Azacalixquinarenes: From Canonical to (Poly-)Zwitterionic Macrocycles.

Azacalixquinarenes, a new family of macrocycles composed of diaminobenzoquinone diimine units linked by dinitrobenzene rings, are synthesized by selective oxidation of the parent azacalixarenes. Crystallographic analyses of two compounds demonstrated the presence of canonical (uncharged) and zwitterionic quinones within a single structure. The electron-withdrawing nature of the dinitrobenzene moieties can trigger the intramolecular H-transfer that generates zwitterionic ground-state quinones. The nature of the N-substituents and the polarity of the solvent have a crucial impact on the equilibrium between the canonical and zwitterionic forms that present distinct optical and electrochemical properties. Thus, within [4]- and [6]-membered macrocycles, poly-zwitterionic structures can be reached, as demonstrated experimentally and theoretically using first-principle approaches.

Modelling excitation energy transfer in covalently linked molecular dyads containing a BODIPY unit and a macrocycle.

With the help of time-dependent density functional theory coupled to an implicit solvation scheme (the polarisable continuum model), we have investigated the singlet-singlet Excitation Energy Transfer (EET) process in a panel of large BODIPY-macrocycle dyads. We have first considered different strategies to compute the electronic coupling in a representative BODIPY-zinc porphyrin assembly and, next evaluated the performances of the chosen computational protocol on several BODIPY-porphyrinoid molecular architectures for which the EET rate constants have been experimentally measured. This step showed the robustness of our approach, which is able to reproduce the magnitude of the measured rate constants in most cases. We have finally applied the validated methodology on newly designed dyads combining a BODIPY unit and an azacalixphyrin macrocycle, a recently synthesised porphyrin analogue that displays exceptional optical properties. This work allowed us to propose new molecular architectures presenting improved properties and also to highlight the interest of using azacalixphyrin as a building block in molecular light-harvesting antennas.

Central substitution of azacalixphyrins: a strategy towards acidochromic NIR dyes.

Azacalixphyrin derivatives constitute one of the most intriguing class of macrocyclic compounds. Indeed, these isostructural and isoelectronic analogues of porphyrins intensively absorb light up to the near infrared region, exist in several tautomeric forms and present a bis-zwitterionic structure, with a central dianionic core surrounded by positively-charged trimethine cyanines. However, control of the position of the absorption bands of azacalixphyrin remains an important challenge, as the experimental attempts reported to date have led to very modest auxochromic shifts only. Inspired by previous work demonstrating that the optical signatures of cyanines can be strongly modified by using central substituents, we have evaluated the validity of this strategy for azacalixphyrin considering several substituents positioned in symmetric or asymmetric manners around the core and linked through both single and double bonds, as well as several protonation states of the macrocycles. It turns out that bromine and dimethylamino substituents have a negligible or weak impact on the optical properties of azacalixphyrins with maximal redshifts smaller than 0.10 eV. The imino substitution induces strong geometrical deformations that counterbalance the electronic effects leading to rather modest variations of the optical signatures. In contrast, for keto-substituted macrocycles, electronic effects dominate and very strong acidochromic shifts are predicted with absorption wavelengths going from 811 to 1095 nm upon double deprotonation.

Rationalisation of the optical signatures of nor-dihydroxanthene-hemicyanine fused near-infrared fluorophores by first-principle tools.

Using a computational approach combining the Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory (TD-DFT) and the second-order Coupled Cluster (CC2) approaches, we investigate the spectral properties of a large panel of nor-dihydroxanthene (DHX)-hemicyanine fused dyes. First we compare the theoretical and experimental 0-0 energies for a set of 14 known synthetic compounds and show that a remarkable agreement between theory and experiment is obtained when a suitable environmental model is selected. In addition, we obtain vibrationally-resolved spectra for several compounds and theory also accurately reproduces the experimental band shapes. We show that the electronic transitions in nor-DHX-based fluorophores are associated with small variations of the dipole moments but large oscillator strengths. Using various chemical strategies, we design a series of compounds with red-shifted 0-0 energies.

Modeling excitation energy transfer in multi-BODIPY architectures.

The excitation energy transfer (EET) allowing the concentration of the energy has been investigated in several multi-BODIPY architectures with the help of an approach coupling time dependent density functional theory to an implicit solvation scheme, the polarizable continuum model. We have first considered several strategies to compute the electronic coupling in a dyad varying the size of the donor/acceptor units, the bridge, the geometries and conformations. We have next studied the electronic coupling in three different architectures for which the EET rate constants have been experimentally measured both from luminescence and transient absorption data and from Förster theory. A good agreement with experimental values was obtained. Finally, in an effort to further improve these systems, we have designed several series of BODIPY triads, investigating the effect of acidochromism, core modifications, the position of the linkage and chemical substitutions on the EET coupling and rate constant. We show that several architectures allow us to increase the EET rate by one order of magnitude compared to the original compound.

Structural and Optical Properties of Subporphyrinoids: A TD-DFT Study.

