently extend the catalytic potential of antibodies. Monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) against Nalpha-phosphopyridoxyl-L-lysine were screened for 1) binding of 5'-phosphopyridoxyl amino acids, 2) binding of the planar Schiff base of pyridoxal-5'-phosphate (PLP) and amino acids, the first intermediate of all PLP-dependent reactions, and 3) catalysis of the PLP-dependent alpha, beta-elimination reaction with beta-chloro-D/L-alanine. Antibody 15A9 fulfilled all criteria and was also found to catalyze the cofactor-dependent transamination reaction of hydrophobic D-amino acids and oxo acids (k'cat = 0.42 min(-1) with D-alanine at 25 degrees C). No other reactions with either D- or L-amino acids were detected. PLP markedly contributes to catalytic efficacy-it is a 10(4) times more efficient acceptor of the amino group than pyruvate. The antibody ensures reaction specificity, stereospecificity, and substrate specificity, and further accelerates the transamination reaction (k'cat(Ab)/k'cat(PLP) = 5 x 10(3)). The successive screening steps simulate the selection criteria that might have been operative in the evolution of protein-assisted pyridoxal catalysis.

Pyridoxal 5'-phosphate-dependent catalytic antibody.

Cofactors might efficiently extend the catalytic potential of antibodies. Monoclonal antibodies against Nalpha-phosphopyridoxyl-L-lysine were screened for: 1) binding of 5'-phosphopyridoxyl amino acids, 2) binding of Schiff base of pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP) and amino acids, the first intermediate of all PLP-dependent reactions, and 3) catalysis of PLP-dependent alpha,beta-elimination with beta-chloro-D/L-alanine. All three criteria were met by antibody 15A9. Further analysis for PLP-dependent reactions showed that this antibody catalyzes the cofactor-dependent transamination of hydrophobic D-amino acids and oxo acids (kcat' = 0.42 min-1 with D-alanine). No other reactions with either D- or L-amino acids were taking place. PLP markedly contributes to catalytic efficacy, being a 10(4) times more efficient acceptor of the amino group than pyruvate. The antibody further accelerates the reaction (kcat(antibody)'/kcat(PLP)' = 5 x 10(3) with D-alanine as substrate) and ensures reaction specificity, stereospecificity, as well as limited substrate specificity.

Monoclonal antibodies against Nalpha-(5'-phosphopyridoxyl)-L-lysine. Screening and spectrum of pyridoxal 5'-phosphate-dependent activities toward amino acids.

Cofactors may be expected to expand the range of reactions amenable to antibody-assisted catalysis. The biological importance of pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP) as enzymic cofactor in amino acid metabolism and its catalytic versatility make it an attractive candidate for the generation of cofactor-dependent abzymes. Here we report an efficient procedure to screen antibodies for PLP-dependent catalytic activity and detail the spectrum of catalytic activities found in monoclonal antibodies elicited against Nalpha-(5'-phosphopyridoxyl)-L-lysine. This hapten is a nonplanar analog of the planar, resonance-stabilized coenzyme-substrate adducts formed in the PLP-dependent reactions of amino acids. The hapten-binding antibodies were screened for binding of the planar Schiff base formed from PLP and D- or L-norleucine by competition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The Schiff base (external aldimine) is an obligatory intermediate in all PLP-dependent reactions of amino acids. This simple, yet highly discriminating screening step eliminated most of the total 24 hapten-binding antibodies. Three positive clones bound the Schiff base with L-norleucine, two preferred that with the D-enantiomer. The positive clones were assayed for catalysis of Schiff base formation and of the alpha,beta-elimination reaction with the D- and L-enantiomers of beta-chloroalanine. Three antibodies were found to accelerate aldimine formation, and two of these catalyzed the PLP-dependent alpha,beta-elimination reaction. One of the alpha, beta-elimination-positive antibodies catalyzed the transamination reaction with hydrophobic D-amino acids and oxoacids (Gramatikova, S. I., and Christen, P. (1996) J. Biol. Chem. 271, 30583-30586). All catalytically active antibodies displayed continuous turnover. No PLP-dependent reactions other than aldimine formation, alpha, beta-elimination of beta-chloroalanine and transamination were detected. The successive screening steps plausibly simulate the functional selection pressures having been operative in the molecular evolution of primordial PLP-dependent protein catalysts to reaction- and substrate-specific enzymes.

RNA cleavage by a DNA enzyme with extended chemical functionality.

In vitro selection techniques were applied to the development of a DNA enzyme that contains three catalytically essential imidazole groups and catalyzes the cleavage of RNA substrates. Nucleic acid libraries for selection were constructed by polymerase-catalyzed incorporation of C5-imidazole-functionalized deoxyuridine in place of thymidine. Chemical synthesis was used to define a minimized catalytic domain composed of only 12 residues. The catalytic domain forms a compact hairpin structure that displays the three imidazole-containing residues. The enzyme can be made to cleave RNAs of almost any sequence by simple alteration of the two substrate-recognition domains that surround the catalytic domain. The enzyme operates with multiple turnover in the presence of micromolar concentrations of Zn2+, exhibiting saturation kinetics and a catalytic rate of >1 min-1. The imidazole-containing DNA enzyme, one of the smallest known nucleic acid enzymes, combines the substrate-recognition properties of nucleic acid enzymes and the chemical functionality of protein enzymes in a molecule that is small, yet versatile and catalytically efficient.