Conformational Dynamics of Lipoxygenases and Their Interaction with Biological Membranes.

Lipoxygenases (LOXs) are a family of enzymes that includes different fatty acid oxygenases with a common tridimensional structure. The main functions of LOXs are the production of signaling compounds and the structural modifications of biological membranes. These features of LOXs, their widespread presence in all living organisms, and their involvement in human diseases have attracted the attention of the scientific community over the last decades, leading to several studies mainly focused on understanding their catalytic mechanism and designing effective inhibitors. The aim of this review is to discuss the state-of-the-art of a different, much less explored aspect of LOXs, that is, their interaction with lipid bilayers. To this end, the general architecture of six relevant LOXs (namely human 5-, 12-, and 15-LOX, rabbit 12/15-LOX, coral 8-LOX, and soybean 15-LOX), with different specificity towards the fatty acid substrates, is analyzed through the available crystallographic models. Then, their putative interface with a model membrane is examined in the frame of the conformational flexibility of LOXs, that is due to their peculiar tertiary structure. Finally, the possible future developments that emerge from the available data are discussed.

The Odd Faces of Oligomers: The Case of TRAF2-C, A Trimeric C-Terminal Domain of TNF Receptor-Associated Factor.

TNF Receptor Associated Factor 2 (TRAF2) is a trimeric protein that belongs to the TNF receptor associated factor family (TRAFs). The TRAF2 oligomeric state is crucial for receptor binding and for its interaction with other proteins involved in the TNFR signaling. The monomer-trimer equilibrium of a C- terminal domain truncated form of TRAF2 (TRAF2-C), plays also a relevant role in binding the membrane, causing inward vesiculation. In this study, we have investigated the conformational dynamics of TRAF2-C through circular dichroism, fluorescence, and dynamic light scattering, performing temperature-dependent measurements. The data indicate that the protein retains its oligomeric state and most of its secondary structure, while displaying a significative increase in the heterogeneity of the tyrosines signal, increasing the temperature from ≈15 to ≈35 °C. The peculiar crowding of tyrosine residues (12 out of 18) at the three subunit interfaces and the strong dependence on the trimer concentration indicate that such conformational changes mainly involve the contact areas between each pair of monomers, affecting the oligomeric state. Molecular dynamic simulations in this temperature range suggest that the interfaces heterogeneity is an intrinsic property of the trimer that arises from the continuous, asymmetric approaching and distancing of its subunits. Such dynamics affect the results of molecular docking on the external protein surface using receptor peptides, indicating that the TRAF2-receptor interaction in the solution might not involve three subunits at the same time, as suggested by the static analysis obtainable from the crystal structure. These findings shed new light on the role that the TRAF2 oligomeric state might have in regulating the protein binding activity in vivo.

The Puzzling Problem of Cardiolipin Membrane-Cytochrome c Interactions: A Combined Infrared and Fluorescence Study.

The interaction of cytochrome c (cyt c) with natural and synthetic membranes is known to be a complex phenomenon, involving both protein and lipid conformational changes. In this paper, we combined infrared and fluorescence spectroscopy to study the structural transformation occurring to the lipid network of cardiolipin-containing large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs). The data, collected at increasing protein/lipid ratio, demonstrate the existence of a multi-phase process, which is characterized by: (i) the interaction of cyt c with the lipid polar heads; (ii) the lipid anchorage of the protein on the membrane surface; and (iii) a long-distance order/disorder transition of the cardiolipin acyl chains. Such effects have been quantitatively interpreted introducing specific order parameters and discussed in the frame of the models on cyt c activity reported in literature.

Studying the TRAF2 binding to model membranes: The role of subunits dissociation.

The ability of a C-terminal truncated form of TRAF2 to bind synthetic vesicles has been quantitatively studied by steady-state fluorescence energy transfer from the protein to large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) prepared with different lipid mixtures. The dissociation constants, the free energy of binding, and the average number of phospholipids interacting with truncated TRAF2 have been evaluated from the corresponding binding curves. The results indicate that the protein strongly interacts with the lipid bilayer, preferentially in the monomeric state. These findings have been discussed in terms of their possible role in the activity of TRAF2 in vivo.

New insight into the interaction of TRAF2 C-terminal domain with lipid raft microdomains.

