RESUMEN
Spatial smoothing models play an important role in the field of small area estimation. In the context of complex survey designs, the use of design weights is indispensable in the estimation process. Recently, efforts have been made in these spatial smoothing models, in order to obtain reliable estimates of the spatial trend. However, the concept of missing data remains a prevalent problem in the context of spatial trend estimation as estimates are potentially subject to bias. In this paper, we focus on spatial health surveys where the available information consists of a binary response and its associated design weight. Furthermore, we investigate the impact of nonresponse as missing data on a range of spatial models for different missingness mechanisms and different degrees of missingness by means of an extensive simulation study. The computations were performed in R, using INLA and other existing packages. The results show that weight adjustment to correct for missingness has a beneficial effect on the bias in the missing at random setting for all models. Furthermore, we estimate the geographical distribution of perceived health at the district level based on the Belgian Health Interview Survey (2001). Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Asunto(s)
Sesgo , Encuestas Epidemiológicas/métodos , Análisis de Área Pequeña , Teorema de Bayes , Simulación por Computador , Interpretación Estadística de Datos , Humanos , Modelos Estadísticos , Encuestas y CuestionariosRESUMEN
It is often the case that researchers wish to simultaneously explore the behavior of and estimate overall risk for multiple, related diseases with varying rarity while accounting for potential spatial and/or temporal correlation. In this paper, we propose a flexible class of multivariate spatio-temporal mixture models to fill this role. Further, these models offer flexibility with the potential for model selection as well as the ability to accommodate lifestyle, socio-economic, and physical environmental variables with spatial, temporal, or both structures. Here, we explore the capability of this approach via a large scale simulation study and examine a motivating data example involving three cancers in South Carolina. The results which are focused on four model variants suggest that all models possess the ability to recover simulation ground truth and display improved model fit over two baseline Knorr-Held spatio-temporal interaction model variants in a real data application.
RESUMEN
Spatio-temporal analysis of small area health data often involves choosing a fixed set of predictors prior to the final model fit. In this paper, we propose a spatio-temporal approach of Bayesian model selection to implement model selection for certain areas of the study region as well as certain years in the study time line. Here, we examine the usefulness of this approach by way of a large-scale simulation study accompanied by a case study. Our results suggest that a special case of the model selection methods, a mixture model allowing a weight parameter to indicate if the appropriate linear predictor is spatial, spatio-temporal, or a mixture of the two, offers the best option to fitting these spatio-temporal models. In addition, the case study illustrates the effectiveness of this mixture model within the model selection setting by easily accommodating lifestyle, socio-economic, and physical environmental variables to select a predominantly spatio-temporal linear predictor.
RESUMEN
Public health and governmental organizations have acknowledged the importance of obtaining information of various characteristics for small areas, such as counties. Spatial smoothing models have been developed to gain reliable information on the geographical distribution of the outcome of interest. When the geographical analysis is based on survey data, two issues pose challenges: (1) the complex design of the survey and (2) the presence of missing data due to non-response. We investigate the influence of missing data and the adjustment thereof in the context of the 2013 Florida Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) health survey. We focus on the application and comparison of the Hajek ratio estimator and two model-based approaches for estimation of the spatial trend of the prevalence of having no health insurance coverage. The model-based methods are compared using the Deviance Information Criterion which show the benefits of modeling the weights as flexibly as possible. Methods are extended towards subgroup analyses and the estimation of area-specific standardized rates, where household incomes was identified as an important factor to include in the analysis.
Asunto(s)
Conductas Relacionadas con la Salud , Seguro de Salud/estadística & datos numéricos , Modelos Estadísticos , Encuestas y Cuestionarios , Adolescente , Adulto , Sistema de Vigilancia de Factor de Riesgo Conductual , Demografía , Femenino , Florida/epidemiología , Humanos , Masculino , Persona de Mediana Edad , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
The recently developed R package INLA (Integrated Nested Laplace Approximation) is becoming a more widely used package for Bayesian inference. The INLA software has been promoted as a fast alternative to MCMC for disease mapping applications. Here, we compare the INLA package to the MCMC approach by way of the BRugs package in R, which calls OpenBUGS. We focus on the Poisson data model commonly used for disease mapping. Ultimately, INLA is a computationally efficient way of implementing Bayesian methods and returns nearly identical estimates for fixed parameters in comparison to OpenBUGS, but falls short in recovering the true estimates for the random effects, their precisions, and model goodness of fit measures under the default settings. We assumed default settings for ground truth parameters, and through altering these default settings in our simulation study, we were able to recover estimates comparable to those produced in OpenBUGS under the same assumptions.