Suboptimal activation of CD8(+) T cells by melanoma-derived altered peptide ligands: role of Melan-A/MART-1 optimized analogues.

Suboptimal activation of T lymphocytes by tumor cells may contribute to the failure of the immune system to control tumor growth. We recently demonstrated that Melan-A/MART-1-reactive CTLs can be anergized by peptide analogues with partial agonist/antagonist functions, which selectively impair interleukin (IL)-2 release. Here we analyze the potential expression of partial agonist/antagonist peptides by tumor cells and their role in suboptimal T-cell activation. HLA-bound peptide fractions were eluted from HLA-A*0201/Melan-A/MART-1(+) melanoma cells and analyzed for reconstitution of the MART-1-specific T-cell epitope. Among the peptide fractions able to induce IFN-gamma release by MART-1-specific T cells, only fraction 43-44 activated IL-2 production by anti-MART-1 T cells, whereas the remaining two fractions acted as peptide antagonists by inhibiting IL-2 release in response to the native epitope. A comparable down-modulation of IL-2 release could also be induced by the MART-1-derived peptide 32-40, previously identified in one of the two anergizing fractions. A substantial deficit in IL-2 release was additionally detected in tumor-specific CD8(+) T cells infiltrating melanoma lesions. To overcome IL-2 impairment by peptide antagonists, anti-MART-1 T cells were generated by in vitro sensitization with the two optimized analogues Melan-A/MART-1(27-35) 1L (with superagonist features) and Melan-A/MART-1(26-35) 2L (with improved HLA-A*0201 binding). T cells raised with the superagonist Melan-A/MART-1(27-35) 1L showed resistance to the inhibition of IL-2 release mediated by melanoma-derived peptide fractions, whereas Melan-A/MART-1(26-35) 2L-specific T cells appeared to be as sensitive as T cells raised with the parental epitope. This resistance was associated with the enhanced ability of Melan-A/MART-1(27-35) 1L-specific T cells to release IL-2. Taken together, these data indicate that melanoma cells can process and present on their surface peptides inhibiting optimal T-cell activation against immunodominant epitopes and that the usage of optimized peptide analogues could represent a promising approach for overcoming tumor-induced immunosuppression and possibly designing more successful vaccines for cancer patients.

The CD4(+) T-cell response of melanoma patients to a MAGE-A3 peptide vaccine involves potential regulatory T cells.

Melanoma patients were injected with various vaccines containing a MAGE-A3 peptide presented by HLA-DP4. Anti-MAGE-A3.DP4 T cells were not detectable in the blood before vaccination, but their frequencies after vaccination ranged from 2 x 10(-6) to 2 x 10(-3) among the CD4(+) blood T lymphocytes of the patients. The CD4(+) blood T lymphocytes that stained ex vivo with HLA-DP4 tetramers folded with the MAGE-A3 peptide were selected by flow cytometry and amplified under clonal conditions. About 5% of the CD4(+) T-cell clones that recognized the MAGE-A3.DP4 antigen had a CD25(+) phenotype in the resting state. These CD25(+) clones had a high capacity to suppress the proliferation of another T-cell clone after peptide stimulation in vitro. Most of them had high FOXP3 expression in the resting state and an unmethylated FOXP3 intron 1. They produced active transforming growth factor-beta but none of cytokines IFN-gamma, interleukin-2 (IL-2), IL-4, IL-5, and IL-10. About 20% of CD25(-) clones had a significant but lower suppressive activity. Most of the CD25(-) clonal populations contained cells that expressed FOXP3 in the resting state, but FOXP3 demethylation was not observed. We conclude that MAGE-A3.DP4 vaccination can produce CD4(+) T cells that may exert regulatory T-cell function in vivo.

Vaccination of a melanoma patient with mature dendritic cells pulsed with MAGE-3 peptides triggers the activity of nonvaccine anti-tumor cells.

We previously characterized the CTL response of a melanoma patient who experienced tumor regression following vaccination with an ALVAC virus coding for a MAGE-A3 Ag. Whereas anti-vaccine CTL were rare in the blood and inside metastases of this patient, anti-tumor CTL recognizing other tumor Ags, mainly MAGE-C2, were 100 times more frequent in the blood and considerably enriched in metastases following vaccination. In this study we report the analysis of the CTL response of a second melanoma patient who showed a mixed tumor response after vaccination with dendritic cells pulsed with two MAGE-A3 antigenic peptides presented, respectively, by HLA-A1 and HLA-DP4. Anti-MAGE-3.A1 CD8 and anti-MAGE-3.DP4 CD4 T cells became detectable in the blood after vaccination at a frequency of approximately 10(-5) among the CD8 or CD4 T cells, respectively, and they were slightly enriched in slowly progressing metastases. Additional anti-tumor CTL were present in the blood at a frequency of 2x10(-4) among the CD8 T cells and, among these, an anti-MAGE-C2 CTL clone was detected only following vaccination and was enriched by >1,000-fold in metastases relative to the blood. The striking similarity of these results with our previous observations further supports the hypothesis that the induction of a few anti-vaccine T cells may prime or restimulate additional anti-tumor T cell clones that are mainly responsible for the tumor regression.

