Utility of genetic testing for prenatal presentations of hypophosphatasia.

Hypophosphatasia (HPP) is a rare inherited disease affecting bone and dental mineralization due to loss-of-function mutations in the ALPL gene encoding the tissue nonspecific alkaline phosphatase (TNSALP). Prenatal benign HPP (PB HPP) is a rare form of HPP characterized by in utero skeletal manifestations that progressively improve during pregnancy but often still leave symptoms after birth. Because the prenatal context limits the diagnostic tools, the main difficulty for clinicians is to distinguish PB HPP from perinatal lethal HPP, the most severe form of HPP. We previously attempted to improve genotype phenotype correlation with the help of a new classification of variants based on functional testing. Among 46 perinatal cases detected in utero or in the neonatal period for whose ALPL variants could be classified, imaging alone was thought to clearly diagnose severe lethal HPP in 35 cases, while in 11 cases, imaging abnormalities could not distinguish between perinatal lethal and BP HPP. We show here that our classification of ALPL variants may improve the ability to distinguish between perinatal lethal and PB HPP in utero.

Genetic analysis of adults heterozygous for ALPL mutations.

Hypophosphatasia (HPP) is a rare inherited metabolic bone disease due to a deficiency of the tissue nonspecific alkaline phosphatase isoenzyme (TNSALP) encoded by the ALPL gene. Patients have consistently low serum alkaline phosphatase (AP), so that this parameter is a good hallmark of the disease. Adult HPP is heterogeneous, and some patients present only mild nonpathognomonic symptoms which are also common in the general population such as joint pain, osteomalacia and osteopenia, chondrocalcinosis, arthropathy and musculoskeletal pain. Adult HPP may be recessively or dominantly inherited; the latter case is assumed to be due to the dominant negative effect (DNE) of missense mutations derived from the functional homodimeric structure of TNSALP. However, there is no biological argument excluding the possibility of other causes of dominant HPP. Rheumatologists and endocrinologists are increasingly solicited for patients with low AP and nonpathognomonic symptoms of HPP. Many of these patients are heterozygous for an ALPL mutation and a challenging question is to determine if these symptoms, which are also common in the general population, are attributable to their heterozygous ALPL mutation or not. In an attempt to address this question, we reviewed a cohort of 61 adult patients heterozygous for an ALPL mutation. Mutations were distinguished according to their statistical likelihood to show a DNE. One-half of the patients carried mutations predicted with no DNE and were slightly less severely affected by the age of onset, serum AP activity and history of fractures. We hypothesized that these mutations result in another mechanism of dominance or are recessive alleles. To identify other genetic factors that could trigger the disease phenotype in heterozygotes for potential recessive mutations, we examined the next-generation sequencing results of 32 of these patients for a panel of 12 genes involved in the differential diagnosis of HPP or candidate modifier genes of HPP. The heterozygous genotype G/C of the COL1A2 coding SNP rs42524 c.1645C > G (p.Pro549Ala) was associated with the severity of the phenotype in patients carrying mutations with a DNE whereas the homozygous genotype G/G was over-represented in patients carrying mutations without a DNE, suggesting a possible role of this variant in the disease phenotype. These preliminary results support COL1A2 as a modifier gene of HPP and suggest that a significant proportion of adult heterozygotes for ALPL mutations may have unspecific symptoms not attributable to their heterozygosity.

Molecular diagnosis of hypophosphatasia and differential diagnosis by targeted Next Generation Sequencing.

