Use of whole-genome sequence data and novel genomic selection strategies to improve selection for age at puberty in tropically-adapted beef heifers.

BACKGROUND: In tropically-adapted beef heifers, application of genomic prediction for age at puberty has been limited due to low prediction accuracies. Our aim was to investigate novel methods of pre-selecting whole-genome sequence (WGS) variants and alternative analysis methodologies; including genomic best linear unbiased prediction (GBLUP) with multiple genomic relationship matrices (MGRM) and Bayesian (BayesR) analyses, to determine if prediction accuracy for age at puberty can be improved. METHODS: Genotypes and phenotypes were obtained from two research herds. In total, 868 Brahman and 960 Tropical Composite heifers were recorded in the first population and 3695 Brahman, Santa Gertrudis and Droughtmaster heifers were recorded in the second population. Genotypes were imputed to 23 million whole-genome sequence variants. Eight strategies were used to pre-select variants from genome-wide association study (GWAS) results using conditional or joint (COJO) analyses. Pre-selected variants were included in three models, GBLUP with a single genomic relationship matrix (SGRM), GBLUP MGRM and BayesR. Five-way cross-validation was used to test the effect of marker panel density (6 K, 50 K and 800 K), analysis model, and inclusion of pre-selected WGS variants on prediction accuracy. RESULTS: In all tested scenarios, prediction accuracies for age at puberty were highest in BayesR analyses. The addition of pre-selected WGS variants had little effect on the accuracy of prediction when BayesR was used. The inclusion of WGS variants that were pre-selected using a meta-analysis with COJO analyses by chromosome, fitted in a MGRM model, had the highest prediction accuracies in the GBLUP analyses, regardless of marker density. When the low-density (6 K) panel was used, the prediction accuracy of GBLUP was equal (0.42) to that with the high-density panel when only six additional sequence variants (identified using meta-analysis COJO by chromosome) were included. CONCLUSIONS: While BayesR consistently outperforms other methods in terms of prediction accuracies, reasonable improvements in accuracy can be achieved when using GBLUP and low-density panels with the inclusion of a relatively small number of highly relevant WGS variants.

Multivariate genomic predictions for age at puberty in tropically adapted beef heifers.

Heifers that have an earlier age at puberty often have greater lifetime productivity. Age at puberty is moderately heritable so selection should effectively reduce the number of days to puberty, and improve heifer productivity and profitability as a result. However, recording age at puberty is intensive, requiring repeat ovarian scanning to determine age at first corpus luteum (AGECL). Genomic selection has been proposed as a strategy to select for earlier age at puberty; however, large reference populations of cows with AGECL records and genotypes would be required to generate accurate GEBV for this trait. Reproductive maturity score (RMS) is a proxy trait for age at puberty for implementation in northern Australia beef herds, where large scale recording of AGECL is not feasible. RMS assigns a score of 0 to 5 from a single ovarian scan to describe ovarian maturity at ~600 d. Here we use multivariate genomic prediction to evaluate the value of a large RMS data set to improve accuracy of GEBV for age at puberty (AGECL). There were 882 Brahman and 990 Tropical Composite heifers with AGECL phenotypes, and an independent set of 974 Brahman, 1,798 Santa Gertrudis, and 910 Droughtmaster heifers with RMS phenotypes. All animals had 728,785 real or imputed SNP genotypes. The correlation of AGECL and RMS (h2 = 0.23) was estimated as -0.83 using the genomic information. This result also demonstrates that using genomic information it is possible to estimate genetic correlations between traits collected on different animals in different herds, with minimal or unknown pedigree linkage between them. Inclusion of heifers with RMS in the multi-trait model improved the accuracy of genomic evaluations for AGECL. Accuracy of RMS GEBV generally did not improve by adding heifers with AGECL phenotypes into the reference population. These results suggest that RMS and AGECL may be used together in a multi-trait prediction model to increase the accuracy of prediction for age at puberty in tropically adapted beef cattle.

