Diagnostic confusion in treatment-refractory psychotic patients.

BACKGROUND: Two surveys of diagnostic practices in the United States suggest that many clinicians base their diagnoses on presenting symptoms and pay little attention to course and exclusionary criteria. Failure to correctly diagnose patients may result in inappropriate therapy and poor treatment response. The purpose of the present study was to investigate diagnostic practices. METHODS: We made detailed assessments of 50 consecutively admitted treatment-refractory psychotic patients and carefully applied DSM-III-R criteria. RESULTS: Referral diagnoses were changed in 23 of the 50 patients. Diagnoses of schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder were made far less frequently and mood disorders (bipolar disorder and major depression) were diagnosed far more frequently by our group than by referring psychiatrists. Patients whose diagnosis was changed were more likely to be given mood-stabilizing medication and tended to show more improvement than patients whose diagnosis was not changed. CONCLUSIONS: These findings raise the possibility that patients may not respond to treatment because incorrect diagnoses result in inappropriate treatment.

Diagnostic reassessment and treatment response in schizophrenia.

BACKGROUND: The reasons for poor treatment response in some patients with schizophrenia remain unclear. It is possible that misdiagnosis of nonschizophrenic disorders as schizophrenia could result in suboptimal pharmacotherapy in some patients. METHOD: To assess this possibility, 110 severely ill, chronic patients with a referral diagnosis of schizophrenia were comprehensively assessed and rediagnosed according to DSM-III-R criteria. Global Assessment of Function (GAF) and Clinical Global Impressions (CGI) ratings were made at admission and at discharge from the ward, after the implementation of individualized treatment plans. RESULTS: The diagnosis of schizophrenia was confirmed in 80 patients (73%) and revised to another type of psychotic illness in 30 patients (27%). The GAF and CGI ratings were similar at admission in patients with confirmed and revised diagnoses. All patients improved by the time of discharge (p = .0001); however, patients with a revised diagnosis improved more than those with confirmed schizophrenia (p = .02). Patients with a revised diagnosis were less likely to require continued hospitalization on chronic care wards (p = .004). At admission, medication regimens were similar in the two groups of patients. At discharge, patients with a revised diagnosis were less likely to have received neuroleptics (p = .007) and more likely to have received antimanic drugs (p = .0002) or electroconvulsive therapy (p = .0004). CONCLUSION: These findings from a clinical sample suggest that diagnostic reassessment is an important first step in the management of apparently refractory schizophrenia.

Low birthweight in schizophrenia: prematurity or poor fetal growth?

In the general population, low birthweight (LBW) is associated with neurological and psychological problems during childhood and adolescence. LBW may result from premature birth or poor fetal growth, and the independent effects of these two events on childhood development are not fully understood. The rate of low weight births is increased in schizophrenia and is associated with social withdrawal during childhood and an early onset of illness. However, it is unclear whether this LBW reflects poor fetal growth or premature birth, or whether these two risk factors have distinct implications for childhood functioning and age at onset of schizophrenia. Subjects included 270 patients with schizophrenia for whom a detailed history of obstetric events could be obtained. The rate of low weight births was high and was associated with poorer premorbid functioning and an earlier age at illness onset. The rate of both premature births and poor fetal growth was high relative to the normal population. Prematurity, but not poor fetal growth, was associated with premorbid social withdrawal and an early age at illness onset. Poor fetal growth, but not prematurity, was associated with low educational achievement. These results suggest that poor fetal growth and prematurity are associated with distinct patterns of childhood maladjustment in individuals who develop schizophrenia.

Coping, social support, and depressive symptoms in Parkinson's disease.

Social support, depressive symptoms, and three methods of coping were assessed in 45 patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) and 24 comparably disabled controls. The PD subjects employed significantly fewer cognitive and behavioral coping strategies compared with the controls. Fewer depressive symptoms were related to increased cognitive coping in PD subjects. Behavioral coping strategies were associated with lesser depression among controls. Avoidance coping methods showed a marginally significant positive association with depressive symptoms in PD subjects. Social support was related to the significant coping predictors in each group, but was not related to depressive symptoms. Although correlational, these results might suggest that active (cognitive and behavioral) coping strategies are superior to avoidance strategies in attenuating the affective distress expected from chronic deteriorative illnesses.

