Enhancing Kidney Transplantation and the Role of Xenografts: Report of a Scientific Workshop Sponsored by the National Kidney Foundation.

Chronic kidney disease affects an estimated 37 million people in the United States; of these,>800,000 have end-stage renal disease requiring chronic dialysis or a kidney transplant to survive. Despite efforts to increase the donor kidney supply, approximately 100,000 people are registered on the kidney transplant wait-list with no measurable decrease over the past 2 decades. The outcomes of kidney transplantation are significantly better than for chronic dialysis: kidney transplant recipients have lower rates of mortality and cardiovascular events and better quality of life, but wait-list time matters. Time on dialysis waiting for a deceased-donor kidney is a strong independent risk factor for outcomes after a kidney transplant. Deceased-donor recipients with wait-list times on dialysis of<6 months have graft survival rates equivalent to living-donor recipients with waitlist times on dialysis of>2 years. In 2021,>12,000 people had been on the kidney transplant waitlist for ≥5 years. As the gap between the demand for and availability of donor kidneys for allotransplantation continues to widen, alternative strategies are needed to provide a stable, sufficient, and timely supply. A strategy that is gaining momentum toward clinical application is pig-to-human kidney xenotransplantation. This report summarizes the proceedings of a meeting convened on April 11-12, 2022, by the National Kidney Foundation to review and assess the state of pig-to-human kidney xenotransplantation as a potential cure for end-stage renal disease.

Xenotransplantation and exotransplantation: Strategies to expand the number of donor organs.

Cardiovascular disease is common and has a high mortality. Due to the limited number of organs available for orthotopic heart transplantation, alternative therapies have received intense interest. In this commentary we contrast xenotransplantation and blastocyst complementation to produce pigs that will serve as donors for organ transplantation. These strategies hold tremendous promise and have the potential to provide an unlimited number of organs for chronic, terminal diseases.

Mechanisms and strategies to promote cardiac xenotransplantation.

End stage heart failure is a terminal disease, and the only curative therapy is orthotopic heart transplantation. Due to limited organ availability, alternative strategies have received intense interest for treatment of patients with advanced heart failure. Recent studies using gene-edited porcine organs suggest that cardiac xenotransplantation may provide a future source of organs. In this review, we highlight the historical milestones for cardiac xenotransplantation and the gene editing strategies designed to overcome immunological barriers, which have culminated in a recent cardiac pig-to-human xenotransplant. We also discuss recent results of studies on the engineering of human-porcine chimeric organs that may provide an alternative and complementary strategy to overcome some of the major immunological barriers to producing a new source of transplantable organs.

Cutaneous leukocyte lineages in tolerant large animal and immunosuppressed clinical vascularized composite allograft recipients.

Vascularized composite allografts (VCAs) can restore fully functional anatomic units in patients with limb amputations or severe facial tissue loss. However, acute rejection of the skin is frequently observed and underscores the importance of developing tolerance induction protocols. In this study, we have characterized the skin immune system in VCAs. We demonstrate infiltration of recipient leukocytes, regardless of rejection status, and in tolerant mixed hematopoietic chimeras, the co-existence of these cells with donor leukocytes in the absence of rejection. Here we characterize the dermal T cell and epidermal Langerhans cell components of the skin immune system in our porcine model of VCA tolerance, and the kinetics of cutaneous chimerism in both of these populations in VCAs transplanted to tolerant and nontolerant recipients, as well as in host skin. Furthermore, in biopsies from the first patient to receive a hand transplant in our program, we demonstrate the presence of recipient T cells in the skin of the transplanted limb in the absence of clinical or histological evidence of rejection.

Expression of human CD47 in pig glomeruli prevents proteinuria and prolongs graft survival following pig-to-baboon xenotransplantation.

