Polygenic adaptation and negative selection across traits, years and environments in a long-lived plant species (Pinus pinaster Ait., Pinaceae).

A decade of genetic association studies in multiple organisms suggests that most complex traits are polygenic; that is, they have a genetic architecture determined by numerous loci, each with small effect-size. Thus, determining the degree of polygenicity and its variation across traits, environments and time is crucial to understand the genetic basis of phenotypic variation. We applied multilocus approaches to estimate the degree of polygenicity of fitness-related traits in a long-lived plant (Pinus pinaster Ait., maritime pine) and to analyse this variation across environments and years. We evaluated five categories of fitness-related traits (survival, height, phenology, functional, and biotic-stress response) in a clonal common-garden network planted in contrasted environments (over 20,500 trees). Most of the analysed traits showed evidence of local adaptation based on Qst -Fst comparisons. We further observed a remarkably stable degree of polygenicity, averaging 6% (range of 0%-27%), across traits, environments and years. We detected evidence of negative selection, which could explain, at least partially, the high degree of polygenicity. Because polygenic adaptation can occur rapidly, our results suggest that current predictions on the capacity of natural forest tree populations to adapt to new environments should be revised, especially in the current context of climate change.

Morphological disparity of extant and extinct pinaceous ovulate cones: How many cones are enough?

PREMISE: The expansion of Pinaceae during the Cretaceous is exemplified by the numerous ovulate cone taxa found in western Europe and North America. The Belgian Wealden facies deposits have delivered hundreds of exceptionally well-preserved yet isolated pinaceous ovulate cones; these cones were placed by convention within form-genera. Ten species have been described in Belgium, representing about 20% of the known fossil record of this period. However, the validity of these taxa is questionable because their intra- and interspecific variabilities have never been thoroughly studied. Moreover, quantifying the expansion of Pinaceae in terms of morphospace occupation is desirable to reveal the dynamics of this critical radiation. METHODS: We used linear and geometric morphometry to quantify the shape of the extensive sample of Cretaceous cones of Belgium. These methods were also applied to extant pinaceous species to compare the morphological disparity of Cretaceous assemblages against those of today in selected ecosystems. We used ordination methods (PCA) to visualize morphospace occupation and test for species delineation. RESULTS: The morphological disparity was not higher in fossil species than in extant species we sampled. Both morphological approaches confirmed that the species Pityostrobus andraei presents high morphological variability. Our resampling tests indicate that ovulate cone morphological variability can be satisfactorily quantified with as few as 15 specimens. CONCLUSIONS: The methodology used here is relevant for quantifying both the variability and the diversity of many fossil assemblages, paving the way for a more robust evaluation of Cretaceous pinaceous diversity.

Protoplast isolation and transcriptome analysis of developing xylem in Pinus massoniana (Pinaceae).

BACKGROUND: With active physiological and biochemical activities, tissue-specific protoplasts from cambial derivatives, could serve as a specific source for information on xylogenesis for softwood species resistant to stable genetic transformation and lacking available mutants. METHODS AND RESULTS: In this study, protoplasts were isolated from developing xylem of the Chinese red pine, Pinus massoniana, by enzymolysis. High-quality RNAs were extracted from developing xylem and their protoplasts for constructing transcriptome libraries. Using Illumina HiSeq 2500 PE150 platform, a total of 362,328,426 clean paired-end reads (54.35G) were generated from multiple cDNA libraries and assembled into 146,422 unigenes. The transcriptome data were further analysed to identify 1567 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between the isolated protoplasts and developing xylem of P. massoniana (Masson pine), 1126 DEGs were upregulated in protoplasts relative to developing xylem cells and 441 were downregulated. Most of the differentially expressed genes in biological process terms are related to plant response, which may be due to the response to cell wall removal. Further, the expression pattern of 71 unigenes involved in lignin biosynthesis was verified by RNA-seq. CONCLUSIONS: This study is the first to report the transcriptome profiles of the developing xylem and its protoplasts of coniferous trees, which provide a new perspective and valuable resource for tracking transcriptional regulatory events in wood formation of Masson pine.

Pseudoamaolides A-O, anti-inflammatory triterpene spiroketal lactones from seeds of Pseudolarix amabilis.

