Report of the IFCC Working Group for Standardization of Thyroid Function Tests; part 3: total thyroxine and total triiodothyronine.

BACKGROUND: Because total thyroid hormone testing is performed on many automated clinical chemistry instruments, the IFCC Scientific Division commissioned the Working Group for Standardization of Thyroid Function Tests to include total thyroxine (TT4) and total triiodothyronine (TT3) in its standardization efforts. METHODS: Existing SI-traceable reference measurement procedures (RMPs) were used to assign TT4 and TT3 values to 40 single-donor serum samples for subsequent use in a method comparison study with 11 TT4 and 12 TT3 immunoassays. Data from comparison of each immunoassay with the RMPs provided a basis for mathematical assay recalibration. RESULTS: Seven TT4 assays had a mean bias within 10% of the RMP, but 2 deviated by an average of -12% and another 2 by +17%. All TT3 assays showed positive biases, 4 within and 8 outside 10%, up to 32%. Mathematical recalibration effectively eliminated assay-specific biases, but sample-related effects remained, particularly for TT3. Correlation coefficients with the RMPs ranged from 0.82 to 0.97 for TT4 and from 0.32 to 0.92 for TT3. The within-run and total imprecision ranges for TT4 were 1.4% to 9.1% and 3.0% to 9.4%, respectively, and for TT3 2.1% to 7.8% and 2.8% to 12.7%, respectively. Approximately one-half of the assays matched the internal QC targets within approximately 5%; however, we observed within-run drifts/shifts. CONCLUSIONS: The study showed that of the assays we examined, only 4 TT4 but the majority of the TT3 assays needed establishment of calibration traceability to the existing RMPs. Most assays performed well, but some would benefit from improved precision, within-run stability, and between-run consistency.

Report of the IFCC Working Group for Standardization of Thyroid Function Tests; part 2: free thyroxine and free triiodothyronine.

BACKGROUND: Free thyroxine (FT4) and free triiodothyronine (FT3) measurements are useful in the diagnosis and treatment of a variety of thyroid disorders. The IFCC Scientific Division established a Working Group to resolve issues of method performance to meet clinical requirements. METHODS: We compared results for measurement of a panel of single donor sera using clinical laboratory procedures based on equilibrium dialysis-isotope dilution-mass spectrometry (ED-ID-MS) (2 for FT4, 1 for FT3) and immunoassays from 9 manufacturers (15 for FT4, 13 for FT3) to a candidate international conventional reference measurement procedure (cRMP) also based on ED-ID-MS. RESULTS: For FT4 (FT3), the mean bias of 2 (4) assays was within 10% of the cRMP, whereas for 15 (9) assays, negative biases up to -42% (-30%) were seen; 1 FT3 assay was positively biased by +22%. Recalibration to the cRMP eliminated assay-specific biases; however, sample-related effects remained, as judged from difference plots with biologic total error limits. Correlation coefficients to the cRMPs ranged for FT4 (FT3) from 0.92 to 0.78 (0.88 to 0.30). Within-run and total imprecision ranged for FT4 (FT3) from 1.0% to 11.1% (1.8% to 9.4%) and 1.5% to 14.1% (2.4% to 10.0%), respectively. Approximately half of the manufacturers matched the internal QC targets within approximately 5%; however, within-run instability was observed. CONCLUSIONS: The study showed that most assays had bias largely correctable by establishing calibration traceability to a cRMP and that the majority performed well. Some assays, however, would benefit from improved precision, within-run stability, and between-run consistency.

Report of the IFCC Working Group for Standardization of Thyroid Function Tests; part 1: thyroid-stimulating hormone.

