Targeted gene knockout mediated by triple helix forming oligonucleotides.

Triple helix forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) recognize and bind sequences in duplex DNA and have received considerable attention because of their potential for targeting specific genomic sites. TFOs can deliver DNA reactive reagents to specific sequences in purified chromosomal DNA (ref. 4) and nuclei. However, chromosome targeting in viable cells has not been demonstrated, and in vitro experiments indicate that chromatin structure is incompatible with triplex formation. We have prepared modified TFOs, linked to the DNA-crosslinking reagent psoralen, directed at a site in the Hprt gene. We show that stable Hprt-deficient clones can be recovered following introduction of the TFOs into viable cells and photoactivation of the psoralen. Analysis of 282 clones indicated that 85% contained mutations in the triplex target region. We observed mainly deletions and some insertions. These data indicate that appropriately constructed TFOs can find chromosomal targets, and suggest that the chromatin structure in the target region is more dynamic than predicted by the in vitro experiments.

Targeting of an interrupted polypurine:polypyrimidine sequence in mammalian cells by a triplex-forming oligonucleotide containing a novel base analogue.

The DNA triple helix consists of a third strand of nucleic acid lying in the major groove of an intact DNA duplex. The most stable triplexes form on polypurine:polypyrimidine sequences, and pyrimidine interruptions in the purine strand are destabilizing. Sequence stringency is imparted by specific Hoogsteen hydrogen bonds between third strand bases and the purine bases in the duplex. Appropriate base and sugar modifications of triple helix-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) confer chromosome targeting activity in living cells. However, broad utilization of TFOs as gene targeting reagents in mammalian cells has been limited by the requirement for homopurine target sequences. Although there have been a number of base analogues described that appear to be promising as candidates for triplex target expansion, none has been examined in a biological system. We have employed a postsynthetic strategy to prepare a collection of TFOs with base analogues at a defined position. Following assessment of affinity for a triplex target with a single C:G inversion, TFOs with a second generation of analogues were synthesized. One of these, TFO-5a, with 2'-OMe-guanidinylethyl-5-methylcytosine at the position corresponding to the C:G interruption in the target sequence, was further modified to confer bioactivity. The activity of this TFO, linked to psoralen, was measured in a mammalian cell line that was engineered by directed sequence conversion to carry a triplex target with a single C:G interruption. TFO-5a was active against this target and inactive against the corresponding target with an uninterrupted polypurine:polypyrimidine sequence.

Mutagenesis in mammalian cells induced by triple helix formation and transcription-coupled repair.

When mammalian cells were treated with triplex-forming oligonucleotides of sufficient binding affinity, mutations were specifically induced in a simian virus 40 vector contained within the cells. Triplex-induced mutagenesis was not detected in xeroderma pigmentosum group A cells nor in Cockayne's syndrome group B cells, indicating a requirement for excision repair and for transcription-coupled repair, respectively, in the process. Triplex formation was also found to stimulate DNA repair synthesis in human cell extracts, in a pattern correlating with the inhibition of transcription in such extracts. These findings may have implications for therapeutic applications of triplex DNA and raise the possibility that naturally occurring triple helices are a source of genetic instability.

Abnormal ultraviolet mutagenic spectrum in plasmid DNA replicated in cultured fibroblasts from a patient with the skin cancer-prone disease, xeroderma pigmentosum.

A shuttle vector plasmid, pZ189, was utilized to assess the types of mutations that cells from a patient with xeroderma pigmentosum, complementation group D, introduce into ultraviolet (UV) damaged, replicating DNA. Patients with xeroderma pigmentosum have clinical and cellular UV hypersensitivity, increased frequency of sun-induced skin cancer, and deficient DNA repair. In comparison to UV-treated pZ189 replicated in DNA repair-proficient cells, there were fewer surviving plasmids, a higher frequency of plasmids with mutations, fewer plasmids with two or more mutations in the marker gene, and a new mutagenic hotspot. The major type of base substitution mutation was the G:C to A:T transition with both cell lines. These results, together with similar findings published earlier with cells from a xeroderma pigmentosum patient in complementation group A, suggest that isolated G:C to A:T somatic mutations may be particularly important in generation of human skin cancer by UV radiation.

Intermolecular homologous recombination between transfected sequences in mammalian cells is primarily nonconservative.