Hypophosphatasia (HPP) is a rare inherited skeletal dysplasia due to loss of function mutations in the ALPL gene. The disease is subject to an extremely high clinical heterogeneity ranging from a perinatal lethal form to odontohypophosphatasia affecting only teeth. Up to now genetic diagnosis of HPP is performed by sequencing the ALPL gene by Sanger methodology. Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) and campomelic dysplasia (CD) are the main differential diagnoses of severe HPP, so that in case of negative result for ALPL mutations, OI and CD genes had often to be analyzed, lengthening the time before diagnosis. We report here our 18-month experience in testing 46 patients for HPP and differential diagnosis by targeted NGS and show that this strategy is efficient and useful. We used an array including ALPL gene, genes of differential diagnosis COL1A1 and COL1A2 that represent 90% of OI cases, SOX9, responsible for CD, and 8 potentially modifier genes of HPP. Seventeen patients were found to carry a mutation in one of these genes. Among them, only 10 out of 15 cases referred for HPP carried a mutation in ALPL and 5 carried a mutation in COL1A1 or COL1A2. Interestingly, three of these patients were adults with fractures and/or low BMD. Our results indicate that HPP and OI may be easily misdiagnosed in the prenatal stage but also in adults with mild symptoms for these diseases.

A molecular-based estimation of the prevalence of hypophosphatasia in the European population.

The prevalence of hypophosphatasia (HP), a rare metabolic disorder due to loss-of-function mutations in the ALPL gene, has never been estimated in the European population. Only one published study evaluated the incidence of severe HP at 1/100,000 in Canada 53 years ago. Moderate forms of hypophosphatasia (mHP), including HP with moderate bone features and the mildest form odontohypophosphatasia, reflect both recessive and dominant inheritance, and are therefore expected to be more frequent than severe forms of HP. Here we estimated both the prevalences of severe and mHP in European populations. The prevalence of severe HP was estimated at 1/300,000 on the basis of the number of cases tested in our laboratory and originating from France during the period 2000-2009. The prevalence of mHP was then estimated by using the proportion of dominant mutations among severe alleles and by estimating the penetrance of the disease in heterozygotes for dominant mutations. According to a genetic model with four alleles resulting in 10 distinct genotypes, the prevalence of dominant mHP in the European population was estimated to be 1/6370, pointing out that mHP is much more frequent than severe HP.

Hypophosphatasia: a genetic-based nosology and new insights in genotype-phenotype correlation.

Hypophosphatasia (HPP) is caused by pathogenic variants in the ALPL gene. There is a large continuum in the severity, ranging from a lethal perinatal form to dental issues. We analyzed a cohort of 424 HPP patients from European geographic origin or ancestry. Using 3D modeling and results of functional tests we classified ALPL pathogenic variants according to their dominant negative effect (DNE) and their severity. The cohort was described by the genotypes resulting from alleles s (severe recessive), Sd (severe dominant), and m (moderate). Many recurrent variants showed a regional anchor pointing out founder effects rather than multiple mutational events. Homozygosity was an aggravating factor of the severity and moderate alleles were rare both in number and frequency. Pathogenic variants with DNE were found in both recessive and dominant HPP. Sixty percent of the adults tested were heterozygous for a variant showing no DNE, suggesting another mechanism of dominance like haploinsufficiency. Adults with dominant HPP without DNE were found statistically less severely affected than adults with DNE variants. Adults with dominant HPP without DNE represent a new clinical entity mostly diagnosed from 2010s, characterized by nonspecific signs of HPP and low alkaline phosphatase, and for which a high prevalence is expected. In conclusion, the genetic composition of our cohort suggests a nosology with 3 clinical forms: severe HPP is recessive and rare, moderate HPP is recessive or dominant and more common, and mild HPP, characterized by low alkaline phosphatase and unspecific clinical signs, is dominantly inherited and very common.

Mild forms of hypophosphatasia mostly result from dominant negative effect of severe alleles or from compound heterozygosity for severe and moderate alleles.

