Biophysical characterization of the phase separation of TDP-43 devoid of the C-terminal domain.

BACKGROUND: Frontotemporal lobar degeneration with ubiquitin-positive inclusions (FTLD-TDP), amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and limbic-predominant age-related TDP-43 encephalopathy (LATE) are associated with deposition of cytoplasmic inclusions of TAR DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43) in neurons. One complexity of this process lies in the ability of TDP-43 to form liquid-phase membraneless organelles in cells. Previous work has shown that the recombinant, purified, prion-like domain (PrLD) forms liquid droplets in vitro, but the behaviour of the complementary fragment is uncertain. METHODS: We have purified such a construct without the PrLD (PrLD-less TDP-43) and have induced its phase separation using a solution-jump method and an array of biophysical techniques to study the morphology, state of matter and structure of the TDP-43 assemblies. RESULTS: The fluorescent TMR-labelled protein construct, imaged using confocal fluorescence, formed rapidly (< 1 min) round, homogeneous and 0.5-1.0 µm wide assemblies which then coalesced into larger, yet round, species. When labelled with AlexaFluor488, they initially exhibited fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), showing a liquid behaviour distinct from full-length TDP-43 and similar to PrLD. The protein molecules did not undergo major structural changes, as determined with circular dichroism and intrinsic fluorescence spectroscopies. This process had a pH and salt dependence distinct from those of full-length TDP-43 and its PrLD, which can be rationalized on the grounds of electrostatic forces. CONCLUSIONS: Similarly to PrLD, PrLD-less TDP-43 forms liquid droplets in vitro through liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS), unlike the full-length protein that rather undergoes liquid-solid phase separation (LSPS). These results offer a rationale of the complex electrostatic forces governing phase separation of full-length TDP-43 and its fragments. On the one hand, PrLD-less TDP-43 has a low pI and oppositively charged domains, and LLPS is inhibited by salts, which attenuate inter-domain electrostatic attractions. On the other hand, PrLD is positively charged due to a high isoionic point (pI) and LLPS is therefore promoted by salts and pH increases as they both reduce electrostatic repulsions. By contrast, full-length TDP-43 undergoes LSPS most favourably at its pI, with positive and negative salt dependences at lower and higher pH, respectively, depending on whether repulsive or attractive forces dominate, respectively.

Conversion of the Native N-Terminal Domain of TDP-43 into a Monomeric Alternative Fold with Lower Aggregation Propensity.

TAR DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43) forms intraneuronal cytoplasmic inclusions associated with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and ubiquitin-positive frontotemporal lobar degeneration. Its N-terminal domain (NTD) can dimerise/oligomerise with the head-to-tail arrangement, which is essential for function but also favours liquid-liquid phase separation and inclusion formation of full-length TDP-43. Using various biophysical approaches, we identified an alternative conformational state of NTD in the presence of Sulfobetaine 3-10 (SB3-10), with higher content of α-helical structure and tryptophan solvent exposure. NMR shows a highly mobile structure, with partially folded regions and ß-sheet content decrease, with a concomitant increase of α-helical structure. It is monomeric and reverts to native oligomeric NTD upon SB3-10 dilution. The equilibrium GdnHCl-induced denaturation shows a cooperative folding and a somewhat lower conformational stability. When the aggregation processes were compared with and without pre-incubation with SB3-10, but at the identical final SB3-10 concentration, a slower aggregation was found in the former case, despite the reversible attainment of the native conformation in both cases. This was attributed to protein monomerization and oligomeric seeds disruption by the conditions promoting the alternative conformation. Overall, the results show a high plasticity of TDP-43 NTD and identify strategies to monomerise TDP-43 NTD for methodological and biomedical applications.

Capturing Aß42 aggregation in the cell.

Novel imaging techniques with ever-increasing resolution are invaluable tools for the study of protein deposition, as they allow the self-assembly of proteins to be directly investigated in living cells. For the first time, the acceleration in Aß42 aggregation induced by the Arctic mutation was monitored in cells, revealing a number of distinct morphologies that form sequentially. This approach will help discriminate the impacts of mutations on amyloid protein processing, Aß aggregation propensity, and other mechanistic outcomes.

