Optimal PPI-based triple therapy for the cure of Helicobacter pylori infection: a single center comparison of four 14-day schedules.

BACKGROUND: Helicobacter pylori eradication is accomplished using a wide array of drugs combined in a multitude of dosage schedules. The aim of the present study was to define the best 14-day eradication schedule using a PPI plus either two antibiotics or one antibiotic and bismuth. MATERIAL AND METHODS: For this study, 367 subjects (198 males, 169 females, age 22-87 years) with document H. pylori infection of the stomach were recruited from out-patients of the Gastroenterology Department of the Venezia Hospital. In all patients, H. pylori infection was identified by histology and the CLO-test. Patients were treated as follows: 1) PPI (P) plus clarithromycin (C) 250 mg plus amoxicillin (A) 1000 mg bid (P + C + A); 2) P plus C plus bismuth subcitrate (B) 120 mg qid (P + C + B); 3) P plus C plus tinidazole (T) 500 mg bid (P + C + T); and 4) P plus A plus T bid (P + A + T). After two months, an upper gastrointestinal endoscopy was repeated for end point histological evaluation and the CLO- test. Positivity of one of the two methods was considered sufficient to define H. pylori as "not eradicated". STATISTICS: Chi-squared test and Fisher exact test. RESULTS: Thirty-three subjects dropped out (six due to adverse events). P + C + B was proven significantly less effective than P + C + A, P + C + T and P + A + T, eradication rates being, respectively, 75.0%, 90.5%, 87.6%, 92.0%, (p = .005, per protocol analysis). CONCLUSIONS: All PPI-based triple therapies tested in this study were effective in curing H. pylori infection; however, P + C + B resulted in rates too low (< 85%) to be recommended. P + C + A and P + A + T resulted in the high cure rates and thus may be considered the treatment of choice.