Using ab initio approaches accounting for environmental effects, we investigate the ground- and excited-state properties of four subporphyrinoids: subporphyrin, subporphyrazine, tribenzosubporphyrin, and subphthalocyanine. We first show that the selected level of theory, that is DFT(PBE0), is able to reproduce the structure and NMR spectra of all compounds. The aromaticity of these four macrocyclic entities are next quantified and it is showed that these bowl-shape induced molecules present very strong aromatic characters. Next we analyze the spectral signatures of all four compounds using an approach going beyond the vertical approximation. The 0-0 energies are reproduced with a mean absolute deviation smaller than 0.1 eV, and the very good agreement obtained between experimental and theoretical band shapes allows us to unravel the vibronic contributions responsible to the specific band shapes of these subporphyrinoids. Finally, we investigate a large series of substituted subporphyrins, demonstrate the quality of the trends that are obtained with theory and design new compounds presenting red-shifted optical bands.

Calculations of n→π* Transition Energies: Comparisons Between TD-DFT, ADC, CC, CASPT2, and BSE/GW Descriptions.

Using a large panel of theoretical approaches, namely, CC2, CCSD, CCSDR(3), CC3, ADC(2), ADC(3), CASPT2, time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT), and BSE/evGW, the two latter combined with different exchange-correlation functionals, we investigate the lowest singlet transition in 23 n→π* compounds based on the nitroso, thiocarbonyl, carbonyl, and diazo chromophores. First, for 16 small derivatives we compare the transition energies provided by the different wave function approaches to define theoretical best estimates. For this set, it surprisingly turned out that ADC(2) offers a better match with CC3 than ADC(3). Next, we use 10 functionals belonging to the "LYP" and "M06" families and compare the TD-DFT and the BSE/evGW descriptions. The BSE/evGW results are less sensitive than their TD-DFT counterparts to the selected functional, especially in the M06 series. Nevertheless, BSE/evGW delivers larger errors than TD-CAM-B3LYP, which provides extremely accurate results in the present case, especially when the Tamm-Dancoff approximation is applied. In addition, we show that, among the different starting points for BSE/evGW calculations, M06-2X eigenstates stand as the most appropriate. Finally, we confirm that the trends observed on the small compounds pertain in larger molecules.

Bethe-Salpeter study of cationic dyes: Comparisons with ADC(2) and TD-DFT.

We present a theoretical investigation of the excited-state properties of a large series of structurally diverse arylcarbonium derivatives that are known to be challenging for theoretical models. More specifically, we compare the pros and cons of TD-DFT (TD-M06-2X), ADC(2), and BSE/GW approaches for a large panel of compounds, using two different solvent models. Both 0-0 and vertical transition energies are considered and compared to the experimental values. All approaches reasonably reproduce the auxochromic and acidochromic shifts, although in most cases both TD-DFT and BSE/GW return larger correlation with experimental values than ADC(2) for these shifts. In contrast, the absolute transition energies obtained with ADC(2) tend to be closer to the measurements, TD-DFT using the M06-2X functional largely overestimating the experimental references (by ca. 0.5 eV), and BSE/GW providing intermediate values. In addition, we show that the selected solvent model has a significant impact on the results, the corrected linear-response approach providing larger transition energies than its linear-response counterpart.

Modeling the photosensitizing properties of thiolate-protected gold nanoclusters.

An accurate computational strategy for studying the structural, redox and optical properties of thiolated gold nanoclusters (GNCs) using (Time-Dependent) Density Functional Theory is proposed. The influence of the pseudopotential/basis set, solvent description and the choice of the functional has been investigated to model the structural and electronic properties of the Au25(SR)18(-) system, with R being an organic ligand. This study aims to describe with a comparable precision both the GNC and the organic ligands and rationalize the effect of coating on different GNC properties. Two differently coated GNCs have been considered: the system with R = CH2CH2Ph and the GNC coated with 17 alkyl chains (C6H13) and functionalized by one fluorophore pyrene derivative (CH2CH2(NH)(CO)Py). The computational protocol we propose should then be used to design more efficient metal cluster-sensitized solar cells.

Elucidating the Nature of Carbazole-Porphyrinoids with First-Principle Approaches.

Carbazole-porphyrinoids are [20]porphyrins that can be oxidized to the so-called porphyrin state, inducing a huge shift of the main absorption band from the UV-visible to the infrared region. In this study, we focus on the compound synthesized by Arnold and co-workers [ Arnold , L. ; Baumgarten , M. ; Müllen , K. A. Chem. Commun. , 2012 , 48 , 9640 - 9642 ], where the two pyrroline units of a porphyrin are replaced with carbazole moieties. Due to the poor stability of these macrocycles, the nature of the oxidation product could not be definitively ascertained experimentally. In that framework, with the help of ab initio approaches, we investigate the structure, the stability, the aromaticity, and the spectroscopic signatures of both the nonoxidized compound and a series of possible oxidation products. Thanks to vibronic simulations, we obtain insights into the nature of the oxidized macrocycle.

Fused bis-azacalixphyrin that reaches NIR-II absorptions.

The fusion of two azacalixphyrin cycles absorbing in the NIR-I domain moves the absorption properties beyond 1000 nm, towards the second biological transparency window (NIR-II). This new type of NIR-II dye was synthesised through the intermediate preparation of a rare example of bis-tetra-azacalix[4]arene where the two macrocycles share a common aromatic unit.