Transthyretin Inhibits Primary and Secondary Nucleations of Amyloid-ß Peptide Aggregation and Reduces the Toxicity of Its Oligomers.

Alzheimer's disease is associated with the deposition of the amyloid-ß peptide (Aß) into extracellular senile plaques in the brain. In vitro and in vivo observations have indicated that transthyretin (TTR) acts as an Aß scavenger in the brain, but the mechanism has not been fully resolved. We have monitored the aggregation process of Aß40 by thioflavin T fluorescence, in the presence or absence of different concentrations of preformed seed aggregates of Aß40, of wild-type tetrameric TTR (WT-TTR), and of a variant engineered to be stable as a monomer (M-TTR). Both WT-TTR and M-TTR were found to inhibit specific steps of the process of Aß40 fibril formation, which are primary and secondary nucleations, without affecting the elongation of the resulting fibrils. Moreover, the analysis shows that both WT-TTR and M-TTR bind to Aß40 oligomers formed in the aggregation reaction and inhibit their conversion into the shortest fibrils able to elongate. Using biophysical methods, TTR was found to change some aspects of its overall structure following such interactions with Aß40 oligomers, as well as with oligomers of Aß42, while maintaining its overall topology. Hence, it is likely that the predominant mechanism by which TTR exerts its protective role lies in the binding of TTR to the Aß oligomers and in inhibiting primary and secondary nucleation processes, which limits both the toxicity of Aß oligomers and the ability of the fibrils to proliferate.

Insight into the Folding and Dimerization Mechanisms of the N-Terminal Domain from Human TDP-43.

TAR DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43) is a 414-residue long nuclear protein whose deposition into intraneuronal insoluble inclusions has been associated with the onset of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and other diseases. This protein is physiologically a homodimer, and dimerization occurs through the N-terminal domain (NTD), with a mechanism on which a full consensus has not yet been reached. Furthermore, it has been proposed that this domain is able to affect the formation of higher molecular weight assemblies. Here, we purified this domain and carried out an unprecedented characterization of its folding/dimerization processes in solution. Exploiting a battery of biophysical approaches, ranging from FRET to folding kinetics, we identified a head-to-tail arrangement of the monomers within the dimer. We found that folding of NTD proceeds through the formation of a number of conformational states and two parallel pathways, while a subset of molecules refold slower, due to proline isomerism. The folded state appears to be inherently prone to form high molecular weight assemblies. Taken together, our results indicate that NTD is inherently plastic and prone to populate different conformations and dimeric/multimeric states, a structural feature that may enable this domain to control the assembly state of TDP-43.

Stability of an aggregation-prone partially folded state of human profilin-1 correlates with aggregation propensity.

A set of missense mutations in the gene encoding profilin-1 has been linked to the onset of familial forms of ALS (fALS), also known as Lou Gehrig's disease. The pathogenic potential of these mutations is linked to the formation of intracellular inclusions of the mutant proteins and correlates with the mutation-induced destabilization of its native, fully folded state. However, the mechanism by which these mutations promote misfolding and self-assembly is yet unclear. Here, using temperature-jump and stopped-flow kinetic measurements, we show that, during refolding, WT profilin-1 transiently populates a partially folded (PF) state endowed with hydrophobic clusters exposed to the solvent and with no detectable secondary structure. We observed that this conformational state is marginally stable at neutral pH but becomes significantly populated at mildly acidic pH. Interestingly, the fALS-associated mutations did not cause a change in the refolding mechanism of profilin-1, but induced a stabilization of the PF state. In the presence of preformed profilin-1 aggregates, the PF state, unlike the unfolded and folded states, could interact with these aggregates via nonspecific hydrophobic interactions and also increase thioflavin-T fluorescence, revealing its amyloidogenic potential. Moreover, in the variants tested, we found a correlation between conformational stability of PF and aggregation propensity, defining this conformational state as an aggregation-prone folding intermediate. In conclusion, our findings indicate that mutation-induced stabilization of a partially folded state can enhance profilin-1 aggregation and thereby contribute to the pathogenicity of the mutations.