In this study we provide the first evidence of the interaction of a truncated-TRAF2 with lipid raft microdomains. We have analyzed this interaction by measuring the diffusion coefficient of the protein in large and giant unilamellar vesicles (LUVs and GUVs, respectively) obtained both from synthetic lipid mixtures and from natural extracts. Steady-state fluorescence measurements performed with synthetic vesicles indicate that this truncated form of TRAF2 displays a tighter binding to raft-like LUVs with respect to the control (POPC-containing LUVs), and that this process depends on the protein oligomeric state. Generalized Polarization measurements and spectral phasor analysis revealed that truncated-TRAF2 affects the membrane fluidity, especially when vesicles are heated up at physiological temperature. The addition of nanomolar concentration of TRAF2 in GUVs also seems to exert a mechanical action, as demonstrated by the formation of intraluminal vesicles, a process in which ganglioside GM1 plays a crucial role.

TNFR-Associated Factor-2 (TRAF2): Not Only a Trimer.

TNF receptor-associated factors (TRAFs) are characterized by an oligomeric structure that plays a fundamental role in the binding process with membrane receptors. In this work, we studied the trimer-to-monomer (T ↔ 3M) equilibrium transition of the TRAF2 C-terminal domain using both chemical (dilution/guanidinium hydrochloride) and mechanical stress (high pressure) to induce the dissociation of the native protein into subunits. The experimental results and computer simulations indicate that stable monomers exist and that their population accounts for 15% of the total TRAF2 molecules already at a physiological intracellular concentration (≈1 µM), being instead the predominant species in the nanomolar concentration range. Because the total amount of TRAF2 changes during a cell cycle, the monomer-trimer equilibrium can be crucial for regulating the activities of TRAF2 in vivo.

Probing conformational changes in lipoxygenases upon membrane binding: fine-tuning by the active site inhibitor ETYA.

Lipoxygenases (LOXs) are lipid-peroxidizing enzymes that are involved in the metabolism of polyunsaturated fatty acids. Their biological activity includes a membrane binding process whose molecular details are not completely understood. The mechanism of enzyme-membrane interactions is thought to involve conformational changes at the level of the protein tertiary structure, and the extent of such alterations depends on the degree of structural flexibility of the different LOX isoforms. In this study, we have tested the resilience properties of a plant and a mammalian LOX, by using high pressure fluorescence measurements at different temperatures. The binding of LOXs to the lipid bilayer has been characterized using both large and giant unilamellar vesicles and electron transfer particles (inner mitochondrial membranes) as model membranes. The data indicate that the degree of LOXs' flexibility is strictly dependent on the two distinct N- and C-terminal domains that characterize the 3D structure of these enzymes. Furthermore, they demonstrate that increasing the rigidity of protein scaffolding by the presence of an active site ligand impairs the membrane binding ability of LOXs. These findings provide evidence that the amphitropic nature of LOXs is finely tuned by the interaction of the substrate with the residues of the active site, suggesting new strategies for the design of enzyme inhibitors.

Role of Arg403 for thermostability and catalytic activity of rabbit 12/15-lipoxygenase.

12/15-Lipoxygenases (12/15-LOX) have been implicated in inflammatory and hyperproliferative diseases but the numerous aspects of structural biology of these enzymes are far from clear. Early mutagenesis data and structural modeling of enzyme-substrate complexes suggested that Arg403, which is localized at the entrance of the putative substrate binding pocket, might interact with the fatty acid carboxylic group. On the other hand, side-chain of Arg403 is a part of an ionic network with the residues of α2-helix, which undergoes pronounced conformation changes upon inhibitor binding. To explore the role of Arg403 for catalysis in more detail we exchanged positively charged Arg403 to neutral Leu and quantified structural and functional consequences of the alteration at the site of mutation using fluorometric techniques. We found that a loss of electrostatic interaction between Arg403 and negatively charged amino acid residues of α2-helix has only minor impact on protein folding, but partially destabilized the tertiary structure of the enzyme. We hypothesize that interaction of Arg403 with the substrate's carboxylate might be involved in a complex mechanism triggering conformational changes of the α2-helix, which are required for formation of the catalytically competent dimer r12/15-LOX complex at pre-catalytic stages.

Modules identification in protein structures: the topological and geometrical solutions.