BACKGROUND: Laboratory testing of serum thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) is an essential tool for the diagnosis and management of various thyroid disorders whose collective prevalence lies between 4% and 8%. However, between-assay discrepancies in TSH results limit the application of clinical practice guidelines. METHODS: We performed a method comparison study with 40 sera to assess the result comparability and performance attributes of 16 immunoassays. RESULTS: Thirteen of 16 assays gave mean results within 10% of the overall mean. The difference between the most extreme means was 39%. Assay-specific biases could be eliminated by recalibration to the overall mean. After recalibration of singlicate results, all assays showed results within the biological total error goal (22.8%), except for 1 result in each of 4 assays. For a sample with a TSH concentration of 0.016 mIU/L, 6 assays either did not report results or demonstrated CVs >20%. Within-run and total imprecision ranged from 1.5% to 5.5% and 2.5% to 7.7%, respectively. Most assays were able to match the internal QC targets within 5%. Within-run drifts and shifts were observed. CONCLUSIONS: Harmonization of TSH measurements would be particularly beneficial for 3 of the 16 examined assays. These data demonstrate that harmonization may be accomplished by establishing calibration traceability to the overall mean values for a panel of patient samples. However, the full impact of the approach must be further explored with a wider range of samples. Although a majority of assays showed excellent quality of performance, some would benefit from improved within-run stability.

Direct equilibrium dialysis compared with two non-dialysis free T4 methods in premature infants.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the incidence of low free T4 values reported by a direct equilibrium dialysis method to their incidence reported by 2 non-dialysis methods. STUDY DESIGN: Ninety-five infants, < or = 33 weeks gestational age at birth, admitted to Loma Linda University Children's Hospital before day 3 of life were studied. Infants were grouped by gestational age ranges: < or = 27, 28-30, and 31-33 weeks. Free T4 determinations were measured at 3, 7, and 14 days of life with 3 different free T4 methods. Gestational age-specific newborn reference ranges were available for the direct equilibrium dialysis method only. The only reference ranges available for the non-dialysis free T4 methods were not gestational age specific. Using available reference ranges we classified free T4 values as either low or not low. The incidence of low free T4 values was compared at 3, 7, and 14 days of life. RESULTS: Low direct equilibrium dialysis free T4 values were substantially less frequent than non-dialysis free T4 values. CONCLUSION: Substantial free T4 inconsistencies occur between dialysis and non-dialysis free T4 methods in preterm infants. It is unclear how much of this inconsistency is method dependent and how much is reference range dependent.

Thyroid hormone levels and psychological symptoms in sexually abused adolescent girls.

OBJECTIVE: To explore the relationships between psychological symptoms and thyroid hormone levels in adolescent girls who had experienced the traumatic stress of sexual abuse. METHOD: The study design was cross-sectional/correlational. Subjects (N=22; age range=12-18 years) had their blood drawn, and they completed 2 psychological tests (depression and general distress/posttraumatic stress disorder [PTSD]). A pediatrician completed a sexual abuse questionnaire after reviewing law enforcement and Child Protective Services reports and conducting forensic interviews and medical examinations. RESULTS: Girls' average free T4, total T4, free T3, total T3, and TSH levels were within age-specific laboratory reference range limits, as were most individual concentrations. The strongest correlations (p<.05) were between free T3 and PTSD total score (-.50), PTSD-avoidance/numbing (-.49), and general distress (-.48); and between total T3 and depression (-.46), general distress (-.45), and PTSD-arousal (-.44). CONCLUSIONS: Our findings support one of the two contemporary models of the relationships between thyroid hormones (i.e., free and total T3) and psychological symptoms (i.e., depression, general distress, and PTSD)--one of "shutting down" (vs. "activation") in the face of trauma.

Autoantibody "subspecificity" in type 1 diabetes: risk for organ-specific autoimmunity clusters in distinct groups.

OBJECTIVE: Autoimmune thyroid disease (AIT), celiac disease, and Addison's disease are characterized by the presence of autoantibodies: thyroid peroxidase antibody (TPOAb) and thyroglobulin antibody (TGAb) in AIT, tissue transglutaminase antibody (TTGAb) in celiac disease, and 21-hydroxylase antibody (21-OHAb) in Addison's disease. The objective of this study was to define the prevalence of these autoantibodies and clinical disease in a population with type 1 diabetes. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS: We screened 814 individuals with type 1 diabetes for TPOAb, TGAb, TTGAb, and 21-OHAb. Clinical disease was defined by chart review. Factors related to the presence of autoimmunity and clinical disease including age at onset of type 1 diabetes, duration of diabetes, age at screening, sex, and the presence of autoantibodies were reviewed. RESULTS: The most common autoantibodies expressed were TPOAb and/or TGAb (29%), followed by TTGAb (10.1%) and 21-OHAb (1.6%). Specific HLA DR/DQ genotypes were associated with the highest risk for expression of 21-OHAb (DRB1*0404-DQ8, DR3-DQ2) and TTGAb (DR3-DQ2- DR3-DQ2). The expression of thyroid autoantibodies was related to 21-OHAb but not to TTGAb. The presence of autoantibodies was associated with and predictive of disease. CONCLUSIONS: In this large cohort of individuals with type 1 diabetes, the expression of organ-specific autoantibodies was very high. The grouping of autoantibody expression suggests common factors contributing to the clustering.

