RESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Specific personal and behavioural characteristics are required for competent health care practice. Research investigating relationships between these characteristics and course performance of health professions students is expanding, yet little research is conducted within the undergraduate physiotherapy student population. This study aimed to explore the relationships between personality, approaches to learning, and coping strategies of undergraduate physiotherapy students and their performance in academic, clinical and in-course assessment tasks and course progression. METHODS: Participants from six cohorts of undergraduate physiotherapy students (commencing years 2012-2017, 66% response rate) completed questionnaires measuring personality (NEO-FFI-3), approaches to learning (RASI) and coping strategies (Brief COPE). Correlation and multiple regression analysis were conducted to investigate relationships between scores on written examinations, in-course assessment tasks and assessments of clinical performance. Mann-Whitney U test was used to compare subgroups on these measures in those who completed or did not complete the course. RESULTS: Conscientiousness and a strategic approach to learning predicted higher scores in written examinations, and for most clinical and in-course assessments with conscientiousness being a stronger predictor. A lack of purpose (surface) learning approach was predictive of lower clinical placement scores. Non-course completers had higher scores for lack of purpose (surface) approach to learning and lower scores for the coping strategies of support seeking and humour. CONCLUSIONS: This study confirms the importance of conscientiousness and a strategic learning approach on the academic and clinical performance of undergraduate physiotherapy students. Identifying learners with a surface learning approach and low support seeking coping strategies could assist in providing support to students at risk of poor performance and minimising attrition.
Asunto(s)
Aprendizaje , Estudiantes del Área de la Salud , Humanos , Adaptación Psicológica , Personalidad , Modalidades de Fisioterapia/educaciónRESUMEN
Introduction: Identifying priority research topics that meet the needs of multiple stakeholders should maximize research investment. Aim: To identify priorities for health education research. Methods: A three-stage sequential mixed methods study was conducted. Priorities for health education research were identified through a qualitative survey with 104 students, patients, academics, and clinicians across five health sciences and 12 professions (stage 1). These findings were analyzed using framework analysis and transposed into a quantitative survey whereby 780 stakeholders rated and ranked the identified priorities. Descriptive statistics identified priorities, exploratory factor analysis grouped priorities and differences between stakeholders were determined using Mann-Whitney U tests (stage 2). Six individual or group interviews with 16 participants (stage 3) further explicated the results from previous stages. Results: Of 30 priorities identified, the top were: how best to ensure students develop the required skills for work; how to promote resiliency and well-being in students; and ensuring the curriculum prepares students for work. For the majority of priorities, no significant differences were found between different stakeholder groups. Conclusions: These findings will be used to inform health educational research strategy both locally and nationally. Further research should explore if setting priorities can be translated effectively into education research policy and practice.
Asunto(s)
Competencia Clínica , Educación en Salud , Prioridades en Salud , Estudiantes del Área de la Salud , Adolescente , Adulto , Australia , Femenino , Humanos , Masculino , Salud Mental , Persona de Mediana Edad , Investigación , Estudiantes del Área de la Salud/psicología , Encuestas y Cuestionarios , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Student failure creates additional economic costs. Knowing the cost of failure helps to frame its economic burden relative to other educational issues, providing an evidence-base to guide priority setting and allocation of resources. The Ingredients Method is a cost-analysis approach which has been previously applied to health professions education research. In this study, the Ingredients Method is introduced, and applied to a case study, investigating the cost of pre-clinical student failure. METHODS: The four step Ingredients Method was introduced and applied: (1) identify and specify resource items, (2) measure volume of resources in natural units, (3) assign monetary prices to resource items, and (4) analyze and report costs. Calculations were based on a physiotherapy program at an Australian university. RESULTS: The cost of failure was £5991 per failing student, distributed across students (70%), the government (21%), and the university (8%). If the cost of failure and attrition is distributed among the remaining continuing cohort, the cost per continuing student educated increases from £9923 to £11,391 per semester. CONCLUSIONS: The economics of health professions education is complex. Researchers should consider both accuracy and feasibility in their costing approach, toward the goal of better informing cost-conscious decision-making.