Intermolecular recombination in mammalian cells was studied by coinfecting African green monkey cells in culture with two shuttle vector plasmids, each carrying an incomplete but overlapping portion of the gene for neomycin resistance. The region of homology between the two plasmids was about 0.6 kilobases. Recombination between the homology regions could reconstruct the neomycin resistance gene, which was monitored by analysis of progeny plasmids in bacteria. The individual plasmids carried additional markers which, in combination with restriction analysis, allowed the determination of the frequency of formation of the heterodimeric plasmid which would be formed in a conservative recombination reaction between the homologous sequences. Reconstruction of the neomycin resistance gene was readily observed, but only 1 to 2% of the neomycin resistance plasmids had the structure of the conservative heterodimer. Treatment of the plasmids which enhanced the frequency of the neomycin resistance gene reconstruction reaction did not significantly increase the relative frequency of conservative product plasmids. The results support nonconservative models for recombination of these sequences.

Intramolecular recombination between transfected repeated sequences in mammalian cells is nonconservative.

When plasmids carrying a fragmented gene with segments present as direct repeats are introduced into mammalian cells, recombination or gene conversion between the repeated sequences can reconstruct the gene. Intramolecular recombination leads to the deletion of the intervening sequences and the loss of one copy of the repeat. This process is known to be stimulated by double-strand breaks. Two current models for recombination in eucaryotic cells propose that the reaction is initiated by double-strand breaks, but differ in their predictions as to the fate of the intervening sequences. One model suggests that these sequences are always lost, while the other indicates that the reaction will be conservative as a function of the position of the double-strand break. We have constructed a plasmid in which two overlapping portions of the simian virus 40 early region, which contains the origin and T-antigen gene, are present as direct repeats separated by sequences containing a plasmid with a simian virus 40 origin of replication. Recombination across the repeated segments could produce a plasmid with an origin of replication and/or a plasmid with a gene for a functional T-antigen which would drive the replication of both. Introduction of this construction into African green monkey kidney cells, without coinfection, establishes a condition in which the products of the recombination or gene conversion can be interpreted unambiguously. We find that the majority of the reconstruction reactions are nonconservative.

Recombination and deletion of sequences in shuttle vector plasmids in mammalian cells.

Shuttle vector plasmids were constructed with directly repeated sequences flanking a marker gene. African green monkey kidney (AGMK) cells were infected with the constructions, and after a period of replication, the progeny plasmids were recovered and introduced into bacteria. Those colonies with plasmids that had lost the marker gene were identified, and the individual plasmids were purified and characterized by restriction enzyme digestion. Recombination between the repeated elements generated a plasmid with a precise deletion and a characteristic restriction pattern, which distinguished the recombined molecules from those with other defects in the marker gene. Recombination among the following different sequences was measured in this assay: (i) the simian virus 40 origin and enhancer region, (ii) the AGMK Alu sequence, and (iii) a sequence from plasmid pBR322. Similar frequencies of recombination among these sequences were found. Recombination occurred more frequently in Cos1 cells than in CV1 cells. In these experiments, the plasmid population with defective marker genes consisted of the recombined molecules and of the spontaneous deletion-insertion mutants described earlier. The frequency of the latter class was unaffected by the presence of the option for recombination represented by the direct repeats. Both recombination and deletion-insertion mutagenesis were stimulated by double-strand cleavage between the repeated sequences and adjacent to the marker, and the frequency of the deletion-insertion mutants in this experiment was again independent of the presence of the direct repeats. We concluded that although recombination and deletion-insertion mutagenesis were both stimulated by double-strand cleavage, the molecules which underwent the two types of change were drawn from separate pools.

Sequence specificity of point mutations induced during passage of a UV-irradiated shuttle vector plasmid in monkey cells.

