The low molecular weight DNA diffusion assay as an indicator of cytotoxicity for the in vitro comet assay.

The low molecular weight DNA diffusion assay (LMW assay) has been recommended as a measure for cytotoxicity for the in vivo comet assay. To better understand the relationship between effects in the LMW assay, DNA migration in the comet assay and effects in established cytotoxicity tests, we performed in vitro experiments with cultured human cell lines (TK6, A549) and comparatively investigated five test substances (methyl methanesulfonate, (±)-benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxide, sodium dodecyl sulphate, menthol and sodium arsenite). We measured DNA migration (tail intensity) in the comet assay and the frequency of 'hedgehogs' (cells with almost all DNA in the tail), DNA diffusion in the LMW assay, cell viability (trypan blue and fluorescein diacetate/ethidium bromide staining) and inhibition of proliferation (relative cell counts). Our in vitro experiments indicate that effects in the LMW assay occur independently from DNA effects in the comet assay and are not related to the occurrence of hedgehogs. Results from the LMW assay are in good agreement with results from viability assays and seem to allow discriminating genotoxic from non-genotoxic substances when appropriate preparation times are considered. Measurements of cytotoxicity by these methods only at an early preparation time after exposure to genotoxic substances may lead to erroneous results.

Investigations on potential co-mutagenic effects of formaldehyde.

The genotoxicity and mutagenicity of formaldehyde (FA) has been well-characterized during the last years. Besides its known direct DNA-damaging and mutagenic activity in sufficiently exposed cells, FA at low concentrations might also enhance the mutagenic and carcinogenic effects of other environmental mutagens by interfering with the repair of DNA lesions induced by these mutagens. To further assess potential co-mutagenic effects of FA, we exposed A549 human lung cells to FA in combination with various mutagens and measured the induction and removal of DNA damage by the comet assay and the production of chromosomal mutations by the cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay (CBMN assay). The mutagens tested were ionizing radiation (IR), (±)-anti-B[a]P-7,8-dihydrodiol-9,10-epoxide (BPDE), N-nitroso-N-methylurea (methyl nitrosourea; MNU) and methyl methanesulfonate (MMS). FA (10-75µM) did not enhance the genotoxic and mutagenic activity of these mutagens under the test conditions applied. FA alone and in combination with MNU or MMS did not affect the expression (mRNA level) of the gene of the O(6)-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT) in A549 cells. The results of these experiments do not support the assumption that low FA concentrations might interfere with the repair of DNA damage induced by other mutagens.

Insensitivity of the in vitro cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay with human lymphocytes for the detection of DNA damage present at the start of the cell culture.

The cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay (CBMN assay) with cultured human lymphocytes is a well-established assay in genotoxicity testing and human biomonitoring. For both approaches, human lymphocytes are stimulated by phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) and cultured for about 72 h; 44 h after PHA stimulation, cytochalasin B (CytB) is added and micronuclei (MN) are scored in binucleated cells. The main difference between these two applications is the way lymphocytes are exposed to mutagens. In order to maximise the probability of detecting a mutagen, the OECD guideline 487 recommends starting the exposure to the test substance at 44-48 h after PHA stimulation. In human biomonitoring, blood samples are taken from subjects exposed to environmental mutagens in vivo and lymphocytes with induced DNA damage at the start of the cell culture are investigated with regard to potentially increased MN frequencies in binuclear lymphocytes. We compared the sensitivity of these two protocols by either treating lymphocyte cultures for 2h with known DNA-damaging mutagens at the start of the culture or 42 h after PHA stimulation. The mutagens used were methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), N-nitroso-N-ethylurea (ethyl nitrosourea; ENU), styrene oxide (SO), (±)-anti-B[a]P-7,8-dihydrodiol-9,10-epoxide (BPDE) and mitomycin C (MMC). All substances induced MN under the conditions of the standard in vitro CBMN assay but only MMC clearly induced MN in lymphocytes exposed at the start of the culture. All mutagens (except MMC, a known crosslinker) were tested by the comet assay with blood cultures exposed at the start of the culture and clearly induced DNA migration. The nuclear division index (NDI) indicated that damaged lymphocytes proliferated well in these experiments. The lack of increased MN frequencies despite increased damage levels and good proliferation suggests that the CBMN assay is rather insensitive for the detection of mutagens/clastogens when damage is induced at the start of the blood cultures. Potential consequences for the interpretation of human biomonitoring studies are discussed in this article.

Re-evaluation of a reported increased micronucleus frequency in lymphocytes of workers occupationally exposed to formaldehyde.

