Small-Scale Serial Size Exclusion Chromatography (s3SEC) for High Sensitivity Top-Down Proteomics of Large Proteoforms.

Top-down-mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics has emerged as a premier technology to examine proteins at the proteoform level, enabling characterization of genetic mutations, alternative splicing, and post-translational modifications. However, significant challenges that remain in top-down proteomics include the analysis of large proteoforms and the sensitivity required to examine proteoforms from minimal amounts of sample. To address these challenges, we have developed a new method termed "small-scale serial Size Exclusion Chromatography" (s3SEC), which incorporates a small-scale protein extraction (1 mg of tissue) and serial SEC without postfractionation sample handling, coupled with online high sensitivity capillary reversed-phase liquid chromatography tandem MS (RPLC-MS/MS) for analysis of large proteoforms. The s3SEC-RPLC-MS/MS method significantly enhanced the sensitivity and reduced the proteome complexity across the fractions, enabling the detection of high MW proteoforms previously undetected in one-dimensional (1D)-RPLC analysis. Importantly, we observed a drastic improvement in the signal intensity of high MW proteoforms in early fractions when using the s3SEC-RPLC method. Moreover, we demonstrate that this s3SEC-RPLC-MS/MS method also allows the analysis of lower MW proteoforms in subsequent fractions without significant alteration in proteoform abundance and equivalent or improved fragmentation efficiency to that of the 1D-RPLC approach. Although this study focuses on the use of cardiac tissue, the s3SEC-RPLC-MS/MS method could be broadly applicable to other systems with limited sample inputs.

Counterion Optimization Dramatically Improves Selectivity for Phosphopeptides and Glycopeptides in Electrostatic Repulsion-Hydrophilic Interaction Chromatography.

A well-hydrated counterion can selectively and dramatically increase retention of a charged analyte in hydrophilic interaction chromatography. The effect is enhanced if the column is charged, as in electrostatic repulsion-hydrophilic interaction chromatography (ERLIC). This combination was exploited in proteomics for the isolation of peptides with certain post-translational modifications (PTMs). The best salt additive examined was magnesium trifluoroacetate. The well-hydrated Mg+2 ion promoted retention of peptides with functional groups that retained negative charge at low pH, while the poorly hydrated trifluoroacetate counterion tuned down the retention due to the basic residues. The result was an enhancement in selectivity ranging from 6- to 66-fold. These conditions were applied to a tryptic digest of mouse cortex. Gradient elution produced fractions enriched in peptides with phosphate, mannose-6-phosphate, and N- and O-linked glycans. The numbers of such peptides identified either equaled or exceeded the numbers afforded by the best alternative methods. This method is a productive and convenient way to isolate peptides simultaneously that contain a number of different PTMs, facilitating study of proteins with "crosstalk" modifications. The fractions from the ERLIC column were desalted prior to C-18-reversed phase liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry analysis. Between 47-100% of the peptides with more than one phosphate or sialyl residue or with a mannose-6 phosphate group were not retained by a C-18 cartridge but were retained by a cartridge of porous graphitic carbon. This finding implies that the abundance of such peptides may have been significantly underestimated in some past studies.

Bullet points to evaluate the performance of the middle-down proteomics workflow for histone modification analysis.

