Development of a zebrafish embryo teratogenicity assay and quantitative prediction model.

BACKGROUND: A zebrafish (Danio rerio) teratogenicity assay has been developed and evaluated for its ability to predict the teratogenic potential of chemicals. METHODS: Zebrafish embryos were dechorionated and then exposed to a test solution from 4-6 hours post-fertilization, and embryos or larvae were assessed up to 5 days post-fertilization (dpf) for viability and morphology. In preliminary experiments, the potential time points for assessment of compound-induced dysmorphology and general toxicity parameters were evaluated, and 5 dpf was found to be the optimum developmental stage for evaluation. Additionally, a morphological scoring system was devised to identify the developmental no-observed-adverse-effect level (NOAEL). For assay evaluation, 34 compounds with adequate in vivo developmental toxicity data were chosen. The compound set represented diversity in teratogenic potencies, structural classes, and pharmacologic targets. For 31 test compounds, each was evaluated over a concentration range, while 3 others were insufficiently aqueous-soluble to be fully tested. For each of the 31 tested compounds, the 5 dpf NOAEL was determined, and the concentration resulting in 25% lethality (LC25) was calculated by curve-fitting. Teratogenic potential of each compound was predicted based on the ratio of the LC25 to the NOAEL. LC25/NOAEL ratios of 10 or greater were considered predictive of teratogenicity. RESULTS: The model successfully categorized 87% of the compounds as teratogens or non-teratogens, with only 2 false-positives (dimethyl phthalate and a Bristol-Myers Squibb (BMS) investigative compound) and 2 false-negatives (valproic acid and a BMS compound). CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that this assay is promising for screening compounds for teratogenic potential. Birth Defects Res (Part B) 89:66-77, 2010. (c) 2010 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

Morphological score assignment guidelines for the dechorionated zebrafish teratogenicity assay.

BACKGROUND: Recently we reported the development and optimization of a zebrafish teratogenicity assay using dechorionated AB strain embryos, a promising assay that was 87% concordant in correctly identifying in vivo teratogens and non-teratogens from a set of 31 compounds (Brannen et al., 2010: Birth Defects Res 89:66-77). METHODS: This assay utilizes a zebrafish morphological score system to characterize adverse effects and identify the no-observed-adverse-effect level (NOAEL). RESULTS: This report describes in detail the morphological score system used in the dechorionated zebrafish embryo culture teratogenicity assay. The morphological assessment includes evaluation of most structures and organ systems and grades relative severity of abnormalities. CONCLUSIONS: To this end, the morphological score system provides information of tissue-specific teratogenicity that has been found to have good concordance with structures found affected in vivo and can also be used to rank compounds based on the severity of malformations.

Optimization and Performance Assessment of the Chorion-Off [Dechorinated] Zebrafish Developmental Toxicity Assay.

The Dechorinated Zebrafish Embryo Developmental toxicity assay was originally developed from a training set of 31 compounds and reported to be 87% concordant with in vivo teratogenicity data (Brannen, K. C., Panzica-Kelly, J. M., Danberry, T. L., and Augustine-Rauch, K. A. (2010). Development of a zebrafish embryo teratogenicity assay and quantitative prediction model. Birth Defects Res. 89, 66-77.). The assay includes scoring larva treated in a concentration range for malformations of specific morphological structures/organ systems. The model includes identifying a no-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) and the concentration resulting in 25% lethality (LC25) at 5 days postfertilization. An LC25/NOAEL ratio ≥10 classifies a compound positive for teratogenic potential. A consortium effort evaluated a modified version of this assay which involved enzymatic chorion treatment instead of manual dissection and used experimental replicates for final classification. The modified assay achieved an 85% overall predictivity (Gustafson, A. L., Stedman, D. B., Ball, J., Hillegass, J. M., Flood, A., Zhang, C. X., Panzica-Kelly, J., Cao, J., Coburn, A., Enright, B. P., et al. (2012). Inter-laboratory assessment of a harmonized zebrafish developmental toxicology assay - progress report on phase I. Reprod. Toxicol. 33, 155-164.). The objective of this study was to perform a thorough performance evaluation of the dechorinated assay by repeating the original training set and testing additional compounds in experimental replicates. When the initial training set was repeated with inclusion of experimental replicates, the overall predictivity was 83%. Model performance was tested with an additional 34 compounds and achieved overall predictivity of 74%. When the training and test sets were combined (63 compounds) the assay's final sensitivity was 83% and the specificity was 71%. Total predictivity was 78% with relatively balanced predictivity for nonteratogens (77%) and teratogens (78%). The chorion-off assay achieved superior sensitivity (83%) compared with sensitivity (63-74%) reported by consortium efforts testing a similar assay with chorion-intact embryos (Ball, J. S., Stedman, D. B., Hillegass, J. M., Zhang, C. X., Panzica-Kelly, J., Coburn, A., Enright, B. P., Tornesi, B., Amouzadeh, H. R., Hetheridge, M., et al. (2014). Fishing for teratogens: a consortium effort for a harmonized zebrafish developmental toxicology assay. Toxicol. Sci. 139, 210-219.). Additional protocol modifications were made to increase assay throughput.