Underestimates and overestimates of total thyroxine concentrations caused by unwanted thyroxine-binding protein effects.

The first evidence of unwanted serum protein effects on analogue-based total thyroxine (T4) determinations came from a study that varied serum protein concentrations while total T4 concentrations were constant. The present study approached this issue by varying total T4 concentrations while protein concentrations were constant. Four analogue-based total T4 immunoassays were applied to solutions that contained either free T4 without binding protein, a T4-binding protein without T4, or protein-bound T4. When total T4 concentrations were 3-12 microg/dL, the assays reported total T4 determinations that ranged from none detected to 23 microg/dL. These T4 determinations reflected the protein to which T4 was bound, in addition to the level of T4. Total T4 was underrepresented when T4 was unbound, or thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG) bound. Total T4 was overrepresented when T4 was albumin-bound, or transthyretin-bound. There were substantial disparities among assays applied to the same total T4 solutions. These assays reported no detectable T4 when applied to T4-binding protein solutions without protein-bound T4. Nonetheless, T4-binding proteins contributed to the underestimates and overestimates of protein bound T4. Different forms of protein bound T4 were quantified differently, evidence that protein-T4 complexes persist during quantification. We attribute the unexpected total T4 values to a combination of incomplete protein-bound T4 release from T4-binding proteins during quantification, and variably inaccurate quantifications of the protein-bound T4 that remained.

Assessing thyroid hormone status in a patient with thyroid disease and renal failure: from theory to practice.

A 35-year-old Asian male, treated for hyperthyroidism, systemic lupus erythematosis, and uremia presented with low serum total thyroxine (T4) and normal serum thyrotropin (TSH) levels. He had been receiving prednisone and methimazole for 15 weeks. Free T4 measured by direct equilibrium dialysis was in the hypothyroid range (0.3 ng/dL; normal, 0.8-2.7). Two possibilities were considered: (1) a weakly bound dialyzable inhibitor in uremic serum that interfered with this serum free T4 determination or (2) hypothyroidism with persistent TSH suppression because of prior hyperthyroidism. To determine whether a weakly bound inhibitor was involved, the patient's serum was serially diluted using two diluents: (1) an ultrafiltrate of the patient's serum, which would contain any unbound inhibitor, as well as free T4 and (2) an inert diluent. Free T4 measurements were similar with both, providing evidence against the presence of a dialyzable and ultrafilterable inhibitor. In conclusion, this patient was hypothyroid because of antithyroid drug administration, associated with prolonged central TSH suppression from preexisting hyperthyroidism. Discontinuation of methimazole resulted in normalization of serum total T4 and TSH values. Thus, paired, serial serum dilutions, using two different diluents, provided evidence for differentiation of appropriately low free T4 measurements (because of hypothyroidism), from spuriously low free T4 measurements (because of an interfering inhibitor).

The nature of analogue-based free thyroxine estimates.

