Immune Mechanisms Underlying Susceptibility to Endotoxin Shock in Aged Hosts: Implication in Age-Augmented Generalized Shwartzman Reaction.

In recent decades, the elderly population has been rapidly increasing in many countries. Such patients are susceptible to Gram-negative septic shock, namely endotoxin shock. Mortality due to endotoxin shock remains high despite recent advances in medical care. The generalized Shwartzman reaction is well recognized as an experimental endotoxin shock. Aged mice are similarly susceptible to the generalized Shwartzman reaction and show an increased mortality accompanied by the enhanced production of tumor necrosis factor (TNF). Consistent with the findings in the murine model, the in vitro Shwartzman reaction-like response is also age-dependently augmented in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells, as assessed by enhanced TNF production. Interestingly, age-dependently increased innate lymphocytes with T cell receptor-that intermediate expression, such as that of CD8+CD122+T cells in mice and CD57+T cells in humans, may collaborate with macrophages and induce the exacerbation of the Shwartzman reaction in elderly individuals. However, endotoxin tolerance in mice, which resembles a mirror phenomenon of the generalized Shwartzman reaction, drastically reduces the TNF production of macrophages while strongly activating their bactericidal activity in infection. Importantly, this effect can be induced in aged mice. The safe induction of endotoxin tolerance may be a potential therapeutic strategy for refractory septic shock in elderly patients.

Contribution of protein Z and protein Z-dependent protease inhibitor in generalized Shwartzman reaction.

OBJECTIVE: Sepsis, a leading cause of mortality in critically ill patients, is closely linked to the excessive activation of coagulation and inflammation. Protein Z, a cofactor for the protein Z-dependent protease inhibitor, enhances the inhibition of coagulation factor Xa, and protein Z-dependent protease inhibitor inhibits factor XIa in a protein Z-independent fashion. The functions of protein Z and protein Z-dependent protease inhibitor in the inflammatory and coagulant responses to septic illness have not been evaluated. DESIGN: For induction of generalized Shwartzman reaction, dorsal skinfold chamber-equipped mice were challenged twice with lipopolysaccharide (0.05 mg/kg on day -1 and 5 mg/kg body weight 24 hr later). Time-matched control animals received equal volumes of saline. SETTING: University research laboratory. SUBJECTS, INTERVENTIONS, AND MEASUREMENTS: Using intravital fluorescence microscopy in protein Z-dependent protease inhibitor deficient (ZPI) and protein Z deficient (PZ) mice, as well as their wild-type littermates (ZPI, PZ), kinetics of light/dye-induced thrombus formation and microhemodynamics were assessed in randomly chosen venules. Plasma concentrations of chemokine (C-X-C motif) ligand 1, interleukin-6, and interleukin-10 were measured. Liver and lung were harvested for quantitative analysis of leukocytic tissue infiltration and thrombus formation. MAIN RESULTS: After induction of generalized Shwartzman reaction, all mice showed significant impairment of microhemodynamics, including blood flow velocity, volumetric blood flow, and functional capillary density, as well as leukocytopenia and thrombocytopenia. Thrombus formation time was markedly prolonged after induction of generalized Shwartzman reaction in all mice, except of ZPI mice, which also had a significantly higher fraction of occluded vessels in liver sections. PZ mice developed the highest concentrations of interleukin-6 and interleukin-10 in response to generalized Shwartzman reaction and showed greater leukocytic tissue infiltration than their wild-type littermates. CONCLUSIONS: In this murine model of generalized Shwartzman reaction, protein Z-dependent protease inhibitor deficiency enhanced the thrombotic response to vascular injury, whereas protein Z deficiency increased inflammatory response.

Cholinergic stimulation blocks endothelial cell activation and leukocyte recruitment during inflammation.