Depressive symptoms in Parkinson's disease: a comparison with disabled control subjects.

A high incidence of depressive symptoms has been observed in patients with Parkinson's disease (PD). PD involves a loss of central monoamines, and a decrease of monoamines has been implicated in depression; therefore, it is possible that depressive symptoms in PD result from the loss of endogenous neurotransmitters. However, it is equally possible that depressive symptoms represent a reaction to the chronic disabling course of PD. By comparing depressive symptoms in PD patients to those in matched patients with other chronic disabling diseases not involving a loss of central monoamines, it may be possible to decide between these alternatives. Thus, depressive symptoms were assessed in 45 patients with PD and 24 disabled controls that did not differ from the PD subjects on a measure of functional disability. Results showed that PD subjects obtained significantly higher total scores on the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) than controls. PD subjects scored significantly higher than controls on BDI items grouped to reflect cognitive-affective and somatic depressive symptoms. The BDI scores of PD subjects were not reliably related to age, sex, duration of PD, or clinical ratings of PD symptom severity or functional disability. Self-rated disability and the number of recent medical problems were the greatest predictors of depressive symptoms. These findings supported the hypothesis that depressive symptoms in PD may not represent solely a reaction to disability.

Outcome measurement in pharmacological trials: validity of the Routine Assessment of Patient Progress (RAPP).

The assessment of outcomes after treatment with antipsychotic medication is fundamental to clinical care and research. The Routine Assessment of Patient Progress (RAPP) is a reliable multidimensional scale that employs nurses' ratings of symptoms and functioning in psychiatric inpatients. The present study sought to extend validity evidence for the RAPP by examining its ability to reflect changes associated with treatment by antipsychotic medications. The use of a different sample in this study also provided the opportunity to replicate earlier validity data collected on the original set of patients. Ninety-seven separate trials were conducted, involving 65 consecutive admissions to a unit that specializes in the assessment and treatment of patients with long standing severe psychiatric disorders. The RAPP, along with the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale and global measures of severity, were administered at baseline and at the end of each trial. Both factor scores and clinically-derived subscales were analysed for sensitivity to change. Patients were globally rated as improved, unchanged or worsened at the end of the medication trial. Results indicated that the RAPP factor, clinical scale and total scores compared favourably to other outcome measures in patients rated as improved or worse. In patients rated as unchanged, RAPP scores displayed significantly less change than did the PANSS scores. These findings support the validity of the RAPP as an outcome measure in treatment trials.

Flupenthixol in chronic schizophrenic inpatients: a controlled comparison with haloperidol.

Two neuroleptics having different effects at dopamine receptors were administered to chronic schizophrenic inpatients to compare their therapeutic efficacy and ability to produce side effects. Haloperidol appeared to produce lower levels of psychopathology than flupenthixol but similar levels of side effects. No evidence was found that flupenthixol is specifically useful in "activating" chronic patients or in alleviating affective symptoms. Although these are preliminary results, they support the view that D2 receptors may mediate the antipsychotic effects of neuroleptic drugs.

Donepezil in schizophrenia--is it helpful? An experimental design case study.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the clinical and cognitive effects of adding donepezil, a reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitor, to the risperidone treatment of a high functioning stable out-patient with schizophrenia. METHOD: Case study using an experimental ABAB design. Assessments were completed objectively by standardized neuropsychological tests and clinical rating scales and subjectively with visual analogue scales. RESULTS: Strong improvements attributable to donepezil were found for verbal fluency and the patient's subjective response. No adverse changes were noted in psychiatric symptoms or side effects. CONCLUSION: Cholinergic enhancement as an adjunctive treatment in schizophrenia should be explored in larger controlled trials.

Multidimensional assessment of psychosis: a factor-analytic validation study of the Routine Assessment of Patient Progress.

