Autopolyreactivity Confers a Holistic Role in the Immune System.

In this review, we summarize and discuss some key findings from the study of naturally occurring autoantibodies. The B-cell compartment of the immune system appears to recognize almost all endogenous and environmental antigens. This ability is accomplished principally through autopolyreactive humoral and cellular immune receptors. This extended autopolyreactivity (1) along immunoglobulin gene recombination contributes to the immune system's ability to recognize a very large number of self and non-self constituents; and (2) generates a vast immune network that creates communication channels between the organism's interior and exterior. Thus, the immune system continuously evolves depending on the internal and external stimuli it encounters. Furthermore, this far-reaching network's existence implies activities resembling those of classical biological factors or activities that modulate the function of other classical biological factors. A few such antibodies have already been found. Another important concept is that natural autoantibodies are highly dependent on the presence or absence of commensal microbes in the organism. These results are in line with past and recent findings showing the fundamental influence of the microbiota on proper immune system development, and necessitate the existence of a host-microbe homeostasis. This homeostasis requires that the participating humoral and cellular receptors are able to recognize self-antigens and commensal microbes without damaging them. Autopolyreactive immune receptors expressing low affinity for both types of antigens fulfil this role. The immune system appears to play a holistic role similar to that of the nervous system.

Detection of simultaneous antibody synthesis in plasma cells and specialized lymphocytes in rabbit lymph nodes.

Antibody to horseradish peroxidase was localized by electron microscopic immunocytochemistry in cells of the popliteal lymph nodes of the rabbit after a single injection of antigen with complete Freund's adjuvant and after a second antigen administration. Synthesis of antibody, chiefly of 7S type, occurred simultaneously in two types of cells: large, clear, fixed, typical plasma cells, and small, dense, circulating cells which exhibit morphological characteristics of both small lymphocytes and plasma cells. We call the latter "lymphoplasmacytes" and propose that they arise from small lymphocytes. They secrete antibody by clasmatosis and continue to develop an elaborate endoplasmic reticulum after specific antibody synthesis ceases. In the presence of an additional antigenic stimulation, a second cycle of antibody synthesis may begin around the nucleus in the same cell, with antibody accumulating in the perinuclear space sometimes even before the previously synthesized antibody has been entirely secreted at the cell periphery. On this basis, we propose that the lymphoplasmacyte is a memory cell and that memory and antibody synthesis are two different activities of the same cell. The appearance of a small amount of 19S antibody may be correlated with the presence of a small number of antibody-containing, large lymphocytes.

Ultrastructural localization of antibody in differentiating plasma cells.

Antibody was localized by electron microscopy within differentiating and mature plasma cells of the spleens of hyperimmunized rabbits. Horseradish peroxidase was used as antigen. Intracellular antibody to peroxidase was revealed in glutaraldehyde-fixed tissue by coupling it with its antigen and then revealing the sites of peroxidase activity cytochemically. Antibody first appears in the perinuclear space of hemocytoblasts where it persists through differentiation into immature plasma cells, but it disappears from this site in mature plasma cells. Concomitant with the development of the ergastoplasm, antibody accumulates in many but not all of its cisternae. Antibody is present in the lamellar portion of the Golgi apparatus in all phases of plasmacytic differentiation. Mature plasma cells exhibit two types of antibody distribution, a concentration into large spherical intracisternal granules or an overflowing into all parts of the cytoplasm.

Detection of plasma membrane carbohydrates with lectin peroxidase conjugates.

With the use of the cytochemical stain for horseradish peroxidase of Graham and Karnovsky (1966. J. Histochem. Cytochem.14:291), conjugates of horseradish peroxidase with ricin, wheat germ agglutinin, and phytohemagglutinin were employed for the morphologic demonstration of d-galactose (ricin), N-acetylglucosamine (wheat germ), and N-acetylgalactosamine (phytohemagglutinin) containing moieties on the surface of unfixed, or paraformaldehyde-fixed rat lymphoid cells. D-Galactose, or d-galactose containing disaccharides inhibited the interaction between ricin peroxidase and lymphoid cell surface; also, N-acetylglucosamine inhibited the wheat germ peroxidase-lymphoid cell interaction, but N-acetylgalactosamine failed to inhibit the reaction between phytohemagglutinin peroxidase and the surface of lymphoid cells.