Clinical laboratories often use analogue-based immunoassays to estimate serum free thyroxine (FT(4)) concentrations. These assays yield FT(4) estimates that correlate closely with thyroxine (T(4)) binding protein concentrations. This correlation implies that either T(4) binding proteins or protein bound T(4) contribute to analogue-based FT(4) values. To study the contributions made by T(4) binding proteins to these FT(4) estimates further, four analogue-based FT(4) assays were applied to: (1) FT(4) solutions without T(4) binding proteins, (2) to T(4) binding protein solutions without T(4), and (3) to total T(4) solutions containing T(4) binding protein, FT(4), and protein-bound T(4). The FT(4) estimates obtained with these solutions ranged from 0.2-8.6 ng/dL, when FT(4) concentrations ranged from less than 0.2-12,000 ng/dL. In the FT(4) solutions, gravimetrically determined FT(4) concentrations were 500-12,000 ng/dL (0.5-12.0 microg/dL) without protein-bound T(4), and the FT(4) estimates obtained were 0.3-6.9 ng/dL. In the total T(4) solutions, dialyzable FT(4) concentrations were less than 0.2-59 ng/dL, retained T(4) concentrations were 499.8-11,441 ng/dL, and the analogue-based FT(4) estimates obtained were 0.2-8.6 ng/dL. Similar FT(4) estimates (0.2-8.6 ng/dL and 0.3-6.9 ng/dL) were obtained with similar concentrations of either protein-bound T(4) or FT(4). Similar test results were associated with similar total T(4) concentrations, not similar FT(4) concentrations. Protein-bound T(4) and T(4) binding protein contributed variably to test results. T(4) quantifications included large analytical losses that are unaccounted for. These assays passed tests of correlation with FT(4) concentrations, but they failed tests of specificity for FT(4) and accuracy in T(4) quantification.

Incidence of low free T4 values in premature infants as determined by direct equilibrium dialysis.

BACKGROUND: The incidence of transient reductions in serum free T(4) (FT(4)) in premature infants may be overestimated because certain FT(4) analytical methods underestimate FT(4) concentrations. Transient reductions of FT(4) measurements have been reported in the majority of premature newborn infants. Direct equilibrium dialysis (DED) does not underestimate FT(4) concentrations and is the best available technique to measure serum FT(4) in the premature infant. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the incidence of low FT(4) concentrations in premature infants using DED to measure FT(4). DESIGN/METHOD: We measured FT(4) by DED in infants with birth weight <1500 g. Infants were excluded if the following conditions were present: congenital anomalies or maternal thyroid disorders. Free T(4) was measured at 14 days of life. Low FT(4) was defined using a statistical definition of FT(4) measurements <10.3 pmol/l (0.8 ng/dl). RESULTS: Free T(4) was measured by DED in 114 infants. Low FT(4) levels were seen in nine infants (7.9%). CONCLUSION: The incidence of low FT(4) was much lower than previously reported when FT(4) was measured using DED indicating that methodological issues are involved in the variability among estimates of the frequency of transient reduction in FT(4).

Accuracy issues in free thyroxine testing methods.

The incidence of low neonatal free thyroxine (T(4)) assay results is methodology-dependent. Nonanalog free T(4) assay results represent free T(4) concentrations when free T(4) is the only form of T(4). Similar analog-based free T(4) assay results are produced by an extraordinary range of free T(4) concentrations, when free T(4) is the only form of T(4). Adding albumin or transthyretin to free T(4) concentrations greatly decreased free T(4) concentrations, as expected, but increased analog-based free T(4) assay results. By contrast, adding thyroxine-binding globulin decreased free T(4) concentrations and free T(4) assay results; but these free T(4) concentrations were not represented by assay results. There was no specificity for the free form of T(4) versus bound forms of T(4) in some free T(4) assay results. The protein that binds T(4) can have a major influence on some of the total T(4) assay results that may be used in free T(4) index methods.

Analog-based free testosterone test results linked to total testosterone concentrations, not free testosterone concentrations.

BACKGROUND: Analog-based free testosterone test results, sex hormone binding globulin (SHBG) concentrations, and total testosterone concentrations are somehow related. This study used new experiments to clarify these relationships. METHODS: An analog-based free testosterone immunoassay and a total testosterone immunoassay were applied to well-defined fractions of serum testosterone. First, they were applied to the 2 fractions (retentate and dialysate) of normal male serum obtained by equilibrium dialysis. Second, they were applied to covaried concentrations of SHBG and total testosterone. Third, they were applied to decreasing concentrations of SHBG and protein-bound testosterone, offset by increasing concentrations of protein-free testosterone, while total testosterone was held constant. RESULTS: The analog-based free testosterone assay and the total testosterone assay detected and reported serum testosterone test results from serum retentate, whereas neither assay detected the free testosterone in serum dialysate. Test results reported by the analog-based free testosterone assay followed varied concentrations of SHBG and total testosterone. When total testosterone was held constant, however, analog-based free testosterone test results did not follow varied concentrations of serum proteins or of free testosterone. CONCLUSION: An analog-based free testosterone immunoassay reported free testosterone test results that were related to total testosterone concentrations under varied experimental conditions. This alleged free testosterone assay did not detect serum free testosterone (the test results it reported were nonspecific) and should not be used for this purpose.