Fifteen new triterpenoids (1-15), along with twenty known ones (16-35), were isolated from Pseudolarix amabilis. The triterpenoid structures include multiple skeleton types, such as 2,3-seco-cycloartane, 3,4-seco-cycloartane, 3,4:9,10-diseco-cycloartane, and 3,4:8,9:9,10-triseco-cycloartane, as elucidated by extensive spectroscopy (1D NMR, 2D NMR, HRESIMS, and IR) and single-crystal X-ray diffraction. The anti-inflammatory activities of compounds 1-35 were evaluated. Compounds 3, 11, 16, 24, 25, and 26 suppressed the transcription of the NF-κB-dependent reporter gene in LPS-induced 293T/NF-κB-Luc cells with IC50 values of 0.12, 0.10, 0.30, 0.09, 0.49, and 0.35 µM, respectively. In addition, compound 16 showed anti-inflammatory activity against xylene-induced ear swelling in vivo with an inhibition rate of 44.7 % (30 mg/kg). Compound 16 significantly improved the disease activity index (DAI) of ulcerative colitis at a dose of 400 mg/kg in a dextran sodium sulfate (DSS)-induced mouse model of experimental ulcerative colitis (P < 0.01).

Variations in Essential Oils from South Siberian Conifers of the Pinaceae Family: New Data towards Identification and Quality Control.

Conifer essential oils have been used for centuries in traditional medicine, and nowadays they are of special interest for official medicine, aromatherapy and perfumery. In the present work, comprehensive information is given on the composition of essential oils prepared from the twigs of the conifer trees of the pine family (Pinaceae): Abies sibirica Ledeb., Larix sibirica Ledeb., Picea obovata Ledeb., Pinus sibirica Du Tour, Pinus sylvestris L. A total of 50 samples of essential oils have been studied. The samples were prepared during vegetation stage in the time period 1998-2012 from the growing wild trees in the South part of the Western Siberia (Russian Federation) and neighboring territories of Republic of Kazakhstan within the area with geographical coordinates LAT 49.180012-57.908583 and LON 83.213217-91.258717 at elevation of 82-2070 m above sea level. All the essential oil samples were obtained from freshly collected plant raw material by steam distillation at atmospheric pressure in stainless steel apparatus, which had been specially designed for field research. All the chromatographic profiles were prepared from authentic samples whose voucher specimens are deposited at the Central Siberian Botanical Garden of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences (NS). The following information for each sample is provided: (1) date and location of the plant raw material collecting, indicating administrative areas and the exact geographic coordinates; (2) yield of essential oil, (3) chemical composition of the essential oil sample based on GC/MS experiments using full mass-spectra (EI, 70 eV) and linear retention indices of the components, (4) results of GC-FID quantification based on internal standards and response factors, (5) enantiomeric composition of the main components based on GC×GC experiments using the 2nd column with cyclodextrin-based chiral selector, (6) GC profile of the high-boiling fractions indicating the characteristic sesquiterpenoids. Therefore, this study provides reliable information about the variability and true composition of the Siberian conifer oils, and the experimental data given can serve as reference chromatographic profiles of volatile substances to solve the problems of quality, authenticity and safety.

Plant Community of Pine Forests (Pinus kochiana, Pinaceae) of Dagestan.

The plant community of Dagestan pine forests, comprising 590 vascular plants species, was examined based on materials from field studies performed from 2012 to 2019. Taxonomic, biomorphological, florocoenotic, and geographical characteristics of the plant community showed its boreal and Mediterranean nature. Mesotrophic and eutrophic plants predominated in terms of soil fertility and mesophytes and mesoxerophytes, in terms of soil water availability. Species of different altitudinal belts, including forest, meadow, and mountain-steppe belts, were observed in the plant community of pine forests. The plant community included 22 species listed in the Red Books of the Russian Federation and the Republic of Dagestan, 82 relict species, and 76 endemics.

Regeneration of Dark Coniferous Species in the Groups of Picea orientalis (Pinaceae) Drying in the Teberda Nature Reserve (Western Caucasus).

