RESUMEN
Two custom-designed bioreactors were used to evaluate the effect of shear on biofilms of a succinic acid producer, Actinobacillus succinogenes. The first bioreactor allowed for in situ removal of small biofilm samples used for microscopic imaging. The second bioreactor allowed for complete removal of all biofilm and was used to analyse biofilm composition and productivity. The smooth, low porosity biofilms obtained under high shear conditions had an average cell viability of 79% compared to 57% at the lowest shear used. The maximum cell-based succinic acid productivity for high shear biofilm was 2.4 g g-1DCW h-1 compared to the 0.8 g g-1DCW h-1 of the low shear biofilm. Furthermore, 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyl tetrazolium bromide (MTT) assays confirmed higher cell metabolic activities for high shear developed biofilm compared to biofilm developed at low shear conditions. Results clearly indicated that high shear biofilm cultivation has beneficial morphological, viability, and cell-based productivity characteristics.
Asunto(s)
Actinobacillus/metabolismo , Biopelículas , Ácido Succínico/metabolismo , Fenómenos Biomecánicos , Reactores Biológicos , Cromatografía Líquida de Alta Presión/métodos , Medios de Cultivo , FermentaciónRESUMEN
Biofilms of Actinobacillus succinogenes have demonstrated exceptional capabilities as biocatalysts for high productivity, titre and yield production of succinic acid (SA). The paper presents a microscopic analysis of A. succinogenes biofilms developed under varied fermenter conditions. The concentration of excretion metabolites is controlled by operating the fermenter in a continuous mode where the liquid throughput is adjusted. It is clearly illustrated how the accumulation of excreted metabolites (concomitant with the sodium build-up due to base dosing) has a severe effect on the biofilm structure and physiology. Under high accumulation (HA) conditions, some cells exhibit severe elongation while maintaining a cross-sectional diameter like the rod/cocci-shaped cells predominantly found in low accumulation (LA) conditions. The elongated cells formed at high accumulation conditions were found to be more viable than the clusters of rod/cocci-shaped cells and appear to form connections between the clusters. The global microscopic structure of the HA biofilms also differed significantly from the LA biofilms. Although both exhibited shedding after 4 days of growth, the LA biofilms were more homogenous (less patchy), thicker and with high viability throughout the biofilm depth. The viability of the HA biofilms was threefold lower than the corresponding LA biofilms towards the end of the fermentation. Visual observations were supported by quantitative analysis of multiple biofilm samples and strengthened the main observations. The work presents valuable insights on the effect of metabolite accumulation on biofilm structure and growth.
Asunto(s)
Actinobacillus/crecimiento & desarrollo , Actinobacillus/metabolismo , Biopelículas/crecimiento & desarrollo , Ácido Succínico/metabolismo , Actinobacillus/citología , Reactores Biológicos/microbiología , Medios de Cultivo/química , Fermentación , MicroscopíaRESUMEN
Increased pentose phosphate pathway flux, relative to total substrate uptake flux, is shown to enhance succinic acid (SA) yields under continuous, non-growth conditions of Actinobacillus succinogenes biofilms. Separate fermentations of glucose and xylose were conducted in a custom, continuous biofilm reactor at four different dilution rates. Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase assays were performed on cell extracts derived from in situ removal of biofilm at each steady state. The results of the assays were coupled to a kinetic model that revealed an increase in oxidative pentose phosphate pathway (OPPP) flux relative to total substrate flux with increasing SA titre, for both substrates. Furthermore, applying metabolite concentration data to metabolic flux models that include the OPPP revealed similar flux relationships to those observed in the experimental kinetic analysis. A relative increase in OPPP flux produces additional reduction power that enables increased flux through the reductive branch of the TCA cycle, leading to increased SA yields, reduced by-product formation and complete closure of the overall redox balance.