Towards multi-breed genomic evaluations for female fertility of tropical beef cattle.

Developing accurate genomic evaluations of fertility for tropical beef cattle must deal with at least two major challenges (i) recording cow fertility traits in extensive production systems on large numbers of cows and (ii) the genomic evaluations should work across the breeds, crossbreds, and composites used in tropical beef production. Here, we assess accuracy of genomic evaluations for a trait which can be collected on a large scale in extensive conditions, corpus luteum score (CLscore), which is 1 if ovarian scanning indicates a heifer has cycled by 600 d and 0 if not, in a multi-breed population. A total of 3,696 heifers, including 979 Brahmans, 914 Droughtmasters, and 1,803 Santa Gertrudis in seven herds across 3-yr cohorts with CLscores, were genotyped for 24,211 SNPs. Genotypes were imputed to 728,785 SNPs. GBLUP and BayesR were used to predict GEBV. Accuracy of GEBV was evaluated with two validation strategies. In the first strategy, the last year cohort of heifers from each herd was used for validation, such that every herd had heifers in both reference and validation populations. In the second validation strategy, each herd in turn was removed in its entirety from the reference population, and was used for validation. For both validation strategies, accuracy of GEBV for single breed and multi-breed reference populations was assessed. For the first validation strategy, accuracy of GEBV ranged from 0.2 for Brahmans to 0.4 for Droughtmasters. Increasing marker density from 24K SNPs to 728K SNPs resulted in a small increase in accuracy, and including multiple-breeds in the reference did not help improve accuracy. These results suggest that provided a herd has animals in the reference population, the accuracy of the GEBV is largely determined by within herd (linkage) information. The situation was very different when entire herds were predicted in the second validation. In this case accuracy of GEBV using only 24K SNPs and only a within breed reference was close to zero for all breeds. Accuracy increased substantially when 728K SNPs, BayesR, and a multi-breed reference were used, from 0.15 for Brahmans to 0.35 for Santa Gertrudis. Given the second validation strategy is more likely to reflect the situation for many herds in tropical beef production (no animals in the reference), genomic evaluations for fertility in tropical beef cattle should be based on high-density markers (728K SNPs) and should be multi-breed.

Ultrasonographic measurements in first trimester concepti identify predictors of birth weight and postnatal development in cattle.

The placenta is a major driver of prenatal growth and involved in programming of postnatal performance. We therefore determined placental and embryo-fetal ultrasonographic parameters in early pregnancy and their relationships with birth weight and postnatal weights in a Bos indicus-Bos taurus composite beef cattle population. Pregnancies were generated in 2-yr-old Droughtmaster heifers by artificial insemination after estrus synchronization in 2 consecutive years (2009, n = 36 and 2010, n = 57), with a subset of 2010 heifers used again as lactating 3-yr-old cows in 2011 (n = 24). Each cohort was managed as 1 contemporary group for measurements of Corpus luteum diameter, amnion length and width, placentome width and thickness, and embryo-fetal crown-rump length, at 7 and 8 wk of gestation. This was followed by recordings of birth weight, branding weight at 5 to 6 mo of age and weaning weight 2 mo later. At a significance threshold of P < 0.05, placentome thickness at week 7 was negatively correlated with weights at birth (r = -0.23), branding (r = -0.25), and weaning (r = -0.35), whereas placentome width at week 7 (r = 0.24) and thickness at week 8 (r = 0.29) were positively correlated with birth weight. Thicker placentomes in males at week 7 (7%) difference mirrored sex differences in weights at birth (7%), branding (10%), and weaning (6%). The sex difference trend for birth weight was not consistent across sire-year combinations, ranging from -3.2 to +4.7 kg (birth weight of males - females per sire). These results support the hypothesis that placental parameters at the transition from embryo to fetal stage are major predictors of fetal and postnatal growth, albeit with significant environmentally induced plasticity, in stabilized B. indicus-B. taurus composite populations, and suggest that elements of B. indicus-B. taurus reciprocal differences in birth weight persist in composite populations.