The paper presents the results of a survey of the groups of oriental spruce (Picea orientalis (L.) Link.) decline in the Teberda State Natural Biosphere Reserve, Western Caucasus. Mass drying of the spruce from the European spruce bark beetle (Ips typographus) was noted both in monodominant spruce forests and in mixed stands with Abies nordmanniana (Stev.) Spach and Fagus orientalis Lipsky. Dark coniferous species currently predominate among the regrowth in the sites of spruce drying, and the participation of deciduous trees is minor. Broadleaf species are present in small numbers in the second layer in a half of the sample plots and do not have a noticeable effect on the abundance of coniferous regeneration. The fir regeneration is more uniform and stable as compared to the spruce. In most of the sample plots, the numbers of fir regrowth naturally decrease with maturing, while spruce has "bursts" of regeneration. The height and radial growth of the fir and spruce regrowth, as well as their density and distribution over the area, are discussed. It is shown that in 7 years after the beginning of the mass spruce drying in the Teberda Nature Reserve, no more than 1/5 of the area of the drying groups is provided with a reliable regrowth of dark coniferous species. In the coming years, the regeneration of dark coniferous species will be replenished only by the fir, since there are scarcely any remaining generative spruce trees. In the future, provided that fires are prevented, part of the large spruce regrowth can become a source of spruce renewal, and the fallen dead wood can become a suitable substrate for young trees.

Effects of Heavy Metals on the Metabolome of Pinus sylvestris (Pinaceae).

The effects of Cu, Ni, and Cd on the Pinus sylvestris metabolome was studied in experimental conditions by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS). Structural changes in plant metabolite network became detectable on day 6 of exposure to the metals, 3-6 days earlier than visual signs of toxicity developed. Differences at the metabolome level arose earlier in a control group of plants, and specific effects of particular metals on the plant metabolome became distinct on day 9. Both nature and concentration of a metal equally contributed to the plant metabolome clustering. Plant responses (changes in concentrations of individual metabolites) to metal exposure substantially differed depending on the metal concentration (1 or 5 mM) and nature. The effects of Cd and Cu were generally similar, while the effect of Ni was often different. Dynamic changes visualized in plant metabolite matrix reflected the changes in its correlation structure, rather than depending on the set of particular compounds.

Early Cretaceous abietoid Pinaceae from Mongolia and the history of seed scale shedding.

PREMISE: Seed cones of extant Pinaceae exhibit two mechanisms of seed release. In "flexers" the cone scales remain attached to the central axis, while flexing and separating from each other to release the seeds. In "shedders" scales are shed from the axis, with the seeds either remaining attached to the scale or becoming detached. The early fossil history of Pinaceae from the Jurassic to Early Cretaceous is dominated by flexing seed cones, while the systematic information provided by shedding fossil cones has been overlooked and rarely integrated with data based on compression and permineralized specimens. We describe the earliest and best-documented evidence of a "shedder" seed cone from the Aptian-Albian of Mongolia. METHODS: Lignite samples from Tevshiin Govi locality were disaggregated in water, washed, and dried in air. Fossils were compared to material of extant Pinaceae using LM and CT scans. RESULTS: Lepidocasus mellonae gen. et sp. nov. is characterized by a seed cone that disarticulated at maturity and shed obovate bract-scale complexes that have a distinctive ribbed surface and an abaxial surface covered with abundant trichomes. The ovuliferous scale has ca. 30-40 resin canals, but only scarce xylem near the attachment to the cone axis. Resin vesicles are present in the seed integument. Phylogenetic analysis places Lepidocasus as sister to extant Cedrus within the abietoid grade. CONCLUSIONS: The exquisite preservation of the trichomes in L. mellonae raises questions about their potential ecological function in the cones of fossil and living Pinaceae. Lepidocasus mellonae also shows that a shedding dispersal syndrome, a feature that has often been overlooked, evolved early in the history of Pinaceae during the Early Cretaceous.

Pestalotiopsis trachicarpicola, a novel pathogen causes twig blight of Pinus bungeana (Pinaceae: Pinoideae) in China.

Pinus bungeana is one of indigenous trees in China and widely distributed in poor and arid regions for vegetation and industrial woody use. However, since a high-incidence disease threatens the growth of mature P. bungeana tree in the garden and in the plantation every year, the overwintering shoots were infected and died in the next spring with a ratio over 70%, but the cause was beyond understood. A total of 120 fungal isolates were separated from symptomatic twigs by histological isolation methods, including Pestalotiopsis spp., Fusarium spp., Trichothecium spp., Penicillium and some unknown fungal species. Pestalotiopsis spp. was dominant, accounting for 85%. Morphological observation under microcopy showed all Pestalotiopsis species are identical, and six isolations among them were randomly selected for pathogenicity tests. Fulfilling Koch's postulates showed that all six isolates of Pestalotiopsis spp. were pathogens of twig blight, causing the same symptoms as observed in the field, while other non-Pestalotiopsis isolates were avirulent to P. bungeana twigs. Multi-gene (ITS, tub2 and TEF1) analysis and morphological observation revealed that all the six Pestalotiopsis isolates belonged to P. trachicarpicola. To our knowledge, this is the first study reporting P. trachicarpicola as the pathogens responsible for P. bungeana twig blight in China.