BACKGROUND: Nephrotic syndrome is a common complication of pig-to-baboon kidney xenotransplantation (KXTx) that adversely affects outcomes. We have reported that upregulation of CD80 and down-regulation of SMPDL-3b in glomeruli have an important role in the development of proteinuria following pig-to-baboon KXTx. Recently we found induced expression of human CD47 (hCD47) on endothelial cells and podocytes isolated from hCD47 transgenic (Tg) swine markedly reduced phagocytosis by baboon and human macrophages. These observations led us to hypothesize that transplanting hCD47 Tg porcine kidneys could overcome the incompatibility of the porcine CD47-baboon SIRPα interspecies ligand-receptor interaction and prevent the development of proteinuria following KXTx. METHODS: Ten baboons received pig kidneys with vascularized thymic grafts (n = 8) or intra-bone bone marrow transplants (n = 2). Baboons were divided into three groups (A, B, and C) based on the transgenic expression of hCD47 in GalT-KO pigs. Baboons in Group A received kidney grafts with expression of hCD47 restricted to glomerular cells (n = 2). Baboons in Group B received kidney grafts with high expression of hCD47 on both glomerular and tubular cells of the kidneys (n = 4). Baboons in Group C received kidney grafts with low/no glomerular expression of hCD47, and high expression of hCD47 on renal tubular cells (n = 4). RESULTS: Consistent with this hypothesis, GalT-KO/hCD47 kidney grafts with high expression of hCD47 on glomerular cells developed minimal proteinuria. However, high hCD47 expression in all renal cells including renal tubular cells induced an apparent destructive inflammatory response associated with upregulated thrombospondin-1. This response could be avoided by a short course of weekly anti-IL6R antibody administration, resulting in prolonged survival without proteinuria (mean 170.5 days from 47.8 days). CONCLUSION: Data showed that transgenic expression of hCD47 on glomerular cells in the GalT-KO donor kidneys can prevent xenograft nephropathy, a significant barrier for therapeutic applications of xenotransplantation. The ability to prevent nephrotic syndrome following KXTx overcomes a critical barrier for future clinical applications of KXTx.

Pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic study of a clinically effective anti-CD2 monoclonal antibody.

The humanized IgG1κ monoclonal antibody siplizumab and its rat parent monoclonal IgG2b antibody BTI-322 are directed against the CD2 antigen. Siplizumab is species-specific, reacting with human and chimpanzee cells but not with cells from any other species, including other non-human primates. Because siplizumab treatment has recently shown great potential in clinical transplantation, we now present the results of our previous pharmacokinetic, pharmacodynamic and safety studies of both antibodies. Fourteen chimpanzees received 1-3 doses of 0.143 to 5.0 mg/kg iv The effects were followed with flow cytometry on peripheral lymphocytes and staining of lymph nodes. Side effects were recorded. Serum antibody concentrations were followed. Across the doses, a rapid, transient depletion of CD2, CD3, CD4 and CD8 lymphocytes and NK cells was observed for both antibodies. Immune reconstitution was more rapid for BTI-322 compared to siplizumab. Paracortical lymph node T cell depletion was moderate, estimated at 45% with doses of >0.6 mg/kg. Restoration of lymph node architecture was seen after two weeks to two months for all animals. All four subjects receiving BTI-322 experienced AEs on the first dosing day, while the eight subjects dosed with siplizumab experienced few mild, transient AEs. Infusion with siplizumab and BTI-322 resulted in rapid depletion of CD2+ cells in circulation and tissue. Siplizumab had a longer t1/2 and fewer AEs compared to BTI-322.

Intra-bone bone marrow transplantation from hCD47 transgenic pigs to baboons prolongs chimerism to >60 days and promotes increased porcine lung transplant survival.