Identification of Novel 1,3,5-Triphenylbenzene Derivative Compounds as Inhibitors of Hen Lysozyme Amyloid Fibril Formation.

Deposition of soluble proteins as insoluble amyloid fibrils is associated with a number of pathological states. There is a growing interest in the identification of small molecules that can prevent proteins from undergoing amyloid fibril formation. In the present study, a series of small aromatic compounds with different substitutions of 1,3,5-triphenylbenzene have been synthesized and their possible effects on amyloid fibril formation by hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL), a model protein for amyloid formation, and of their resulting toxicity were examined. The inhibitory effect of the compounds against HEWL amyloid formation was analyzed using thioflavin T and Congo red binding assays, atomic force microscopy, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, and cytotoxicity assays, such as the 3-(4,5-Dimethylthiazol)-2,5-Diphenyltetrazolium Bromide (MTT) reduction assay and caspase-3 activity measurements. We found that all compounds in our screen were efficient inhibitors of HEWL fibril formation and their associated toxicity. We showed that electron-withdrawing substituents such as -F and -NO2 potentiated the inhibitory potential of 1,3,5-triphenylbenzene, whereas electron-donating groups such as -OH, -OCH3, and -CH3 lowered it. These results may ultimately find applications in the development of potential inhibitors against amyloid fibril formation and its biologically adverse effects.

FRET studies of various conformational states adopted by transthyretin.

Transthyretin (TTR) is an extracellular protein able to deposit into well-defined protein aggregates called amyloid, in pathological conditions known as senile systemic amyloidosis, familial amyloid polyneuropathy, familial amyloid cardiomyopathy and leptomeningeal amyloidosis. At least three distinct partially folded states have been described for TTR, including the widely studied amyloidogenic state at mildly acidic pH. Here, we have used fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) experiments in a monomeric variant of TTR (M-TTR) and in its W41F and W79F mutants, taking advantage of the presence of a unique, solvent-exposed, cysteine residue at position 10, that we have labelled with a coumarin derivative (DACM, acceptor), and of the two natural tryptophan residues at positions 41 and 79 (donors). Trp41 is located in an ideal position as it is one of the residues of ß-strand C, whose degree of unfolding is debated. We found that the amyloidogenic state at low pH has the same FRET efficiency as the folded state at neutral pH in both M-TTR and W79F-M-TTR, indicating an unmodified Cys10-Trp41 distance. The partially folded state populated at low denaturant concentrations also has a similar FRET efficiency, but other spectroscopic probes indicate that it is distinct from the amyloidogenic state at acidic pH. By contrast, the off-pathway state accumulating transiently during refolding has a higher FRET efficiency, indicating non-native interactions that reduce the Cys10-Trp41 spatial distance, revealing a third distinct conformational state. Overall, our results clarify a negligible degree of unfolding of ß-strand C in the formation of the amyloidogenic state and establish the concept that TTR is a highly plastic protein able to populate at least three distinct conformational states.

Direct Conversion of an Enzyme from Native-like to Amyloid-like Aggregates within Inclusion Bodies.

The acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus (Sso AcP) is a globular protein able to aggregate in vitro from a native-like conformational ensemble without the need for a transition across the major unfolding energy barrier. This process leads to the formation of assemblies in which the protein retains its native-like structure, which subsequently convert into amyloid-like aggregates. Here, we investigate the mechanism by which Sso AcP aggregates in vivo to form bacterial inclusion bodies after expression in E. coli. Shortly after the initiation of expression, Sso AcP is incorporated into inclusion bodies as a native-like protein, still exhibiting small but significant enzymatic activity. Additional experiments revealed that this overall process of aggregation is enhanced by the presence of the unfolded N-terminal region of the sequence and by destabilization of the globular segment of the protein. At later times, the Sso AcP molecules in the inclusion bodies lose their native-like properties and convert into ß-sheet-rich amyloid-like structures, as indicated by their ability to bind thioflavin T and Congo red. These results show that the aggregation behavior of this protein is similar in vivo to that observed in vitro, and that, at least for a predominant part of the protein population, the transition from a native to an amyloid-like structure occurs within the aggregate state.