The flattened and needlelike leaves of the pine family (Pinaceae) share a conserved genetic network for adaxial-abaxial polarity but have diverged for photosynthetic adaptation.

BACKGROUND: Leaves have highly diverse morphologies. However, with an evolutionary history of approximately 200 million years, leaves of the pine family are relatively monotonous and often collectively called "needles", although they vary in length, width and cross-section shapes. It would be of great interest to determine whether Pinaceae leaves share similar morpho-physiological features and even consistent developmental and adaptive mechanisms. RESULTS: Based on a detailed morpho-anatomical study of leaves from all 11 Pinaceae genera, we particularly investigated the expression patterns of adaxial-abaxial polarity genes in two types of leaves (needlelike and flattened) and compared their photosynthetic capacities. We found that the two types of leaves share conserved spatial patterning of vasculatures and genetic networks for adaxial-abaxial polarity, although they display different anatomical structures in the mesophyll tissue differentiation and distribution direction. In addition, the species with needlelike leaves exhibited better photosynthetic capacity than the species with flattened leaves. CONCLUSIONS: Our study provides the first evidence for the existence of a conserved genetic module controlling adaxial-abaxial polarity in the development of different Pinaceae leaves.

Disclosing the composition of unknown historical drug formulations: an emblematic case from the Spezieria of St. Maria della Scala in Rome.

This paper reports a pioneering study of an unknown historical drug formulation preserved in the Spezieria of Santa Maria della Scala in Rome, founded at the end of the seventeenth century by the Discalced Carmelites. Due to limited literature related to pharmaceutical remedies and drugs of the Early Modern Era (between the XV and XVIII centuries) and the complexity in their formulations, the study of these drugs represents a great challenge. The untargeted nature of the selected drug required a multi-analytical approach with complementary techniques to formulate a compositional hypothesis: FT-IR spectroscopy, gas chromatography-associated/mass spectrometry (GC-MS) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) were successfully employed to identify different organic compounds. Systematic archaeobotanical research was performed as well, allowing us to acquire data related to the possible genus of plants from which these natural compounds derive and their geographical origin. The unknown drug formulation turned out to be a complex mixture used as an ointment with an anti-inflammatory purpose. It mainly contains a mixture of Venetian turpentine; a Pine resin (colophony) from the Pinaceae family; an exudate of a plant from South America, whose identified components are triterpenic compounds such as alpha- and beta-amyrins, betulin and lupeol; and saturated fatty acids which act as carriers and/or to reduce the viscosity of abovementioned exudates and resins. The study of historical drugs is important not only in order to know the practices handed down by the speziali in the past but also to reconstruct historical recipes, which can inspire new dermatological, cosmetic, hygienic and current healing products.Graphical abstract.

Evaluation of antioxidant and antimicrobial activities on various extracts of Himalayan medicinal plants.

The DPPH radical scavenging potentials of the fractions were determined in comparison to positive controls such as quercetin with EC50 = 4.12±1.27, ascorbic acid with EC50 = 6.20±1.67, gallic acid with EC50 = 4.75±1.24 and α-tocopherol with EC50 = 32.50±1.57 µg/mL. The experiment showed that aqueous fractions of the bark extracts of Abies pindrow (fraction: C2) and Cedrus deodara (fraction: E2) showed significantly lower EC50 values of 2.5±0.5 and 2.5±0.6 µg/mL, respectively. In reducing power assay, lower EC50 values of 5.5 and 4.5µg/mL were recorded for the aqueous fraction (fraction: C 2) and final residue (fraction: C5), of Abies pindrow, respectively. The ethyl acetate, acetone and final fractions of knot wood of Picea smithiana were found significantly active against all bacterial strains. Of the most sensitive fractions towards all the fungal strains was ethyl acetate fraction obtained from the bark of Cedrus deodara with a zone of inhibition ranging from 75 to 88 % that was more than the standard fluconazole.

