Lower respiratory tract infections in adults: non-antibiotic prescriptions by GPs.

BACKGROUND: The AIR II study is a prospective multicentre assessing management of lower respiratory tract infections (LRTIs) in adults by general practitioners (GPs). Epidemiological studies generally address the prescriptions of antibiotics. To our knowledge, little is known about the real impact of non-antibiotic therapeutic prescriptions (defined here as co-prescriptions) in LRTI. Therefore, the aim of the study was to evaluate non-antibiotic prescriptions in LRTIs. METHODS: Two thousand general practitioners (GPs) were randomly selected and asked to participate in each of 30 predefined areas covering mainland France. The patient's sociomedical record was completed by the GP during the consultation and sent to the data processing centre at the same time as an anonymous copy of his prescription. The GP also had to report the inclusion by telephone and agree to a telephone appointment with an interviewer. RESULTS: GPs (n = 3144) reported 5469 evaluable cases. Pneumonia accounted for 9.6% of diagnoses, acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis 14.9% and acute bronchitis 72.5%. Antibiotics were prescribed to 96.5% of patients. In addition to the 5270 prescriptions of antibiotics, co-prescriptions proved to be twice as numerous as prescriptions of antibiotics (10,027 prescriptions for 5115 patients). Mucomodifiers, steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and bronchodilators were significantly more prescribed in AECB than others. Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and antitussives were significantly more prescribed in acute bronchitis than AECB or CAP. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that recommendations of management in LRTIs need to take into account co-prescriptions.

[Management of lower respiratory tract infections by general practitioners in France]. / Prise en charge des infections respiratoires basses en médecine générale en France.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to describe the diagnostic and therapeutic strategies used by general practitioners (GPs) in patients with lower respiratory tract infections (LRTI). METHODS: Four hundred fifty GPs practicing in France participated in the study; they included 804 patients. The GP recorded social and demographic data and their prescription on a data sheet and responded to a phone questionnaire about their strategy. RESULTS: Most of the LRTI were acute bronchitis (72%); pneumonia and acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis were observed respectively in 11% of the patients recruited. Diagnostic criteria used by the GPs were generally auscultation signs in patients with fever, cough and expectoration. Specialized advice (always a chest physician) and hospitalization were exceptional. Prescription of complementary exams was strongly related to the diagnosis of pneumonia (OR = 33.3; CI0.95: 15.48-70.4). Sick leaves were related to general symptoms (fever, asthenia). Antibiotics were prescribed in 95.7% of the patients, mainly aminopenicillin (40.4%) and macrolides (33.2%). Nonsteroidal or steroidal antiinflammatory drugs were prescribed in 72.5% of the patients irrespective of the LRTI diagnosis. DISCUSSION: The fact that GPs do not often refer patients to specialists or order hospitalization confirms their important role in setting up recommendations. It would also be necessary to develop an education program on better use of antibiotics targeted to GPs and patients.