Internalization of lectins in neuronal GERL.

Conjugates of ricin agglutinin and phytohemagglutinin with horseradish peroxidase (HRP) were used for a cytochemical study of internalization of their plasma membrane "receptors" in cultured isolated mouse dorsal root ganglion neurons. Labeling of cells with lectin-HRP was done at 4 degrees C, and internalization was performed at 37 degrees C in a culture medium free of lectin-HRP. 15-20 min after incubation at 37 degrees C, lectin-HRP receptor complexes were seen in vesicles or tubules located near the plasma membrane. After 1-3 h at 37 degrees C, lectin-HRP-receptor complexes accumulated in vesicles and tubules corresponding to acid phosphatase-rich vesicles and tubules (GERL) at the trans aspect of the Golgi apparatus. A few coated vesicles and probably some dense bodies contained HRP after 3-6 h of incubation at 37 degrees C. Soluble HRP was not endocytosed under the conditions of this experiment or when it was present in the incubation medium at 37 degrees C. Internalization of lectin-HRP-receptor conjugates was decreased or inhibited by mitochondrial respiration inhibitors but not by cytochalasin B or colchicine. These studies indicate that lectin-labeled plasma membrane moieties of neurons are endocytosed primarily in elements of GERL.

Quantitative ultrastructural autoradiographic studies of iodinated plasma membranes of lymphocytes during segregation and internalization of surface immunoglobulins.

Rat spleen lymphocytes were iodinated (125 I) with lactoperoxidase. Quantitative autoradiographic studies on cells fixed immediately after iodination showed 19-24% of intracytoplasmic grains at 3HD and over from the plasma membrane. Normalization of grain density distribution and comparison of resulting curves with the universal curve of grain scatter of 125 I showed that a significant percentage of intracytoplasmic grains (36%) originates from intracytoplasmic labeled sources rather than from scattering from the heavily labeled plasma membrane. Damaged cells had a threefold grain density than intact cells. Radioactivity counts in sliced polyacrylamide gels of iodinated cells revealed 65-72% of total radioactivity in five peaks of apparent mol wt of 44, 50, 57, 90 and 195 thousand daltons. Segregation and internalization of anti-immunoglobulin-Ig-horseradish peroxidase (HRP) complexes from the iodinated plasma membrane proteins of lymphocytes was studied with quantitative autoradiography (125 I) and peroxidase cytochemistry; 64% of grains at 1.5HD (1,500 A) from the plasma membrane were within the cap zone, and 36% of grains remained outside the capped immunoglobulins; 45-57% of grains internalized together with Fab-anti-Ig-Ig-HRP, and 68% of grains internalized together with anti-Ig-Ig-HRP. These studies indicate that (a) iodination of rat spleen lymphocytes results in a significant internal labeling and that (b) immunoglobulins segregate into caps and internalize together with other iodinated plasma membrane proteins while a significant percentage of iodinated proteins (36%) are excluded from the immunoglobulin caps or internalization sites (32-55%).

Plasma membrane and internalized immunoglobulins of lymph node cells studied with conjugates of antibody or its Fab fragments with horseradish peroxidase.