Asunto(s)
Actinobacillus/fisiología , Biopelículas , Vía de Pentosa Fosfato , Ácido Succínico/metabolismo , Actinobacillus/metabolismo , Fermentación , Glucosa/metabolismo , Glucosafosfato Deshidrogenasa/análisis , Análisis de Flujos Metabólicos , Xilosa/metabolismoRESUMEN
Continuous, anaerobic fermentations of D-xylose were performed by Actinobacillus succinogenes 130Z in a custom, biofilm reactor at dilution rates of 0.05, 0.10 and 0.30 h(-1). Succinic acid yields on xylose (0.55-0.68 g g(-1)), titres (10.9-29.4 g L(-1)) and productivities (1.5-3.4 g L(-1) h(-1)) were lower than those of a previous study on glucose, but product ratios (succinic acid/acetic acid = 3.0-5.0 g g(-1)) and carbohydrate consumption rates were similar. Also, mass balance closures on xylose were up to 18.2 % lower than those on glucose. A modified HPLC method revealed pyruvic acid excretion at appreciable concentrations (1.2-1.9 g L(-1)) which improved the mass balance closure by up to 16.8 %. Furthermore, redox balances based on the accounted xylose consumed and the excreted metabolites, indicated an overproduction of reducing power. The oxidative pentose phosphate pathway was shown to be a plausible source of the additional reducing power.
Asunto(s)
Actinobacillus/crecimiento & desarrollo , Ácido Succínico/metabolismo , Xilosa/metabolismo , Anaerobiosis/fisiologíaRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Succinic acid is well established as bio-based platform chemical with production quantities expecting to increase exponentially within the next decade. Actinobacillus succinogenes is by far the most studied wild organism for producing succinic acid and is known for high yield and titre during production on various sugars in batch culture. At low shear conditions continuous fermentation with A. succinogenes results in biofilm formation. In this study, a novel shear controlled fermenter was developed that enabled: 1) chemostat operation where self-immobilisation was opposed by high shear rates and, 2) in-situ removal of biofilm by increasing shear rates and subsequent analysis thereof. RESULTS: The volumetric productivity of the biofilm fermentations were an order of magnitude more than the chemostat runs. In addition the biofilm runs obtained substantially higher yields. Succinic acid to acetic acid ratios for chemostat runs were 1.28±0.2 g.g(-1), while the ratios for biofilm runs started at 2.4 g.g(-1) and increased up to 3.3 g.g(-1) as glucose consumption increased. This corresponded to an overall yield on glucose of 0.48±0.05 g.g(-1) for chemostat runs, while the yields varied between 0.63 g.g(-1) and 0.74 g.g(-1) for biofilm runs. Specific growth rates (µ) were shown to be severely inhibited by the formation of organic acids, with µ only 12% of µ(max) at a succinic acid titre of 7 g.L(-1). Maintenance production of succinic acid was shown to be dominant for the biofilm runs with cell based production rates (extracellular polymeric substance removed) decreasing as SA titre increases. CONCLUSIONS: The novel fermenter allowed for an in-depth bioreaction analysis of A. succinogenes. Biofilm cells achieve higher SA yields than suspended cells and allow for operation at higher succinic acid titre. Both growth and maintenance rates were shown to drastically decrease with succinic acid titre. The A. succinogenes biofilm process has vast potential, where self-induced high cell densities result in higher succinic acid productivity and yield.
Asunto(s)
Actinobacillus/fisiología , Biopelículas/crecimiento & desarrollo , Reactores Biológicos/microbiología , Biotecnología/instrumentación , Biotecnología/métodos , Ácido Succínico/metabolismo , Actinobacillus/efectos de los fármacos , Técnicas de Cultivo Celular por Lotes , Biopelículas/efectos de los fármacos , Biomasa , Glucosa/metabolismo , Cinética , Resistencia al Corte , Ácido Succínico/farmacologíaRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Succinic acid (SA) has become a prominent biobased platform chemical with global production quantities increasing annually. Numerous genetically modified E. coli strains have been developed with the main aim of increasing the SA yield of the organic carbon source. In this study, a promising SA-producing strain, E. coli KJ134 [Biotechnol. Bioeng. 101:881-893, 2008], from the Department of Microbiology and Cell Science of the University of Florida was evaluated under continuous and batch conditions using D-glucose and CO2 in a mineral salt medium. Production characteristics entailing growth and maintenance rates, growth termination points and metabolic flux distributions under growth and non-growth conditions were determined. RESULTS: The culture remained stable for weeks under continuous conditions. Under growth conditions the redox requirements of the reductive tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle was solely balanced by acetic acid (AcA) production via the pyruvate dehydrogenase route resulting in a molar ratio of SA:AcA of two. A maximum growth rate of 0.22 h(-1) was obtained, while complete growth inhibition occurred at a SA concentration of 18 g L(-1). Batch culture revealed that high-yield succinate production (via oxidative TCA or glyoxylate redox balancing) occurred under non-growth conditions where a SA:AcA molar ratio of up to five was attained, with a final SA yield of 0.94 g g(-1). Growth termination of the batch culture was in agreement with that of the continuous culture. The maximum maintenance production rate of SA under batch conditions was found to be 0.6 g g(-1) h(-1). This is twice the maintenance rate observed in the continuous runs. CONCLUSIONS: The study revealed that the metabolic flux of E. coli KJ134 differs significantly for growth and non-growth conditions, with non-growth conditions resulting in higher SA:AcA ratios and SA yields. Bioreaction characteristics entailing growth and maintenance rates, as well as growth termination markers will guide future fermentor designs and improvements.