Middle-down proteomics has emerged as the method of choice to study combinatorial histone post translational modifications (PTMs). In the common bottom-up workflow, histones are digested into relatively short peptides (4-20 aa), separated using reversed-phase chromatography and analyzed using typical proteomics methods in mass spectrometry. In middle-down, histones are cleaved into longer polypeptides (50-60 aa) mostly corresponding to their N-terminal tails, resolved using weak cation exchange-hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (WCX-HILIC) and analyzed with less conventional mass spectrometry, i.e. using Electron Transfer Dissociation (ETD) for analyte fragmentation. Middle-down is not nearly as utilized as bottom-up for PTM analysis, partially due to its limited reproducibility and robustness. This has also limited the establishment of rigorous benchmarks to discriminate good vs poor quality experiments. Here, we describe critical aspects of the middle-down workflow to assist the user in evaluating the presence of biased and misleading results. Specifically, we tested the use of porous graphitic carbon (PGC) during the desalting step, demonstrating that desalting using only C18 material leads to sample loss. We also tested different salts in the WCX-HILIC buffers for their effect on retention, selectivity, and reproducibility of analysis of variants of histone tail fragments, in particular replacing ammonium ion with ethylenediammonium ion in buffer A. These substitutions had marked effects on selectivity and retention. Our results provide a streamlined way to evaluate middle-down performance to identify and quantify combinatorial histone PTMs.

Top-Down Proteomics of Endogenous Membrane Proteins Enabled by Cloud Point Enrichment and Multidimensional Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry.

Although top-down proteomics has emerged as a powerful strategy to characterize proteins in biological systems, the analysis of endogenous membrane proteins remains challenging due to their low solubility, low abundance, and the complexity of the membrane subproteome. Here, we report a simple but effective enrichment and separation strategy for top-down proteomics of endogenous membrane proteins enabled by cloud point extraction and multidimensional liquid chromatography coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry (MS). The cloud point extraction efficiently enriched membrane proteins using a single extraction, eliminating the need for time-consuming ultracentrifugation steps. Subsequently, size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) with an MS-compatible mobile phase (59% water, 40% isopropanol, 1% formic acid) was used to remove the residual surfactant and fractionate intact proteins (6-115 kDa). The fractions were separated further by reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) coupled with MS for protein characterization. This method was applied to human embryonic kidney cells and cardiac tissue lysates to enable the identification of 188 and 124 endogenous integral membrane proteins, respectively, some with as many as 19 transmembrane domains.

Online Hydrophobic Interaction Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry for the Analysis of Intact Monoclonal Antibodies.

Therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are an important class of drugs for a wide spectrum of human diseases. Liquid chromatography (LC) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) is one of the techniques in the forefront for comprehensive characterization of analytical attributes of mAbs. Among various protein chromatography modes, hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) is a popular offline nondenaturing separation technique utilized to purify and analyze mAbs, typically with the use of non-MS-compatible mobile phases. Herein we demonstrate for the first time, the application of direct HIC-MS and HIC-tandem MS (MS/MS) with electron capture dissociation (ECD) for analyzing intact mAbs on quadrupole-time-of-flight (Q-TOF) and Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometers, respectively. Our method allows for rapid determination of relative hydrophobicity, intact masses, and glycosylation profiles of mAbs as well as sequence and structural characterization of the complementarity-determining regions in an online configuration.

Hydrophobic Interaction Chromatography for Bottom-Up Proteomics Analysis of Single Proteins and Protein Complexes.

Hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) is a robust standard analytical method to purify proteins while preserving their biological activity. It is widely used to study post-translational modifications of proteins and drug-protein interactions. In the current manuscript we employed HIC to separate proteins, followed by bottom-up LC-MS/MS experiments. We used this approach to fractionate antibody species followed by comprehensive peptide mapping as well as to study protein complexes in human cells. HIC-reversed-phase chromatography (RPC)-mass spectrometry (MS) is a powerful alternative to fractionate proteins for bottom-up proteomics experiments making use of their distinct hydrophobic properties.

Top-Down Proteomics of Large Proteins up to 223 kDa Enabled by Serial Size Exclusion Chromatography Strategy.