Normal rat and mouse lymphoid cells were incubated at 0 degrees -4 degrees C for 1 h with purified rabbit or sheep antirat (mouse) immunoglobulin (Ig)-horseradish peroxidase (PO) conjugates or with Fab fragments of antibody coupled with peroxidase. Cells were subsequently washed and incubated in fresh medium, without labeled antibody or Fab fragments for 5-30 min at 20 degrees or 37 degrees C. With the use of the diaminobenzidine (DAB) method, distribution of peroxidase was studied in the light and electron microscopes. Fab fragments of antirat Ig antibody were iodinated with (125)I and subsequently coupled with horseradish PO. Plasma membrane and internalized immunoglobulins were detected by electron microscope autoradiography and peroxidase cytochemistry. Single- (Fab-PO), and double- ([(125)I]Fab-PO) labeled lymphoid cells showed identical patterns of surface or internal distribution of immunoglobulins. In the electron microscope, Fab-PO conjugates at 0 degrees -4 degrees C resulted in a diffuse specific staining of the plasmalemma of lymphocytes and plasma cells. Most of the small dark lymphocytes (T cells?) did not show plasma membrane Ig. Macrophages did not show plasmalemma staining, but displayed nonspecific cytoplasmic staining after incubation at 20 degrees or 37 degrees C with antibody or Fab-PO conjugates. Lymphocytes and plasma cells, after incubation with antibody-PO conjugates at 0 degrees -4 degrees C, had patchy deposits of oxidized DAB on their plasma membranes. Macrophages, similarly treated, had no plasmalemmal staining. Patch and cap formation on the plasma membrane of lymphocytes and plasma cells was seen regularly after antibody-PO incubation at 37 degrees C. Internalization patterns were different in lymphocytes and plasma cells. In lymphocytes, peroxidase staining was observed in small round or oval vesicles clustered at one pole of the cell (30 min at 37 degrees C). In plasma cells, peroxidase staining was seen in clusters of tubules resembling the Golgi apparatus. Internalization of plasma membrane IgG was less pronounced after antibody-PO labeling as compared to Fab-PO labeling.

Natural autoantibodies.

Autoantibodies of the IgM, IgG and IgA classes, reactive with a variety of serum proteins, cell surface structures and intracellular structures, are 'naturally' found in all normal individuals. Present in human cord blood and in 'antigen-free' mice, their variable-region repertoire is selected by antigenic structures in the body and remains conserved throughout life. Encoded by germline genes with no, or few, mutations, natural autoantibodies are characteristically 'multireactive' and do not undergo affinity maturation in normal individuals. Natural autoantibodies may participate in a variety of physiological activities, from immune regulation, homeostasis and repertoire selection, to resistance to infections, transport and functional modulation of biologically active molecules.

Immunochemical studies of a murine polyreactive IgG2b autoantibody with rheumatoid factor activity.

The hybridoma, 62H3, which secretes a monoclonal IgG2b with anti-HLA-DR specificity, was expanded in pristane-primed BALB/c mice and the antibody was isolated from the ascitic fluid by affinity chromatography on Protein A-Sepharose. The purified IgG2b antibody was tested by an enzyme immunoassay for antibody activity against a panel of 40 self and non-self antigens. It was found to react strongly with beta-galactosidase, actin, glutamate dehydrogenase, rabbit and human IgG and di- and trinitrophenyl groups; and moderately with tubulin, insulin and phosphorylcholine; but it did not react with various other self and non-self antigens, such as DNA, albumin, keyhole limpet hemocyanin, hen lysozyme and horseradish peroxidase. Fab and Fc fragments were prepared from this IgG2b by papain proteolysis. The Fab fragment possessed the same spectrum of polyreactivities as the native IgG2b, whereas no activity was detected with the Fc fraction. In order to investigate the properties of the antigen binding site, the actin, TNP and rabbit IgG antibody activities were studied in more detail by enzyme immunoassay, Western blot and immunocytochemistry. The monomolecular nature of this multireactivity was confirmed by immunoabsorption analysis. Furthermore, 62H3 monoclonality was also verified by comparative isoelectric focusing and sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis with other monospecific antibodies. The dissociation constants (Kd) of antigen-antibody equilibria in solution were measured. The Kd for actin was 1.11 +/- 0.24 x 10(-5) M and the Kd for TNP-BSA was 8.7 +/- 0.51 x 10(-7) M. No interaction with rabbit IgG could be detected in solution. These findings raise the question of the possible implication in autoimmune pathology or in normal physiology of IgG class polyspecific antibodies with solid-phase restricted cross-reactive rheumatoid factor activity.

Characterization of a murine immunoglobulin VH gene segment in subgroup III: a new member of the 7183 gene family.