A direct free thyroxine (T4) immunoassay with the characteristics of a total T4 immunoassay.

BACKGROUND: Direct free thyroxine (T(4)) measurements have been linked to both T(4)-binding serum protein concentrations and protein-bound T(4) concentrations. Whether this is evidence of a relationship to total T(4) concentrations has not been reported. METHODS: We compared an analog-based direct free T(4) immunoassay and a total T(4) immunoassay. Each assay was applied to the fractions of serum T(4) obtained by ultrafiltration and equilibrium dialysis. Both were applied to serum-based solutions in which free T(4), T(4)-binding proteins, protein-bound T(4), and total T(4) were systematically varied, held constant, or excluded. RESULTS: Neither the free T(4) assay nor the total T(4) assay detected dialyzable or ultrafilterable serum T(4). Both assays detected and reported the T(4) retained with serum proteins. Both free and total T(4) results were related to the same total T(4) concentrations in the presence and absence of T(4)-binding proteins. Both results were similarly related to total T(4) concentrations when free T(4) was held constant while total T(4) was varied. Both were similarly related to a total T(4) concentration that was held constant while free T(4) progressively replaced protein-bound T(4). These free T(4) results, like total T(4) results, were unresponsive to a 500-fold variation in dialyzable T(4) concentrations. CONCLUSION: New experiments extend the characterization of a longstanding and incompletely characterized analog-based free T(4) immunoassay. These free T(4) measurements relate to total T(4) concentrations in the same way that total T(4) measurements do.

Quantifying spurious free T4 results attributable to thyroxine-binding proteins in serum dialysates and ultrafiltrates.

BACKGROUND: Direct equilibrium dialysis and direct ultrafiltration free thyroxine (T(4)) assays rely on semipermeable membranes to exclude T(4)-binding serum proteins from dialysates and ultrafiltrates. The presence of these proteins in dialysates or ultrafiltrates will yield spuriously high free T(4) values when free T(4) is quantified by RIA. METHODS: We used a nonanalog free T(4) RIA that detects and quantifies dialyzable and ultrafilterable serum free T(4) to detect T(4)-binding serum proteins. Two equilibrium dialysis devices and 3 ultrafiltration devices were used to illustrate this application. Displacements of [(125)I]T(4) from anti-T(4) by various concentrations of T(4)-depleted thyroxine-binding globulin, albumin, and serum total protein were compared to displacements by various concentrations of free T(4). RESULTS: Both dialysis devices excluded detectable T(4)-binding serum proteins from dialysates. Two of 3 ultrafiltration devices excluded detectable T(4)-binding serum proteins from ultrafiltrates. One did not, and its ultrafiltrate yielded spurious free T(4) values that correlated directly with serum protein concentrations. CONCLUSION: The presence or absence of T(4)-binding proteins in dialysates and ultrafiltrates and the spurious free T(4) values that these proteins cause can be documented using a nonanalog free T(4) RIA.

Proposal of a candidate international conventional reference measurement procedure for free thyroxine in serum.

In the present paper the IFCC WG-STFT recommends and provides the rationale to establish metrological traceability of serum free thyroxine (FT4) measurements to a candidate international conventional reference measurement procedure. It is proposed that this procedure be based on equilibrium dialysis combined with determination of thyroxine in the dialysate with a trueness-based reference measurement procedure. The measurand is thus operationally defined as "thyroxine in the dialysate from equilibrium dialysis of serum prepared under defined conditions". With regard to the trueness-based reference measurement procedure, the WG-STFT recommends use of an isotope dilution-liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (ID-LC/tandem MS) procedure for total thyroxine that has been optimized towards measurement at picomolar concentration levels and that is listed in the database of the Joint Committee for Traceability in Laboratory Medicine (JCTLM). For calibration, the purified thyroxine material IRMM-468 (resulting from a project funded by the European Commission and recently submitted to the JCTLM) is proposed. The WG-STFT stresses that according to this recommendation it is a prerequisite to strictly adhere to the defined equilibrium dialysis procedure, whereas it is permissible to introduce variants in the ID-LC/tandem MS procedure.