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based top-down proteomics is a powerful method for the comprehensive analysis of proteoforms that arise from genetic variations and post-translational modifications (PTMs). However, top-down MS analysis of high molecular weight (MW) proteins remains challenging mainly due to the exponential decay of signal-to-noise ratio with increasing MW. Size exclusion chromatography (SEC) is a favored method for size-based separation of biomacromolecules but typically suffers from low resolution. Herein, we developed a serial size exclusion chromatography (sSEC) strategy to enable high-resolution size-based fractionation of intact proteins (10-223 kDa) from complex protein mixtures. The sSEC fractions could be further separated by reverse phase chromatography (RPC) coupled online with high-resolution MS. We have shown that two-dimensional (2D) sSEC-RPC allowed for the identification of 4044 more unique proteoforms and a 15-fold increase in the detection of proteins above 60 kDa, compared to one-dimensional (1D) RPC. Notably, effective sSEC-RPC separation of proteins significantly enhanced the detection of high MW proteins up to 223 kDa and also revealed low abundance proteoforms that are post-translationally modified. This sSEC method is MS-friendly, robust, and reproducible and, thus, can be applied to both high-efficiency protein purification and large-scale proteomics analysis of cell or tissue lysate for enhanced proteome coverage, particularly for low abundance and high MW proteoforms.

Online Hydrophobic Interaction Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry for Top-Down Proteomics.

Recent progress in top-down proteomics has led to a demand for mass spectrometry (MS)-compatible chromatography techniques to separate intact proteins using volatile mobile phases. Conventional hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) provides high-resolution separation of proteins under nondenaturing conditions but requires high concentrations of nonvolatile salts. Herein, we introduce a series of more-hydrophobic HIC materials that can retain proteins using MS-compatible concentrations of ammonium acetate. The new HIC materials appear to function as a hybrid form of conventional HIC and reverse phase chromatography. The function of the salt seems to be preserving protein structure rather than promoting retention. Online HIC-MS is feasible for both qualitative and quantitative analysis. This is demonstrated with standard proteins and a complex cell lysate. The mass spectra of proteins from the online HIC-MS exhibit low charge-state distributions, consistent with those commonly observed in native MS. Furthermore, HIC-MS can chromatographically separate proteoforms differing by minor modifications. Hence, this new HIC-MS combination is promising for top-down proteomics.

Protein Fractionation and Enrichment Prior to Proteomics Sample Preparation.

Proteins may be considered as polypeptides large enough to have a well-defined tertiary, or three-dimensional structure. In aqueous media, this structure is typically one in which polar and charged amino acid residues are on the surface while hydrophobic residues tend to be sequestered in the core and reasonably inaccessible to the aqueous environment. Proteins that are not normally found free in aqueous media, such as membrane proteins and apolipoproteins, can have tertiary structures that deviate from this model. In general, the biological activity of proteins requires the preservation of their tertiary structure, and this sets more limits upon the chromatography than is true of peptides. In proteomics, the concern is with which proteins are present and in what quantity rather than maintaining biological activity. Such applications are freer to use mobile and stationary phases that denature protein structure. However, considerations of solubility and recovery may still set more limits on the chromatography than is the case with peptides.

Anion-exchange chromatography of phosphopeptides: weak anion exchange versus strong anion exchange and anion-exchange chromatography versus electrostatic repulsion-hydrophilic interaction chromatography.

Most phosphoproteomics experiments rely on prefractionation of tryptic digests before online liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. This study compares the potential and limitations of electrostatic repulsion-hydrophilic interaction chromatography (ERLIC) and anion-exchange chromatography (AEX). At a pH higher than 5, phosphopeptides have two negative charges per residue and are well-retained in AEX. However, peptides with one or two phosphate groups are not separated from peptides with multiple Asp or Glu residues, interfering with the identification of phosphopeptides. At a pH of 2, phosphate residues have just a single negative charge but Asp and Glu are uncharged. This facilitates the separation of phosphopeptides from unmodified acidic peptides. Singly phosphorylated peptides are retained weakly under these conditions, due to electrostatic repulsion, unless hydrophilic interaction is superimposed in the ERLIC mode. Weak anion-exchange (WAX) and strong anion-exchange (SAX) columns were compared, with both peptide standards and a HeLa cell tryptic digest. The SAX column exhibited greater retention at pH 6 than did the WAX column. However, only about 60% as many phosphopeptides were identified with SAX at pH 6 than via ERLIC at pH 2. In one ERLIC run, 12 467 phosphopeptides were identified, including 4233 with more than one phosphate. We conclude that chromatography of phosphopeptides is best performed at low pH in the ERLIC mode. Under those conditions, the performances of the SAX and WAX materials were comparable. The data have been deposited with the ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD001333.