BACKGROUND: We have recently demonstrated that human-CD47 (hCD47) expressed on endothelial cells of porcine lung xenografts extended median graft survival from 3.5 days to 8.7 days in baboons. Intra-bone bone marrow transplantation (IBBMTx) in a pig-to-baboon model was previously shown to markedly prolong the duration of macrochimerism up to 21 days from 1 to 4 days by intravenous BMTx. We now examined whether the use of hCD47 transgenic (Tg) BM further prolonged the duration of chimerism following IBBMTx. We then tested if lung xenograft survival was prolonged following IBBMTx. METHODS: Baboons received GalTKO-hCD47/hCD55Tg (n = 5) or -hCD55Tg (n = 1) or -hCD46/HLA-E Tg (n = 1) pig IBBMTx. Macrochimerism, anti-pig T cells and antibody responses were assessed. Animals received lung xenografts from either hCD47+ or hCD47- porcine lungs 1-3 months later. RESULTS: All baboons that received hCD47Tg porcine IBBM maintained durable macrochimerism >30 days, and two maintained chimerism for >8 weeks. Notably, anti-pig antibody levels decreased over time and anti-pig cellular unresponsiveness developed following IBBMTx. Lungs from hCD47Tg IBBMTx matched pigs were transplanted at day 33 or day 49 after IBBMTx. These animals showed extended survival up to 13 and 14 days, while animals that received lungs from hCD47 negative pigs displayed no prolonged survival (1-4 days). CONCLUSION: This is the first report demonstrating durable macrochimerism beyond 8 weeks, as well as evidence for B cell tolerance in large animal xenotransplantation. Using hCD47Tg pigs as both IBBMTx and lung donors prolongs lung xenograft survival. However, additional strategies are required to control the acute loss of lung xenografts.

Safety and pharmacodynamics of anti-CD2 monoclonal antibody treatment in cynomolgus macaques - an experimental study.

Anti-CD2 treatment provides targeted immunomodulatory properties that have demonstrated clinical usefulness to condition the immune system and to treat transplant rejection. The treatment is species-specific due to structural CD2 antigen differences between nonhuman primates and humans. Herein, we report the safety profile and efficacy of two modifications of the same anti-CD2 monoclonal antibody in cynomolgus macaques. Twelve subjects received one i.v. anti-CD2 (of rat or rhesus type) dose each, range 1-4 mg/kg, and were followed for 1-7 days. Treatment effects were evaluated with flow cytometry on peripheral blood and histopathological evaluation of secondary lymphoid organs. In vitro inhibitory activity on primary MHC disparate mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLRs) was determined. Upon anti-CD2 treatment, CD4+ , CD8+ memory subsets were substantially depleted. Naïve T cells and Tregs were relatively spared and exhibited lower CD2 expression than memory T cells. Early immune reconstitution was noted for naïve cells, while memory counts had not recovered after one week. Both antibodies displayed a concentration-dependent MLR inhibition. Lymph node examination revealed no significant lymphocyte depletion. None of the animals experienced any significant study drug-related adverse events. This study outlines the safety and pharmacodynamic profile of primate-specific anti-CD2 treatment, relevant for translation of anti-CD2-based animal models into clinical trials.

Development of transplantable B-cell lymphomas in the MHC-defined miniature swine model.

BACKGROUND: Establishment of transplantable tumors in clinically relevant large animals allows translational studies of novel cancer therapeutics. METHODS: Here we describe the establishment, characterization, and serial transplantation of a naturally occurring B-cell lymphoma derived from a unique, highly inbred sub-line of Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-defined miniature swine. RESULTS: The lymphoblastic cell line (LCL) originated from peripheral blood of a 2.5 year old female swine leukocyte antigen (SLA)dd-inbred miniature swine breeder demonstrating clinical signs of malignancy. Flow cytometric phenotypic analysis of subclones derived from the original cell line revealed surface markers commonly expressed in a B-cell lineage neoplasm. A subclone of the original LCL was transplanted into mildly-conditioned histocompatible miniature swine and immunocompromised NOD.Cg-Prkdc scid Il2rg tm1Wjl /SzJ (NSG) mice. Tissue and blood samples harvested 2 weeks following subcutaneous and intravenous injection in a highly inbred SLAdd pig were cultured for tumor growth and phenotypic analysis before serial transfer into NSG mice. Evidence of tumor growth in vivo was found in all tumor cell recipients. In vitro growth characteristics and surface phenotype were comparable between the original and serially transplanted tumor cell lines. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate the feasibility of developing a large-animal transplantable tumor model using cells derived from spontaneously occurring hematologic malignancies within the highly inbred miniature swine herd.