A new gene for the variable region of the immunoglobulin heavy chain (VH gene) has been isolated from BALB/c adult liver DNA using a cDNA plasmid probe containing a mouse VH sequence. The complete nucleotide sequence of this germline gene (VH10-19), shows that it belongs to the 7183 gene family. The VH gene appears to contain an intervening 104-base-long sequence and displays the same recombination signal sequences that those observed in the germline 81X. The presence of an internal heptamer at the 3' end of the VH10-19 coding region let an alternative recombination event that could increase the representation of this gene in the immature repertoire.

Monoclonal IgG and IgM autoantibodies obtained after polyclonal activation, show reactivities similar to those of polyclonal natural autoantibodies.

In this study, we described the properties of two groups of polyreactive IgG monoclonal antibodies (mAb) derived from splenocytes of a Plasmodium chabaudi-infected BALB/c mouse. These IgG mAb reacted with self antigens, but not with the parasite. Depending upon the antigen under study, they showed low (10(-5) M) to high (10(-8) M) affinities. When examined by immunoblotting using mouse organ extracts as the antigen source, each IgG mAb had a different reactivity profile. The IgG2b, but not the IgG2a mAb group, reacted with F(ab')2 fragments of IgG from normal mouse sera, as well as with F(ab')2 fragments of other mAb from the same fusion. Their anti-F(ab')2 activity was inhibited by various antigens, suggesting that the binding sites for these antigens and F(ab')2 fragments were close or overlapping. We also characterized two monoclonal IgM that were strongly and almost exclusively reactive with polyclonal F(ab')2 fragments of normal IgG, and that inhibited the binding of normal polyclonal IgG to self antigens. We previously described such properties for polyclonal IgM from normal mouse sera. The binding of the F(ab')2-reactive IgG mAb to self antigens was also inhibited by normal polyclonal IgM. These results indicate that the IgG and IgM obtained after polyclonal stimulation, exhibit characteristics similar to those of autoantibodies present in normal mouse sera. Furthermore, they confirm our previous studies showing the polyreactivity of polyclonal IgG. Finally, they also show that such IgG mAb exhibit properties similar to those of natural IgM, namely polyreactivity, affinity and connectivity.

IgG auto- and polyreactivities of normal human sera.

Using a panel of self antigens, IgM autoreactivities were clearly and constantly detected by enzyme immunoassay (EIA) in the sera of 29 normal human individuals. Similarly, IgM autoreactivities in sera were reproducibly detected by immunoblotting, using human organ extracts as the antigen sources. In contrast, IgG reactivities were low in whole sera but were considerably increased after affinity-chromatography purification on protein G-Sepharose. These increases differed from one individual IgG preparation to another and from one antigen to another (from 1-94 times) resulting in a unique IgG autoreactivity pattern for each subject. IgG reactivities diminished markedly when the IgG-depleted serum was added to the isolated autologous IgG. IgM antibodies isolated from sera on F(ab')2 IgG immunoadsorbent partially inhibited the binding of IgG to tubulin and myosin but not to actin. The individual IgG preparations examined separately exhibited, with all the autoantigens of the panel, higher autoreactivities than those of the same-but-pooled IgGs, which in turn were higher than those of a commercially available human IgG preparation obtained from approximately 8,000 healthy donors and used for intravenous injection. Depending upon the individual IgG sample, 31-65% of the IgG were bound to a DNP-Sepharose column and were eluted with DNP-glycine. The isolated anti-DNP antibodies were found to be polyreactive and possess higher autoreactivities than the original IgG preparation for all the antigens of the panel. Similarly, IgG antibodies analysed using an antibody exchange procedure were found to be essentially polyreactive but some apparently monospecific antibodies were also noted. These results suggest that the great majority of IgG present in normal humans are composed of polyreactive autoantibodies. IgG autoreactivities are only marginally expressed in these whole sera because of IgM-IgG, IgG-IgG and other, still unidentified, interactions.

Reactivity and structure of a mouse anti-F(ab')2 IgM. Comparison of its variable region sequences with those of a structurally close polyreactive natural IgM.