BACKGROUND: Mild hypophosphatasia (HPP) phenotype may result from ALPL gene mutations exhibiting residual alkaline phosphatase activity or from severe heterozygous mutations exhibiting a dominant negative effect. In order to determine the cause of our failure to detect a second mutation by sequencing in patients with mild HPP and carrying on a single heterozygous mutation, we tested the possible dominant effect of 35 mutations carried by these patients. METHODS: We tested the mutations by site-directed mutagenesis. We also genotyped 8 exonic and intronic ALPL gene polymorphisms in the patients and in a control group in order to detect the possible existence of a recurrent intronic mild mutation. RESULTS: We found that most of the tested mutations exhibit a dominant negative effect that may account for the mild HPP phenotype, and that for at least some of the patients, a second mutation in linkage disequilibrium with a particular haplotype could not be ruled out. CONCLUSION: Mild HPP results in part from compound heterozygosity for severe and moderate mutations, but also in a large part from heterozygous mutations with a dominant negative effect.

Delayed transport of tissue-nonspecific alkaline phosphatase with missense mutations causing hypophosphatasia.

Hypophosphatasia is a rare genetic disease characterized by diminished bone and tooth mineralization due to deficient activity of tissue-nonspecific alkaline phosphatase (TNSALP). The disease is clinically heterogeneous due to different mutations in the TNSALP gene. In order to determine whether mutated TNSALP proteins may be sequestered, degraded, or subjected to delay in their transport to the cell membrane, we built a plasmid expressing a YFP-TNSALP fluorescent fusion protein allowing the observation of cellular localization in live cells by fluorescence confocal microscopy at different time points after transfection. We studied five mutants (c. 571G>A, c. 653T>C, c. 746G>T, c. 1363G>A and c. 1468A>T) exhibiting various levels of in vitro residual enzymatic activity. While the wild-type protein reached the membrane within the first 24h after transfection, the mutants reached the membrane with delays of 24, 48 or 72 h. For all of the tested mutations, accumulation of the mutated proteins, mainly in the Golgi apparatus, was observed. We concluded that reduced ALP activity of these TNSALP mutants results from structural disturbances and delay in membrane anchoring, and not from compromised catalytic activity.

Characterization of missense mutations and large deletions in the ALPL gene by sequencing and quantitative multiplex PCR of short fragments.

Hypophosphatasia is a rare inherited bone disorder characterized by defective bone and dental mineralization and deficiency of serum and liver/bone/kidney alkaline phosphatase activity. The disease is due to mutations in the alkaline phosphatase liver-type (ALPL) gene. Gross deletions or insertions have not previously been reported in this gene. We report here the characterization of nine novel ALPL gene mutations in a series of 8 patients affected by various forms of hypophosphatasia. The newly discovered mutations included five missense mutations (c.368C --> A, c.814C--> T, c.1196C--> T, c.1199C--> T, c.1283G--> C), two small deletions (c.797_802del, c.1044_1055del), and two large deletions. The large deletions were detected by quantitative multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of short fluorescent fragments (QMPSF). We conclude that QMPSF slightly reduces the proportion of undetected mutations in hypophosphatasia and improves genetic counselling in the affected families.

Evidence of a founder effect for the tissue-nonspecific alkaline phosphatase (TNSALP) gene E174K mutation in hypophosphatasia patients.

Hypophosphatasia is a rare inborn error of metabolism characterised by defective bone mineralisation caused by a deficiency of liver-, bone- or kidney-type alkaline phosphatase due to mutations in the tissue-nonspecific alkaline phosphatase (TNSALP) gene. The clinical expression of the disease is highly variable, ranging from stillbirth with a poorly mineralised skeleton to pathologic skeletal fractures which develop in late adulthood only. This clinical heterogeneity is due to the strong allelic heterogeneity in the TNSALP gene. We found that mutation E174K is the most frequent in Caucasian patients, and that it was carried by 31% of our patients with mild hypophosphatasia. Because the mutation was found in patients of various geographic origins, we investigated whether it had a unique origin or rather multiple origins due to recurrence of de novo mutations. Three intragenic polymorphisms, S93S, 472+12delG and V505A, were genotyped in patients carrying E174K and in normal unrelated individuals. Our results show that all the E174K mutations are carried by a common ancestral haplotype, also found at low frequency in normal and hypophosphatasia chromosomes. We conclude that the TNSALP gene E174K mutation is the result of a relatively ancient ancestral mutation that occurred on a single chromosome in the north of Western Europe and spread throughout the rest of Europe and into the New World as a result of human migration.

