Differences between syncope resulting from rapid onset acceleration and orthostatic stress.

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND AND HYPOTHESIS: Orthostatically-induced syncope is accompanied by venous pooling and vasodilatation. Loss of consciousness during head-to-foot acceleration (G-LOC) in aviators may be caused by a different mechanism, as venous pooling should be prevented through the use of an anti-G suit. This research was conducted to test the hypothesis that in individuals wearing a well-fitted anti-G garment, no important changes occur in the volume of dependent regions during loss of consciousness resulting from rapid onset acceleration stress. Further, this work compares venous pooling patterns in G-LOC subjects to patterns seen during syncope in volunteers and patients subjected to orthostatic stress. We conducted the tilt/LBNP tests to establish what level of venous pooling was required to induce syncope in the absence of a hydrostatic component (other than 1 G) and to confirm that our equipment was sensitive enough to detect volume changes large enough to cause syncope. METHODS: Shifts in blood volume to the calf, thigh and abdominal segments were compared in subjects with G-LOC to those in subjects taken to presyncope with orthostatic stress created by upright tilt and lower body negative pressure (LBNP). Centrifuge subjects were exposed to a 15 s rapid onset (6 G.s-1) + 5 Gz exposure on the centrifuge while remaining relaxed and wearing a well-fitting anti-G suit, but with the anti-G suit pressure inactivated. RESULTS: Blood volume decreased an average of 14.9 +/- 22.1 ml in the calf segment; increased an average of 64.1 +/- 7.9 ml in the thigh segment, and decreased an average of 80.1 +/- 29.7 ml in the abdominal segment. The mean net change in volume of the three combined regions was not significantly different from zero. Presyncope was induced in subjects by a progressive exposure to upright tilt, and then addition of LBNP at -20 mm Hg and -40 mm Hg. In the tilt/LBNP group, there was a net increase of 1022 +/- 269.8 ml for the combined segments. Changes in all three segments were significantly different than the mean segmental volume changes seen in centrifuge subjects at G-LOC endpoints. Significant changes from baseline mean arterial pressure, but not heart rate were also seen within, but not between the 2 groups, with mean eye level blood pressures (ELBP) falling an average of 45.6 +/- 7.7 mm Hg in the tilt/LBNP group at syncope and 105.1 +/- 15.5 mm Hg in the centrifuge subjects at G-LOC. CONCLUSIONS: These differences suggest that G-LOC may be due entirely to hydrostatic effects, with venous pooling being prevented by the wearing of an ant-G garment, even when it remains uninflated.