Combined TD-DFT-SOS-CIS(D) Study of BOPHY Derivatives with Potential Application in Biosensing.

A set of 13 bis(difluoroboron)-1,2-bis((pyrrol-2-yl)methylene)hydrazine (BOPHY) dyes is studied through a hybrid time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT)-scaled opposite spin-configuration interaction singles with a double correction [SOS-CIS(D)] approach accounting for solvent effects, to shed light onto the structure-property relationships of these recently developed chromophores. In the first step, we calculate the absorption-fluorescence crossing points with refined TD-DFT models considering the influences of both vibrational and solvent contributions. We found that the systematic overestimation of the 0-0 energies is effectively reduced by combining polarizable continuum model-TD-DFT with a scaled opposite spin-configuration interaction singles with a double correction [SOS-CIS(D)]. Next, for a representative system, the vibrationally resolved spectrum within the harmonic approximation is computed on the basis of TD-DFT vibrational signatures and an excellent match with experiment is found. Finally, the influence of different lateral groups on the spectroscopic properties is rationalized by investigating charge transfer parameters and examining electronic density difference maps. It is found that one can tune the position of the absorption/emission maxima by a judicious choice of the lateral substituents or by using π-extended segments. The largest absorption and emission wavelengths as well as the largest Stokes shifts are obtained for BOPHYs containing strong electron-donor dimethylaminophenyl groups attached to the α-positions of the pyrrole units through vinyl linkers, making these chromophores promising candidates for bioluminescence applications.

Symmetry Breaking in Pyrrolo[3,2-b]pyrroles: Synthesis, Solvatofluorochromism and Two-photon Absorption.

Five centrosymmetric and one dipolar pyrrolo[3,2-b]pyrroles, possessing either two or one strongly electron-withdrawing nitro group have been synthesized in a straightforward manner from simple building blocks. For the symmetric compounds, the nitroaryl groups induced spontaneous breaking of inversion symmetry in the excited state, thereby leading to large solvatofluorochromism. To study the origin of this effect, the series employed peripheral structural motifs that control the degree of conjugation via altering of dihedral angle between the 4-nitrophenyl moiety and the electron-rich core. We observed that for compounds with a larger dihedral angle, the fluorescence quantum yield decreased quickly when exposed to even moderately polar solvents. Reducing the dihedral angle (i.e., placing the nitrobenzene moiety in the same plane as the rest of the molecule) moderated the dependence on solvent polarity so that the dye exhibited significant emission, even in THF. To investigate at what stage the symmetry breaking occurs, we measured two-photon absorption (2PA) spectra and 2PA cross-sections (σ2PA ) for all six compounds. The 2PA transition profile of the dipolar pyrrolo[3,2-b]pyrrole, followed the corresponding one-photon absorption (1PA) spectrum, which provided an estimate of the change of the permanent electric dipole upon transition, ≈18 D. The nominally symmetric compounds displayed an allowed 2PA transition in the wavelength range of 700-900 nm. The expansion via a triple bond resulted in the largest peak value, σ2PA =770 GM, whereas altering the dihedral angle had no effect other than reducing the peak value two- or even three-fold. In the S0 →S1 transition region, the symmetric structures also showed a partial overlap between 2PA and 1PA transitions in the long-wavelength wing of the band, from which a tentative, relatively small dipole moment change, 2-7 D, was deduced, thus suggesting that some small symmetry breaking may be possible in the ground state, even before major symmetry breaking occurs in the excited state.

Highly fluorescent extended 2-(2'-hydroxyphenyl)benzazole dyes: synthesis, optical properties and first-principle calculations.

The investigation of the optical properties of extended 2-(2-hydroxyphenyl)benzazole dyes showed a complete frustration of the excited-state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT) process leading to a novel family of highly fluorescent fluorophores. In the case of a benzothiazole ring, restoration of ESIPT can be observed in acidic medium leading to ratiometric sensing. These experimental results have been rationalised by first-principle calculations.

Tuning ESIPT fluorophores into dual emitters.

Dyes undergoing excited-state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT) are known to present large Stokes shifts as a result of the important geometrical reorganisation following photon absorption. When the ESIPT process is not quantitative, one can obtain dual emitters characterised by two distinct fluorescence bands, observed due to emissions from both the canonical and ESIPT isomers. However, dual emission generally requires to maintain a very specific balance, as the relative excited-state free energies of the two tautomers have to be within a narrow window to observe the phenomenon. Consequently, simple chemical intuition is insufficient to optimise dual emission. In the present contribution, we investigate, with the help of quantum-mechanical tools and more precisely, time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) and algebraic diagrammatic construction (ADC), a wide panel of possible ESIPT/dual emitters with various substituents. The selected protocol is first shown to be very robust on a series of structures with known experimental behaviour, and next is applied to novel derivatives with various substituents located at different positions. This work encompasses the largest chemical library of potential ESIPT compounds studied to date. We pinpoint the most promising combinations for building dual emitters, highlight unexpected combination effects and rationalise the impact of the different auxochromes.