A polyclonal anti-vaccine CD4 T cell response detected with HLA-DP4 multimers in a melanoma patient vaccinated with MAGE-3.DP4-peptide-pulsed dendritic cells.

During the last few years, HLA class I tetramers have been successfully used to demonstrate anti-vaccine CD8 CTL proliferation in cancer patients vaccinated with tumor antigens. Frequencies of CTL as low as 10(-6) among CD8 cells were observed even in patients showing tumor regression. Little is known about the role of tumor-antigen-specific CD4 T cells in the context of these anti-vaccine responses. Therefore, we developed a very sensitive approach using fluorescent class-II-peptide multimers to detect antigen-specific CD4 T cells in vaccinated cancer patients. We produced HLA-DP4 multimers loaded with the MAGE-3(243-258) peptide and used them to stain ex vivo PBL from melanoma patients injected with dendritic cells pulsed with several class I and class II tumor antigenic peptides, including the MAGE-3(243-258) peptide. The multimer(+) CD4 T cells were sorted and amplified in clonal conditions; specificity was assessed by their ability to secrete IFN-gamma upon contact with the MAGE-3 antigen. We detected frequencies of about 1x10(-6) anti-MAGE-3.DP4 cells among CD4 cells. A detailed analysis of one patient showed an anti-MAGE-3.DP4 CD4 T cell amplification of at least 3000-fold upon immunization. TCR analysis of the clones from this patient demonstrated a polyclonal response against the MAGE-3 peptide.

Monitoring of anti-vaccine CD4 T cell frequencies in melanoma patients vaccinated with a MAGE-3 protein.

Quantitative evaluation of T cell responses of patients receiving antitumoral vaccination with a protein is difficult because of the large number of possible HLA-peptide combinations that could be targeted by the response. To evaluate the responses of patients vaccinated with protein MAGE-3, we have developed an approach that involves overnight stimulation of blood T cells with autologous dendritic cells loaded with the protein, sorting by flow cytometry of the T cells that produce IFN-gamma, cloning of these cells, and evaluation of the number of T cell clones that secrete IFN-gamma upon stimulation with the Ag. An important criterion is that T cell clones must recognize not only stimulator cells loaded with the protein, but also stimulator cells transduced with the MAGE-3 gene, so as to exclude the T cells that recognize contaminants generated by the protein production system. Using this approach it is possible to measure T cell frequencies as low as 10(-6). We analyzed the frequencies of anti-vaccine CD4 T cells in five metastatic melanoma patients who had been injected with a MAGE-3 protein without adjuvant and showed evidence of tumor regression. Anti-MAGE-3 CD4 T cells were detected in one of the five patients. The frequency of the anti-MAGE-3 CD4 T cells was estimated at 1/60,000 of the CD4 T cells in postvaccination blood samples, representing at least an 80-fold increase in the frequency found before immunization. The frequencies of one anti-MAGE-3 CD4 T cell clonotype were confirmed by PCR analysis on blood lymphocytes. The 13 anti-MAGE-3 clones, which corresponded to five different TCR clonotypes, recognized the same peptide presented by HLA-DR1.

Identification of a mutated receptor-like protein tyrosine phosphatase kappa as a novel, class II HLA-restricted melanoma antigen.

Recent studies increasingly point to a pivotal role of CD4(+) T cells in human anti-tumor immune response. Here we show that lymphocytes purified from a tumor-infiltrated lymph node of a melanoma patient that had remained disease free for 10 years after surgical resection of a lymph node metastasis comprised oligoclonal class II HLA-restricted CD4(+) T cells recognizing the autologous tumor cells in vitro. In fact, the CD4(+) T cell clones isolated from these lymphocytes displayed a tumor-specific, cytotoxic activity in addition to a Th1-like cytokine profile. By a genetic approach, a peptide derived from a mutated receptor-like protein tyrosine phosphatase kappa was identified as a novel HLA-DR10-restricted epitope for all the melanoma-specific CD4(+) T cell clones. The immunogenic peptide was shown to contain the mutated residue that was crucial for T cell recognition and activation. Moreover, a systemic immunity against the mutated peptide was detectable in the patient's peripheral blood T lymphocytes obtained during the disease-free period of follow-up. These findings further support the relevance of CD4(+) T cells directed against mutated epitopes in tumor immunity and provide the rationale for a possible usage of mutated, tumor-specific Ags for immunotherapy of human cancer.