IE12 is a monoclonal IgM with strong anti-F(ab')2 activity that inhibits the binding of normal mouse IgG to self antigens. In this study, we found that this IgM was also reactive with several monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), myeloma proteins and B lymphocytes from normal BALB/c mouse. The nucleotide sequences of the variable region of the heavy and light chains of IE12 were determined, and compared to those of another mAb already described in the literature. This mAb uses the same light chain and also the same VH, D and JH segments, but unlike IE12, is polyreactive. The comparison of the amino acid composition of these two mAbs and of the computer predictions for their structure and hydrophilicity indicated that the most striking difference between them was located in the third complementarity determining region (CDR3) of the heavy chain. Indeed, they used the same D segment but translated in two different reading frames, leading to different amino acid compositions. The CDR3 of IE12 contains aliphatic amino acids, while that of the polyreactive IgM does not. In addition, IE12 has two prolines, one at each at each extremity of its D segment, that could confer a certain rigidity to this region. Finally, the CDR3 of IE12 is predicted to be hydrophobic, while the one of the polyreactive IgM is predicted to be hydrophilic and more flexible, suggesting that the hydrophilicity and the flexibility of this region might be critical for polyreactivity.

Anti-tubulin antibodies in rabbits before and after immunization with pig tubulin.

Sera from rabbits before and after repeated injections of pig tubulin in complete Freund's adjuvant were examined for antibody activity against pig and rabbit tubulins and against a panel of antigens: actin, myosin, DNA, TNP/BSA. Antibody activity against all the antigens of the panel (PAg) increased moderately after the first but not after subsequent injections. Antibody activity against pig and rabbit tubulins strongly increased after the second immunization when the maximum was reached. Isolation of anti-tubulin antibodies from normal or immune sera on tubulin-immunoadsorbent demonstrated the presence of three different antibody populations: (1) polyspecific IgM reacting with the PAg and the tubulins, present in substantial amounts in normal sera and moderately increased in immune sera; (2) small amounts of polyspecific IgG detected only in immune sera; (3) high amounts of specific IgG reacting with pig and rabbit tubulins, present in immune but not normal sera. Western blot analysis of the specific IgG population showed that it contained antibodies reacting with both native pig and rabbit tubulins, as well as antibodies recognizing only the 30,000 proteolytic fragment of pig, but not that of rabbit tubulin. The results indicate that the immunization of rabbits with heterologous tubulin induced specific IgG anti-tubulin antibodies which recognize the self and non-self antigens differently.

A method for the quantification of a colored or fluorescent signal in enzyme immunoassays by photodensitometry.

A colored or fluorescent signal is generally evaluated with the naked eye, or by means of different more or less sophisticated and costly instruments. Photodensitometry is an additional technique which is both inexpensive and simple to perform. This technique can satisfactorily quantify a signal without the use of either a spectrophotometer or a fluorometer. In this study we compared readings obtained by spectrophotometry, fluorometry and photodensitometry in 96-well ELISA plates and in Terasaki plates. In ELISA plates, it is possible to detect 1220-300,000 femtograms (fg) of peroxidase by spectrophotometry and 4800-125,000 fg by photodensitometry. In Terasaki plates, we were able to measure between 3.8 and 8000 fg of beta-galactosidase per sample by spectrofluorometry, and from 30 to 8000 fg by photodensitometry. Using a sandwich procedure in Terasaki plates we were able to measure between 100 and 10,000 fg of IgE per sample by spectrofluorometry and from 500 to 10,000 fg by photodensitometry. Photodensitometry is the least expensive technique for the reliable detection of enzyme or enzymatic marker in small sample volumes treated with a fluorogenic substrate.

Enzyme/anti-enzyme monoclonal antibody soluble immune complexes (EMAC): their use in quantitative immunoenzymatic assays.

