Identification of best protein crystallization methods by molecular dynamics (MD).

A full-atom structure of a protein provides an important piece of information for molecular biologists, but has to be complemented by further knowledge concerning its conformational mobility and functional properties. Some scholars have proposed to integrate proteomics-derived data (mainly obtained with techniques like X-ray and NMR crystallography) with protein bioinformatics and computational approaches, above all molecular dynamics (MD), in order to gain better elucidations about proteins. MD simulations have been applied to different areas of protein sciences, but so far few efforts have been made to couple MD with an understanding of the different crystallization techniques that have been proposed during the decades, like classical vapor diffusion hanging drop and its variants (such as sitting drop), in space- and LB (Langmuir-Blodgett)-based crystallization procedures. Using MD, we show here that the optimal protein crystallization techniques prove to be significantly those based on the LB nanotemplate and on space when compared to the classical vapour diffusion hanging drop and its variants.

A quality comparison of protein crystals grown under containerless conditions generated by diamagnetic levitation, silicone oil and agarose gel.

High-quality crystals are key to obtaining accurate three-dimensional structures of proteins using X-ray diffraction techniques. However, obtaining such protein crystals is often a challenge. Several containerless crystallization techniques have been reported to have the ability to improve crystal quality, but it is unknown which is the most favourable way to grow high-quality protein crystals. In this paper, a quality comparison of protein crystals which were grown under three containerless conditions provided by diamagnetic levitation, silicone oil and agarose gel was conducted. A control experiment on a vessel wall was also simultaneously carried out. Seven different proteins were crystallized under the four conditions, and the crystal quality was assessed in terms of the resolution limit, the mosaicity and the Rmerge. It was found that the crystals grown under the three containerless conditions demonstrated better morphology than those of the control. X-ray diffraction data indicated that the quality of the crystals grown under the three containerless conditions was better than that of the control. Of the three containerless crystallization techniques, the diamagnetic levitation technique exhibited the best performance in enhancing crystal quality. This paper is to our knowledge the first report of improvement of crystal quality using a diamagnetic levitation technique. Crystals obtained from agarose gel demonstrated the second best improvement in crystal quality. The study indicated that the diamagnetic levitation technique is indeed a favourable method for growing high-quality protein crystals, and its utilization is thus potentially useful in practical efforts to obtain well diffracting protein crystals.

A universal indicator dye pH assay for crystallization solutions and other high-throughput applications.

In protein crystallization, as well as in many other fields, it is known that the pH at which experiments are performed is often the key factor in the success or failure of the trials. With the trend towards plate-based high-throughput experimental techniques, measuring the pH values of solutions one by one becomes prohibitively time- and reagent-expensive. As part of an HT crystallization facility, a colour-based pH assay that is rapid, uses very little reagent and is suitable for 96-well or higher density plates has been developed.

Thermofluor-based optimization strategy for the stabilization and crystallization of Campylobacter jejuni desulforubrerythrin.

Desulforubrerythrin from Campylobacter jejuni has recently been biochemical and spectroscopically characterized. It is a member of the rubrerythrin family, and it is composed of three structural domains: the N-terminal desulforedoxin domain with a non-heme iron center, followed by a four-helix bundle domain harboring a binuclear iron center and finally a C-terminal rubredoxin domain. To date, this is the first example of a protein presenting this kind of structural domain organization, and therefore the determination of its crystal structure may unveil unexpected structural features. Several attempts were made in order to obtain protein crystals, but always without success. As part of our strategy the thermofluor method was used to increase protein stability and its propensity to crystallize. This approach has been recently used to optimize protein buffer formulation, thus yielding more stable and homogenous protein samples. Thermofluor has also been used to identify cofactors/ligands or small molecules that may help stabilize native protein states. A successful thermofluor approach was used to select a pH buffer condition that allowed the crystallization of Campylobacter jejuni desulforubrerythrin, by screening both buffer pH and salt concentration. A buffer formulation was obtained which increased the protein melting temperature by 7°C relatively to the initial purification buffer. Desulforubrerythrin was seen to be stabilized by lower pH and high salt concentration, and was dialyzed into the new selected buffer, 100mM MES pH 6.2, 500mM NaCl. This stability study was complemented with a second thermofluor assay in which different additives were screened. A crystallization screening was carried out and protein crystals were rapidly obtained in one condition. Protein crystal optimization was done using the same additive screening. Interestingly, a correlation between the stability studies and crystallization experiments using the additive screening could be established. The work presented here shows an elegant example where thermofluor was shown to be a key biophysical method that allowed the identification of an improved buffer formulation and the applicability of this technique to increase the propensity of a protein to crystallize is discussed.

