Mental health in the UK Biobank: A roadmap to self-report measures and neuroimaging correlates.

The UK Biobank (UKB) is a highly promising dataset for brain biomarker research into population mental health due to its unprecedented sample size and extensive phenotypic, imaging, and biological measurements. In this study, we aimed to provide a shared foundation for UKB neuroimaging research into mental health with a focus on anxiety and depression. We compared UKB self-report measures and revealed important timing effects between scan acquisition and separate online acquisition of some mental health measures. To overcome these timing effects, we introduced and validated the Recent Depressive Symptoms (RDS-4) score which we recommend for state-dependent and longitudinal research in the UKB. We furthermore tested univariate and multivariate associations between brain imaging-derived phenotypes (IDPs) and mental health. Our results showed a significant multivariate relationship between IDPs and mental health, which was replicable. Conversely, effect sizes for individual IDPs were small. Test-retest reliability of IDPs was stronger for measures of brain structure than for measures of brain function. Taken together, these results provide benchmarks and guidelines for future UKB research into brain biomarkers of mental health.

Opaque Ontology: Neuroimaging Classification of ICD-10 Diagnostic Groups in the UK Biobank.

Background: 1.The use of machine learning to classify diagnostic cases versus controls defined based on diagnostic ontologies such as the ICD-10 from neuroimaging features is now commonplace across a wide range of diagnostic fields. However, transdiagnostic comparisons of such classifications are lacking. Such transdiagnostic comparisons are important to establish the specificity of classification models, set benchmarks, and assess the value of diagnostic ontologies. Results: 2.We investigated case-control classification accuracy in 17 different ICD-10 diagnostic groups from Chapter V (mental and behavioral disorders) and Chapter VI (diseases of the nervous system) using data from the UK Biobank. Classification models were trained using either neuroimaging (structural or functional brain MRI feature sets) or socio-demographic features. Random forest classification models were adopted using rigorous shuffle splits to estimate stability as well as accuracy of case-control classifications. Diagnostic classification accuracies were benchmarked against age classification (oldest versus youngest) from the same feature sets and against additional classifier types (K-nearest neighbors and linear support vector machine). In contrast to age classification accuracy, which was high for all feature sets, few ICD-10 diagnostic groups were classified significantly above chance (namely, demyelinating diseases based on structural neuroimaging features, and depression based on socio-demographic and functional neuroimaging features). Conclusion: 3.These findings highlight challenges with the current disease classification system, leading us to recommend caution with the use of ICD-10 diagnostic groups as target labels in brain-based disease prediction studies.

Systematic evaluation of MRI-based characterization of tumor-associated vascular morphology and hemodynamics via a dynamic digital phantom.

Purpose: Validation of quantitative imaging biomarkers is a challenging task, due to the difficulty in measuring the ground truth of the target biological process. A digital phantom-based framework is established to systematically validate the quantitative characterization of tumor-associated vascular morphology and hemodynamics based on dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE-MRI). Approach: A digital phantom is employed to provide a ground-truth vascular system within which 45 synthetic tumors are simulated. Morphological analysis is performed on high-spatial resolution DCE-MRI data (spatial/temporal resolution = 30 to 300 µm/60 s) to determine the accuracy of locating the arterial inputs of tumor-associated vessels (TAVs). Hemodynamic analysis is then performed on the combination of high-spatial resolution and high-temporal resolution (spatial/temporal resolution = 60 to 300 µm/1 to 10 s) DCE-MRI data, determining the accuracy of estimating tumor-associated blood pressure, vascular extraction rate, interstitial pressure, and interstitial flow velocity. Results: The observed effects of acquisition settings demonstrate that, when optimizing the DCE-MRI protocol for the morphological analysis, increasing the spatial resolution is helpful but not necessary, as the location and arterial input of TAVs can be recovered with high accuracy even with the lowest investigated spatial resolution. When optimizing the DCE-MRI protocol for hemodynamic analysis, increasing the spatial resolution of the images used for vessel segmentation is essential, and the spatial and temporal resolutions of the images used for the kinetic parameter fitting require simultaneous optimization. Conclusion: An in silico validation framework was generated to systematically quantify the effects of image acquisition settings on the ability to accurately estimate tumor-associated characteristics.

Pharmacokinetic Analysis of Enhancement-Constrained Acceleration (ECA) reconstruction-based high temporal resolution breast DCE-MRI.