Enzyme/anti-enzyme antibody soluble immune complexes were prepared with monoclonal mouse antibodies (MA) which were directed against peroxidase (PO) and beta-galactosidase (GAL). These enzyme monoclonal antibody complexes (EMAC) functioned as markers to quantify mouse antibodies using an enzyme immunoassay which incorporated an anti-mouse Ig as the bridge between the EMAC and the specific antibody bound to an antigen immobilized on a polystyrene plate. EMAC prepared with PO (PO-MAC) or with GAL (GAL-MAC) were both effective in quantifying polyclonal as well as monoclonal mouse antibodies, and gave sensitivity equal or superior to that obtained with covalent enzyme/anti-mouse Ig conjugates. The smaller amount of antibodies detected with EMAC depended on the affinity of both the antibody tested and the monoclonal antibody used to prepare EMAC. This method is an improvement on the 'antibody bridge' method, because EMAC can be prepared easily by simply mixing the enzyme and the MA at the appropriate amounts 2 h prior to use. In addition, EMAC can be prepared using crude preparations of enzyme and unpurified ascitic fluids containing the MA, thus decreasing the cost of the test considerably.

Quantitation of 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine incorporation into DNA: an enzyme immunoassay for the assessment of the lymphoid cell proliferative response.

As an alternative to the measurement of radiolabeled thymidine incorporated into DNA, a method is presented in which thymidine has been replaced by its analogue, 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BUdR). BUdR incorporated into DNA (BUdR-DNA) is measured by a sandwich-type enzyme immunoassay using a monoclonal anti-BUdR antibody. This method allows the quantitation of 4 ng of BUdR-DNA. Comparative experiments with myeloma cells and LPS stimulated spleen B-cells have shown that this technique is at least as sensitive as the traditional counting of [3H]thymidine.

Polyacrylamide-agarose beads for the preparation of effective immunoabsorbents.

Gluxaraldehyde-activated polyacrylamide-agarose beads (Ultro-gel) have been employed to bind proteins. The derivatives obtained were found to be effective immunoabsorbents allowing the quick isolation of pure antibodies in high yields.

Detection of anti-TNP antibody-forming cells (AFC) with TNP-enzyme and TNP-Fab anti-enzyme conjugates.

Peroxidase (PO), alkaline phosphatase, and glucose oxidase, as well as Fab anti-PO, were coupled with varying molar ratios of trinitrophenyl (TNP) hapten. These reagents were evaluated for their ability to detect anti-TNP antibodies in the lymph node cells of Balb/c mice immunized with heavily-substituted TNP45 alkaline phosphate, which gave rise only to anti-hapten antibody-forming cells (AFC). The best results were obtained with lightly-substituted TNP-Fab anti-PO plus PO, TNP-alkaline phosphatase, and TNP-glucose oxidase. These reagents gave strong, specific staining of AFC, and negative background staining. Anti-hapten and anti-carrier AFC could be stained in contrasting colors on the same slide, when immunization was performed with lightly-substituted TNP5.9 alkaline phosphatase. Anti-hapten AFC were detected with TNP-Fab anti-PO or TNP-glucose oxidase, and unsubstituted alkaline phosphatase was used to reveal anti-carrier AFC. The number of AFC detected with these reagents was compared with the number of direct and indirect anti-TNP plaque-forming cells (PFC). At three and five weeks after primary immunization, 40 and 70% more AFC than PFC were detected. These methods can be employed alone, to enumerate anti-TNP AFC and, if desired, anti-carrier AFC; they can also be used in parallel with anti-TNP PFC assays, to determine the fractions of AFC that are not actively involved in antibody secretion.

Lectin immuno tests: quantitation and titration of antigens and antibodies using lectin-antibody conjugates.

We have investigated the possibility of using lectin-antibody conjugates as general reagents in immunological procedures requiring a labeled antigen or antibody. Using these conjugates, labeling is achieved through saccharide binding sites of lectins which operate as acceptors for glycoconjugate marker substances added secondarily. Marker substances used in this work were enzymes, radioactively labeled glycoconjugates and erythrocytes, but other markers can also be used. Using the first two markers, antigens and antibodies were determined with accuracy and sensitivity equal to those of conventional enzyme or radioimmunoassays. Using erythrocytes as a marker, a simple erythro-adsorption procedure, possibly followed by hemolysis, has been developed which allowed the titration of antigens and antibodies to be carried out with a sensitivity at least equal to enzyme or radioimmunoassays.