Asunto(s)
Empleos en Salud/economía , Fisioterapeutas/economía , Especialidad de Fisioterapia/economía , Abandono Escolar , Universidades/economía , Australia , Análisis Costo-Beneficio , Empleos en Salud/educación , Humanos , Estudios de Casos Organizacionales , Fisioterapeutas/educación , Especialidad de Fisioterapia/educación , Estudiantes del Área de la Salud , Encuestas y CuestionariosRESUMEN
CONTEXT: Failure by students in health professional clinical education intertwines the health and education sectors, with actions in one having potential downstream effects on the other. It is unknown what economic costs are associated with failure, how these costs are distributed, and the impacts these have on students, clinicians and workplace productivity. An understanding of cost drivers and cost boundaries will enable evidence-based targeting of strategic investments into clinical education, including where they should be made and by whom. OBJECTIVES: This study was designed to determine the additional economic costs associated with failure by students in health professional clinical education. METHODS: A cost analysis study involving cost identification, measurement, valuation and the calculation of total cost was conducted. Costs were considered from the perspective of the student, the education institution, the clinical educator, the health service placement provider organisation and the government. Data were based on a 5-week clinical education programme at Monash University, Australia. Data were collected using quantitative surveys and interviews conducted with health professional students, clinical educators and education institute staff. Reference group representation was also sought at various education institution and health service organisation levels. A transferable model with sensitivity analysis was developed. RESULTS: There is a total additional cost of US$9371 per student failing in clinical education from the perspective of all stakeholders considered. Students bear the majority of this burden, incurring 49% of costs, followed by the government (22%), the education institution (18%), the health service organisation (10%) and the clinical educator (1%). CONCLUSIONS: Strong economic links for multiple stakeholders as a result of failure by students in clinical education have been identified. The cost burden is skewed in the direction of students. Any generalisation of these results should be made with consideration for the unique clinical education context in which each health professional education programme operates.
Asunto(s)
Competencia Clínica , Análisis Costo-Beneficio , Educación de Pregrado en Medicina/economía , Estudiantes , Australia , Humanos , Lugar de TrabajoRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Case-based learning (CBL) is an educational approach where students work in small, collaborative groups to solve problems. Computer assisted learning (CAL) is the implementation of computer technology in education. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of a remote-online CBL (RO-CBL) with traditional face-to-face CBL on learning the outcomes of undergraduate physiotherapy students. METHODS: Participants were randomized to either the control (face-to-face CBL) or to the CAL intervention (RO-CBL). The entire 3rd year physiotherapy cohort (n = 41) at Monash University, Victoria, Australia, were invited to participate in the randomized controlled trial. Outcomes included a postintervention multiple-choice test evaluating the knowledge gained from the CBL, a self-assessment of learning based on examinable learning objectives and student satisfaction with the CBL. In addition, a focus group was conducted investigating perceptions and responses to the online format. RESULTS: Thirty-eight students (control n = 19, intervention n = 19) participated in two CBL sessions and completed the outcome assessments. CBL median scores for the postintervention multiple-choice test were comparable (Wilcoxon rank sum P = 0.61) (median/10 [range] intervention group: 9 [8-10] control group: 10 [7-10]). Of the 15 examinable learning objectives, eight were significantly in favor of the control group, suggesting a greater perceived depth of learning. Eighty-four percent of students (16/19) disagreed with the statement "I enjoyed the method of CBL delivery." Key themes identified from the focus group included risks associated with the implementation of, challenges of communicating in, and flexibility offered, by web-based programs. DISCUSSION: RO-CBL appears to provide students with a comparable learning experience to traditional CBL. Procedural and infrastructure factors need to be addressed in future studies to counter student dissatisfaction and decreased perceived depth of learning.
Asunto(s)
Instrucción por Computador/métodos , Sistemas en Línea , Especialidad de Fisioterapia/educación , Estudiantes del Área de la Salud/psicología , Evaluación Educacional , Femenino , Humanos , Aprendizaje , Masculino , VictoriaRESUMEN
Effective education of practical skills can alter clinician behaviour, positively influence patient outcomes, and reduce the risk of patient harm. This study compares the efficacy of two innovative practical skill teaching methods, against a traditional teaching method. Year three pre-clinical physiotherapy students consented to participate in a randomised controlled trial, with concealed allocation and blinded participants and outcome assessment. Each of the three randomly allocated groups were exposed to a different practical skills teaching method (traditional, pre-recorded video tutorial or student self-video) for two specific practical skills during the semester. Clinical performance was assessed using an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). The students were also administered a questionnaire to gain the participants level of satisfaction with the teaching method, and their perceptions of the teaching methods educational value. There were no significant differences in clinical performance between the three practical skill teaching methods as measured in the OSCE, or for student ratings of satisfaction. A significant difference existed between the methods for the student ratings of perceived educational value, with the teaching approaches of pre-recorded video tutorial and student self-video being rated higher than 'traditional' live tutoring. Alternative teaching methods to traditional live tutoring can produce equivalent learning outcomes when applied to the practical skill development of undergraduate health professional students. The use of alternative practical skill teaching methods may allow for greater flexibility for both staff and infrastructure resource allocation.