Endothelial cell activation plays a critical role in regulating leukocyte recruitment during inflammation and infection. Based on recent studies showing that acetylcholine and other cholinergic mediators suppress the production of proinflammatory cytokines via the alpha7 nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (alpha7 nAChR) expressed by macrophages and our observations that human microvascular endothelial cells express the alpha7 nAChR, we examined the effect of cholinergic stimulation on endothelial cell activation in vitro and in vivo. Using the Shwartzman reaction, we observed that nicotine (2 mg/kg) and the novel cholinergic agent CAP55 (12 mg/kg) inhibit endothelial cell adhesion molecule expression. Using endothelial cell cultures, we observed the direct inhibitory effects of acetylcholine and cholinergic agents on tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-induced endothelial cell activation. Mecamylamine, an nAChR antagonist, reversed the inhibition of endothelial cell activation by both cholinergic agonists, confirming the antiinflammatory role of the nAChR cholinergic pathway. In vitro mechanistic studies revealed that nicotine blocked TNF-induced nuclear factor-kappaB nuclear entry in an inhibitor kappaB (IkappaB)alpha- and IkappaBepsilon-dependent manner. Finally, with the carrageenan air pouch model, both vagus nerve stimulation and cholinergic agonists significantly blocked leukocyte migration in vivo. These findings identify the endothelium, a key regulator of leukocyte trafficking during inflammation, as a target of anti-inflammatory cholinergic mediators.

A cross-linked anti-TNF-α aptamer for neutralization of TNF-α-induced cutaneous Shwartzman phenomenon: A simple and novel approach for improving aptamers' affinity and efficiency.

To increase the efficiency of aptamers to their targets, a simple and novel method has been developed based on aptamer oligomerization. To this purpose, previously anti-human TNF-α aptamer named T1-T4 was trimerized through a trimethyl aconitate core for neutralization of in vitro and in vivo of TNF-α. At first, 54 mer T1-T4 aptamers with 5'-NH2 groups were covalently coupled to three ester residues in the trimethyl aconitate. In vitro activity of novel anti-TNF-α aptamer and its dissociation constant (Kd ) was done using the L929 cell cytotoxicity assay. In vivo anti-TNF-α activity of new oligomerized aptamer was assessed in a mouse model of cutaneous Shwartzman. Anchoring of three T1-T4 aptamers to trimethyl aconitate substituent results in formation of the 162 mer fragment, which was well revealed by gel electrophoresis. In vitro study indicated that the trimerization of T1-T4 aptamer significantly improved its anti-TNF-α activity compared to non-modified aptamers (P < 0.0001) from 40% to 60%. The determination of Kd showed that trimerization could effectively enhance Kd of aptamer from 67 nM to 36 nM. In vivo study showed that trimer aptamer markedly reduced mean scar size from 15.2 ± 1.2 mm to 1.6 ± 0.1 mm (P < 0.0001), which prevent the formation of skin lesions. In vitro and in vivo studies indicate that trimerization of anti-TNF-α aptamer with a novel approach could improve the anti-TNF-α activity and therapeutic efficacy. According to our findings, a new anti-TNF-α aptamer described here could be considered an appropriate therapeutic agent in treating several inflammatory diseases.

Prevention of the localized and generalized Shwartzman reactions by an anticomplementary agent, cobra venom factor.

Both localized and generalized Shwartzman reactions were induced in the same rabbits by simultaneous administration of preparatory intravenous and intradermal doses of endotoxin followed in 24 hr by the provocative dose. Control rabbits with more than 80% positive responses showed corresponding changes of platelet, white blood cell, fibrinogen, and hemolytic complement levels. Circulating fibrinogen and fibrin degradation products were detected shortly after the preparatory dose and persisted for at least 3 days. Rabbits given cobra venom anticomplementary factor showed hypocomplementemia (less than 10% of normal), leukocytosis, and elevated fibrinogen levels. After the administration of endotoxin, only one of 15 CVF-treated animals developed a Shwartzman reaction and that was mild. These rabbits showed only minor changes of platelet and fibrinogen levels throughout the experiment although their white blood cell responses were similar to those of the control group. No detectable fibrinogen and fibrin degradation products appeared in circulation, and the hemolytic complement activity increased gradually beginning with the preparatory dose of endotoxin. Thus depletion of terminal complement components (mainly C3) in rabbits is protective against the development of both localized and generalized Shwartzman reactions; its mechanism of action is probably through the sparing of platelets by inhibiting platelet-endotoxin interaction. The essential role of the complement system in Shwartzman reaction indicates that this coagulopathy probably represents a manifestation of immunologic injury.