Effective protein separation by coupling hydrophobic interaction and reverse phase chromatography for top-down proteomics.

One of the challenges in proteomics is the proteome's complexity, which necessitates the fractionation of proteins prior to the mass spectrometry (MS) analysis. Despite recent advances in top-down proteomics, separation of intact proteins remains challenging. Hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) appears to be a promising method that provides high-resolution separation of intact proteins, but unfortunately the salts conventionally used for HIC are incompatible with MS. In this study, we have identified ammonium tartrate as a MS-compatible salt for HIC with comparable separation performance as the conventionally used ammonium sulfate. Furthermore, we found that the selectivity obtained with ammonium tartrate in the HIC mobile phases is orthogonal to that of reverse phase chromatography (RPC). By coupling HIC and RPC as a novel two-dimensional chromatographic method, we have achieved effective high-resolution intact protein separation as demonstrated with standard protein mixtures and a complex cell lysate. Subsequently, the separated intact proteins were identified by high-resolution top-down MS. For the first time, these results have shown the high potential of HIC as a high-resolution protein separation method for top-down proteomics.

Detection, evaluation and minimization of nonenzymatic deamidation in proteomic sample preparation.

Identification of deamidated sites in proteins is commonly used for assignment of N-glycosylation sites. It is also important for assessing the role of deamidation in vivo. However, nonenzymatic deamidation occurs easily in peptides under conditions commonly used in treatment with trypsin and PNGase F. The impact on proteomic sample preparation has not yet been evaluated systematically. In addition, the (13)C peaks of amidated peptides can be misassigned as monoisotopic peaks of the corresponding deamidated ones in database searches. The 19.34 mDa mass difference between them is proposed as a means for eliminating the resulting false positive identifications in large-scale proteomic analysis. We evaluated five groups of proteomic data, obtained mainly through an electrostatic repulsion-hydrophilic interaction chromatography (ERLIC)-reverse phase (RP) chromatography sequence, and ascertained that nonenzymatic asparagine deamidation occurred to some extent on 4-9% of the peptides, resulting in the false positive identification of many N-glycosylation sites. A comprehensive investigation indicated that the chief causative factors were the mildly alkaline pH and prolonged incubations at 37 °C during proteomic sample preparation. An improved protocol is proposed featuring tryptic digestion at pH 6 and deglycosylation at pH 5, resulting in a significant decrease in nonenzymatic deamidation while conserving adequate digestion efficiency. The number of identified deamidation sites was improved significantly by increasing the sample loading amount in liquid chromatography-tandem MS. This permitted the identification of a significant number of glutamine deamidation sites, which featured sequence motifs largely different from those for asparagine deamidation: -Q-V-, -Q-L- and -Q-G- and, to a lesser extent, -Q-A- and -Q-E-.

Structure and dynamics of endogenous protein complexes in human heart tissue captured by native nanoproteomics.

