Comparison of Nutrient and Metal Loadings with the Application of Swine Manure Slurries and Their Liquid Separates to Soils.

The accumulation of phosphorus (P) and metals is a serious concern with the continuous application of manure to agricultural soils. Solid-liquid separation of swine slurry is a promising approach to reduce P and metal loadings through application of separated liquid (SL) as a nutrient source. However, little information is available on nutrient and metal loadings with the application of SL compared with unseparated raw manure (RM). We analyzed element concentrations and calculated nutrient and metal loadings for RM and their respective SL applications, considering an application rate of 100 kg total nitrogen (N) ha. Samples of SL were obtained through three separation techniques: (i) centrifugation without a flocculant, (ii) centrifugation with a flocculant, and (iii) rotary press with a flocculant. Irrespective of separation technique, calculated P loadings with the application of SL were only 50 to 70% of that of RM at equivalent rates of total N yet exceeded crop removal rate. In contrast, calculated K and Na loadings with SL application were significantly greater than with RM, indicating a possible build-up of K and Na in soil. Calculated Ca and Mg loadings were significantly greater with RM than with SL. Loadings of Al, As, Ba, Cd, Cr, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb, Sn, Se, Ti, and V were low, whereas Cu and Zn loadings were above crop removal rates for RM and SL. For solid-liquid separation to provide a lasting solution to the problem of P and metal accumulation, the SL must be supplemented with commercial N fertilizer to meet crop N demand.

Laboratory characterization of phosphorus in fresh and oven-dried organic amendments.

This study was performed to determine the forms of P and to examine the influence of oven-drying on P forms in different organic amendments. Samples of biosolids, beef and dairy cattle manures, and hog manures from sow and nursery barns were used in this study. Both fresh and oven-dried amendments were analyzed for inorganic (Pi), organic (Po), and total phosphorus using a modified Hedley fractionation technique. Water extracted about 10% of total biosolids P and 30 to 40% of total hog and cattle manure P. The amount of P extracted by NaHCO3 ranged from 21 to 32% of total P in all organic amendments except in the dairy cattle manure with 45% of total P. The labile P fraction (sum of H2O- and NaHCO3-extractable P) was 24% of biosolids P, 60% of hog manure P, and 70% of dairy cattle manure P. The residual P was about 10% in biosolids and cattle manures and 5 to 8% in hog manures. Oven-drying caused a transformation in forms of P in the organic amendments. In hog manures, H2O-extractable Po was transformed to Pi, while in the dairy manure NaHCO3-extractable P was converted to H2O-extractable Pi with oven-drying. Therefore, caution should be exercised in using oven-drying for studies that evaluate forms of P in organic amendments. Overall, these results indicate that biosolids P may be less susceptible to loss by water when added to agricultural land.