Structure/function relationships of polyamidoamine/DNA dendrimers as gene delivery vehicles.

PAMAM dendrimers are members of a class of polyamine polymers that demonstrate significant gene delivery ability. In this study, a selection of PAMAM dendrimers, spanning a range of sizes (generations 2, 4, 7, and 9) and transfection efficiencies, are characterized by various biophysical methods to search for structural properties that correlate with transfection. Measurements of colloidal properties (size and zeta potential) as a function of charge ratio reveal that highly transfecting dendrimer/DNA complexes have size/zeta potential values between 4 and 8. Circular dichroism (CD) and FTIR spectroscopy of complexes confirm the DNA component remains in B form when associated with all dendrimer generations up to a 5:1 charge ratio (+/-). Isothermal titration calorimetry and differential scanning calorimetry detect changes that are related to polymer structure and charge ratio but do not directly correlate with transfection efficiency. Despite DNA structural and stability changes detected by CD, FTIR, DSC, and ITC that are similar to those seen with other cationic delivery vehicles [e.g., cationic lipids, peptoids/lipitoids, peptides, polyethyleneimines (PEIs), etc.], clear correlations with transfection activity are not readily apparent. This may be due, at least in part, to the heterogeneity of the complexes.

Thermodynamic analysis of binding and protonation in DOTAP/DOPE (1:1): DNA complexes using isothermal titration calorimetry.

A better understanding of the nature of the interaction between various cationic lipids used for gene delivery and DNA would lend insight into their structural and physical properties that may modulate their efficacy. We therefore separated the protonation and binding events which occur upon complexation of 1:1 DOTAP (1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium propane):DOPE (1,2-dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine) liposomes to DNA using proton linkage theory and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). The enthalpy of DOPE protonation was estimated as -45.0+/-0.7 kJ/mol and the intrinsic binding enthalpy of lipid to DNA as +2.8+/-0.3 kJ/mol. The pK(a) of DOPE was calculated to shift from 7.7+/-0.1 in the free state to 8.8+/-0.1 in the complex. At physiological ionic strength, proton linkage was not observed upon complex formation and the buffer-independent binding enthalpy was +1.0+/-0.4 kJ/mol. These studies indicate that the intrinsic interaction between 1:1 DOTAP/DOPE and DNA is an entropy-driven process and that the affinities of cationic lipids that are formulated with and without DOPE for DNA are controlled by the positive entropic changes that occur upon complex formation.

Compositional effects of cationic lipid/DNA delivery systems on transgene expression in cell culture.

Studies of the contribution of various physical properties of cationic lipid/DNA complexes (CLDCs) to their observed transgene expression in vitro were conducted using cationic liposomes composed of the cationic lipids 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium propane (DOTAP) and dimethyldioctadecylammonium bromide (DDAB), with or without equimolar amounts of cholesterol (CHOL) or 1,2-dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE). The relative degree of luciferase expression by CLDCs is dependent on a complex relationship between net charge of the CLDC as well as previously reported properties, such as membrane fluidity and curvature of the cationic bilayer. Assessments were made of the role of these physical properties on CLDC stability in the extracellular medium, the extent of DNA cellular association, and membrane disruption activity. The efficiency of luciferase expression from negatively charged CLDCs is greatly improved by incorporation of DOPE. This result correlates with enhanced resistance to inhibition of gene delivery by heparan sulfate, increased cellular association of DNA, and enhanced membrane disruption activity. Luciferase expression by positively charged CLDCs is greatly reduced by incorporating equimolar amounts of CHOL and DOPE. This result occurs is in spite of increased resistance to heparan sulfate-mediated inhibition of gene delivery, increased DNA cellular association, and enhanced membrane disruption activity. The observed CLDC compositional effects on luciferase expression along with observed effects on the delivery process suggest that a better understanding of the kinetics and specific routes of gene delivery is necessary.

Biophysical characterization of PEI/DNA complexes.

The main goal of this study was to determine the effects of polyethylenimine (PEI) molecular weight and structure (750 kDa, 25 kDa, 2 kDa branched, and 25 kDa linear PEI) and the nitrogen/phosphate (N/P) molar ratio on the physical properties and transfection efficiencies of PEI/DNA complexes. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy revealed that DNA remained in the B conformation when complexed to all PEIs. Unique alterations in the circular dichroism spectra of DNA were observed in the presence of each PEI, whereas differential scanning calorimetry measurements showed that all PEIs examined destabilized supercoiled DNA at N/P < 3/1, but not at higher ratios. Isothermal titration calorimetry revealed the existence of protonation changes at low ionic strength due to possible shifts in pK(a) of the ionizable groups of PEI during complex formation. Twenty-five kilodalton branched and 25 kDa linear PEI complexes showed the highest transfection efficiencies at an N/P ratio of 6:1 in COS-7 and CHO-K1 cells, respectively. These investigations have detected alterations in the physical and colloidal properties of the complexes that were sensitive to polymer structure, molecular weight, and polymer/DNA ratio, but these properties did not directly correlate with their transfection efficiencies. To further probe any possible relationship between these parameters and activity, a more refined biophysical analysis of any subpopulations in these samples that may differ in transfection activity is suggested, although the existence of such species remains unknown.

A fluorescence study of the structure and accessibility of plasmid DNA condensed with cationic gene delivery vehicles.