Molecular insights into cell toxicity of a novel familial amyloidogenic variant of ß2-microglobulin.

The first genetic variant of ß2 -microglobulin (b2M) associated with a familial form of systemic amyloidosis has been recently described. The mutated protein, carrying a substitution of Asp at position 76 with an Asn (D76N b2M), exhibits a strongly enhanced amyloidogenic tendency to aggregate with respect to the wild-type protein. In this study, we characterized the D76N b2M aggregation path and performed an unprecedented analysis of the biochemical mechanisms underlying aggregate cytotoxicity. We showed that, contrarily to what expected from other amyloid studies, early aggregates of the mutant are not the most toxic species, despite their higher surface hydrophobicity. By modulating ganglioside GM1 content in cell membrane or synthetic lipid bilayers, we confirmed the pivotal role of this lipid as aggregate recruiter favouring their cytotoxicity. We finally observed that the aggregates bind to the cell membrane inducing an alteration of its elasticity (with possible functional unbalance and cytotoxicity) in GM1-enriched domains only, thus establishing a link between aggregate-membrane contact and cell damage.

A complex equilibrium among partially unfolded conformations in monomeric transthyretin.

Aggregation of transthyretin (TTR) is known to be linked to the development of systemic and localized amyloidoses. It also appears that TTR exerts a protective role against aggregation of the Aß peptide, a process linked to Alzheimer's disease. In vitro, both processes correlate with the ability of TTR to populate a monomeric state, yet a complete description of the possible conformational states populated by monomeric TTR in vitro at physiological pH is missing. Using an array of biophysical methods and kinetic tests, we show that once monomers of transthyretin are released from the tetramer, equilibrium is established between a set of conformational states possessing different degrees of disorder. A molten globular state appears in equilibrium with the fully folded monomer, whereas an off-pathway species accumulates transiently during refolding of TTR. These two conformational ensembles are distinct in terms of structure, kinetics, and their pathways of formation. Further subpopulations of the protein fold differently because of the occurrence of proline isomerism. The identification of conformational states unrevealed in previous studies opens the way for further characterization of the amyloidogenicity of TTR and its protective role in Alzheimer's disease.

Amyloid Aggregation Is Potently Slowed Down by Osmolytes Due to Compaction of Partially Folded State.

Amyloid aggregation is a key process in amyloidoses and neurodegenerative diseases. Hydrophobicity is one of the major driving forces for this type of aggregation, as an increase in hydrophobicity generally correlates with aggregation susceptibility and rate. However, most experimental systems in vitro and prediction tools in silico neglect the contribution of protective osmolytes present in the cellular environment. Here, we assessed the role of hydrophobic mutations in amyloid aggregation in the presence of osmolytes. To achieve this goal, we used the model protein human muscle acylphosphatase (mAcP) and mutations to leucine that increased its hydrophobicity without affecting its thermodynamic stability. Osmolytes significantly slowed down the aggregation kinetics of the hydrophobic mutants, with an effect larger than that observed on the wild-type protein. The effect increased as the mutation site was closer to the middle of the protein sequence. We propose that the preferential exclusion of osmolytes from mutation-introduced hydrophobic side-chains quenches the aggregation potential of the ensemble of partially unfolded states of the protein by inducing its compaction and inhibiting its self-assembly with other proteins. Our results suggest that including the effect of the cellular environment in experimental setups and predictive softwares, for both mechanistic studies and drug design, is essential in order to obtain a more complete combination of the driving forces of amyloid aggregation.

Quantitative Attribution of the Protective Effects of Aminosterols against Protein Aggregates to Their Chemical Structures and Ability to Modulate Biological Membranes.

Natural aminosterols are promising drug candidates against neurodegenerative diseases, like Alzheimer and Parkinson, and one relevant protective mechanism occurs via their binding to biological membranes and displacement or binding inhibition of amyloidogenic proteins and their cytotoxic oligomers. We compared three chemically different aminosterols, finding that they exhibited different (i) binding affinities, (ii) charge neutralizations, (iii) mechanical reinforcements, and (iv) key lipid redistributions within membranes of reconstituted liposomes. They also had different potencies (EC50) in protecting cultured cell membranes against amyloid-ß oligomers. A global fitting analysis led to an analytical equation describing quantitatively the protective effects of aminosterols as a function of their concentration and relevant membrane effects. The analysis correlates aminosterol-mediated protection with well-defined chemical moieties, including the polyamine group inducing a partial membrane-neutralizing effect (79 ± 7%) and the cholestane-like tail causing lipid redistribution and bilayer mechanical resistance (21 ± 7%), linking quantitatively their chemistry to their protective effects on biological membranes.