Amino acid and lipid profiles following pig-to-primate liver xenotransplantation.

As outcomes in clinical liver transplantation steadily improve, demand continues to exceed supply, leading to a substantial disparity in organ availability. The translation of porcine liver xenotransplantation (LXT) into a clinical reality aims to address this dilemma. Our laboratory has previously established an applicable model of α-1,3-galactosyltransferase knockout (GalT-KO) pig-to-primate LXT with continuous human coagulation factor infusion and costimulation blockade. This report aims to further investigate the post-LXT lipid and amino acid metabolism profile in our longest surviving recipients (25 and 29 days). Experimental samples and control samples, consisting of pre-transplant porcine and baboon serum and plasma, were analyzed for standard lipid profiles and for amino acid levels. Lipid profiles of LXT recipients remained stable following xenotransplantation compared to donor porcine baseline levels. Amino acid concentrations also remained similar to baseline controls, with the exception of a 3-fold increase in l-ornithine and more than a 10-fold decrease in l-arginine post-transplant when compared to both porcine and baboon baseline levels. The observed changes in l-arginine are consistent with prior studies investigating the effects of graft preservation injury following liver transplantation. These results indicate that the porcine liver can maintain most biochemical profiles stably post-operatively in baboons and suggest that arginine supplementation post-LXT may potentially be useful for further prolongation of xenograft survival.

Transplantation tolerance through mixed chimerism: From allo to xeno.

To date, the only successful means of achieving allogeneic transplantation tolerance in the clinic has involved induction of mixed lymphohematopoietic chimerism. Such chimerism was first achieved in mice and subsequently in large animals, including miniature swine, monkeys and most recently humans. The mechanism of tolerance has differed between models, involving both deletional and regulatory mechanisms, in varying proportions, depending on the model. Considerable progress has also been made toward induction of tolerance across the xenogeneic pig-to-primate barrier, although complete success has not yet been achieved. The two approaches toward xenograft tolerance currently being investigated both involve establishment of a mixture of host and donor cells in the thymus, in one case through administration of donor bone marrow to the recipient and in the other through vascularized donor thymus transplantation to a thymectomized recipient. Hopefully, a combination of these approaches may provide an effective means for achieving full tolerance and thereby bringing xenograft organ transplantation to the clinic.

Absence of interaction between porcine endogenous retrovirus and porcine cytomegalovirus in pig-to-baboon renal xenotransplantation in vivo.

BACKGROUND: Studies of xenotransplantation from swine have identified porcine viruses as potential barriers to clinical trials. The biology of these viruses has not been extensively investigated in the in vivo xeno-environment. Enhancement of viral gene expression by viral and cellular factors acting in trans has been demonstrated for certain viruses, including bidirectional interactions between human herpesviruses and endogenous (HERV) and exogenous (HIV) retroviruses. Both porcine cytomegalovirus (PCMV) and porcine endogenous retrovirus (PERV) infections have been identified in xenografts from swine. PERV receptors exist on human cells with productive infection in vitro in permissive human target cell lines. PCMV is largely species-specific with infection restricted to the xenograft in pig-to-baboon transplants. It is unknown whether coinfection by PCMV affects the replication of PERV within xenograft tissues which might have implications for the risk of retroviral infection in the human host. METHODS: A series of 11 functioning, life-supporting pig-to-baboon kidney xenografts from PERV-positive miniature swine were studied with and without PCMV co-infection. Frozen biopsy samples were analyzed using quantitative, real-time PCR with internal controls. RESULTS: PERV replication was not altered in the presence of PCMV coinfection (P = .70). The absence of variation with coinfection was confirmed when PERV quantitation was expressed relative to simultaneous cellular GAPDH levels with or without PCMV coinfection (P = .59). CONCLUSIONS: PCMV coinfection does not alter the replication of PERV in life-supporting renal xenotransplantation in vivo in baboons.