A simian virus 40-based shuttle vector was used to characterize UV-induced mutations generated in mammalian cells. The small size and placement of the mutagenesis marker (the supF suppressor tRNA gene from Escherichia coli) within the vector substantially reduced the frequency of spontaneous mutations normally observed after transfection of mammalian cells with plasmid DNA; hence, UV-induced mutations were easily identified above the spontaneous background. UV-induced mutations characterized by DNA sequencing were found primarily to be base substitutions; about 56% of these were single-base changes, and 17% were tandem double-base changes. About 24% of the UV-induced mutants carried multiple mutations clustered within the 160-base-pair region sequenced. The majority (61%) of base changes were the G . C----A . T transitions; the other transition (A . T----G . C) and all four transversions occurred at about equal frequencies. Hot spots for UV mutagenesis did not correspond to hot spots for UV-induced photoproduct formation (determined by a DNA synthesis arrest assay); in particular, sites of TT dimers were underrepresented among the UV-induced mutations. These observations suggest to us that the DNA polymerase(s) responsible for mutation induction exhibits a localized loss of fidelity in DNA synthesis on UV-damaged templates such that it synthesizes past UV photoproducts, preferentially inserting adenine, and sometimes misincorporates bases at undamaged sites nearby.

Targeted mutagenesis in mammalian cells mediated by intracellular triple helix formation.

As an alternative to standard gene transfer techniques for genetic manipulation, we have investigated the use of triple helix-forming oligonucleotides to target mutations to selected genes within mammalian cells. By treating monkey COS cells with oligonucleotides linked to psoralen, we have generated targeted mutations in a simian virus 40 (SV40) vector contained within the cells via intracellular triple helix formation. Oligonucleotide entry into the cells and sequence-specific triplex formation within the SV40 DNA deliver the psoralen to the targeted site. Photoactivation of the psoralen by long-wavelength UV light yields adducts and thereby mutations at that site. We engineered into the SV40 vector novel supF mutation reporter genes containing modified polypurine sites amenable to triplex formation. By comparing the abilities of a series of oligonucleotides to target these new sites, we show that targeted mutagenesis in vivo depends on the strength and specificity of the third-strand binding. Oligonucleotides with weak target site binding affinity or with only partial target site homology were ineffective at inducing mutations in the SV40 vectors within the COS cells. We also show that the targeted mutagenesis is dependent on the oligonucleotide concentration and is influenced by the timing of the oligonucleotide treatment and of the UV irradiation of the cells. Frequencies of intracellular targeted mutagenesis in the range of 1 to 2% were observed, depending upon the conditions of the experiment. DNA sequence analysis revealed that most of the mutations were T.A-to-A.T transversions precisely at the targeted psoralen intercalation site. Several deletions encompassing that site were also seen. The ability to target mutations to selected sites within mammalian cells by using modified triplex-forming oligonucleotides may provide a new research tool and may eventually lead to therapeutic applications.

Recombination induced by triple-helix-targeted DNA damage in mammalian cells.

Gene therapy has been hindered by the low frequency of homologous recombination in mammalian cells. To stimulate recombination, we investigated the use of triple-helix-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) to target DNA damage to a selected site within cells. By treating cells with TFOs linked to psoralen, recombination was induced within a simian virus 40 vector carrying two mutant copies of the supF tRNA reporter gene. Gene conversion events, as well as mutations at the target site, were also observed. The variety of products suggests that multiple cellular pathways can act on the targeted damage, and data showing that the triple helix can influence these pathways are presented. The ability to specifically induce recombination or gene conversion within mammalian cells by using TFOs may provide a new research tool and may eventually lead to novel applications in gene therapy.

Triple-helix formation induces recombination in mammalian cells via a nucleotide excision repair-dependent pathway.

The ability to stimulate recombination in a site-specific manner in mammalian cells may provide a useful tool for gene knockout and a valuable strategy for gene therapy. We previously demonstrated that psoralen adducts targeted by triple-helix-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) could induce recombination between tandem repeats of a supF reporter gene in a simian virus 40 vector in monkey COS cells. Based on work showing that triple helices, even in the absence of associated psoralen adducts, are able to provoke DNA repair and cause mutations, we asked whether intermolecular triplexes could stimulate recombination. Here, we report that triple-helix formation itself is capable of promoting recombination and that this effect is dependent on a functional nucleotide excision repair (NER) pathway. Transfection of COS cells carrying the dual supF vector with a purine-rich TFO, AG30, designed to bind as a third strand to a region between the two mutant supF genes yielded recombinants at a frequency of 0.37%, fivefold above background, whereas a scrambled sequence control oligomer was ineffective. In human cells deficient in the NER factor XPA, the ability of AG30 to induce recombination was eliminated, but it was restored in a corrected subline expressing the XPA cDNA. In comparison, the ability of triplex-directed psoralen cross-links to induce recombination was only partially reduced in XPA-deficient cells, suggesting that NER is not the only pathway that can metabolize targeted psoralen photoadducts into recombinagenic intermediates. Interestingly, the triplex-induced recombination was unaffected in cells deficient in DNA mismatch repair, challenging our previous model of a heteroduplex intermediate and supporting a model based on end joining. This work demonstrates that oligonucleotide-mediated triplex formation can be recombinagenic, providing the basis for a potential strategy to direct genome modification by using high-affinity DNA binding ligands.

