RESUMEN
Background: Tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) is an autosomal dominant neurocutaneous disorder of non-malignant tumor growths throughout major organ systems and neurological, neuropsychiatric, renal, and pulmonary co-morbidities. Skin manifestations are readily visible, often develop early in life, and are major features that contribute to TSC diagnosis. Medical photographs of such manifestations are commonly shown as examples from White individuals creating a potential barrier to accurately identifying these features in darker skinned individuals. Objectives: The aim of this report is to raise awareness of dermatological manifestations associated with TSC, compare their appearance by race, and consider how recognition of these features could impact diagnosis and treatment of TSC. Design and Methods: We conducted a retrospective chart review at the TSC Center of Excellence (TSCOE) at the Kennedy Krieger Institute, which included all patients in the center from 2009 (inception) through the end of the calendar year 2015 and analyzed data from the TSC Alliance Natural History Database (NHD). Results: Among TSCOE patients, 50% of Black patients were diagnosed before the age of 1 year, compared with 70% of White patients. NHD data corroborated this trend showing a significant difference with only 38% of Blacks as compared with 50% of Whites were diagnosed at age ⩽1 year. A significant difference was observed where White participants had higher odds of having received genetic testing in both data sets. While no differences in the total number of TSC features was observed in either data set, shagreen patches and cephalic fibrous plaques were more frequently recorded in the NHD for Black individuals. Conclusion: We highlight a disparity in the representation of Black participants within the NHD, TSCOE, and TSC trials, in addition to differences in utilization of molecular testing and topical mechanistic target of rapamycin (mTOR) inhibitor therapy between Black and White individuals. We show a trend toward later diagnosis age in Black individuals. These differences between races warrant further study across additional clinical sites and other minority groups.
Differences in skin manifestations between races in individuals with tuberous sclerosis complex and the potential effects of these differences on diagnosis and care Background: To our knowledge, tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) does not affect races at different frequencies; however, observations in clinical settings anecdotally, and results from research studies, suggest a disparity in the representation and diagnosis of Black individuals with TSC. Historically, it has been noted that TSC facial features, such as angiofibromas, present differently in individuals with darker skin tones and are often misdiagnosed leading to delays in TSC diagnosis and treatment. Objectives: The aim of this publication is to identify differences in TSC skin features between Black and White individuals to raise awareness in the clinics and community. In addition, we provide insight into how these differences can affect the timing of TSC diagnosis and subsequent treatment regimens. We aim to highlight these potential disparities to ensure improved timing in diagnosis and treatment regimens for all affected by TSC in the future. Design and Methods: Differences between Black and White individuals with TSC were observed looking at historical medical data collected at a TSC Center of Excellence (TSCOE) on all patients seen in the center from 2009 through the end of 2015 and in the TSC Alliance Natural History Database (NHD) that has been collecting clinical data on individuals with TSC since 2006. Results: We observed that Black individuals are less likely to be diagnosed at ⩽1 year of age as compared with White individuals within the NHD. Data from the TSCOE support these findings but were not statistically significant. We observed a difference in NHD participation with only 150 Black individuals participating, representing 6% of total NHD participants. Our data indicate a difference between Black and White individuals both in the TSCOE and NHD showing that Black individuals are less likely to receive genetic testing, utilize topical mTOR therapy, and participate in TSC clinical trials. Conclusion: Given the observed trends, outreach and education to clinicians and other healthcare providers is needed to inform of these differences. Given that skin manifestations play an essential role in early recognition of TSC and timely referral to TSC specialists, we hope these data lead to improvement in the recognition of TSC in darker skinned individuals at earlier ages, thus improving clinical outcomes associated with TSC manifestations by optimizing treatment early in life.
RESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) is an autosomal dominant genetic disease affecting multiple body systems with wide variability in presentation. In 2013, Pediatric Neurology published articles outlining updated diagnostic criteria and recommendations for surveillance and management of disease manifestations. Advances in knowledge and approvals of new therapies necessitated a revision of those criteria and recommendations. METHODS: Chairs and working group cochairs from the 2012 International TSC Consensus Group were invited to meet face-to-face over two days at the 2018 World TSC Conference on July 25 and 26 in Dallas, TX, USA. Before the meeting, working group cochairs worked with group members via e-mail and telephone to (1) review TSC literature since the 2013 publication, (2) confirm or amend prior recommendations, and (3) provide new recommendations as required. RESULTS: Only two changes were made to clinical diagnostic criteria reported in 2013: "multiple cortical tubers and/or radial migration lines" replaced the more general term "cortical dysplasias," and sclerotic bone lesions were reinstated as a minor criterion. Genetic diagnostic criteria were reaffirmed, including highlighting recent findings that some individuals with TSC are genetically mosaic for variants in TSC1 or TSC2. Changes to surveillance and management criteria largely reflected increased emphasis on early screening for electroencephalographic abnormalities, enhanced surveillance and management of TSC-associated neuropsychiatric disorders, and new medication approvals. CONCLUSIONS: Updated TSC diagnostic criteria and surveillance and management recommendations presented here should provide an improved framework for optimal care of those living with TSC and their families.