Not all 'pine cones' flex: functional trade-offs and the evolution of seed release mechanisms.

Seed dispersal is critical for plants, but the evolution of mechanisms that actually release seeds from their parents is not well understood. We use the reproductive cones of conifers, specifically the Pinaceae clade, to explore the factors driving the evolution of different release mechanisms in plants. We combine comparative anatomical and phylogenetic analyses to test whether fundamental trade-offs in the mechanical and hydraulic properties of vasculature underlie the evolution of two seed release mechanisms: cone scale flexion and cone scale shedding. We then test whether these mechanisms are linked with differences in seed size, dispersal syndrome and reproductive allocation. Cone scale xylem in flexing species is tough, but poorly conductive. Xylem in shedding species is less extensive, fragile and highly conductive; its thin-walled tracheids allow scales to easily fracture at maturity. Shedding is also consistently associated with large, densely packed seeds. Pinaceae cones exploit a well-known trade-off in xylem mechanical strength vs hydraulic efficiency to generate release mechanisms that allow seeds of various sizes to leave the protecting cone. The linkage among release mechanisms, vascular anatomy and seed traits illustrates how a wide variety of selective pressures may influence the function and physiology of reproductive structures.

Assembly processes of trophic guilds in the root mycobiome of temperate forests.

Root-associated mycobiomes (RAMs) link plant and soil ecological processes, thereby supporting ecosystem functions. Understanding the forces that govern the assembly of RAMs is key to sustainable ecosystem management. Here, we dissected RAMs according to functional guilds and combined phylogenetic and multivariate analyses to distinguish and quantify the forces driving RAM assembly processes. Across large biogeographic scales (>1,000 km) in temperate forests (>100 plots), RAMs were taxonomically highly distinct but composed of a stable trophic structure encompassing symbiotrophic, ectomycorrhizal (55%), saprotrophic (7%), endotrophic (3%) and pathotrophic fungi (<1%). Taxonomic community composition of RAMs is explained by abiotic factors, forest management intensity, dominant tree family (Fagaceae, Pinaceae) and root resource traits. Local RAM assemblies are phylogenetically clustered, indicating stronger habitat filtering on roots in dry, acid soils and in conifer stands than in other forest types. The local assembly of ectomycorrhizal communities is driven by forest management intensity. At larger scales, root resource traits and soil pH shift the assembly process of ectomycorrhizal fungi from deterministic to neutral. Neutral or weak deterministic assembly processes are prevalent in saprotrophic and endophytic guilds. The remarkable consistency of the trophic composition of the RAMs suggests that temperate forests attract fungal assemblages that afford functional resilience under the current range of climatic and edaphic conditions. At local scales, the filtering processes that structure symbiotrophic assemblies can be influenced by forest management and tree selection, but at larger scales, environmental cues and host resource traits are the most prevalent forces.

Phylotranscriptomics resolves interspecific relationships and indicates multiple historical out-of-North America dispersals through the Bering Land Bridge for the genus Picea (Pinaceae).

A robust phylogeny is prerequisite to understand the evolution and biogeography of organisms. However, ancient and recent evolutionary radiations occurred in many plant lineages, which pose great challenges for phylogenetic analysis, especially for conifers characterized by large effective population sizes and long generation times. Picea is an important component of the dark coniferous forests in the Northern Hemisphere. Previous studies improved our understanding of its evolutionary history, but its interspecific relationships and biogeographic history remain largely unresolved. In the present study, we reconstructed a well-resolved phylogeny of Picea by comparative transcriptomic analysis based on a complete species sampling. The phylogenetic analysis, together with molecular dating and ancestral area reconstruction, further supports the North American origin hypothesis for Picea, and indicates that this genus experienced multiple out-of-North America dispersals by the Bering Land Bridge. We also found that spruces in the Japanese Archipelago have multiple origins, and P. morrisonicola from the Taiwan Island has a close relationship with species from the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau and adjacent regions. Our study provides the first complete phylogeny of Picea at the genomic level, which is important for future studies of this genus.

Management of Western North American Bark Beetles with Semiochemicals.