The areas of function affected by major mental disorders are more diverse than the list of core symptoms assessed by many psychiatric rating scales, and the cross-sectional picture obtained in mental status interviews often fails to capture important data. Information on patient function can be obtained from measures that are based on extended observation and complement symptom-focused assessments. The Routine Assessment of Patient Progress (RAPP) is a 21-item rating scale that assesses both functional and psychiatric symptoms. It is usually completed by nursing staff who have observed patients over a 1-week period. Previous research has shown it to be reliable, valid, simple to complete, and of substantial value for patient care and diagnosis. The present study sought to examine the psychometric structure of the RAPP to define what domains of symptoms and behavior it measures. RAPP scores obtained from 165 psychotic inpatients were submitted to a factor analysis. A five-factor solution was derived in which 18 of 21 RAPP items were assigned to factors. The factors were labeled aggression, positive symptoms, negative symptoms, somatization/anxiety, and organic/ disorganization. The RAPP factors were moderately correlated with conceptually similar factor scores derived from the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS). RAPP aggression scores were validated with an independent clinical measure of aggression. Patients who were independently rated as improved over their hospital stay showed significant improvement on all RAPP factors, and unimproved patients showed stability or deterioration on RAPP measures. The data indicate that RAPP factors assess domains of psychopathology that are moderately correlated with both global ratings and symptom-focused scales. The RAPP's sensitivity to change suggests it is a valid measure of treatment outcome that could be used in controlled trials, as well as standard care outcome evaluation.

Neuropsychological correlates of the PANSS Cognitive Factor.

OBJECTIVE: Factor analytic studies of the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS) have consistently isolated a factor that is frequently labeled as 'cognitive'. The present study sought to further explore the factor by examining the relationships between 4 versions of the cognitive factor and a set of neuropsychological tests. METHOD: Thirty-seven inpatients diagnosed with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder were assessed with the PANSS and neuropsychological measures. RESULTS: Verbal intelligence and verbal memory were found to be most closely associated with cognitive factor scores. A global rating of illness severity showed greater relationships to cognitive variables than any cognitive factor. CONCLUSIONS: The PANSS cognitive factor may reflect verbal ability and memory, but is not sufficiently comprehensive to be considered as a replacement for direct assessment of cognitive functioning.

Routine assessment of patient progress: a multiformat, change-sensitive nurses' instrument for assessing psychotic inpatients.

A new instrument, the Routine Assessment of Patient Progress (RAPP), is a standardized scale with a unique format that allows trained nurses to incorporate both interview and observational data into a comprehensive assessment of psychiatric inpatients. The scale was developed to accurately document treatment effects, assist in treatment planning, and provide ancillary judgments of psychopathology that may affect diagnosis. The RAPP demonstrates satisfactory interrater reliability and internal consistency. The RAPP total score and its two subscales correlated highly, where expected, with an observation-based nursing scale, global measures, and an interview-based psychopathology scale. RAPP scores demonstrated sensitivity to change over time in patient functioning. It reliably discriminated among patients discharged to settings with varying degrees of independent living. The use of the RAPP over several years on a psychiatric inpatient unit has shown it to be a practical clinical tool that eases nurses' charting demands, helps create care plans, and facilitates interdisciplinary communication.

Violence in treatment resistant psychotic inpatients.

This study sought to: a) ascertain the effect on rates of violence by varying its operational definition and b) compare characteristics of violent and nonviolent patients. Aggressive behavior was recorded daily for every patient (N = 78) during a 2-year period. Standardized rating scales were used to rate psychopathology and functioning. Almost two thirds of patients were aggressive to others, and 26% violently assaulted another person. Official incident reports underestimated rates of violence to others, self- harm, and property damage. Multivariate predictive models that greatly improved accuracy over base rates showed that violent patients tended to be female, schizophrenic (nonparanoid type), and abusive of alcohol before admission. Violence is more common in treatment resistant psychotic inpatients than suggested by incident reports. Standardized definitions of violence are urged in order to accurately study its prevalence and correlates. Models combining both historical/demographic and clinical data may enhance prediction of violence.