Protein complexes are highly dynamic entities that display substantial diversity in their assembly, post-translational modifications, and non-covalent interactions, allowing them to play critical roles in various biological processes. The heterogeneity, dynamic nature, and low abundance of protein complexes in their native states present tremendous challenges to study using conventional structural biology techniques. Here we develop a "native nanoproteomics" strategy for the native enrichment and subsequent native top-down mass spectrometry (nTDMS) of low-abundance protein complexes. Specifically, we demonstrate the first comprehensive characterization of the structure and dynamics of cardiac troponin (cTn) complexes directly from human heart tissue. The endogenous cTn complex is effectively enriched and purified using peptide-functionalized superparamagnetic nanoparticles under non-denaturing conditions to enable the isotopic resolution of cTn complexes, revealing their complex structure and assembly. Moreover, nTDMS elucidates the stoichiometry and composition of the heterotrimeric cTn complex, localizes Ca2+ binding domains (II-IV), defines cTn-Ca2+ binding dynamics, and provides high-resolution mapping of the proteoform landscape. This native nanoproteomics strategy opens a new paradigm for structural characterization of low-abundance native protein complexes.

Structure and dynamics of endogenous protein complexes in human heart tissue captured by native nanoproteomics.

Protein complexes are highly dynamic entities that display substantial diversity in their assembly, post-translational modifications, and non-covalent interactions, allowing them to play critical roles in various biological processes. The heterogeneity, dynamic nature, and low abundance of protein complexes in their native states present tremendous challenges to study using conventional structural biology techniques. Here we develop a "native nanoproteomics" strategy for the native enrichment and subsequent native top-down mass spectrometry (nTDMS) of low-abundance protein complexes. Specifically, we demonstrate the first comprehensive characterization of the structure and dynamics of cardiac troponin (cTn) complexes directly from human heart tissue. The endogenous cTn complex is effectively enriched and purified using peptide-functionalized superparamagnetic nanoparticles under non-denaturing conditions to enable the isotopic resolution of cTn complexes, revealing their complex structure and assembly. Moreover, nTDMS elucidates the stoichiometry and composition of the heterotrimeric cTn complex, localizes Ca2+ binding domains (II-IV), defines cTn-Ca2+ binding dynamics, and provides high-resolution mapping of the proteoform landscape. This native nanoproteomics strategy opens a new paradigm for structural characterization of low-abundance native protein complexes.

Structure and dynamics of endogenous cardiac troponin complex in human heart tissue captured by native nanoproteomics.

Protein complexes are highly dynamic entities that display substantial diversity in their assembly, post-translational modifications, and non-covalent interactions, allowing them to play critical roles in various biological processes. The heterogeneity, dynamic nature, and low abundance of protein complexes in their native states present challenges to study using conventional structural biology techniques. Here we develop a native nanoproteomics strategy for the enrichment and subsequent native top-down mass spectrometry (nTDMS) analysis of endogenous cardiac troponin (cTn) complex directly from human heart tissue. The cTn complex is enriched and purified using peptide-functionalized superparamagnetic nanoparticles under non-denaturing conditions to enable the isotopic resolution of cTn complex, revealing their complex structure and assembly. Moreover, nTDMS elucidates the stoichiometry and composition of the cTn complex, localizes Ca2+ binding domains, defines cTn-Ca2+ binding dynamics, and provides high-resolution mapping of the proteoform landscape. This native nanoproteomics strategy opens a paradigm for structural characterization of endogenous native protein complexes.

Peptide orientation affects selectivity in ion-exchange chromatography.

Here we demonstrate that separation of proteolytic peptides, having the same net charge and one basic residue, is affected by their specific orientation toward the stationary phase in ion-exchange chromatography. In electrostatic repulsion-hydrophilic interaction chromatography (ERLIC) with an anion-exchange material, the C-terminus of the peptides is, on average, oriented toward the stationary phase. In cation exchange, the average peptide orientation is the opposite. Data with synthetic peptides, serving as orientation probes, indicate that in tryptic/Lys-C peptides the C-terminal carboxyl group appears to be in a zwitterionic bond with the side chain of the C-terminal Lys/Arg residue. In effect, the side chain is then less basic than the N-terminus, accounting for the specific orientation of tryptic and Lys-C peptides. Analyses of larger sets of peptides, generated from lysates by either Lys-N, Lys-C, or trypsin, reveal that specific peptide orientation affects the ability of charged side chains, such as phosphate residues, to influence retention. Phosphorylated residues that are remote in the sequence from the binding site affect retention less than those that are closer. When a peptide contains multiple charged sites, then orientation is observed to be less rigid and retention tends to be governed by the peptide's net charge rather than its sequence. These general observations could be of value in confirming a peptide's identification and, in particular, phosphosite assignments in proteomics analyses. More generally, orientation accounts for the ability of chromatography to separate peptides of the same composition but different sequence.