Interferon gamma, a mediator of lethal lipopolysaccharide-induced Shwartzman-like shock reactions in mice.

The involvement of cytokines in the pathogenesis of a generalized, Shwartzman-like lethal inflammatory response to bacterial lipopolysaccharides (LPS) was studied by testing the ability of cytokines or neutralizing anticytokine antibodies to modify the course of the syndrome. The reaction was elicitable in non-SPF NMRI mice by two consecutive injections of S. marcescens LPS: a first injection in the footpad, followed after 24 h by an intravenous dose; the size and route of the preparatory LPS dose were found to be critical. Treatment with mAbs against IFN-gamma was found to completely prevent the reaction. Treatment with IFN-gamma on the other hand, rendered the mice more sensitive to elicitation of the reaction. In contrast, systemic administration of IFN-alpha/beta exerted a desensitizing effect. The role of endogenous cytokines in the pathogenesis of this generalized Shwartzman reaction was also documented by a study of the cytokine levels in the serum of the mice. In comparisons between mice given lethal and nonlethal induction schedules, a good correlation was found between mortality rates and height of IFN or TNF levels, but no correlation was seen with IL-6 levels. Also, in mice that were protected by anti-IFN-gamma antibody, serum IFN and TNF were undetectable, whereas IL-6 levels were as high as in unprotected mice. These data provide evidence that among the cytokines that govern the inflammatory response to LPS, endogenous IFN-gamma occupies a key position. These findings therefore also open perspectives for clinical application of IFN-gamma antagonists.

The role of the platelet in the generalized Shwartzman reaction.

Rabbits were injected with an antiplatelet serum to produce selective thrombocytopenia without inducing a significant alteration of their leukocyte counts. Thrombocytopenic levels persisted for 8 hr after the injection of platelet antiserum. During this time, the generalized Shwartzman reaction could not be provoked with the second injection of endotoxin. Since platelet phospholipid is required for the formation of plasma thromboplastin, the results indicate that platelets are essential to the evolution of the generalized Shwartzman reaction and endotoxin triggers the intrinsic rather than the extrinsic clotting system to elicit the lesions.

Necrotic inflammatory reaction induced by muramyl dipeptide in guinea pigs sensitized by tubercle bacilli.

In the course of studies aimed at determining whether MDP was antigenic or not, a hitherto unreported phenomenon was noticed. Injection (a provocative injection) of muramyl dipeptide (MDP) caused severe inflammation, with hemorrhage and necrosis in the footpads of guinea pigs, where tubercle bacilli in water-oil emulsion (a preparatory injection) had been injected 3-8 wk earlier. Sometimes the reaction was accompanied by generalized and fatal shock. Several related substances were tested, and only a combination of tubercle bacilli, or MDP plus proteins as the preparatory injection, and MDP as the provocative injection was found to induce this inflammatory necrotic reaction. Development of delayed hypersensitivity to protein antigens may be important for priming, but MDP and not the protein antigens provoked the reaction. This reaction was, so far, only observed in guinea pigs. Although this reaction appears to be similar to the Shwartzman reaction, the two reactions were found to differ from each other in several important points.

Role of meningococcal endotoxin in meningococcal purpura.

Enteric bacilli and meningococci (MGC) both contain potent endotoxins, but purpuric skin lesions indistinguishable from the experimental dermal Shwartzman reaction are much more common during meningococcal bacteremia than during bacteremia with enteric organisms. Highly purified lipopolysaccharides (LPS), virtually free of contamination by protein, RNA, and capsule, were extracted by a modification of the phenol-water technique from MGC (serogroups A, B, and C) and enteric bacilli (Escherichia coli 04 and 0:111, and Salmonella typhimurium). Polysaccharides in these LPS were similar by gas chromatography except for one galactose-deficient strain of MGC (135B). LPS from MGC and enterics were equally potent for the general Shwartzman reaction and mouse lethality, but LPS from MGC was 5-10 times more potent in inducing the dermal Shwartzman reaction. The greater skin potency of LPS from MGC explains the prominence of purpura in meningococcemia. Comparison of the properties of LPS may explain other differences in clinical syndromes caused by gram-negative bacteria.