Physico-mechanical and stability evaluation of carbamazepine cocrystal with nicotinamide.

The focus of this investigation was to prepare the cocrystal of carbamazepine (CBZ) using nicotinamide as a coformer and to compare its preformulation properties and stability profile with CBZ. The cocrystal was prepared by solution cooling crystallization, solvent evaporation, and melting and cryomilling methods. They were characterized for solubility, intrinsic dissolution rate, chemical identification by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, crystallinity by differential scanning calorimetry, powder X-ray diffraction, and morphology by scanning electron microscopy. Additionally, mechanical properties were evaluated by tensile strength and Heckel analysis of compacts. The cocrystal and CBZ were stored at 40°C/94% RH, 40°C/75% RH, 25°C/60% RH, and 60°C to determine their stability behavior. The cocrystals were fluffy, with a needle-shaped crystal, and were less dense than CBZ. The solubility profiles of the cocrystals were similar to CBZ, but its intrinsic dissolution rate was lower due to the high tensile strength of its compacts. Unlike CBZ, the cocrystals were resistant to hydrate transformation, as revealed by the stability studies. Plastic deformation started at a higher compression pressure in the cocrystals than CBZ, as indicated by the high yield pressure. In conclusion, the preformulation profile of the cocrystals was similar to CBZ, except that it had an advantageous resistance to hydrate transformation.

Investigation into stability of poly(vinyl alcohol)-based Opadry® II films.

Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA)-based formulations are used for pharmaceutical tablet coating with numerous advantages. Our objective is to study the stability of PVA-based coating films in the presence of acidic additives, alkaline additives, and various common impurities typically found in tablet formulations. Opadry® II 85F was used as the model PVA-based coating formulation. The additives and impurities were incorporated into the polymer suspension prior to film casting. Control and test films were analyzed before and after exposure to 40°C/75% relative humidity. Tests included film disintegration, size-exclusion chromatography, thermal analysis, and microscopy. Under stressed conditions, acidic additives (hydrochloric acid (HCl) and ammonium bisulfate (NH(4)HSO(4))) negatively impacted Opadry® II 85F film disintegration while NaOH, formaldehyde, and peroxide did not. Absence of PVA species from the disintegration media corresponded to an increase in crystallinity of PVA for reacted films containing HCl. Films with NH(4)HSO(4) exhibited slower rate of reactivity and less elevation in melting temperature with no clear change in melting enthalpy. Acidic additives posed greater risk of compromise in disintegration of PVA-based coatings than alkaline or common impurities. The mechanism of acid-induced reactivity due to the presence of acidic salts (HCl vs. NH(4)HSO(4)) may be different.

Polymorph transformation in paracetamol monitored by in-line NIR spectroscopy during a cooling crystallization process.

The reliable in-line monitoring of pharmaceutical processes has been regarded as a key tool toward the full implementation of process analytical technology. In this study, near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy was examined for use as an in-line monitoring method of the paracetamol cooling crystallization process. The drug powder was dissolved in ethanol-based cosolvent at 60°C and was cooled by 1°C/min for crystallization. NIR spectra acquired by in-line measurement were interpreted by principal component analysis combined with off-line characterizations via X-ray diffraction, optical microscopy, and transmission electron microscopy. The whole crystallization process appeared to take place in three steps. A metastable form II polymorph of paracetamol was formed and transformed into the stable form I polymorph on the way to the growth of pure form I by cooling crystallization. These observations are consistent with a previous focused beam reflectance method-based study (Barthe et al., Cryst Growth Des 8:3316-3322, 2008).