Asunto(s)
Escherichia coli/crecimiento & desarrollo , Escherichia coli/metabolismo , Ácido Succínico/metabolismo , Técnicas de Cultivo Celular por Lotes , Medios de Cultivo , Escherichia coli/genética , FermentaciónRESUMEN
Phytoremediation technologies are employed worldwide to remove nutrient pollutants from agricultural and industrial wastewater. Unlike in algae-based nutrient removal, control methodologies for plant-based remediation have not been standardized. Control systems that guarantee consistently low outlet concentrations of nitrogen and phosphorous often use expensive analytical instruments and are therefore rarely viable. In this study, pH measurement was used as the sole input to control the nitrate outlet concentration in a continuously operated Lemna minor (lesser duckweed) phytoremediation tank. When grown in 20 L batches of modified Hoagland's solution, it was found that a constant ratio exists between the amount of nitrate removed and the amount of acid dosed (required for pH control), which was equal to 1.25 mol N·(mol H+)-1. The nitrate uptake rates were determined by standard spetrophotometric method. At critically low nitrate concentrations, this ratio reduced slightly to 1.08 mol N·(mol H+)-1. Assuming a constant nitrogen content, the biomass growth rate could be predicted based on the acid dosing rate. A proportional-integral controller was used to maintain pH on 6.5 in a semi-continuously operated tank covered by L. minor. A nitrogen control strategy was developed which exploited this relationship between nitrate uptake and dosing and successfully removed upwards of 80% of the fed nitrogen from synthetic wastewater while a constant biomass layer was maintained. This study presents a clear illustration of how advanced chemical engineering control principles can be applied in phytoremediation processes.
RESUMEN
Nitrogen pollution from agriculture is a major challenge facing our society today. Biological nitrogen fixation is key to combat the damage that is caused by synthetic nitrogen. Azolla spp. are ideal candidates for fast nitrogen fixation. This study aimed to investigate the optimal growth conditions for Azolla pinnata R. Brown. The growth conditions that were investigated included the growth medium type and strength, light intensity, the presence/absence of nitrogen in the medium, pH control, and humidity. Higher light intensities increased plant growth by 32%, on average. The highest humidity (90%) yielded higher growth rate values than lower humidity values (60% and 75%). The presence of nitrogen in the medium had no significant effect on the growth rate of the plants. pH control was critical under the fast growth conditions of high light intensity and high humidity, and it reduced algal growth (from visual observation). The optimal growth rate that was achieved was 0.321 day-1, with a doubling time of 2.16 days. This was achieved by using a 15% strength of the Hoagland solution, high light intensity (20,000 lx), nitrogen present in the medium, and pH control at 90% humidity. These optimised conditions could offer an improvement to the existing phytoremediation systems of Azolla pinnata and aid in the fight against synthetic nitrogen pollution.