Association between protective efficacy of anti-lipopolysaccharide (LPS) antibodies and suppression of LPS-induced tumor necrosis factor alpha and interleukin 6. Comparison of O side chain-specific antibodies with core LPS antibodies.

Two-core LPS antibodies, the rabbit J5 polyclonal antiserum and the human anti-lipid A IgM mAb HA-1A, did not improve the survival of mice challenged with E. coli O111 or P. aeruginosa 3, or with the LPS extracted from them, and did not decrease the incidence of Shwartzman reactions in rabbits challenged with O111 LPS. In contrast, O side chain-specific rabbit antisera were protective in these models. The protection afforded by O side chain-specific antisera against endotoxin lethality was associated with decreased LPS-induced serum TNF and IL-6 levels, whereas core LPS antibodies had no effect on TNF or IL-6 levels. The absence of reduction of LPS-induced cytokines levels by core LPS antibodies suggests that these antibodies are not able to prevent the interactions between LPS and target cells.

Resistance of natural killer T cell-deficient mice to systemic Shwartzman reaction.

The generalized Shwartzman reaction in mice which had been primed and challenged with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) depends on interleukin (IL)-12-induced interferon (IFN)-gamma production at the priming stage. We examined the involvement in the priming mechanism of the unique population of Valpha14 natural killer T (NKT) cells because they promptly produce IFN-gamma after IL-12 stimulation. We report here that LPS- or IL-12-primed NKT cell genetically deficient mice were found to be resistant to LPS-elicited mortality. This outcome can be attributed to the reduction of IFN-gamma production, because injection of recombinant mouse IFN-gamma, but not injection of IL-12, effectively primed the NKT cell-deficient mice. However, priming with high doses of LPS caused mortality of severe combined immunodeficiency, NKT cell-deficient, and CD1-deficient mice, indicating a major contribution of NKT cells to the Shwartzman reaction elicited by low doses of LPS, whereas at higher doses of LPS NK cells play a prominent role. These results suggest that the numerically small NKT cell population of normal mice apparently plays a mandatory role in the priming stage of the generalized Shwartzman reaction.

Interleukin 12, interferon gamma, and tumor necrosis factor alpha are the key cytokines of the generalized Shwartzman reaction.

The Shwartzman reaction is elicited by two injections of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in mice. The priming LPS injection is given in the footpad, whereas the lethal LPS challenge is given intravenously 24 h later. The injection of interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) or interleukin 12 (IL-12) instead of the LPS priming injection induced the lethal reaction in mice further challenged with LPS. Antibodies against IFN-gamma when given together with the priming agent, prevented the lethal reaction in mice primed with either LPS, IL-12, or IFN-gamma. Antibodies against IL-12, when given together with the priming agent, prevented the lethal reaction in mice primed with either LPS or IL-12 but not with IFN-gamma. These results strongly suggest that LPS induces the release of IL-12, that IL-12 induces the production of IFN-gamma, and that IFN-gamma is the cytokine that primes macrophages and other cell types. Upon LPS challenge, the lethal Shwartzman reaction is induced by a massive production of inflammatory cytokines that act on the target sites already sensitized by IFN-gamma. If mixtures of TNF and IL-1 or mixtures of TNF and IFN-gamma are used to challenge mice previously primed with IFN-gamma or IL-12, mortality is induced. In the same conditions, the individual cytokines or a mixture of IL-1 and IFN-gamma do not replace the LPS challenge. When the mice are primed with LPS, the combination of TNF, IL-1, and IFN-gamma induced only a partial mortality incidence suggesting that the involvement of other LPS-induced factors.

Biological properties of cell wall mucopeptide of hemolytic streptococci.