The cationic lipids 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium-propane and dimethyldioctadecylammonium bromide, with or without the helper lipids 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine or cholesterol, and the cationic polymer polyethyleneimine, were compared for their ability to displace fluorescent dyes from DNA. Differences in displacement of the intercalating dyes ethidium bromide and ethidium homodimer correlate with their relative affinities with DNA, with the extent of ethidium homodimer displacement significantly less. Differences in ethidium homodimer and ethidium bromide displacement as a function of the ratio of polycation to DNA and the charge density of the polycation suggest a greater sensitivity of the former to topological changes in condensed DNA. Marked differences in the ability of these cationic delivery systems to displace the minor groove binding dyes 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole and Hoechst 33258 upon interaction with DNA are also apparent, with the majority of Hoechst 33258 remaining bound to DNA. Changes in the spectral properties of Hoechst 33258 were further used to characterize polycation-induced changes in solvent accessibility of the DNA minor groove. Taken together, these studies demonstrate differences in the interaction of various cationic lipids and polyethyleneimine in terms of regional displacement of dyes, polycation-induced structural changes in DNA, as well as polycation-mediated changes in solvent accessibility of the minor groove. The relevance of these studies to current models of the structure and assembly of polycation/DNA complexes are discussed.

An infrared spectroscopic study of the effect of hydration on cationic lipid/DNA complexes.

Infrared spectroscopy was used to examine the effect of dehydration on the structure of DNA and cationic lipid/DNA complexes (CLDCs). Information regarding the effect of hydration on the interface between the cationic lipids and DNA was obtained by following subtle but reproducible changes in vibrational bands arising from the DNA bases and phosphate backbone as well as bands from the lipid ester groups within the interfacial region of the bilayer. Dehydration of supercoiled plasmid DNA induces a transition from a B-conformation in solution to a mixed conformation in the dried state. Changes in vibrations of the bases upon drying suggest a change to an A-conformation whereas vibrations from the phosphate moieties suggest A- or C-forms. Vibrational changes in the ribose ring suggest adoption of a C-conformation. When CLDCs composed of either DOTAP (1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium-propane) or DDAB (dioctadecyldimethylammonium bromide) cationic lipids with or without equimolar amounts of the helper lipids cholesterol or DOPE (1,2-dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamin) are dried, the DNA is still able to undergo these structural transitions suggesting a nonrigid CLDC structure. The effect of dehydration on these interfacial interactions was found to be dependent on the type of cationic lipid used as well as the type of helper lipid. In addition, this work provides a simple spectroscopic analytical approach that can be used for the characterization of nonviral vectors that has potential pharmaceutical utility.

A stopped-flow kinetic study of the assembly of nonviral gene delivery complexes.

Stopped-flow circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy are used to characterize the assembly of complexes consisting of plasmid DNA bound to the cationic lipids dimethyldioctadecylammonium bromide and 1, 2-dioleoyl- 3-trimethylammonium-propane and a series of polyamidoamine dendrimers. The kinetics of complexation determined from the stopped-flow circular dichroism measurements suggests complexation occurs within 50 ms. Further analysis, however, was precluded by the presence of mixing (shear) artifacts. Stopped-flow fluorescence employing the high-affinity DNA dyes Hoechst 33258 and YOYO-1 was able to resolve two sequential steps in the assembly of complexes that are assigned to binding/dehydration and condensation events. The rates of each process were determined over the temperature range of 10-50 degrees C and activation energies were determined from the slope of Arrhenius plots. The behavior of polyamidoamine dendrimers can be separated into two classes based on their differing binding modes: generation 2 and the larger generations (G4, G7, and G9). The larger generations have activation energies for binding that follow the trend G4 > G7 > G9. The activation energies for condensation (compaction) of complexes composed of these same dendrimers have the opposite trend G9 > G7 > G4. It is postulated that a balance between a more energetically favorable condensation and less favorable binding may prove beneficial in enhancing gene delivery.

The structural organization of cationic lipid-DNA complexes.

The interaction of cationic liposomes with supercoiled plasmid DNA results in a major rearrangement of each component to form compact multilamellar structures comprised of alternating layers of two-dimensional arrays of DNA sandwiched between lipid bilayers. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer was used to estimate the distance of closest approach of DNA to the lipid bilayers in these complexes. The effect of several compositional variables on this distance, including the ratio of cationic lipid to DNA, and the charge density, intrinsic curvature, and fluidity of the lipid bilayer were examined. Additionally, the effect of ionic strength was studied. For complexes prepared at or above a 3:1 charge ratio (+/-), the observed distance of closest approach was found to be in agreement with the intercalation of DNA between lipid bilayers. As the charge ratio was decreased, a monotonic increase in the distance was observed with a maximum observed at 0.5:1. Correlations between differences in the proximity of DNA to the lipid bilayer and the hydrodynamic size of the complexes were also found. A model based on these observations and previous reports suggests the formation of discrete populations of complexes below a charge ratio of 0.5:1 and above 3:1. The structure of the negatively charged complexes is consistent with DNA extending from the surface of the particles, whereas those possessing excess positive charge were multilamellar aggregates with the DNA effectively condensed between lipid bilayers. Complexes between these two states consist of weighted fractions of these two species.