RESUMEN
BACKGROUND: The four-carbon dicarboxylic acids of the tricarboxylic acid cycle (malate, fumarate and succinate) remain promising bio-based alternatives to various precursor chemicals derived from fossil-based feed stocks. The double carbon bond in fumarate, in addition to the two terminal carboxylic groups, opens up an array of downstream reaction possibilities, where replacement options for petrochemical derived maleic anhydride are worth mentioning. To date the most promising organism for producing fumarate is Rhizopus oryzae (ATCC 20344, also referred to as Rhizopus delemar) that naturally excretes fumarate under nitrogen-limited conditions. Fumarate excretion in R. oryzae is always associated with the co-excretion of ethanol, an unwanted metabolic product from the fermentation. Attempts to eliminate ethanol production classically focus on enhanced oxygen availability within the mycelium matrix. In this study our immobilised R. oryzae process was employed to investigate and utilise the Crabtree characteristics of the organism in order to establish the limits of ethanol by-product formation under growth and non-growth conditions. RESULTS: All fermentations were performed with either nitrogen excess (growth phase) or nitrogen limitation (production phase) where medium replacements were done between the growth and the production phase. Initial experiments employed excess glucose for both growth and production, while the oxygen partial pressure was varied between a dissolved oxygen of 18.4% and 85%. Ethanol was formed during both growth and production phases and the oxygen partial pressure had zero influence on the response. Results clearly indicated that possible anaerobic zones within the mycelium were not responsible for ethanol formation, hinting that ethanol is formed under fully aerobic conditions as a metabolic overflow product. For Crabtree-positive organisms like Saccharomyces cerevisiae ethanol overflow is manipulated by controlling the glucose input to the fermentation. The same strategy was employed for R. oryzae for both growth and production fermentations. It was shown that all ethanol can be eliminated during growth for a glucose addition rate of 0.07 g L - 1 h - 1 . The production phase behaved in a similar manner, where glucose addition of 0.197 g L - 1 h - 1 resulted in fumarate production of 0.150 g L - 1 h - 1 and a yield of 0.802 g g - 1 fumarate on glucose. Further investigation into the effect of glucose addition revealed that ethanol overflow commences at a glucose addition rate of 0.395 g g - 1 h - 1 on biomass, while the maximum glucose uptake rate was established to be between 0.426 and 0.533 g g - 1 h - 1 . CONCLUSIONS: The results conclusively prove that R. oryzae is a Crabtree-positive organism and that the characteristic can be utilised to completely discard ethanol by-product formation. A state referred to as "homofumarate production" was illustrated, where all carbon input exits the cell as either fumarate or respiratory CO 2 . The highest biomass-based "homofumarate production": rate of 0.243 g g - 1 h - 1 achieved a yield of 0.802 g g - 1 on glucose, indicating the bounds for developing an ethanol free process. The control strategy employed in this study in conjunction with the uncomplicated scalability of the immobilised process provides new direction for further developing bio-fumarate production.
RESUMEN
A novel fermentation system was employed whereby the mycelial mat of Rhizopus oryzae was attached to a polypropylene tube. Batch operation was used for growth, while continuous operation was employed during the fumaric acid production phase. A clear decrease in respiration, fumaric acid (FA) and ethanol production was observed when zero nitrogen was fed in the production phase, with FA productivity decreasing from an initial 0.7â¯gâ¯L-1â¯h-1 to 0.3â¯gâ¯L-1â¯h-1 after 150â¯h. With the addition of 0.625â¯mgâ¯L-1â¯h-1 of urea FA productivity dropped to only 0.4â¯gâ¯L-1â¯h-1 after 150â¯h and 0.3â¯gâ¯L-1â¯h-1 after 400â¯h. Under these conditions it was observed that the ethanol production rate decreased 20 times faster compared with the FA production rate, therefore resulting in high FA yields towards the end of the fermentation (instantaneous 0.96â¯gâ¯g-1 and average 0.81â¯gâ¯g-1 after 400â¯h). Increasing the urea feed rate to 1.875â¯mgâ¯L-1â¯h-1 resulted in a clear increase in FA production and respiration rates. This condition also resulted in a 25% increase in biomass after 150â¯h, while the decline in the ethanol production rate was seven times lower than in the 0.625â¯mgâ¯L-1â¯h-1 urea fermentation, resulting in lower FA yields.