Characterizing intermolecular interactions that initiate native-like protein aggregation.

Folded proteins can access aggregation-prone states without the need for transitions that cross the energy barriers for unfolding. In this study we characterized the initial steps of aggregation from a native-like state of the acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus (Sso AcP). Using computer simulations restrained by experimental hydrogen/deuterium (H/D) exchange data, we provide direct evidence that under aggregation-promoting conditions Sso AcP populates a conformational ensemble in which native-like structure is retained throughout the sequence in the absence of local unfolding (N∗), although the protein exhibits an increase in hydrodynamic radius and dynamics. This transition leads an edge strand to experience an increased affinity for a specific unfolded segment of the protein. Direct measurements by means of H/D exchange rates, isothermal titration calorimetry, and intermolecular relaxation enhancements show that after formation of N∗, an intermolecular interaction with an antiparallel arrangement is established between the edge strand and the unfolded segment of the protein. However, under conditions that favor the fully native state of Sso AcP, such an interaction is not established. Thus, these results reveal a novel (to our knowledge) self-assembly mechanism for a folded protein that is based on the increased flexibility of highly aggregation-prone segments in the absence of local unfolding.

Biological function in a non-native partially folded state of a protein.

As structural flexibility is known to be required for enzyme catalysis and pattern recognition and a significant fraction of eukaryotic proteins appear to be unfolded or contain unstructured regions, biological activity of conformational states distinct from fully folded structures could be more common than previously thought. By applying a procedure that allows the recovery of enzymatic activity to be monitored in real time, we show that a non-native state populated transiently during folding of the acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus is enzymatically active. The structural characterization of this partially folded state reveals that enzymatic activity is possible even if the catalytic site is structurally heterogeneous, whereas the remainder of the structure acts as a scaffold. These results extend the spectrum of biological functions carried out in the absence of a folded state to include enzyme catalysis.

The Transthyretin/Oleuropein Aglycone Complex: A New Tool against TTR Amyloidosis.

The release of monomers from the homotetrameric protein transthyretin (TTR) is the first event of a cascade, eventually leading to sporadic or familial TTR amyloidoses. Thus, ligands able to stabilize TTR and inhibit monomer release are subject of intense scrutiny as potential treatments against these pathologies. Here, we investigated the interaction between TTR and a non-glycated derivative of the main olive polyphenol, oleuropein (OleA), known to interfere with TTR aggregation. We coupled fluorescence studies with molecular docking to investigate the OleA/TTR interaction using wild-type TTR, a monomeric variant, and the L55P cardiotoxic mutant. We characterized a fluorescence band emitted by OleA upon formation of the OleA/TTR complex. Exploiting this signal, we found that a poorly specific non-stoichiometric interaction occurs on the surface of the protein and a more specific stabilizing interaction takes place in the ligand binding pocket of TTR, exhibiting a KD of 3.23 ± 0.32 µM, with two distinct binding sites. OleA interacts with TTR in different modes, stabilizing it and preventing its dissociation into monomers, with subsequent misfolding. This result paves the way to the possible use of OleA to prevent degenerative diseases associated with TTR misfolding.

The role of structural dynamics in the thermal adaptation of hyperthermophilic enzymes.