Effect of salts on retention in hydrophilic interaction chromatography.

There is a widespread belief that salts promote retention of solutes in hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) by expanding the volume of the immobilized layer of water on the surface of the stationary phase. To date, all studies of this premise have had flaws or limitations that left the question open. This study explored the effects of salt type and concentration. The effect of the anion was studied with four triethylammonium salts, ranging from the kosmotropic sulfate to the chaotropic perchlorate, at pH values of both 3 and 6. Concentrations ranged from 5-120 mM. All analytes were neutral except for cytosine and cytidine, which had (+) charge at pH 3. Sulfate markedly promoted retention of cytosine, cytidine and phloroglucinol. At high sulfate levels retention of cytosine and cytidine decreased again, presumably due to a "salting-out" effect. With perchlorate anion, retention of cytosine decreased steadily as salt concentration increased, while retention of other standards increased or was unchanged. The effect of the cation was examined by comparing the retention of a tryptic peptide containing either phosphoserine or aspartic acid at the same position. Salts of methylphosphonic acid were used at pH 2.5. The higher the hydration number of the cation, the better the selectivity between the two peptides. The best separation was obtained with the magnesium salt and the worst with the tetramethylammonium salt. The retention contributed by a highly hydrated cation exceeded retention due to electrostatic attraction. These results demonstrate that counterions that are well hydrated serve to promote partitioning of charged solutes into the immobilized aqueous layer in HILIC, while poorly hydrated counterions have the opposite effect. Effects on neutral solutes were more modest; retention times remained unchanged or increased modestly with an increase in concentration of any salt.

Rapid preparative purification of West Nile and Sindbis virus PCR products utilizing a microbore anion-exchange column.

Analysis and purification of specific PCR products from PCR reactions can be problematic due to several issues relating to amplification and low product yield. The use of HPLC as a preparative tool in PCR product analysis is common but has not replaced traditional electrophoretic techniques for purifying DNA to be used in subsequent experiments. Gel purification of PCR products can result in a net loss greater than 50% of the starting DNA amount. Thus, this method of recovery can become the limiting factor in the overall cloning protocol. This paper describes a simple and relatively inexpensive micro-preparative HPLC method to purify and analyze nM quantities of DNA. A microbore polyethyleneimine-based anion-exchange column fractionates PCR mixtures in less than 40 min with a recovery of the purified specific product as high as 80%, thus eliminating the need for gel purification. Using this method, nested PCR products from Sindbis virus differing by 18 bp in some cases and a 277 bp fragment from West Nile virus were resolved and quantified. This method differs from existing methodologies because separation is based on size and charge as well as the overall G + C content of the PCR product.

Electrostatic repulsion hydrophilic interaction chromatography for isocratic separation of charged solutes and selective isolation of phosphopeptides.

If an ion-exchange column is eluted with a predominantly organic mobile phase, then solutes can be retained through hydrophilic interaction even if they have the same charge as the stationary phase. This combination is termed electrostatic repulsion-hydrophilic interaction chromatography (ERLIC). With mixtures of solutes that differ greatly in charge, repulsion effects can be exploited to selectively antagonize the retention of the solutes that normally would be the best retained. This permits the isocratic resolution of mixtures that normally require gradients, including peptides, amino acids, and nucleotides. ERLIC affords convenient separations of highly charged peptides that cannot readily be resolved by other means. In addition, phosphopeptides can be isolated selectively from a tryptic digest.