Primary retinal pathology in multiple sclerosis as detected by optical coherence tomography.

Optical coherence tomography studies in multiple sclerosis have primarily focused on evaluation of the retinal nerve fibre layer. The aetiology of retinal changes in multiple sclerosis is thought to be secondary to optic nerve demyelination. The objective of this study was to use optical coherence tomography to determine if a subset of patients with multiple sclerosis exhibit primary retinal neuronopathy, in the absence of retrograde degeneration of the retinal nerve fibre layer and to ascertain if such patients may have any distinguishing clinical characteristics. We identified 50 patients with multiple sclerosis with predominantly macular thinning (normal retinal nerve fibre-layer thickness with average macular thickness < 5th percentile), a previously undescribed optical coherence tomography defined phenotype in multiple sclerosis, and compared them with 48 patients with multiple sclerosis with normal optical coherence tomography findings, 48 patients with multiple sclerosis with abnormal optical coherence tomography findings (typical for multiple sclerosis) and 86 healthy controls. Utilizing a novel retinal segmentation protocol, we found that those with predominant macular thinning had significant thinning of both the inner and outer nuclear layers, when compared with other patients with multiple sclerosis (P < 0.001 for both), with relative sparing of the ganglion cell layer. Inner and outer nuclear layer thicknesses in patients with non-macular thinning predominant multiple sclerosis were not different from healthy controls. Segmentation analyses thereby demonstrated extensive deeper disruption of retinal architecture in this subtype than may be expected due to retrograde degeneration from either typical clinical or sub-clinical optic neuropathy. Functional corroboration of retinal dysfunction was provided through multi-focal electroretinography in a subset of such patients. These findings support the possibility of primary retinal pathology in a subset of patients with multiple sclerosis. Multiple sclerosis-severity scores were also significantly increased in patients with the macular thinning predominant phenotype, compared with those without this phenotype (n = 96, P=0.006). We have identified a unique subset of patients with multiple sclerosis in whom there appears to be disproportionate thinning of the inner and outer nuclear layers, which may be occurring as a primary process independent of optic nerve pathology. In vivo analyses of retinal layers in multiple sclerosis have not been previously performed, and structural demonstration of pathology in the deeper retinal layers, such as the outer nuclear layer, has not been previously described in multiple sclerosis. Patients with inner and outer nuclear layer pathology have more rapid disability progression and thus retinal neuronal pathology may be a harbinger of a more aggressive form of multiple sclerosis.

Longitudinal study of vision and retinal nerve fiber layer thickness in multiple sclerosis.

OBJECTIVE: Cross-sectional studies of optical coherence tomography (OCT) show that retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness is reduced in multiple sclerosis (MS) and correlates with visual function. We determined how longitudinal changes in RNFL thickness relate to visual loss. We also examined patterns of RNFL thinning over time in MS eyes with and without a prior history of acute optic neuritis (ON). METHODS: Patients underwent OCT measurement of RNFL thickness at baseline and at 6-month intervals during a mean follow-up of 18 months at 3 centers. Low-contrast letter acuity (2.5%, 1.25% contrast) and visual acuity (VA) were assessed. RESULTS: Among 299 patients (593 eyes) with >or=6 months follow-up, eyes with visual loss showed greater RNFL thinning compared to eyes with stable vision (low-contrast acuity, 2.5%: p < 0.001; VA: p = 0.005). RNFL thinning increased over time, with average losses of 2.9microm at 2 to 3 years and 6.1microm at 3 to 4.5 years (p < 0.001 vs 0.5-1-year follow-up interval). These patterns were observed for eyes with or without prior history of ON. Proportions of eyes with RNFL loss greater than test-retest variability (>or=6.6microm) increased from 11% at 0 to 1 year to 44% at 3 to 4.5 years (p < 0.001). INTERPRETATION: Progressive RNFL thinning occurs as a function of time in some patients with MS, even in the absence of ON, and is associated with clinically significant visual loss. These findings are consistent with subclinical axonal loss in the anterior visual pathway in MS, and support the use of OCT and low-contrast acuity as methods to evaluate the effectiveness of putative neuroprotection protocols.

Reproducibility of high-resolution optical coherence tomography in multiple sclerosis.

Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is a non-invasive method to quantify neurodegeneration as an outcome in multiple sclerosis clinical trials; however, no data exist on Cirrus spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) reproducibility in patients with multiple sclerosis. The objective of this study was to determine the protocol for achieving optimal inter-visit, inter-rater, and intra-rater reproducibility for studies performed on healthy controls and multiple sclerosis patients utilizing novel high-definition SD-OCT. This is a prospective study of inter-visit, inter-rater, and intra-rater reproducibility in multiple sclerosis patients (n = 58) and healthy controls (n = 32) on Cirrus-HD SD-OCT. Excellent reproducibility of average and quadrantic retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness values, average macular thickness (AMT), and total macular volume (TMV) [measured by intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC)] was found for inter-visit (healthy controls: mean RNFL = 0.97, quadrant range = 0.92-0.97, AMT = 0.97, TMV = 0.92), inter-rater (MS: mean RNFL = 0.97, quadrant = 0.94-0.98, AMT = 0.99, TMV = 0.96; healthy controls: mean RNFL = 0.97, quadrant = 0.94-0.97, AMT = 0.98, TMV = 0.99), and intra-rater (MS patients: mean RNFL = 0.99, quadrant = 0.83-0.99, AMT = 0.97, TMV = 0.98) reproducibility. The reproducibility of retinal measures derived by Cirrus HD-OCT, especially quadrantic values, is excellent. Specific procedures for OCT acquisition and analysis of retinal imaging metrics using SD-OCT technology may improve the application of this novel technology in multiple sclerosis.