The identification of modules in protein structures has major relevance in structural biology, with consequences in protein stability and functional classification, adding new perspectives in drug design. In this work, we present the comparison between a topological (spectral clustering) and a geometrical (k-means) approach to module identification, in the frame of a multiscale analysis of the protein architecture principles. The global consistency of an adjacency matrix based technique (spectral clustering) and a method based on full rank geometrical information (k-means) give a proof-of-concept of the relevance of protein contact networks in structure determination. The peculiar "small-world" character of protein contact graphs is established as well, pointing to average shortest path as a mesoscopic crucial variable to maximize the efficiency of within-molecule signal transmission. The specific nature of protein architecture indicates topological approach as the most proper one to highlight protein functional domains, and two new representations linking sequence and topological role of aminoacids are demonstrated to be of use for protein structural analysis. Here we present a case study regarding azurin, a small copper protein implied in the Pseudomonas aeruginosa respiratory chain. Its pocket molecular shape and its electron transfer function have challenged the method, highlighting its potentiality to catch jointly the structure and function features of protein structures through their decomposition into modules.

Human cytochrome C natural variants: Studying the membrane binding properties of G41S and Y48H by fluorescence energy transfer and molecular dynamics.

Cytochrome C (cyt C), the protein involved in oxidative phosphorylation, plays several other crucial roles necessary for both cell life and death. Studying natural variants of cyt C offers the possibility to better characterize the structure-to-function relationship that modulates the different activities of this protein. Naturally mutations in human cyt C (G41S and Y48H) occur in the protein central Ω-loop and cause thrombocytopenia 4. In this study, we have investigated the binding of such variants and of wild type (wt) cyt C to synthetic cardiolipin-containing vesicles. The mutants have a lower propensity in membrane binding, displaying higher dissociation constants with respect to the wt protein. Compressibility measurements reveal that both variants are more flexible than the wt, suggesting that the native central Ω-loop is important for the interaction with membranes. Such hypothesis is supported by molecular dynamics simulations. A minimal distance analysis indicates that in the presence of cardiolipin the central Ω-loop of the mutants is no more in contact with the membrane, as it happens instead in the case of wt cyt C. Such finding might provide a hint for the reduced membrane binding capacity of the variants and their enhanced peroxidase activity in vivo.

Rat and human fatty acid amide hydrolases: overt similarities and hidden differences.

Fatty acid amide hydrolase (FAAH) is a membrane protein that plays a relevant role in the metabolism of fatty acid amides and esters. It degrades important neurotransmitters such as oleamide and anandamide, and it has been involved in a number of human pathological conditions, representing therefore a valuable target for biochemical and pharmacological research. In this study, we have investigated in vitro the structure-function relationship of rat and human FAAHs. In particular circular dichroism, fluorescence spectroscopy and light scattering measurements have been performed, in order to characterize the structural features of the two proteins, both in the presence and absence of the irreversible inhibitor methoxyarachidonyl-fluorophosphonate. The results demonstrate that the structural dynamics of the two FAAHs are different, despite their high sequence homology and overall similarity in temperature-dependence. Additionally, membrane binding and kinetic assays of both FAAHs indicate that also the functional properties of the two enzymes are different in their interaction with lipid bilayers and with exogenous inhibitors. These findings suggest that pre-clinical studies of FAAH-dependent human diseases based only on animal models should be interpreted with caution, and that the efficacy of new drugs targeted to FAAH should be tested in vitro, on both rat and human enzymes.

Head or tail? A molecular dynamics approach to the complex structure of TNF-associated factor TRAF2.

Tumor necrosis factor receptor-associated factor proteins (TRAFs) are trimeric proteins that play a fundamental role in signaling, acting as intermediaries between the tumor necrosis factor (TNF) receptors and the proteins that transmit the downstream signal. The monomeric subunits of all the TRAF family members share a common tridimensional structure: a C-terminal globular domain and a long coiled-coil tail characterizing the N-terminal section. In this study, the dependence of the TRAF2 dynamics on the length of its tail was analyzed in silico. In particular, we used the available crystallographic structure of a C-terminal fragment of TRAF2 (168 out of 501 a.a.), TRAF2-C, and that of a longer construct, addressed as TRAF2-plus, that we have re-constructed using the AlphaFold2 code. The results indicate that the longer N-terminal tail of TRAF2-plus has a strong influence on the dynamics of the globular regions in the protein C-terminal head. In fact, the quaternary interactions among the TRAF2-C subunits change asymmetrically in time, while the movements of TRAF2-plus monomers are rather limited and more ordered than those of the shorter construct. Such findings shed a new light on the dynamics of TRAF subunits and on the protein mechanism in vivo, since TRAF monomer-trimer equilibrium is crucial for several reasons (receptor recognition, membrane binding, hetero-oligomerization).