Ultraviolet mutagenesis in a plasmid vector replicated in lymphoid cells from patient with the melanoma-prone disorder dysplastic nevus syndrome.

The hereditary dysplastic nevus syndrome (DNS) is an autosomal dominant disorder in which affected individuals have increased numbers of dysplastic (premalignant) nevi and a greater than 100-fold increased risk of developing cutaneous melanoma. Epstein-Barr virus-transformed lymphoblastoid cell lines from patients with hereditary DNS have been shown to be hypermutable to UV radiation (M.I.R. Perera et al., Cancer Res., 46: 1005-1009, 1986). To examine the mechanism involved in this UV hypermutability, we used a shuttle vector plasmid, pZ189, which carries a 160-base pair marker gene, supF, and can replicate in human cells. pZ189 was treated with UV radiation and transfected into DNS6BE, a lymphoblastoid cell line from a patient with hereditary DNS. Plasmid survival after UV was similar with the DNS6BE line and with a lymphoblastoid cell line from a normal donor. Plasmid mutation frequency was greater with the DNS line in accord with the DNS cellular hypermutability. Base sequence analysis was performed on 69 mutated plasmids recovered from the DNS line. There were significantly more plasmids with single base substitution mutations (P less than 0.01) in comparison to UV-treated plasmids passed through normal fibroblasts. pZ189 hypermutability and an increased frequency of single base substitutions was previously found with a cell line from a melanoma-prone xeroderma pigmentosum patient. These differences may be related to the increased melanoma susceptibility in both DNS and xeroderma pigmentosum.

Sequence specificity of aflatoxin B1-induced mutations in a plasmid replicated in xeroderma pigmentosum and DNA repair proficient human cells.

The mutagenic spectrum induced by aflatoxin-DNA lesions in DNA repair deficient and repair proficient human cells was investigated. The reactive metabolite aflatoxin B1-8,9-epoxide was synthesized and reacted in vitro with the shuttle vector plasmid pS189. Plasmids were transfected into human fibroblasts and allowed to replicate, and the recovered plasmids were screened in indicator bacteria for plasmid survival and mutations in the supF marker gene. Sequence data were obtained from 71 independently arising mutants recovered from DNA repair deficient xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) cells [XP12BE(SV40)] and 60 mutants recovered from a DNA repair proficient cell line (GM0637). Plasmid survival was lower and mutation frequency higher with the XP cells, and the mutation hotspots differed substantially for the 2 cell lines. Most mutations (> 90%) were base substitutions at G:C pairs, only about one-half of which were G:C-->T:A transversions, the expected predominant mutation. One-third of the mutations at GG sites and none of those at isolated Gs were G:C-->A:T transitions. Tandem base substitutions also occurred only at GG sites and were found only with XP cells. The location of mutation hotspots with either cell line did not correlate with the level of modification within the sequence as assessed by a DNA polymerase stop assay. These results suggest that the DNA repair deficiency associated with XP can influence not only the overall frequency of mutations but also the distribution of mutations within a gene. The finding of transition mutations exclusively at GG sites may be of predictive value in attempts to link dietary aflatoxin exposure to cancers associated with specific mutations in the c-ras oncogene and the p53 tumor suppressor gene.

The human DNA repair gene, ERCC2 (XPD), corrects ultraviolet hypersensitivity and ultraviolet hypermutability of a shuttle vector replicated in xeroderma pigmentosum group D cells.