Proteins from hyperthermophilic organisms are evolutionary optimised to adopt functional structures and dynamics under conditions in which their mesophilic homologues are generally inactive or unfolded. Understanding the nature of such adaptation is of crucial interest to clarify the underlying mechanisms of biological activity in proteins. Here we measured NMR residual dipolar couplings of a hyperthermophilic acylphosphatase enzyme at 80°C and used these data to generate an accurate structural ensemble representative of its native state. The resulting energy landscape was compared to that obtained for a human homologue at 37°C, and additional NMR experiments were carried out to probe fast (15N relaxation) and slow (H/D exchange) backbone dynamics, collectively sampling fluctuations of the two proteins ranging from the nanosecond to the millisecond timescale. The results identified key differences in the strategies for protein-protein and protein-ligand interactions of the two enzymes at the respective physiological temperatures. These include the dynamical behaviour of a ß-strand involved in the protection against aberrant protein aggregation and concerted motions of loops involved in substrate binding and catalysis. Taken together these results elucidate the structure-dynamics-function relationship associated with the strategies of thermal adaptation of protein molecules.

Structural and dynamics characteristics of acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus in the monomeric state and in the initial native-like aggregates.

It has previously been shown that the acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus is capable of forming amyloid-like aggregates under conditions in which the native structure is maintained and via the transient formation of native-like aggregates. Based on the previously determined NMR structure of the native protein, showing a ferredoxin-like fold and the peculiar presence of an unstructured N-terminal segment, we show here, at a molecular level using NMR spectroscopy, that indeed S. solfataricus acylphosphatase remains in a native-like conformation when placed in aggregating conditions and that such a native-like structure persists when the protein forms the initial aggregates, at least within the low molecular weight species. The analysis carried out under different solution conditions, based on the measurement of the combined (1)H and (15)N chemical shifts and hydrogen/deuterium exchange rates, enabled the most significant conformational changes to be monitored upon transfer of the monomeric state into aggregating conditions and upon formation of the initial native-like aggregates. Important increases of the hydrogen/deuterium exchange rates throughout the native protein, accompanied by small and localized structural changes, in the monomeric protein were observed. The results also allow the identification of the intermolecular interaction regions within the native-like aggregates, that involve, in particular, the N-terminal unstructured segment, the apical region including strands S4 and S5 with the connecting loop, and the opposite active site.

A model for the aggregation of the acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus in its native-like state.

Evidence is accumulating that normally folded proteins retain a significant tendency to form amyloid fibrils through a direct assembly of monomers in their native-like conformation. However, the factors promoting such processes are not yet well understood. The acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus (Sso AcP) aggregates under conditions in which a native-like state is initially populated and forms, as a first step, aggregates in which the monomers maintain their native-like topology. An unstructured N-terminal segment and an edge beta-strand were previously shown to play a major role in the process. Using kinetic experiments on a set of Sso AcP variants we shall show that the major event of the first step is the establishment of an inter-molecular interaction between the unstructured segment of one Sso AcP molecule and the globular unit of another molecule. This interaction is determined by the primary sequence of the unstructured segment and not by its physico-chemical properties. Moreover, we shall show that the conversion of these initial aggregates into amyloid-like protofibrils is an intra-molecular process in which the Sso AcP molecules undergo conformational modifications. The obtained results allow the formulation of a model for the assembly of Sso AcP into amyloid-like aggregates at a molecular level.

Probing conformational changes of monomeric transthyretin with second derivative fluorescence.

We have studied the intrinsic fluorescence spectra of a monomeric variant of human transthyretin (M-TTR), a protein involved in the transport of the thyroid hormone and retinol and associated with various forms of amyloidosis, extending our analysis to the second order derivative of the spectra. This procedure allowed to identify three peaks readily assigned to Trp41, as the three peaks were also visible in a mutant lacking the other tryptophan (Trp79) and had similar FRET efficiency values with an acceptor molecule positioned at position 10. The wavelength values of the three peaks and their susceptibility to acrylamide quenching revealed that the three corresponding conformers experience different solvent-exposure, polarity of the environment and flexibility. We could monitor the three peaks individually in urea-unfolding and pH-unfolding curves. This revealed changes in the distribution of the corresponding conformers, indicating conformational changes and alterations of the dynamics of the microenvironment that surrounds the associated tryptophan residue in such transitions, but also native-like conformers of such residues in unfolded states. We also found that the amyloidogenic state adopted by M-TTR at mildly low pH has a structural and dynamical microenvironment surrounding Trp41 indistinguishable from that of the fully folded and soluble state at neutral pH.