The energetic basis of specificity in the Eco RI endonuclease--DNA interaction.

High sequence selectivity in DNA-protein interactions was analyzed by measuring discrimination by Eco RI endonuclease between the recognition site GAATTC and systematically altered DNA sites. Base analogue substitutions that preserve the sequence-dependent conformational motif of the GAATTC site permit deletion of single sites of protein-base contact at a cost of +1 to +2 kcal/mol. However, the introduction of any one incorrect natural base pair costs +6 to +13 kcal/mol in transition state interaction energy, the resultant of the following interdependent factors: deletion of one or two hydrogen bonds between the protein and a purine base; unfavourable steric apposition between a group on the protein and an incorrectly placed functional group on a base; disruption of a pyrimidine contact with the protein; loss of some crucial interactions between protein and DNA phosphates; and an increased energetic cost of attaining the required DNA conformation in the transition state complex. Eco RI endonuclease thus achieves stringent discrimination by both "direct readout" (protein-base contracts) and "indirect readout" (protein-phosphate contacts and DNA conformation) of the DNA sequence.

Facilitated distortion of the DNA site enhances EcoRI endonuclease-DNA recognition.

We have measured the binding of EcoRI endonuclease to a complete set of purine-base analogue sites, each of which deletes one functional group that forms a hydrogen bond with the endonuclease in the canonical GAATTC complex. For five of six functional group deletions, the observed penalty in binding free energy is +1.3 to +1.7 kcal/mol. For two of these cases (replacement of adenine N7 with carbon) a single protein-base hydrogen bond is removed without deleting an interstrand Watson-Crick hydrogen bond or causing structural "adaptation" in the complex. This observation establishes that the incremental energetic contribution of one protein-base hydrogen bond is about -1.5 kcal/mol. By contrast, deletion of the N6-amino group of the inner adenine in the site improves binding by -1.0 kcal/mol because the penalty for deleting a protein-base hydrogen bond is outweighed by facilitation of the required DNA distortion ("kinking") in the complex. This result provides direct evidence that the energetic cost of distorting a DNA site can make an unfavorable contribution to protein-DNA binding.

Chiral phosphorothioates as probes of protein interactions with individual DNA phosphoryl oxygens: essential interactions of EcoRI endonuclease with the phosphate at pGAATTC.

The contact between EcoRI endonuclease and the "primary clamp" phosphate of its recognition site pGAATTC is absolutely required for recognition of the canonical and all variant DNA sites. We have probed this contact using oligonucleotides containing single stereospecific (Rp)- or (Sp)- phosphorothioates (Ps). At the GAApTTC position, where the endonuclease interacts with only one phosphoryl oxygen at the central DNA kink, Rp-Ps inhibits and Sp-Ps stimulates binding and cleavage [Lesser et al. (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 24810-24818]: in contrast, at the pGAATTC position both diastereomers inhibit binding. For single-strand substitution, the penalty in binding free energy (delta delta G0bind) is slightly greater for Sp-Ps (+ 0.9 kcal/mol) than for Rp-Ps (+ 0.7 kcal/mol). Binding penalties are approximately additive for double-strand substitution (Rp,Rp-Ps or Sp,Sp-Ps). Neither Ps diastereomer in one DNA strand affects the first-order rate constants for cleavage in the unmodified DNA strand, and only Sp-Ps inhibits the cleavage rate constant (3-fold) in the modified DNA strand. Thus, the second-order cleavage rate (including binding and catalysis) is inhibited 14-fold by Sp-Ps and 45-fold by Sp,Sp-Ps. In the canonical complex, the phosphate at pGAATTC is completely surrounded by protein and each nonbridging phosphoryl oxygen receives two hydrogen bonds from the endonuclease, such that in either orientation the increased bond length of P-S- inhibits binding. However, the pro-Sp oxygen interacts with residues that are connected (by proximity or inter-side-chain hydrogen bonding) to side chains with essential roles in catalysis, so cleavage is preferentially inhibited when these side chains are slightly displaced by the Sp-Ps diastereomer.