Tight association of N-terminal and catalytic subunits of rabbit 12/15-lipoxygenase is important for protein stability and catalytic activity.

12/15-Lipoxygenases (12/15-LOXs) have been implicated in inflammatory and hyperproliferative diseases but the structural biology of these enzymes is not well developed. Most LOXs constitute single polypeptide chain proteins that fold into a two-domain structure. In the crystal structure the two domains are tightly associated, but small angle X-ray scattering data and dynamic fluorescence studies suggested a high degree of structural flexibility involving movement of the N-terminal domain relative to catalytic subunit. When we inspected the interdomain interface we have found a limited number of side-chain contacts which are involved in interactions of these two structural subunits. One of such contact points involves tyrosine 98 of N-terminal domain. This aromatic amino acid is invariant in vertebrate LOXs regardless of overall sequence identity. To explore in more detail the role of aromatic interactions in interdomain association we have mutated Y98 to various residues and quantified the structural and functional consequences of these alterations. We have found that loss of an aromatic moiety at position 98 impaired the catalytic activity and membrane binding capacity of the mutant enzymes. Although CD and fluorescence emission spectra of wild-type and mutant enzyme species were indistinguishable, the mutation led to enlargement of the molecular shape of the enzyme as detected by analytic gel filtration and this structural alteration was shown to be associated with a loss of protein thermal stability. The possible role of tight interdomain association for the enzyme's structural performance is discussed.

Ligand-induced formation of transient dimers of mammalian 12/15-lipoxygenase: a key to allosteric behavior of this class of enzymes?

Mammalian lipoxygenases (LOXs) have been implicated in cellular defense response and are important for physiological homeostasis. Since their discovery, LOXs have been believed to function as monomeric enzymes that exhibit allosteric properties. In aqueous solutions, the rabbit 12/15-LOX is mainly present as hydrated monomer but changes in the local physiochemical environment suggested a monomer-dimer equilibrium. Because the allosteric character of the enzyme can hardly be explained using a single ligand binding-site model, we proposed that the binding of allosteric effectors may shift the monomer-dimer equilibrium toward dimer formation. To test this hypothesis, we explored the impact of an allosteric effector [13(S)-hydroxyoctadeca-9(Z),11(E)-dienoic acid] on the structural properties of rabbit 12/15-LOX by small-angle X-ray scattering. Our data indicate that the enzyme undergoes ligand-induced dimerization in aqueous solution, and molecular dynamics simulations suggested that LOX dimers may be stable in the presence of substrate fatty acids. These data provide direct structural evidence for the existence of LOX dimers, where two noncovalently linked enzyme molecules might work in unison and, therefore, such mode of association might be related to the allosteric character of 12/15-LOX. Introduction of negatively charged residues (W181E + H585E and L183E + L192E) at the intermonomer interface disturbs the hydrophobic dimer interaction of the wild-type LOX, and this structural alteration may lead to functional distortion of mutant enzymes.

Conversion of cytochrome c into a peroxidase: inhibitory mechanisms and implication for neurodegenerative diseases.

A further function of cytochrome c (cyt c), beyond respiration, is realized outside mitochondria in the apoptotic program. In the early events of apoptosis, the interaction of cyt c with a mitochondrion-specific phospholipid, cardiolipin (CL), brings about a conformational transition of the protein and acquirement of peroxidase activity. The hallmark of cyt c with peroxidase activity is its partial unfolding accompanied by loosening of the Fe sixth axial bond and an enhanced access of the heme catalytic site to small molecules like H2O2. To investigate the peroxidase activity of non-native cyt c, different forms of the protein were analyzed with the aim to correlate their structural features with the acquired enzymatic activity and apoptogenic properties (wt cyt c/CL complex and two single cyt c variants, H26Y and Y67H, free and bound to CL). The results suggest that cyt c may respond to different environments by changing its fold thus favouring the exertion of different biological functions in different pathophysiological cell conditions. Transitions among different conformations are regulated by endogenous molecules such as ATP and may be affected by synthetic molecules such as minocycline, thus suggesting a mechanism explaining its use as therapeutic agent impacting on disease-associated oxidative and apoptotic mechanisms.