We summarize the status of semiochemical-based management of the major bark beetle species in western North America. The conifer forests of this region have a long history of profound impacts by phloem-feeding bark beetles, and species such as the mountain pine beetle (Dendroctonus ponderosae) and the spruce beetle (D. rufipennis) have recently undergone epic outbreaks linked to changing climate. At the same time, great strides are being made in the application of semiochemicals to the integrated pest management of bark beetles. In this review, we synthesize and interpret these recent advances in applied chemical ecology of bark beetles for scientists and land managers.

Polyamine- and Amino Acid-Related Metabolism: The Roles of Arginine and Ornithine are Associated with the Embryogenic Potential.

The mechanisms that control polyamine (PA) metabolism in plant cell lines with different embryogenic potential are not well understood. This study involved the use of two Araucaria angustifolia cell lines, one of which was defined as being blocked, in that the cells were incapable of developing somatic embryos, and the other as being responsive, as the cells could generate somatic embryos. Cellular PA metabolism was modulated by using 5 mM arginine (Arg) or ornithine (Orn) at two time points during cell growth. Two days after subculturing with Arg, an increase in citrulline (Cit) content was observed, followed by a higher expression of genes related to PA catabolism in the responsive cell line; whereas, in the blocked cell line, we only observed an accumulation of PAs. After 14 d, metabolism was directed towards putrescine accumulation in both cell lines. Exogenous Arg and Orn not only caused a change in cellular contents of PAs, but also altered the abundance of a broader spectrum of amino acids. Specifically, Cit was the predominant amino acid. We also noted changes in the expression of genes related to PA biosynthesis and catabolism. These results indicate that Arg and Orn act as regulators of both biosynthetic and catabolic PA metabolites; however, we suggest that they have distinct roles associated with embryogenic potential of the cells.

Chemical characterization and identification of Pinaceae pollen by infrared microspectroscopy.

MAIN CONCLUSION: FTIR microspectroscopy, in combination with spectral averaging procedure, enables precise analysis of pollen grains for chemical characterization and identification studies of fresh and fossilised pollen in botany, ecology and palaeosciences. Infrared microspectroscopy (µFTIR) of Pinaceae pollen can provide valuable information on plant phenology, ecophysiology and paleoecology, but measurements are challenging, resulting in unreproducible spectra. The comparative analysis of µFTIR spectra belonging to morphologically different Pinaceae pollen, namely bisaccate Pinus and monosaccate Tsuga pollen, was conducted. The study shows that the main cause of spectral variability is non-radial symmetry of bisaccate pollen grains, while additional variation is caused by Mie scattering. Averaging over relatively small number of single pollen grain spectra (approx. 5-10) results with reproducible data on pollen chemical composition. The practical applicability of the µFTIR spectral averaging method has been demonstrated by the partial least-squares regression-based differentiation of the two closely related Pinus species with morphologically indistinguishable pollen: Pinus mugo (mountain pine) and Pinus sylvestris (Scots pine). The study has demonstrated that the µFTIR approach can be used for identification, differentiation and chemical characterization of pollen with complex morphology. The methodology enables analysis of fresh pollen, as well as fossil pollen from sediment core samples, and can be used in botany, ecology and paleoecology for study of biotic and abiotic effects on plants.

Ectomycorrhizal host specificity in a changing world: can legacy effects explain anomalous current associations?

Despite the importance of ectomycorrhizal (ECM) fungi in forest ecosystems, knowledge about the ecological and co-evolutionary mechanisms underlying ECM host associations remains limited. Using a widely distributed group of ECM fungi known to form tight associations with trees in the family Pinaceae, we characterized host specificity among three unique Suillus-host species pairs using a combination of field root tip sampling and experimental bioassays. We demonstrate that the ECM fungus S. subaureus can successfully colonize Quercus hosts in both field and glasshouse settings, making this species unique in an otherwise Pinaceae-specific clade. Importantly, however, we found that the colonization of Quercus by S. subaureus required co-planting with a Pinaceae host. While our experimental results indicate that gymnosperms are required for the establishment of new S. subaureus colonies, Pineaceae hosts are locally absent at both our field sites. Given the historical presence of Pineaceae hosts before human alteration, it appears the current S. subaureus-Quercus associations represent carryover from past host presence. Collectively, our results suggest that patterns of ECM specificity should be viewed not only in light of current forest community composition, but also as a legacy effect of host community change over time.