A replicate evaluation of increased micronucleus (MN) frequencies in peripheral lymphocytes of workers occupationally exposed to formaldehyde (FA) was undertaken to verify the observed effect and to determine scoring variability. May-Grünwald-Giemsa-stained slides were obtained from a previously performed cytokinesis-block micronucleus test (CBMNT) with 56 workers in anatomy and pathology laboratories and 85 controls. The first evaluation by one scorer (scorer 1) had led to a highly significant difference between workers and controls (3.96 vs 0.81 MN per 1000 cells). The slides were coded before re-evaluation and the code was broken after the complete re-evaluation of the study. A total of 1000 binucleated cells (BNC) were analysed per subject and the frequency of MN (in ‰) was determined. Slides were distributed equally and randomly between two scorers, so that the scorers had no knowledge of the exposure status. Scorer 2 (32 exposed, 36 controls) measured increased MN frequencies in exposed workers (9.88 vs 6.81). Statistical analysis with the two-sample Wilcoxon test indicated that this difference was not significant (p=0.17). Scorer 3 (20 exposed, 46 controls) obtained a similar result, but slightly higher values for the comparison of exposed and controls (19.0 vs 12.89; p=0.089). Combining the results of the two scorers (13.38 vs 10.22), a significant difference between exposed and controls (p=0.028) was obtained when the stratified Wilcoxon test with the scorers as strata was applied. Interestingly, the re-evaluation of the slides led to clearly higher MN frequencies for exposed and controls compared with the first evaluation. Bland-Altman plots indicated that the agreement between the measurements of the different scorers was very poor, as shown by mean differences of 5.9 between scorer 1 and scorer 2 and 13.0 between scorer 1 and scorer 3. Calculation of the intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) revealed that all scorer comparisons in this study were far from acceptable for the reliability of this assay. Possible implications for the use of the CBMNT in human biomonitoring studies are discussed.

Investigations of potential susceptibility toward formaldehyde-induced genotoxicity.

Blood samples were taken from three groups of volunteers (30 male smokers, 30 female non-smokers, and 30 school children) and tested for ex vivo susceptibility toward formaldehyde (FA)-induced genotoxicity. Blood samples were exposed to 150 µM FA for 2 h, and the induction of DNA-protein crosslinks (DPX) in leukocytes was measured by a modification of the alkaline comet assay (i.e., reduction of γ-irradiation induced DNA migration). Removal of DPX was determined by the abolition of FA-induced reduction in DNA migration within 4 h after the end of the exposure. Induction and persistence of FA-induced DNA lesions was also measured by the sister chromatid exchange (SCE) test with cultured lymphocytes after treatment of whole blood cultures with FA (150 µM). Furthermore, the expression (mRNA level) of the GSH-dependent formaldehyde dehydrogenase (FDH, identical to alcohol dehydrogenase 5; ADH5) was measured in leukocytes by quantitative real-time RT-PCR with TaqMan probes. The subjects were also analyzed for the GSTM1 and GSTT1 metabolic gene polymorphisms and a correlation analysis with the investigated genetic endpoints for FA-induced genotoxicity was performed. The results indicate that there are no biologically relevant differences between the three study groups with regard to the various indicators of cellular sensitivity toward FA-induced genotoxic effects and the expression of FDH. The induced genotoxic effects were not associated with polymorphisms in GSTM1 and GSTT1. None of the study groups showed particular mutagen sensitivity toward FA-induced genotoxicity. These results suggest that a low scaling factor to address possible human inter-individual differences in FA-induced genotoxicity could be reasonable.

Does formaldehyde induce aneuploidy?

Formaldehyde (FA) was tested for a potential aneugenic activity in mammalian cells. We employed tests to discriminate between aneugenic and clastogenic effects in accordance with international guidelines for genotoxicity testing. The cytokinesis-block micronucleus test (CBMNT) in combination with fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) with a pan-centromeric probe was performed with cultured human lymphocytes and the human A549 lung cell line. FA induced micronuclei (MN) in binuclear cells of both cell types under standard in vitro test conditions following the OECD guideline 487. FISH analysis revealed that the vast majority of induced MN were centromere negative, thus indicating a clastogenic effect. A similar result was obtained for MN induced by γ-irradiation, whereas the typical aneugens colcemid (COL) and vincristine (VCR) predominantly induced centromere-positive MN. Furthermore, COL and VCR clearly enhanced the MN frequency in mononuclear lymphocytes in the CBMNT, whereas such an effect was not observed for γ-irradiation and FA. In experiments with the Chinese hamster V79 cell line, the aneugens COL and VCR clearly increased the frequency of tetraploid second division metaphases, whereas FA did not cause such an effect. Altogether, our results confirm the clastogenicity of FA in cultured mammalian cells but exclude a significant aneugenic activity.