The high spatial and temporal resolution of dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI (DCE-MRI) can improve the diagnostic accuracy of breast cancer screening in patients who have dense breasts or are at high risk of breast cancer. However, the spatiotemporal resolution of DCE-MRI is limited by technical issues in clinical practice. Our earlier work demonstrated the use of image reconstruction with enhancement-constrained acceleration (ECA) to increase temporal resolution. ECA exploits the correlation in k-space between successive image acquisitions. Because of this correlation, and due to the very sparse enhancement at early times after contrast media injection, we can reconstruct images from highly under-sampled k-space data. Our previous results showed that ECA reconstruction at 0.25 seconds per image (4 Hz) can estimate bolus arrival time (BAT) and initial enhancement slope (iSlope) more accurately than a standard inverse fast Fourier transform (IFFT) when k-space data is sampled following a Cartesian based sampling trajectory with adequate signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). In this follow-up study, we investigated the effect of different Cartesian based sampling trajectories, SNRs and acceleration rates on the performance of ECA reconstruction in estimating contrast media kinetics in lesions (BAT, iSlope and Ktrans) and in arteries (Peak signal intensity of first pass, time to peak, and BAT). We further validated ECA reconstruction with a flow phantom experiment. Our results show that ECA reconstruction of k-space data acquired with 'Under-sampling with Repeated Advancing Phase' (UnWRAP) trajectories with an acceleration factor of 14, and temporal resolution of 0.5 s/image and high SNR (SNR ≥ 30 dB, noise standard deviation (std) < 3%) ensures minor errors (5% or 1 s error) in lesion kinetics. Medium SNR (SNR ≥ 20 dB, noise std ≤ 10%) was needed to accurately measure arterial enhancement kinetics. Our results also suggest that accelerated temporal resolution with ECA with 0.5 s/image is practical.

Enhancement-constrained acceleration: A robust reconstruction framework in breast DCE-MRI.

In patients with dense breasts or at high risk of breast cancer, dynamic contrast enhanced MRI (DCE-MRI) is a highly sensitive diagnostic tool. However, its specificity is highly variable and sometimes low; quantitative measurements of contrast uptake parameters may improve specificity and mitigate this issue. To improve diagnostic accuracy, data need to be captured at high spatial and temporal resolution. While many methods exist to accelerate MRI temporal resolution, not all are optimized to capture breast DCE-MRI dynamics. We propose a novel, flexible, and powerful framework for the reconstruction of highly-undersampled DCE-MRI data: enhancement-constrained acceleration (ECA). Enhancement-constrained acceleration uses an assumption of smooth enhancement at small time-scale to estimate points of smooth enhancement curves in small time intervals at each voxel. This method is tested in silico with physiologically realistic virtual phantoms, simulating state-of-the-art ultrafast acquisitions at 3.5s temporal resolution reconstructed at 0.25s temporal resolution (demo code available here). Virtual phantoms were developed from real patient data and parametrized in continuous time with arterial input function (AIF) models and lesion enhancement functions. Enhancement-constrained acceleration was compared to standard ultrafast reconstruction in estimating the bolus arrival time and initial slope of enhancement from reconstructed images. We found that the ECA method reconstructed images at 0.25s temporal resolution with no significant loss in image fidelity, a 4x reduction in the error of bolus arrival time estimation in lesions (p < 0.01) and 11x error reduction in blood vessels (p < 0.01). Our results suggest that ECA is a powerful and versatile tool for breast DCE-MRI.

An in silico validation framework for quantitative DCE-MRI techniques based on a dynamic digital phantom.