Revisiting brain atrophy and its relationship to disability in multiple sclerosis.

BACKGROUND: Brain atrophy is a well-accepted imaging biomarker of multiple sclerosis (MS) that partially correlates with both physical disability and cognitive impairment. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: Based on MRI scans of 60 MS cases and 37 healthy volunteers, we measured the volumes of white matter (WM) lesions, cortical gray matter (GM), cerebral WM, caudate nucleus, putamen, thalamus, ventricles, and brainstem using a validated and completely automated segmentation method. We correlated these volumes with the Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS), MS Severity Scale (MSSS), MS Functional Composite (MSFC), and quantitative measures of ankle strength and toe sensation. Normalized volumes of both cortical and subcortical GM structures were abnormally low in the MS group, whereas no abnormality was found in the volume of the cerebral WM. High physical disability was associated with low cerebral WM, thalamus, and brainstem volumes (partial correlation coefficients ~0.3-0.4) but not with low cortical GM volume. Thalamus volumes were inversely correlated with lesion load (r = -0.36, p<0.005). CONCLUSION: The GM is atrophic in MS. Although lower WM volume is associated with greater disability, as might be expected, WM volume was on average in the normal range. This paradoxical result might be explained by the presence of coexisting pathological processes, such as tissue damage and repair, that cause both atrophy and hypertrophy and that underlie the observed disability.

Diffusion tensor imaging of the optic tracts in multiple sclerosis: association with retinal thinning and visual disability.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Visual disability is common in multiple sclerosis, but its relationship to abnormalities of the optic tracts remains unknown. Because they are only rarely affected by lesions, the optic tracts may represent a good model for assessing the imaging properties of normal-appearing white matter in multiple sclerosis. METHODS: Whole-brain diffusion tensor imaging was performed on 34 individuals with multiple sclerosis and 26 healthy volunteers. The optic tracts were reconstructed by tractography, and tract-specific diffusion indices were quantified. In the multiple-sclerosis group, peripapillary retinal nerve-fiber-layer thickness and total macular volume were measured by optical coherence tomography, and visual acuity at 100%, 2.5%, and 1.25% contrast was examined. RESULTS: After adjusting for age and sex, optic-tract mean and perpendicular diffusivity were higher (P=.002) in multiple sclerosis. Lower optic-tract fractional anisotropy was correlated with retinal nerve-fiber-layer thinning (r=.51, P=.003) and total-macular-volume reduction (r=.59, P=.002). However, optic-tract diffusion indices were not specifically correlated with visual acuity or with their counterparts in the optic radiation. CONCLUSIONS: Optic-tract diffusion abnormalities are associated with retinal damage, suggesting that both may be related to optic-nerve injury, but do not appear to contribute strongly to visual disability in multiple sclerosis.

The impact of utilizing different optical coherence tomography devices for clinical purposes and in multiple sclerosis trials.

Optical coherence tomography (OCT) derived retinal measures, particularly peri-papillary retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness, have been proposed as outcome measures in remyelinating and neuroprotective trials in multiple sclerosis (MS). With increasing utilization of multiple centers to improve power, elucidation of the impact of different OCT technologies is crucial to the design and interpretation of such studies. In this study, we assessed relation and agreement between RNFL thickness and total macular volume (in MS and healthy controls) derived from three commonly used OCT devices: Stratus time-domain OCT, and Cirrus HD-OCT and Spectralis, two spectral-domain (SD) OCT devices. OCT was performed on both Cirrus HD-OCT and Stratus in 229 participants and on both Cirrus HD-OCT and Spectralis in a separate cohort of 102 participants. Pearson correlation and Bland-Altman analyses were used to assess correlation and agreement between devices. All OCT retinal measures correlated highly between devices. The mean RNFL thickness was 7.4 µm lower on Cirrus HD-OCT than Stratus, indicating overall poor agreement for this measurement between these machines. Further, the limits of agreement (LOA) between Cirrus HD-OCT and Stratus were wide (-4.1 to 18.9 µm), indicating poor agreement at an individual subject level. The mean RNFL thickness was 1.94 µm (LOA: -5.74 to 9.62 µm) higher on Spectralis compared to Cirrus HD-OCT, indicating excellent agreement for this measurement across this cohort. Although these data indicate that these three devices agree poorly at an individual subject level (evidenced by wide LOA in both study cohorts) precluding their co-utilization in everyday practice, the small difference for mean measurements between Cirrus HD-OCT and Spectralis indicate pooled results from these two SD-devices could be used as outcome measures in clinical trials, provided patients are scanned on the same machine throughout the trial, similar to the utilization of multiple different MRI platforms in MS clinical trials.