GalT-KO pig lungs are highly susceptible to acute vascular rejection in baboons, which may be mitigated by transgenic expression of hCD47 on porcine blood vessels.

BACKGROUND: Despite recent progress in survival times of xenografts in non-human primates, there are no reports of survival beyond 5 days of histologically well-aerated porcine lung grafts in baboons. Here, we report our initial results of pig-to-baboon xeno-lung transplantation (XLTx). METHODS: Eleven baboons received genetically modified porcine left lungs from either GalT-KO alone (n = 3), GalT-KO/humanCD47(hCD47)/hCD55 (n = 3), GalT-KO/hD47/hCD46 (n = 4), or GalT-KO/hCD39/hCD46/hCD55/TBM/EPCR (n = 1) swine. The first 2 XLTx procedures were performed under a non-survival protocol that allowed a 72-hour follow-up of the recipients with general anesthesia, while the remaining 9 underwent a survival protocol with the intention of weaning from ventilation. RESULTS: Lung graft survivals in the 2 non-survival animals were 48 and >72 hours, while survivals in the other 9 were 25 and 28 hours, at 5, 5, 6, 7, >7, 9, and 10 days. One baboon with graft survival >7 days, whose entire lung graft remained well aerated, was euthanized on POD 7 due to malfunction of femoral catheters. hCD47 expression of donor lungs was detected in both alveoli and vessels only in the 3 grafts surviving >7, 9, and 10 days. All other grafts lacked hCD47 expression in endothelial cells and were completely rejected with diffuse hemorrhagic changes and antibody/complement deposition detected in association with early graft loss. CONCLUSIONS: To our knowledge, this is the first evidence of histologically viable porcine lung grafts beyond 7 days in baboons. Our results indicate that GalT-KO pig lungs are highly susceptible to acute humoral rejection and that this may be mitigated by transgenic expression of hCD47.

Upregulation of CD80 on glomerular podocytes plays an important role in development of proteinuria following pig-to-baboon xeno-renal transplantation - an experimental study.

We have previously reported that co-transplantation of the kidney with vascularized donor thymus from α-1,3-galactosyltransferase gene knockout pigs with an anti-CD154 with rituximab-based regimen led to improved xenograft survival in baboons with donor-specific unresponsiveness. However, nephrotic syndrome emerged as a complication in which the glomeruli showed mild mesangial expansion with similarities to minimal change disease (MCD) in humans. Since MCD is associated with CD80 expression in glomeruli and elevated urinary excretion, we evaluated a potential role for CD80 in xenograft nephropathy. Study 1 confirmed high urinary CD80 excretion in nephrotic animals with renal xenografts showing CD80 expression in glomeruli. In Study 2, baboons receiving xenografts received CTLA4-Ig once a week from the second postoperative week or no CTLA4-Ig. The non-CTLA4-Ig group developed severe proteinuria with modest mesangial expansion with high urinary excretion of CD80 and documented CD80 expression in glomerular podocytes. All of the recipients in non-CTLA4-Ig groups had to be euthanized before POD 60. In contrast, CTLA4-Ig group showed a marked reduction in proteinuria and survived significantly longer, up to 193 days. These results demonstrate that anti-CD80 targeted therapy represents a promising strategy for reduction of proteinuria following renal xeno-transplantation with improved survival.

The effects of galectin-3 depletion apheresis on induced skin inflammation in a porcine model.