Iterative screen optimization maximizes the efficiency of macromolecular crystallization.

Advances in X-ray crystallography have streamlined the process of determining high-resolution three-dimensional macromolecular structures. However, a rate-limiting step in this process continues to be the generation of crystals that are of sufficient size and quality for subsequent diffraction experiments. Here, iterative screen optimization (ISO), a highly automated process in which the precipitant concentrations of each condition in a crystallization screen are modified based on the results of a prior crystallization experiment, is described. After designing a novel high-throughput crystallization screen to take full advantage of this method, the value of ISO is demonstrated by using it to successfully crystallize a panel of six diverse proteins. The results suggest that ISO is an effective method to obtain macromolecular crystals, particularly for proteins that crystallize under a narrow range of precipitant concentrations.

Improvement of the quality of lumazine synthase crystals by protein engineering.

Icosahedral macromolecules have a wide spectrum of potential nanotechnological applications, the success of which relies on the level of accuracy at which the molecular structure is known. Lumazine synthase from Bacillus subtilis forms a 150 A icosahedral capsid consisting of 60 subunits and crystallizes in space group P6(3)22 or C2. However, the quality of these crystals is poor and structural information is only available at 2.4 A resolution. As classical strategies for growing better diffracting crystals have so far failed, protein engineering has been employed in order to improve the overexpression and purification of the molecule as well as to obtain new crystal forms. Two cysteines were replaced to bypass misfolding problems and a charged surface residue was replaced to force different molecular packings. The mutant protein crystallizes in space group R3, with unit-cell parameters a = b = 313.02, c = 365.77 A, alpha = beta = 90.0, gamma = 120 degrees , and diffracts to 1.6 A resolution.

SIMBAD: a sequence-independent molecular-replacement pipeline.

The conventional approach to finding structurally similar search models for use in molecular replacement (MR) is to use the sequence of the target to search against those of a set of known structures. Sequence similarity often correlates with structure similarity. Given sufficient similarity, a known structure correctly positioned in the target cell by the MR process can provide an approximation to the unknown phases of the target. An alternative approach to identifying homologous structures suitable for MR is to exploit the measured data directly, comparing the lattice parameters or the experimentally derived structure-factor amplitudes with those of known structures. Here, SIMBAD, a new sequence-independent MR pipeline which implements these approaches, is presented. SIMBAD can identify cases of contaminant crystallization and other mishaps such as mistaken identity (swapped crystallization trays), as well as solving unsequenced targets and providing a brute-force approach where sequence-dependent search-model identification may be nontrivial, for example because of conformational diversity among identifiable homologues. The program implements a three-step pipeline to efficiently identify a suitable search model in a database of known structures. The first step performs a lattice-parameter search against the entire Protein Data Bank (PDB), rapidly determining whether or not a homologue exists in the same crystal form. The second step is designed to screen the target data for the presence of a crystallized contaminant, a not uncommon occurrence in macromolecular crystallography. Solving structures with MR in such cases can remain problematic for many years, since the search models, which are assumed to be similar to the structure of interest, are not necessarily related to the structures that have actually crystallized. To cater for this eventuality, SIMBAD rapidly screens the data against a database of known contaminant structures. Where the first two steps fail to yield a solution, a final step in SIMBAD can be invoked to perform a brute-force search of a nonredundant PDB database provided by the MoRDa MR software. Through early-access usage of SIMBAD, this approach has solved novel cases that have otherwise proved difficult to solve.

Pre-assembled clusters distort crystal nucleation kinetics in supersaturated lysozyme solutions.