Asunto(s)
Células Inmovilizadas/metabolismo , Fumaratos/metabolismo , Nitrógeno/metabolismo , Rhizopus/metabolismo , Células Inmovilizadas/citología , Etanol/metabolismo , Rhizopus/citologíaRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Co-production of chemicals from lignocellulosic biomass alongside fuels holds promise for improving the economic outlook of integrated biorefineries. In current biochemical conversion processes that use thermochemical pretreatment and enzymatic hydrolysis, fractionation of hemicellulose-derived and cellulose-derived sugar streams is possible using hydrothermal or dilute acid pretreatment (DAP), which then offers a route to parallel trains for fuel and chemical production from xylose- and glucose-enriched streams. Succinic acid (SA) is a co-product of particular interest in biorefineries because it could potentially displace petroleum-derived chemicals and polymer precursors for myriad applications. However, SA production from biomass-derived hydrolysates has not yet been fully explored or developed. RESULTS: Here, we employ Actinobacillus succinogenes 130Z to produce succinate in batch fermentations from various substrates including (1) pure sugars to quantify substrate inhibition, (2) from mock hydrolysates similar to those from DAP containing single putative inhibitors, and (3) using the hydrolysate derived from two pilot-scale pretreatments: first, a mild alkaline wash (deacetylation) followed by DAP, and secondly a single DAP step, both with corn stover. These latter streams are both rich in xylose and contain different levels of inhibitors such as acetate, sugar dehydration products (furfural, 5-hydroxymethylfurfural), and lignin-derived products (ferulate, p-coumarate). In batch fermentations, we quantify succinate and co-product (acetate and formate) titers as well as succinate yields and productivities. We demonstrate yields of 0.74 g succinate/g sugars and 42.8 g/L succinate from deacetylated DAP hydrolysate, achieving maximum productivities of up to 1.27 g/L-h. Moreover, A. succinogenes is shown to detoxify furfural via reduction to furfuryl alcohol, although an initial lag in succinate production is observed when furans are present. Acetate seems to be the main inhibitor for this bacterium present in biomass hydrolysates. CONCLUSION: Overall, these results demonstrate that biomass-derived, xylose-enriched hydrolysates result in similar yields and titers but lower productivities compared to clean sugar streams, which can likely be improved via fermentation process developments and metabolic engineering. Overall, this study comprehensively examines the behavior of A. succinogenes on xylose-enriched hydrolysates on an industrially relevant, lignocellulosic feedstock, which will pave the way for future work toward eventual SA production in an integrated biorefinery.
RESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Bio-manufacturing of high-value chemicals in parallel to renewable biofuels has the potential to dramatically improve the overall economic landscape of integrated lignocellulosic biorefineries. However, this will require the generation of carbohydrate streams from lignocellulose in a form suitable for efficient microbial conversion and downstream processing appropriate to the desired end use, making overall process development, along with selection of appropriate target molecules, crucial to the integrated biorefinery. Succinic acid (SA), a high-value target molecule, can be biologically produced from sugars and has the potential to serve as a platform chemical for various chemical and polymer applications. However, the feasibility of microbial SA production at industrially relevant productivities and yields from lignocellulosic biorefinery streams has not yet been reported. RESULTS: Actinobacillus succinogenes 130Z was immobilised in a custom continuous fermentation setup to produce SA on the xylose-enriched fraction of a non-detoxified, xylose-rich corn stover hydrolysate stream produced from deacetylation and dilute acid pretreatment. Effective biofilm attachment, which serves as a natural cell retention strategy to increase cell densities, productivities and resistance to toxicity, was accomplished by means of a novel agitator fitting. A maximum SA titre, yield and productivity of 39.6 g L(-1), 0.78 g g(-1) and 1.77 g L(-1) h(-1) were achieved, respectively. Steady states were obtained at dilution rates of 0.02, 0.03, 0.04, and 0.05 h(-1) and the stirred biofilm reactor was stable over prolonged periods of operation with a combined fermentation time of 1550 h. Furthermore, it was found that a gradual increase in the dilution rate was required to facilitate adaptation of the culture to the hydrolysate, suggesting a strong evolutionary response to the toxic compounds in the hydrolysate. Moreover, the two primary suspected fermentation inhibitors, furfural and HMF, were metabolised during fermentation with the concentration of each remaining at zero across all steady states. CONCLUSIONS: The results demonstrate that immobilised A. succinogenes has the potential for effective conversion of an industrially relevant, biomass-derived feed stream to succinic acid. Furthermore, due to the attractive yields, productivities and titres achieved in this study, the process has the potential to serve as a means for value-added chemical manufacturing in the integrated biorefinery.
RESUMEN
A tubular recycle bioreactor was employed to ensure homogeneous shear conditions on the biofilm surface. Superficial liquid velocities of 0.19 ms(-1), 0.37 ms(-1), 0.55 ms(-1) and 3.65 ms(-1) were used. The highest velocity resulted in negligible cell attachment (chemostat) while the ratio of attached-to-total cell mass escalated as the superficial velocity decreased. The lactic acid yield on glucose increased from 0.75 g g(-1) to 0.90 g g(-1) with declining shear while the corresponding acetoin yield on glucose decreased from 0.074 g g(-1) to 0.017 g g(-1). Redox analysis of the catabolites revealed a net consumption of NADH in the anabolism, while the extent of NADH consumption decreased when shear was reduced. This was attributed to the formation of more extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) at low shear conditions. A simplified metabolic flux model was used to estimate the EPS content of the biomass as a function of the shear velocity. Rate data supported the notion of increased EPS at lower shear.