Asunto(s)
Competencia Clínica , Especialidad de Fisioterapia/educación , Enseñanza/métodos , Humanos , Proyectos Piloto , Estudiantes del Área de la Salud , Enseñanza/normas , VictoriaRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: The current workforce does not meet the demand for physiotherapy services in Australia. Future demand is predicted to expand driven primarily by the aging population. Previous research describes significant attrition and short career intentions of junior physiotherapists. OBJECTIVE: This study explored factors associated with physiotherapy graduates' early career intentions and satisfaction. METHOD: Four cohorts of student physiotherapists completed two online surveys designed specifically for this study assessing their immediate and future career intentions and satisfaction. Surveys were completed after undergraduate training (Student Survey) and 2 years later (Practitioner Survey). Question formats included single or multiple select, Likert scale, and free-text responses. Responses were analyzed via descriptive statistics and content and relational analysis. RESULTS: Despite most early career practitioners (83%) reporting career satisfaction, 27% intended to pursue long-term physiotherapy careers (>20 years) and 15% intended to work for 5 years or less. Fewer (11%) reported a longer career intention and 26% a shorter career intention compared to their student survey. Extrinsic occupational factors, such as support, were mentioned as influential in increasing intended future career length since course completion. CONCLUSION: This study found some evidence of factors contributing to shorter career intentions of early career physiotherapists. Specific support of early career physiotherapists may encourage longer career intentions and help build future workforce capacity.
RESUMEN
OBJECTIVES: Despite a large body of research on selection in medical education, very little is conducted in other health professions. This study investigated the predictive validity of multiple selection tools on academic and clinical performance outcomes of undergraduate physiotherapy students. DESIGN: A retrospective observational study. SETTING: Undergraduate physiotherapy program in Australia. PARTICIPANTS: 497 undergraduate physiotherapy students across seven entry cohorts. Including students directly from secondary school (n=381) and with prior tertiary study (n=116). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Academic performance as measured by written examinations. Clinical performance, measured by Objective Structured Clinical Examinations (OSCEs) during on-campus units and the Assessment of Physiotherapy Practice (APP) for off-campus clinical placements. Predictor variables included selection tools (academic achievement, interview, aptitude test) and demographic variables (age, gender). RESULTS: Selection interview was a positive predictor of OSCEs and final year clinical performance in direct school leaver participants. Academic achievement scores from selection positively predicted written examinations scores. CONCLUSION: Clinical and academic performance were predicted by tools measuring different domains at selection. Assessing broadly across academic and non-academic domains at selection can be valuable in identifying applicants who will be able to meet the range of outcomes for course completion and subsequent registration in the physiotherapy profession.
Asunto(s)
Educación de Pregrado en Medicina , Criterios de Admisión Escolar , Pruebas de Aptitud , Australia , Evaluación Educacional , Humanos , Modalidades de FisioterapiaRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Resource and curriculum constraints within contemporary university programmes limit opportunities for supervision and feedback of student practice. This study investigated the technological challenges, solutions and educational rewards in implementing Web-based student self-video of performance as a method to foster the development of student self-evaluation. METHODS: Physiotherapy students (n = 60) in their final preclinical semester participated in the study. All students received guidelines for constructing and uploading self-videos of performance to a Web-based learning system. Students completed a reflective task on each video submission after receiving online tutor feedback and viewing an exemplar peer performance. Students completed a survey of their learning experiences and challenges in completing the learning tasks. Technical information on submissions was obtained in usage reports from the Web-based learning system. RESULTS: Students were successful in recording and uploading digital videos of performance for remote tutor review. Students and tutors encountered technical problems that could be rectified and potentially avoided through activity design. Students reported that the utility of Web-based self-video for enhancing clinical performance outweighed the additional time and effort required in participation. CONCLUSIONS: Web-based student self-video of performance, with remote tutor feedback and guided reflection, is a feasible method for increasing students' capacity for reflection and self-evaluation. Although technical difficulties are inherent in any technology-reliant activity, the students' increasing competence with emerging technologies encourage self-video teaching and learning activities as a resource for facilitating clinical skill development.