Proteases of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans.

Crude homogenates of the soil nematode Caenorhabditis elegans exhibit strong proteolytic activity at acid pH. Several kinds of enzyme account for much of this activity: cathepsin D, a carboxyl protease which is inhibited by pepstatin and optimally active toward hemoglobin at pH 3; at least two isoelectrically distinct thiol proteases (cathepsins Ce1 and Ce2) which are inhibited by leupeptin and optimally active toward Z-Phe-Arg-7-amino-4-methylcoumarin amide at pH 5; and a thiol-independent leupeptin-insensitive protease (cathepsin Ce3) with optimal activity toward casein at pH 5.5. Cathepsin D is quantitatively most significant for digestion of macromolecular substrates in vitro, since proteolysis is inhibited greater than 95% by pepstatin. Cathepsin D and the leupeptin-sensitive proteases act synergistically, but the relative contribution of the leupeptin-sensitive proteases depends upon the protein substrate.

Stereoselective interaction with chiral phosphorothioates at the central DNA kink of the EcoRI endonuclease-GAATTC complex.

We have probed the contacts between EcoRI endonuclease and the central phosphate of its recognition site GAApTTC, using synthetic oligonucleotides containing single stereospecific Rp- or Sp-phosphorothioates (Ps). These substitutions produce subtle stereospecific effects on EcoRI endonuclease binding and cleavage. An Sp-Ps substitution in one strand of the DNA duplex improves binding free energy by -1.5 kcal/mol, whereas the Rp-Ps substitution has an unfavorable effect (+0.3 kcal/mol) on binding free energy. These effects derive principally from changes in the first order rate constants for dissociation of the enzyme-DNA complexes. The first order rate constants for strand scission are also affected, in that a strand containing Sp-Ps substitution is cleaved 2 to 3 times more rapidly than a strand containing a normal prochiral phosphate, whereas a strand containing Rp-Ps substitution is cleaved about 3 times slower than normal. As a result, single-strand substitutions produce pronounced asymmetry in the rates of cleavage of the two DNA strands, and this effect is exaggerated in an Rp,Sp-heteroduplex. Ethylation-interference footprinting indicates that none of the Ps substitutions cause any major change in contacts between endonuclease and DNA phosphates. When an Sp-Ps localizes P = O in the DNA major groove, a hydrogen-bonding interaction with the backbone amide-NH of Gly116 of the endonuclease is improved relative to that with a prochiral phosphate having intermediate P-O bond order and delocalized charge.

Structural adaptations in the interaction of EcoRI endonuclease with methylated GAATTC sites.

We have studied the interaction of EcoRI endonuclease with oligonucleotides containing GAATTC sites bearing one or two adenine-N6-methyl groups, which would be in steric conflict with key protein side chains involved in recognition and/or catalysis in the canonical complex. Single-strand methylation of either adenine produces small penalties in binding free energy (deltadeltaG0(S) approximately +1.4 kcal/mol), but elicits asymmetric structural adaptations in the complex, such that cleavage rate constants are strongly inhibited and unequal in the two DNA strands. The dependences of cleavage rate constants on the concentration of the Mg2+ cofactor are unaltered. When either adenine is methylated on both DNA strands, deltadeltaG0(S) (approximately +4 kcal/mol) is larger than the expected sum of the deltadeltaG0(S) values for the single-strand methylations, because the asymmetric adaptations cannot occur. Cleavage rate constants are reduced by 600 000-fold for the biologically relevant GAmATTC/CTTmAAG site, but the GmAATTC/CTTAmAG site forms only a non-specific complex that cannot be cleaved. These observations provide a detailed thermodynamic and kinetic explanation of how single-strand and double-strand methylation protect against endonuclease cleavage in vivo. We propose that non-additive effects on binding and structural 'adaptations' are important in understanding how DNA methylation modulates the biological activities of non-catalytic DNA binding proteins.