A study of vehicles for dosing rodent whole embryo culture with non aqueous soluble compounds.

In rodent whole embryo culture (WEC), finding vehicles for non-aqueous-soluble compounds has been problematic due to developmental toxicity associated with many solvents. The purpose of this study was to identify alternative vehicles for insoluble compounds. In WEC, we evaluated carrier solutions containing bovine serum albumin (BSA) and glycerol as well as the solvents, formamide, dimethylformamide (DMF), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and ethanol, for relative teratogenicity and delivery of the insoluble teratogen, all-trans retinoic acid (RA). At a concentration of

Fishing for teratogens: a consortium effort for a harmonized zebrafish developmental toxicology assay.

A consortium of biopharmaceutical companies previously developed an optimized Zebrafish developmental toxicity assay (ZEDTA) where chorionated embryos were exposed to non-proprietary test compounds from 5 to 6 h post fertilization and assessed for morphological integrity at 5 days post fertilization. With the original 20 test compounds, this achieved an overall predictive value for teratogenicity of 88% of mammalian in vivo outcome [Gustafson, A. L., Stedman, D. B., Ball, J., Hillegass, J. M., Flood, A., Zhang, C. X., Panzica-Kelly, J., Cao, J., Coburn, A., Enright, B. P., et al. (2012). Interlaboratory assessment of a harmonized Zebrafish developmental toxicology assay-Progress report on phase I. Reprod. Toxicol. 33, 155-164]. In the second phase of this project, 38 proprietary pharmaceutical compounds from four consortium members were evaluated in two laboratories using the optimized method using either pond-derived or cultivated-strain wild-type Zebrafish embryos at concentrations up to 100µM. Embryo uptake of all compounds was assessed using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. Twenty eight of 38 compounds had a confirmed embryo uptake of >5%, and with these compounds the ZEDTA achieved an overall predictive value of 82% and 65% at the two respective laboratories. When low-uptake compounds (≤ 5%) were retested with logarithmic concentrations up to 1000µM, the overall predictivity across all 38 compounds was 79% and 62% respectively, with the first laboratory achieving 74% sensitivity (teratogen detection) and 82% specificity (non-teratogen detection) and the second laboratory achieving 63% sensitivity (teratogen detection) and 62% specificity (non-teratogen detection). Subsequent data analyses showed that technical differences rather than strain differences were the primary contributor to interlaboratory differences in predictivity. Based on these results, the ZEDTA harmonized methodology is currently being used for compound assessment at lead optimization stage of development by 4/5 of the consortium companies.

Establishment of a molecular embryonic stem cell developmental toxicity assay.

The mouse embryonic stem cell test (EST) is a 10-day screen for teratogenic potential developed to reduce animal use for embryotoxicity testing of chemicals (Spielmann, 2005; Spielmann et al., 1997). In this study, we used the cytotoxicity IC(50) values and transcriptional expression changes as primary endpoints in a shorter 4-day version of the EST, the molecular embryonic stem cell assay. Mouse D3 embryonic stem cells were used for cytotoxicity assessment (monolayers) or grown as embryoid bodies in low attachment plates for transcriptional profiling. Sixty-five compounds with known in vivo teratogenicity (33 teratogens and 32 nonteratogens) were evaluated to develop a model for classifying compounds with teratogenic potential. The expression of 12 developmentally regulated gene targets (nanog, fgf5, gsc, cd34, axin2, apln, chst7, lhx1, fgf8, sox17, foxa2, and cxcr4) was measured following exposure of embryoid bodies to a single compound concentration (0.1 × the cytotoxicity IC(20)) for 4 days. In the decision-tree model, compounds with IC(50) values < 22 µM were categorized as teratogens, whereas compounds in the two groups with IC(50) values between 22-200 µM and > 200 µM were categorized as teratogens if ≥ 8 and 12 genes, respectively, were deregulated by at least 10%. Forty-seven of 65 compounds of the training set were correctly identified (72% total concordance). In a test set of 12 additional compounds (5 teratogens, 7 nonteratogens), 10 were correctly classified by this approach (83% concordance). The false positive rate in the training and test sets was 24 and 0%, respectively, indicating that this assay has potential to identify teratogens.

Selection of normalizer genes in conducting relative gene expression analysis of embryos.