To determine the contribution of a human DNA repair gene, ERCC2 (XPD), to mutagenesis in human cells, two ERCC2 (XPD)-transformed xeroderma pigmentosum complementation group D (XPD) cell lines with increased UV survival compared to XP6BE(SV40), the original XPD line, were studied: D6BE-ER2-2 with slightly increased UV survival; and D6BE-ER2-9 with normal UV survival. ERCC2 (XPD) antibody-reactive protein levels were elevated 4.8-fold in D6BE-ER2-2 and 17.6-fold in D6BE-ER2-9 relative to XP6BE(SV40). DNA repair ability was assessed by measuring the ability of the cells to restore expression to UV-treated plasmids. Transfection of pRSVcat exposed to 1000 J/m2 UV resulted in 0.3% chloramphenicol acetyltransferase activity in XP6BE(SV40) cells but 20-80% in D6BE-ER2-2, D6BE-ER2-9, and repair-proficient cells compared to untreated control plasmids. The UV hypersensitivity of the mutagenesis shuttle vector pSP189 in XP6BE(SV40) cells was partially corrected and the UV hypermutability and excess of G:C-->A:T mutations of pSP189 fell to the normal range in D6BE-ER2-2 and D6BE-ER2-9 cells. However, the frequency of plasmids recovered with multiple base substitution mutations was significantly reduced with XP6BE(SV40) cells and remained low in D6BE-ER2-2 and D6BE-ER2-9 cells, when compared with the normal fibroblasts. The human DNA excision repair gene, ERCC2 (XPD), substantially corrected the plasmid UV hypersensitivity and UV hypermutability of xeroderma pigmentosum complementation group D cells; however, the dose response relationship varied for different end points.

Modulation of ultraviolet light mutational hotspots by cellular stress.

Stressful treatments of cells provoke broad, transient, changes in cellular physiology and gene expression. In addition to these effects, DNA-damaging agents often induce permanent change in the form of mutations. Mutational patterns in target genes typically show hotspots and coldspots, the molecular basis of which appears to lie in the sequence context of the particular site. We determined the mutational pattern in an ultraviolet light-modified (in vitro) marker gene in a shuttle vector passaged through repair deficient (xeroderma pigmentosum) cells and compared it with patterns obtained from cells exposed to stress imposed by a DNA-damaging agent or a calcium ionophore. We found that the mutational hotspot pattern was altered by both stress treatments. We conclude that the cellular environment can influence the probability of mutagenesis at specific sites and propose that some of these effects on mutagenesis are mediated by alterations in cellular calcium levels.

The influence of single base changes on UV mutational activity at two translocated hotspots.

Mutation hotspots have been a staple of mutation spectra since the introduction of fine structure mutation mapping almost 40 years ago. It has been well established that sequence context is an important determinant of mutational activity at mutagen induced hotspots and coldspots. However, our understanding of the sequence effectors of base substitution hotspots is quite limited. This is because manipulation of the sequence about a hotspot site in a marker gene is restricted by the need to maintain a functional marker. In this work, we describe a generalizable system for studying sequence context effects on mutagenesis. We have prepared a variant of the supF tRNA gene (a marker used by us in previous studies) in which an eight-base palindrome, the site of two UV hotspots in the interior of the gene, was copied into the acceptor stem and pre-tRNA region. The variant tRNA was active. The UV mutation spectrum of this variant showed that the new copy of the palindrome generated two hotspots which were as intense as the original sites in the interior of the gene. Variant genes were constructed with all possible bases at the first position in the palindrome in the pre-tRNA sequence, which does not affect tRNA function. The mutation analysis showed that activity at one of the hotspots could be reduced or enhanced by the changes, while activity at the other site was not significantly affected. The base changes did not influence the frequency of cyclobutane dimer or (6-4) photoproduct formation at the two hotspot sites. Thus, the changes in mutational activity were due to the influence of sequence context on the efficiency of mutation formation at the sites of UV lesions.

Proximal and distal effects of sequence context on ultraviolet mutational hotspots in a shuttle vector replicated in xeroderma cells.

Hotspots are a standard feature of mutational spectra induced by mutagens in a variety of marker genes. While it is generally believed that sequence context exerts an important influence on hotspot location, direct experimental evidence is quite limited. We have studied ultraviolet mutagenesis in a suppressor tRNA marker gene (supF) carried in a mammalian shuttle vector and replicated in Xeroderma pigmentosum cells in culture. We have now constructed a small family of functional variant suppressor tRNA marker gene which differ from one another by one or two nucleotide changes. UV mutational spectra were generated for each variant gene. We found that the change of a dipyrimidine from 5' TC to 5' CC eliminated a strong mutational hotspot. In addition a single base change in the supF gene was accompanied by the appearance of a new hotspot eight bases away. Finally, another single base change suppressed a major hotspot 48 bases away. Polymerase stop assays on the UV modified marker genes were used to measure the frequency and distribution of photoproducts. The differences in hotspot patterns could not be explained by differences in modification patterns. These results indicate that a change in sequence context can directly influence the probability of mutagenesis at specific sites.

