Objective assessment of simulated non-carious cervical lesion by tridimensional digital scanning - An in vitro study.

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVE: Clinical assessment of progression of non-carious cervical lesions (NCCLs) is currently based on subjective methods. We hypothesize that 3D digital intraoral scanners (IOS) can provide quantitative outcomes for objective measuring and monitoring of NCCLs. This in vitro study verified the reliability of IOS to monitor dental structure loss of simulated NCCLs, in comparison to a reference bench-top 3D optical profilometer (BTS). METHODS: NCCLs of different severity levels (early, moderate, or severe, n = 150) were simulated in a preceding study. Impressions of the lesions were taken and scanned with both BTS (ProScan; Scantron) and IOS (TRIOS4; 3Shape). Generated 3D images were analyzed for volumetric tooth loss (mm3) by superimposition followed by subtraction analysis. ProForm (Scantron) and WearCompare (Leeds Digital Dentistry) software were used in association to BTS and IOS, respectively. Agreement was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC, alpha=0.05) and Bland-Altman plots. RESULTS: ICC (confidence interval at 95 %) between IOS and BTS for all data combined was 0.962 (0.942-0.973), showing excellent reliability. Subset analyses showed that NCCLs with lower volume loss (early- and moderate-stage lesions) resulted in moderate ICCs, whereas severe lesions showed excellent ICC. Bland-Altman plots demonstrated general good agreement, with narrower limits for early stage-lesions. CONCLUSION: IOS data demonstrated good agreement to BTS, when measuring tooth structure loss in simulated NCCLs, with particularly higher ICC in more severe lesions. Considering the accessibility and ease-of-use, IOS showed to be a good alternative for the objective assessment of NCCLs in vitro. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: 3D intraoral scanners' accessibility and objectivity make them potentially valuable tools for assessing and monitoring NCCLs.