Several of the toxic properties of streptococcal mucopeptide have been studied in detail. Intravenous injection of as little as 1 microg of mucopeptide, solubilized by ultrasonic treatment, elicits a reproducible febrile response. Rabbits which are made tolerant to Escherichia coli endotoxin are only partially tolerant to the subsequent injection of streptococcal mucopeptide. Soluble mucopeptide was successfully employed to prepare and provoke the localized Shwartzman reaction. Intravenous injection of 80 microg of solubilized mucopeptide leads to diffuse cellular infiltration as well as focal areas of myocardial necrosis, surrounded by inflammatory cells.

Role of hypercoagulability in steroid-induced femoral head necrosis in rabbits.

BACKGROUND: The pathogenesis of femoral head necrosis is still uncertain. Both steroid treatment and hypercoagulopathy are considered risk factors. To investigate possible changes in coagulability and histology during steroid-induced osteonecrosis, we used a combination of the Shwartzman reaction and corticoid injections in rabbits to develop an animal model of femoral head necrosis. We studied blood coagulability and histopathological characteristics of the femoral head and liver. METHODS: A total of 30 rabbits were divided into three groups. In group A, rabbits were given two injections of lipopolysaccharide (40 microg/kg) at an interval of 24 h and were then immediately given one injection of prednisolone acetate (20 mg/kg). In group B, 10 rabbits were given one injection of prednisolone acetate (20 mg/kg). In group C, 10 rabbits were given no treatment and served as controls. At 1, 3, 7, 14, and 21 days after prednisolone injection, coagulability, blood lipid levels, and blood platelet levels were measured; and the femoral head and liver were removed for histopathological examination. RESULTS: At 24 h after the prednisolone injection in group A, coagulability and blood lipid levels were increased (P < 0.01), and blood platelet levels were decreased (P < 0.01). These abnormal levels were maintained throughout the entire observation period. Histologically, degeneration and necrosis of hepatocytes and osteocytes were found at day 21 after prednisolone injection in group A. In group B, coagulability and blood lipid levels were significantly increased by day 3 after treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Abnormal hypercoagulability might potentiate the thrombotic status and induce thrombus formation in the presence of steroid-induced necrosis of the femoral head.

Vascular lesions: possible pathogenetic basis of the generalized Shwartzman reaction.

Evidence of vascular injury was found in rabbits after a single small dose of endotoxin from Escherichia coli. Eighty percent of the treated animals developed circulating endothelial cells, leukopenia, and thrombocytopenia, and 50 percent had aortic endothelial lesions as determined by electron microscopy. Prior anticoagulation with heparin did not prevent this response. No control animals showed these abnormalities.

Detoxification of bacterial lipopolysaccharides (endotoxins) by a human neutrophil enzyme.

Lipopolysaccharides in the cell walls of Gram-negative bacteria elicit toxic as well as potentially beneficial inflammatory responses in animals. It is now reported that tissue toxicity caused by lipopolysaccharides is preferentially reduced by an enzymatic activity in human neutrophils. Acyloxyacyl hydrolysis removes fatty acyl chains that are linked to the hydroxyl groups of 3-hydroxytetradecanoyl residues in the bioactive lipid A moiety of the lipopolysaccharides. Maximal acyloxyacyl hydrolysis reduced lipopolysaccharide tissue toxicity, as measured in the dermal Shwartzman reaction, by a factor of 100 or more. In contrast, the ability of the deacylated lipopolysaccharides to stimulate B lymphocytes to divide was decreased only by a factor of 12. It is suggested that during tissue invasion by Gram-negative bacteria acyloxyacyl hydrolysis may be a defense mechanism that reduces the toxicity of lipopolysaccharides while preserving some of their potentially beneficial inflammatory and immune stimuli.