Galectin-3 (Gal-3), a ß-galactoside-binding lectin that is expressed in mammalian cells, is known to modulate several biological functions such as cell-cell adhesion, macrophage activation, angiogenesis, metastasis, and fibrosis. The goal of this study was to evaluate the ability of Gal-3 depletion apheresis using an adsorption column with immobilized anti-Gal-3-antibody to reduce inflammation induced by Complete Freund's Adjuvant injection in a skin inflammation porcine model. Here, we report that plasma perfusion by apheresis through a Gal-3 binding immuno-affinity column reduces plasma Gal-3 levels to below limits of quantitative detection, and results in significant decrease in skin inflammation, including degree and duration of inflammatory lesions. Human plasma was tested ex vivo and found to be efficiently depleted using the anti-Gal-3 affinity column. This study demonstrates the potential of Gal-3 depletion apheresis as a therapeutic method for inflammation-mediated disease, supporting continued research in this area for clinical application.

Testing of microencapsulated porcine hepatocytes in a new model of fulminant liver failure in baboons.

BACKGROUND: There is no standard therapy for acute liver failure. Hepatocyte transplantation has been proposed for temporary liver function support, while the injured liver regenerates or while waiting for transplantation. We have previously shown such efficacy for microencapsulated porcine hepatocytes in mice with fulminant liver failure. We aimed to establish a large animal model for fulminant liver failure to assess the efficacy of microencapsulated porcine hepatocytes in temporary liver function support. METHODS: The model was developed in baboons; for testing microencapsulated hepatocytes, the best condition was 75% hepatectomy and 60 min warm ischemia time. Fulminant liver failure was characterized by steep increases in liver biochemical parameters, severe steatosis, and massive hepatocyte necrosis during the first 10 days. Hepatocytes from miniature swine were microencapsulated in alginate-poly-l-lysine microspheres, and transplanted intraperitoneally immediately after hepatectomy and warm ischemia (80-120 mL packed hepatocytes in 200-350 mL microspheres, about 30%-50% of the baboon's native liver volume). RESULTS: In the control group, three of five animals were sacrificed after 6-10 days because of fulminant liver failure, and two of five animals recovered normal liver function and survived until elective euthanasia (28 days). In the treatment group of four animals, one animal developed liver failure but survived to 21 days, and three animals recovered completely with normal liver function. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that microencapsulated porcine hepatocytes provide temporary liver function support in baboons with fulminant liver failure. These data support development of this cell therapy product toward clinical trials in patients with acute liver failure.

Methods for the detection and serum depletion of porcine galectin-3.

BACKGROUND: Circulating galectin-3 (Gal-3) is elevated in systemic inflammatory disorders, fibrotic diseases, and in cancers. Gal-3 is a promising cancer target where it promotes tumorigenesis and metastasis, as well as in renal, pulmonary, hepatic, and cardiovascular diseases, because of its role as a driver of fibrotic remodeling. This reports goal was to establish methods for the detection and removal of porcine Gal-3 that will enable further studies of the therapeutic potential of Gal-3 depletion by apheresis in porcine disease models. The long-term aim is to develop a safe, effective method of removing Gal-3 via apheresis as a standalone therapeutic tool and as an adjuvant to other therapies. METHODS: Purified recombinant porcine Gal-3 was prepared and used as the standard for development of a porcine Gal-3 enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Different affinity column matrices that incorporated either a rat IgG2a anti-Gal-3 monoclonal antibody or carbohydrate ligand were assessed for depletion of Gal-3 from porcine serum. RESULTS: A porcine Gal-3 ELISA with a linear range from 0.3 to 20 ng/mL was able to detect native porcine Gal-3 in both fetal (∼150-200 ng/mL) and juvenile (∼5-15 ng/mL) porcine serum samples. Use of an anti-Gal-3 monoclonal antibody affinity column depleted Gal-3 from porcine serum to at least 313 pg/mL, the limit of ELISA detection. CONCLUSIONS: Methods have been developed for the detection and depletion of porcine Gal-3. These methods will be used to study the specific effects of Gal-3 depletion via apheresis in porcine models of disease.