A novel role for iron in modulating the activity and membrane-binding ability of a trimmed soybean lipoxygenase-1.

Lipoxygenases (LOXs) are iron-containing enzymes that play critical roles in plants and animals. As yet, metal atom extraction, reconstitution, and substitution have not been successfully applied to soybean LOX-1 [Glycine max (L.) Merrill], a prototype member of the LOX family that is widely used in structural and kinetic studies. Here, tryptic digestion of native LOX-1, used as a control, allowed us to isolate the 60-kDa C-terminal region (termed miniLOX), that retains the catalytically active iron in a more accessible position. Then, iron was removed to obtain an unprecedented apo-miniLOX, which was reconstituted and substituted with different metal ions. These forms of miniLOX were characterized vs. native LOX-1 by kinetic analysis, near UV circular dichroism, steady-state fluorescence, and fluorescence resonance energy transfer. MiniLOX showed a 2-fold increase in the membrane-binding affinity compared with native LOX-1 and a remarkable 4-fold increase compared with apo-miniLOX (K(d)=9.2+/-1.0, 17.9+/-2.0, and 45.4+/-4.3 microM, respectively). Furthermore, miniLOX reconstituted with Fe(II) or Fe(III) partially recovered its membrane-binding ability (K(d)=21.4+/-2.4 and 18.9+/-5.5 microM, respectively), overall supporting a novel noncatalytic role for iron in the LOX family.

Allostery: The Rebound of Proteins.

The discovery of hemoglobin allosteric properties is briefly summarized and contextualized in the frame of the main biochemical revelations that characterized the first half of the XX century. In particular, the historical background of DNA, RNA, and protein structure research is recalled and the new role that protein-protein interaction may have on allosteric regulation is discussed.

Disclosing Allostery Through Protein Contact Networks.

Proteins are located in the twilight zone between chemistry and biology, where a peculiar kind of complexity starts. Proteins are the smallest 'devices' showing a sensible adaptation to their environment by the production of appropriate behavior when facing a specific stimulus. This fact qualifies (from the 'effector' side) proteins as nanomachines working as catalysts, motors, or switches. However (from the sensor side), the need to single out the 'specific stimulus' out of thermal noise qualifies proteins as information processing devices. Allostery corresponds to the modification of the configuration (in a broad sense) of the protein molecule in response to a specific stimulus in a non-strictly local way, thereby connecting the sensor and effector sides of the nanomachine. This is why the 'disclosing' of allostery phenomenon is at the very heart of protein function; in this chapter, we will demonstrate how a network-based representation of protein structure in terms of nodes (aminoacid residues) and edges (effective contacts between residues) is the natural language for getting rid of allosteric phenomena and, more in general, of protein structure/function relationships.

Protein Assembly: Defining the Strength of Protein-Protein Interactions Coupling the Theory with Experiments.

In this paper we report a procedure to analyze protein homodimer interfaces.We approached the problem by means of a topological methodology. In particular, we analyzed the subunits interface of about 50 homodimers and we have defined a few parameters that allow to organize these proteins in six different classes. The main characteristics of each class of homodimers have been discussed also taking into account their stabilization energy, as reported in the literature from the experimental measurements. A paradigmatic example for each class has been reported and a graphical representation proposed in order to better explain the meaning of the parameters chosen.

Non-symmetrical structural behavior of a symmetric protein: the case of homo-trimeric TRAF2 (tumor necrosis factor-receptor associated factor 2).

The oligomeric state of TRAF2 (tumor necrosis factor-receptor associated factor 2), a TNF (tumor necrosis factor) receptor-associated factor, is crucial for membrane binding and probably plays a fundamental role in regulating the protein function in vivo. In this study we have combined molecular dynamics with the protein contact network approach to characterize the interaction of the three identical subunits of TRAF2. The average structure obtained after a 225 ns simulation reveals that two clusters of different size are formed, one of which includes almost completely two subunits, while the third monomer appears to be more independent. This picture is also confirmed by the estimated average number of inter-subunit contacts and by the comparison of side chains mobility in each monomer. The analysis of equilibrium pressure-induced dissociation measurements supports such findings, indicating that the dimeric-monomeric (2 + 1) might be prevalent with respect to the trimeric configuration, especially in the case of more diluted samples. These findings suggest that the formation of monomeric species, which is crucial for the formation of intra-luminal vesicles, might depend on preferential asymmetric interactions among the three subunits.Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.