Pivotal advance: alpha-galactosylceramide induces protection against lipopolysaccharide-induced shock.

alpha-galactosylceramide, a natural killer T cell ligand, and its synthetic homolog, KRN7000, consistently influence IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha release, both mediators of LPS-induced shock. To modify the course of endotoxin shock, we injected KRN7000 at different time points of experimental systemic Shwartzman reaction. Mice treated with KRN7000 survived when it was injected within 2 h before and after LPS challenge. Mice survival was associated with low levels of T helper 1 (Th1) cytokines, such as IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha. By contrast, protection from endotoxin shock was associated with an increase of T helper 2 (Th2) cytokines, like IL-4 and IL-10. A role of Th2 cytokines in counteracting LPS-induced shock was supported by experiments in which the protection against Shwartzman reaction by KRN7000 was abrogated by in vivo coadministration of anti-Th2 cytokines antibodies. In addition, cytofluorimetric analysis showed that surviving animals have higher percentages of NKT-IL-10-positive cells and lower percentages of NKT-IFN-gamma and macrophages/TNF-alpha-stained cells than nonprotected mice. Taken together, our data demonstrate that KRN7000 treatment given at times near LPS challenge is protective for endotoxin shock inhibiting IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha release. Moreover, KRN7000-mediated protection occurs through an increased production of IL-4 and IL-10, which are mainly secreted by NKT cells. Since IFN-gamma release by NKT requires a longer TCR stimulation than that required for Th2 cytokines production, we demonstrate that timing of KRN7000 in vivo exposure affect the pattern of cytokines expression protecting animals by endotoxin shock.

Whatever happened to the Shwartzman phenomenon?

Ninety years ago, Gregory Shwartzman first reported an unusual discovery following the intradermal injection of sterile culture filtrates from principally Gram-negative strains from bacteria into normal rabbits. If this priming dose was followed in 24 h by a second intravenous challenge (the provocative dose) from same culture filtrate, dermal necrosis at the first injection site would regularly occur. This peculiar, but highly reproducible, event fascinated the microbiologists, hematologists, and immunologists of the time, who set out to determine the mechanisms that underlie the pathogenesis of this reaction. The speed of this reaction seemed to rule out an adaptive, humoral, immune response as its cause. Histopathologic material from within the necrotic center revealed fibrinoid, thrombo-hemorrhagic necrosis within small arterioles and capillaries in the micro-circulation. These pathologic features bore a striking resemblance to a more generalized coagulopathic phenomenon following two repeated endotoxin injections described 4 yr earlier by Sanarelli. This reaction came to be known as the generalized Shwartzman phenomenon, while the dermal reaction was named the localized or dermal Shwartzman reaction. A third category was later added, called the single organ or mono-visceral form of the Shwartzman phenomenon. The occasional occurrence of typical pathological features of the generalized Shwartzman reaction limited to a single organ is notable in many well-known clinical events (e.g., hyper-acute kidney transplant rejection, fulminant hepatic necrosis, or adrenal apoplexy in Waterhouse-Fredrickson syndrome). We will briefly review the history and the significant insights gained from understanding this phenomenon regarding the circuitry and control mechanisms responsible for disseminated intravascular coagulation, the vasculopathy and the immunopathy of sepsis.

Human antiserum for prevention of the local shwartzman reaction and death from bacterial lipopolysaccharides.

Bacterial lipopolysaccharides from dead bacteria have been blamed for the continuing high mortality from gram-negative infections despite antibiotic treatment. Because animal antiserum against these lipopolysaccharides has been shown to protect against several of the effects of endotoxin, we undertook the development of antiserum in human subjects. 21 men were immunized with a single injection of Salmonclla typhimurium or Escherichia coli 0:111 heat-killed cells and immune serum was collected at 2 wk. Preimmune serum was obtained as a control in all animal experiments. 1 ml antiserum given intravenously protected mice against a lethal intravenous dose of homologous endotoxin (P < 0.005 for both antisera). E. coli antiserum reduced the incidence of positive local Shwartzman reactions with E. coli endotoxin from 100 to 38%; S. typhimurium antiserum reduced the incidence from 92 to 35%. (P < 0.0005 for both antisera). There was no protection against heterologous endotoxin in either animal model. These experiments demonstrate for the first time that human antiserum confers exceedingly potent passive immunity to the effects of endotoxin.