Hypophosphatasia: molecular testing of 19 prenatal cases and discussion about genetic counseling.

OBJECTIVE: We studied hypophosphatasia (HP) mutations in 19 cases prenatally detected by ultrasonography without familial history of HP. We correlated the mutations with the reported ultrasound signs, and discussed genetic counseling with regard to the particular dominantly inherited prenatal benign form of HP. METHOD: The coding sequence of the tissue nonspecific alkaline phosphatase (TNSALP) gene was analyzed by DNA sequencing, and 3D modeling was used to locate the mutated amino acids with regard to the functional domains of TNSALP. RESULTS: Although reported ultrasound signs were heterogeneous, two mutated alleles were found in 18 of the 19 cases studied, indicating recessive transmission of the disease. Functional domains of TNSALP were affected by 74% of missense mutations. In all the cases, including one with only a heterozygous mutation, molecular, biological, and familial data do not corroborate the hypothesis of prenatal benign HP. The mutation c.1133A>T observed in the prenatal benign form of HP and common in USA was not found in this series. CONCLUSION: The results point out the prenatally detectable allelic heterogeneity of HP. The nature of the detected mutations and the evidence of recessive inheritance do not support these cases being affected with prenatal benign HP.

Characterization of 11 novel mutations in the tissue non-specific alkaline phosphatase gene responsible for hypophosphatasia and genotype-phenotype correlations.

Hypophosphatasia is an inherited disorder caused by mutations in the bone alkaline phosphatase gene. We report here 11 new mutations responsible for hypophosphatasia. Four of them were deletions or insertions resulting in frameshift, two affected a donor splice site and five were missense mutations. Site-directed mutagenesis and transfection experiments of missense mutations showed that the mutations resulted in loss of most enzymatic activity, confirming the disease-causing role of these mutations. Analysis of the 3D model of tissue non-specific alkaline phosphatase showed that among the five missense mutations, one affected a residue in the crown domain and four affected residues located in the calcium-binding region. Alignment of the protein sequences of the calcium-binding region from 11 species showed that the four residues coordinating the calcium ion and the residues affected by the missense mutations described here are conserved in vertebrates. Together, our results confirm the functional role of the calcium site and suggest that its function is likely to be specific to vertebrates.

Five years of molecular diagnosis of Fragile X syndrome (1997-2001): a collaborative study reporting 95% of the activity in France.

The Fragile X syndrome is the most common cause of inherited mental retardation. Clinical features are neither specific nor constant and molecular diagnosis is thus widely used since the characterization of the causal mutation in 1991. The aim of this project was to study the evolution of Fragile X diagnosis in France. A preliminary study of the efficiency of screening for the Fragile X mutation in mentally retarded probands with no previous familial diagnosis was done in the Strasbourg's laboratory with a comparison between data from 1991-1994 and 1997-2000. This study showed an improvement in the use of the Fragile X testing regarding the probands' age at diagnosis and the recruitment of sporadic and female cases. To avoid possible bias in clinical referrals and to evaluate the situation nation wide, this study was enlarged to 28 of the 30 laboratories involved in the Fragile X diagnosis in France from 1997 to 2001 (20,816 probands tested, data representative of 95% of the national screening activity). Median age at diagnosis decreased from 9.2 to 5.8 (average 16-11.6y) between the 1991-1994 and the 1997-2001 studies. Over this period, 477 new families were diagnosed with Fragile X, representing 2.8% of tested male probands (417/14,867) and 1.0% of tested female probands (60/5,949). Forty one percent of positive cases corresponded to probands with a familial history of mental retardation, compared to 66% in the initial (1991-1994) study. We also discuss issues concerning premutations discovered in affected individuals and in females with premature ovarian failure (POF).