BACKGROUND: In relative gene expression analysis, a reference gene for sample normalization is required for determining target expression changes among experimental treatment groups. Since some developmental toxicants secondarily cause general growth retardation and/or other general biological changes, commonly used housekeeping genes may not serve as accurate normalizers. METHODS: We conducted real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) with normalization to calculate relative target transcriptional change, using housekeeping and structure-specific expression genes as normalizers. Relative levels of Hoxb1 expression were measured in cultured rodent embryos at 24 hr post retinoic acid (RA) administration. Transcriptional response was also evaluated using two novel compounds that produced posterior axial and growth defects in rat whole-embryo culture. Embryos treated with these compounds were evaluated for general biological processes, and their respective biological states were considered in the context of the relative gene expression change calculated with the housekeeping normalizers. RESULTS: Normalized RA-induced Hoxb1 expression demonstrated that only some reference genes accurately quantitated the expected 1.5- to 2-fold increase in Hoxb1 expression. Evaluation of the test compounds demonstrated that only normalization with the spatially-restricted hindbrain gene, Krox-20, calculated significant expression decreases of T-gene, a gene known to be functionally relevant in posterior axial development. Reduction in T-gene expression was confirmed qualitatively by whole-mount in situ hybridization. CONCLUSIONS: Prudent reference gene selection is important in evaluating relative gene expression in embryos. An experimental control design is proposed to facilitate the identification of normalizing genes that will accurately calculate relative gene expression change in treated embryos.

Evidence for a molecular mechanism of teratogenicity of SB-236057, a 5-HT1B receptor inverse agonist that alters axial formation.

BACKGROUND: SB-236057 is a potent skeletal teratogen in rodents and rabbits, producing axial and posterior somite malformations in cultured rat embryos. The compound shares some structural similarity to cyclopamine. METHODS: M13 phage display was used to identify amino acid motifs with binding affinity to SB-236057. A 10 microM SB-236057 solution was administered to cultured day 9 postcoitus rat embryos and real-time PCR was conducted at 6 hr posttreatment to evaluate early transcriptional response of axial development genes. Whole-mount in situ hybridization of selected transcripts was conducted on embryos at 48 hr post-compound administration. The rat-enhancer of split protein 1 (r-esp1) expression-functional characterization was done by transcriptional expression and morpholino antisense approaches. RESULTS: We identified several amino acid motifs that had high binding affinity to SB-236057-biotin conjugates, one with 100% sequence homology to a region of r-esp1, one of the Groucho homologs transcribed by the enhancer of split complex (En[spl]C). SB-236057 repressed expression of r-esp1 and members of the Notch-En[spl]C pathway. Goosecoid and HNF3-beta, both suspected to associate with Groucho proteins, were also responsive, although expression of another putative binding protein, engrailed-1 (en-1), and other en-1 pathway members was not affected. R-esp1 mRNA was localized along the axis and antisense inhibition produced similar somite malformations as SB-236057 did. At 48 hr post-SB-236057 or post-r-esp1 antisense administration, affected embryos demonstrated unchanged sonic hedgehog (shh) expression, however HNF3-beta expression was either absent, altered, or reduced. CONCLUSIONS: We present experimental evidence that the mechanism of SB-236057 teratogenicity includes transcriptional alterations to the Notch1-En[spl] pathway. In addition, alterations in HNF3-beta expression were similar to those induced by cyclopamine. The relationships between r-esp1 with Notch1 and shh signaling pathways and potential mechanisms of SB-236057 teratogenicity are also discussed.

SB-236057: Critical window of sensitivity study and embryopathy of a potent musculoskeletal teratogen.

BACKGROUND: SB-236057 is a potent skeletal teratogen in rodents and rabbits. The study objective was to identify the critical developmental window of compound sensitivity and to characterize the early onset of SB-236057 embryopathy. METHODS: SB-236057 was orally administered to Sprague Dawley dams at 100 mg/kg/day on days 6-7, 8-11, 12-14, or 15-17 postcoitus (pc). The critical window of sensitivity was identified to occur between days 8-11 pc. Dams were then dosed on days 8-11 pc and embryos were evaluated by histochemical procedures on days 11, 13, or 15 pc. RESULTS: Axial malformations were evident by day 11 pc. Analysis of the cartilaginous skeleton revealed missing posterior axial skeletal elements. However, only about one-third of the malformed fetuses exhibited obvious rib and vertebrae abnormalities, and none of the affected fetuses exhibited abnormal appendicular skeletal elements. Expression pattern of sonic hedgehog in the notochord and floor plate was not affected, suggesting ventral midline signaling was not disrupted. Histological analysis demonstrated hypoplastic and/or missing musculature in proximity to the ribs and vertebrae. Caspase 3 analysis revealed no increases in apoptotic cells in the musculature. Confocal analysis of the limbs demonstrated truncated peripheral nerve formation and shortening of the appendicular musculature. CONCLUSIONS: SB-236057 is speculated to alter paraxial mesoderm programming. Many of the skeletal malformations may be caused secondarily from musculature abnormalities, suggesting that the myotome may be particularly sensitive to the compound. Furthermore, the finding that peripheral nerve trajectories were altered along the axis and in the limb suggests that SB-236057 may alter early embryonic signaling pathways necessary for neuronal differentiation/axonal guidance that occur subsequently in embryo-fetal development.