Efficient determination of three-dimensional protein structures is critical for unraveling structure-function relationships and for supporting targeted drug design. A major impediment to these efforts is our lack of control over the nucleation and growth of high-quality protein crystals for X-ray structure determinations. While basic research on protein crystal growth mechanisms has provided valuable new insights, studies of crystal nucleation have been plagued by inconsistent and outright contradictory results. Using dynamic light scattering and SDS gel electrophoresis, we have investigated possible causes of these inconsistencies. We find that commercial sources of lyophilized hen-egg white lysozyme (HEWL) used in nucleation studies contain significant populations of large (approximately 100 nm), pre-assembled lysozyme clusters that can readily evade standard assays of sample purity. In supersaturated solutions, these clusters act as heterogeneous nucleation centers that enhance the rate of crystal nucleation and significantly deteriorate the quality of macroscopic crystals.

Optimization of crystallization conditions for biological macromolecules.

For the successful X-ray structure determination of macromolecules, it is first necessary to identify, usually by matrix screening, conditions that yield some sort of crystals. Initial crystals are frequently microcrystals or clusters, and often have unfavorable morphologies or yield poor diffraction intensities. It is therefore generally necessary to improve upon these initial conditions in order to obtain better crystals of sufficient quality for X-ray data collection. Even when the initial samples are suitable, often marginally, refinement of conditions is recommended in order to obtain the highest quality crystals that can be grown. The quality of an X-ray structure determination is directly correlated with the size and the perfection of the crystalline samples; thus, refinement of conditions should always be a primary component of crystal growth. The improvement process is referred to as optimization, and it entails sequential, incremental changes in the chemical parameters that influence crystallization, such as pH, ionic strength and precipitant concentration, as well as physical parameters such as temperature, sample volume and overall methodology. It also includes the application of some unique procedures and approaches, and the addition of novel components such as detergents, ligands or other small molecules that may enhance nucleation or crystal development. Here, an attempt is made to provide guidance on how optimization might best be applied to crystal-growth problems, and what parameters and factors might most profitably be explored to accelerate and achieve success.

Simultaneous quantitative analysis of mebendazole polymorphs A-C in powder mixtures by DRIFTS spectroscopy and ANN modeling.

In the present study, a simple method, based on diffuse reflectance FTIR spectroscopy (DRIFTS) and artificial neural network (ANN) modeling is developed for the simultaneous quantitative analysis of mebendazole polymorphs A-C in powder mixtures. Spectral differences between the polymorphs are elucidated by computationally assisted band assignments on the basis of quantum chemical calculations, and subsequently, the spectra are preprocessed by calculation of 1st and 2nd derivatives. Then ANN models are fitted after PCA compression of the input space. Finally the predictive performance of the ANNs is compared with that of PLS regression. It was found that simultaneous quantitative analysis of forms A-C in powder mixtures is possible by fitting an ANN model to the 2nd derivative spectra even after PCA compression of the data (RMSEP of 1.75% for form A, 1.85% for B, and 1.65% for C), while PLS regression, applied for comparison purposes, results in acceptable predictions only within the 700-1750cm(-1) spectral range and after direct orthogonal signal correction (DOSC), with RMSEP values of 2.69%, 2.68%, and 3.40% for forms A, B, and C, respectively. Application of the ANN to commercial samples of raw material and formulation (suspension) proved its suitability for the prediction of polymorphic content.

Improving quality and harvest period of protein crystals for structure-based drug design: effects of a gel and a magnetic field on bovine adenosine deaminase crystals.

The overall crystal quality as well as the harvest period of bovine adenosine deaminase containing a zinc ion at the active centre has been compared in three different environments: crystallization as a control, crystallization with agarose gel and crystallization in a high magnetic field. In crystallization with agarose gel, the probability of obtaining high-quality crystals was somewhat increased, but the harvest period was elongated. On the other hand, in crystallization in a magnetic field, the probability of obtaining high-quality crystals was greatly increased. Furthermore, the harvest period for crystal growth in a magnetic field was much shorter than that with agarose gel.