Single nucleotide positions have proximal and distal influence on UV mutation hotspots and coldspots.

Base substitution mutation frequency is influenced by the sequence context surrounding lesions in the DNA. We have been studying ultraviolet mutagenesis in human repair-deficient cells in the supF marker gene carried in a shuttle vector plasmid. There are prominent hotspots, on opposite strands, at the 5' TC sites in the eight base palindrome 5' CTTCGAAG. Recently, we developed a reporter system which permits sequence manipulation in the vicinity of mutational hotspots. We have used the system to characterize the influence of individual positions in the palindrome on the frequency of mutagenesis at the two UV hotspots. In this paper we have determined the contribution of bases at the second and third positions in the palindrome. Changes in bases that were in the primer template duplex when the replication complex encountered the photoproducts at one of the hotspot sites significantly increased or decreased the probability of mutations at the site. We also observed modulation of hotspot activity at other sites as a function of single base changes as much as 80 bases away from the hotspots. In these instances, the site of the changed base was in the unreplicated template ahead of the primer terminus when the polymerase encountered the relevant photoproduct. Our results indicate that sequence context has both proximal and distal consequences for mutagenesis.

Mutational hotspot variability in an ultraviolet-treated shuttle vector plasmid propagated in xeroderma pigmentosum and normal human lymphoblasts and fibroblasts.

The mutagenesis shuttle vector, pZ189, was treated with ultraviolet (u.v.) radiation in vitro and passed through a DNA repair-deficient lymphoblastoid cell line derived from a patient with xeroderma pigmentosum complementation group A (XP-A) (XP12BE(EBV)) and a DNA repair-proficient lymphoblastoid cell line (GM606(EBV)). After u.v. treatment, plasmid survival was lower and mutation frequency higher with the XP-A cells mirroring the survival and mutagenesis of the host cells. The nature of the mutations in the suppressor tRNA marker gene was determined by direct sequence analysis. The G.C to A.T transition was the dominant (85%) base substitution mutation with the XP lymphoblasts and was the major (56%) base substitution mutation with the repair-proficient lymphoblasts. We found a G.C to A.T transition mutational hotspot with the XP lymphoblasts not seen in our previous experiments with fibroblasts from the same patient. Comparison of the data presented here with our results with DNA repair-deficient and DNA repair-proficient fibroblasts suggests that hotspot variability is not due to genetic polymorphism or repair capacity of the cells. Instead it appears that cellular factors can influence the probability of mutagenesis of modified DNA at particular sites.

A new culture and quantitation system for megakaryocyte growth using cord blood CD34+ cells and the GPIIb/IIIa marker.

A new culture and quantitation system has been established for growth of megakaryocyte-lineage cells from human progenitor cells. CD34+ progenitor cells were enriched from umbilical cord blood using an avidin-biotin immunoadsorption process. These cells were preincubated in bulk liquid culture for 3 to 4 days in the presence of the growth factors interleukin-3 (IL-3) and IL-6. The cells were then washed and seeded at 5000 cells/well in 96-well plates that contained a variety of test samples. The plates were incubated for 7 days, and the cells were then washed, transferred to ELISA plates, and fixed. Megakaryocyte growth was determined by an ELISA for the platelet glycoprotein (GP) IIb/IIIa, an abundant membrane protein found on cells committed to the megakaryocyte lineage. The growth factor IL-3 was found to produce a very strong signal in this assay. The addition of granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), IL-6, stem cell factor (SCF), or leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF) to low levels of IL-3 also stimulated megakaryocyte growth, as measured by IIb/IIIa expression. Plasma from patients with aplastic anemia was also stimulatory in this assay, and showed marked synergy with IL-3. This progenitor cell culture system, due to its judicious use of progenitor cells and an automated, 96-well quantitation method, allows for screening large numbers of test samples and multiple combinations and concentrations of growth factors.