Supplementation of thyroid hormone in children undergoing cardiac surgery.

Triiodothyronine has been introduced as a promising new supplement for patients undergoing open-heart surgery. This manuscript will review the existing literature regarding supplementation with triiodothyronine in children. Infants and children undergoing cardiac surgery experience a profound decrease in levels of free and total triiodothyronine. These decreases are of sufficient magnitude to effect cardiac function. Supplementation with triiodothyronine has been shown to enhance myocardial performance, improve recovery of circulating levels of triiodothyronine, and to result in an increase in mixed venous oxygen saturation. As encouraging as these results are, there is no definitive study which demonstrates that triiodothyronine improves clinical outcome in children. Thus, while triiodothyronine appears to have promise as a supplement for children undergoing open-heart surgery, more studies are needed to establish the efficacy of such therapy scientifically.

Follow-up of newborns with elevated screening T4 concentrations.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the type and incidence of hyperthyroxinemic disorders detected by follow-up of infants with elevated screening total T4 (TT4) values. STUDY DESIGN: Infants born in Oregon with a screening TT4 measurement >3 SD above the mean were offered enrollment. Serum TT4, free T4, total T3, free T3, and thyroid-stimulating hormone concentrations were measured in study infants and their mothers. RESULTS: Over a 20-month period, 101 infants (51 boys) and their mothers enrolled in the study (of 241 eligible infants), from a total screening population of 80,884; 17 infants were identified with persistent hyperthyroxinemia (TT4 >16 microg/dL). Ten had thyroxine-binding globulin excess (1:8088), 5 had evidence for increased T4 binding but not thyroxine-binding globulin excess (1:16,177), and 2 had findings compatible with thyroid hormone resistance (1:40,442); the other 84 infants had transient hyperthyroxinemia. Sequence analysis revealed a point mutation in the thyroid hormone receptor-beta gene in one infant with thyroid hormone resistance; no mutation was identified in the other infant. CONCLUSIONS: Although neonatal Graves' disease occurs in approximately 1 in 25,000 newborn infants, we did not detect any case among 80,884 infants, most likely because their mothers were receiving antithyroid drugs. Although the other hyperthyroxinemic disorders in the aggregate occur frequently (1:4758) and may benefit from detection, in general they do not require treatment.

Initial treatment dose of L-thyroxine in congenital hypothyroidism.

OBJECTIVES: To determine the optimal initial treatment dose of L-thyroxine in congenital hypothyroidism (CH) by evaluating the time course of rise of thyroxine (T(4)) and free T(4) concentrations into an established "target range" and normalization of thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) and to reevaluate the "target range" for T(4) and free T(4) concentrations during the first 2 weeks of CH treatment. STUDY DESIGN: Infants of birth weight 3 to 4 kg with CH (n = 47) detected by newborn screening were randomly assigned into three L-thyroxine treatment dose arms: 37.5 microg/day (group 1); 62.5 microg/day for 3 days, then 37.5 microg/day (group 2); and 50 microg/day (group 3). Serum T(4), free T(4), triiodothyronine (T(3)), free T(3), and TSH were measured before treatment and at 3 days and 1, 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks after treatment. RESULTS: T(4) and free T(4) concentrations increased into the target range (10 to 16 microg/dL) by 3 days of therapy in infants in groups 2 and 3 and by 1 week in group 1; 50 microg/day (average 14.5 microg/kg/day) provided the most rapid normalization of TSH by 2 weeks. With the use of linear regression analysis of T(4) versus TSH or free T(4) versus TSH plots, the intercept at the lower range of normal for TSH (1.7 mU/L) showed T(4) = 19.5 microg/dL and free T(4) = 5.23 ng/dL. CONCLUSIONS: Initial dosing of 50 microg/day (12-17 microg/kg per day) raised serum T(4) and free T(4) concentrations to target range by 3 days and normalized TSH by 2 weeks of therapy. We recommend consideration of a somewhat higher "target range" of 10 to 18 microg/dL for T(4) and 2 to 5.0 ng/dL for free T(4) during the first 2 weeks of L-thyroxine treatment. After 2 weeks of treatment, the target range drops to 10 to 16 microg/dL for T(4) and 1.6 to 2.2 for free T(4).