Quantitative evaluation of an image processing method to perform as designed is central to both its utility and its ability to guide the data acquisition process. Unfortunately, these tasks can be quite challenging due to the difficulty of experimentally obtaining the "ground truth" data to which the output of a given processing method must be compared. One way to address this issue is via "digital phantoms", which are numerical models that provide known biophysical properties of a particular object of interest.  In this contribution, we propose an in silico validation framework for dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE-MRI) acquisition and analysis methods that employs a novel dynamic digital phantom. The phantom provides a spatiotemporally-resolved representation of blood-interstitial flow and contrast agent delivery, where the former is solved by a 1D-3D coupled computational fluid dynamic system, and the latter described by an advection-diffusion equation. Furthermore, we establish a virtual simulator which takes as input the digital phantom, and produces realistic DCE-MRI data with controllable acquisition parameters. We assess the performance of a simulated standard-of-care acquisition (Protocol A) by its ability to generate contrast-enhanced MR images that separate vasculature from surrounding tissue, as measured by the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR). We find that the CNR significantly decreases as the spatial resolution (SRA, where the subscript indicates Protocol A) or signal-to-noise ratio (SNRA) decreases. Specifically, with an SNRA / SRA = 75 dB / 30 µm, the median CNR is 77.30, whereas an SNRA / SRA = 5 dB / 300 µm reduces the CNR to 6.40. Additionally, we assess the performance of simulated ultra-fast acquisition (Protocol B) by its ability to generate DCE-MR images that capture contrast agent pharmacokinetics, as measured by error in the signal-enhancement ratio (SER) compared to ground truth (PESER). We find that PESER significantly decreases the as temporal resolution (TRB) increases. Similar results are reported for the effects of spatial resolution and signal-to-noise ratio on PESER. For example, with an SNRB / SRB / TRB = 5 dB / 300 µm / 10 s, the median PESER is 21.00%, whereas an SNRB / SRB / TRB = 75 dB / 60 µm / 1 s, yields a median PESER of 0.90%. These results indicate that our in silico framework can generate virtual MR images that capture effects of acquisition parameters on the ability of generated images to capture morphological or pharmacokinetic features. This validation framework is not only useful for investigations of perfusion-based MRI techniques, but also for the systematic evaluation and optimization new MRI acquisition, reconstruction, and image processing techniques.

Dynamic field-of-view imaging to increase temporal resolution in the early phase of contrast media uptake in breast DCE-MRI: A feasibility study.

PURPOSE: To increase diagnostic accuracy of breast MRI by increasing temporal resolution and more accurately sampling the early kinetics of contrast media uptake. We tested the feasibility of accelerating bilateral breast DCE-MRI by reducing the FOV, allowing aliasing, and unfolding the resulting images. METHODS: Previous experience with an "ultrafast" protocol for bilateral breast DCE-MRI (6-10 s temporal resolution) showed that the number of significantly enhancing voxels is very low in the first 30-45 s after contrast media injection. This suggests that overlap of enhancing voxels in aliased images will be very infrequent. Therefore, aliased images can be acquired during the first 30-45 s after contrast media injection and unfolded to produce full-FOV images with few errors. In a proof-of-principle test, aliased images were simulated from the first 30 s of full-FOV acquisitions. Cases with relatively dense early enhancement were selected to test this method in a worst-case scenario. In an initial test, an FOV of 60% the size of the full FOV was simulated. To reduce the probability of errors due to overlapping voxels in aliased images, we then tested a dynamic FOV approach. The FOV was progressively increased so that enhancing voxels could not overlap at multiple time-points, and areas where enhancing voxels overlapped at a given time-point could be unfolded by interpolating between the preceding and subsequent time-points (acquired with different FOVs). The simulated FOV sizes for each of the time-points were 31%, 44%, and 77% of the full FOV. Subtraction images (post- minus precontrast) were generated for aliased images and filtered to select significantly enhancing voxels. Comparison of early, highly aliased images, with later, less aliased images then helped to identify the true locations of enhancing voxels. RESULTS: In the initial aliasing simulations, an average of 2.9% of the enhancing voxels above the chest wall overlapped in the aliased images (range 0.1%-6.7%). The similarity between simulated unfolded images and the correct full-FOV images, evaluated using CW-SSIM (complex wavelet similarity index), was 0.50 ± 0.26, 0.76 ± 0.09, and 0.80 ± 0.10 for the first, second, and third time-point, respectively (numbers closer to 1 indicate more similar images). For the dynamic FOV tests, an average of 11% of the enhancing voxels above the chest wall overlapped (range 0%-40%) due to greater aliasing at early time-points. Despite more voxels overlapping, the CW-SSIM values for the data acquired with dynamic FOVs were 0.64 ± 0.25, 0.93 ± 0.04, and 0.97 ± 0.02 for the first, second, and third time-points, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Dynamic FOV imaging allows accelerated bilateral breast DCE-MRI during the early contrast media uptake phase. This method relies on the sparsity of enhancement at the early phases of DCE-MRI of the breast. The results of simulations suggest that dynamic FOV imaging and unfolding produces images that are very close to fully sampled images, and allows temporal resolution as high as 2 s per image.