Lower intracellular concentration of cryoprotectants after vitrification than after slow freezing despite exposure to higher concentration of cryoprotectant solutions.

STUDY QUESTION: What is the intracellular concentration of cryoprotectant (ICCP) in mouse zygotes during vitrification (VIT) and slow-freezing (SLF) cryopreservation procedures? SUMMARY ANSWER: Contrary to common beliefs, it was observed that the ICCP in vitrified zygotes is lower than after SLF, although the solutions used in VIT contain higher concentrations of cryoprotectants (CPs). WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: To reduce the likelihood of intracellular ice crystal formation, which has detrimental effects on cell organelles and membranes, VIT was introduced as an alternative to SLF to cryopreserve embryos and gametes. Combined with high cooling and warming rates, the use of high concentrations of CPs favours an intracellular environment that supports and maintains the transition from a liquid to a solid glass-like state devoid of crystals. Although the up-to-date publications are reassuring in terms of obstetric and perinatal outcomes after VIT, a fear about exposing gametes and embryos to high amounts of CPs that exceed 3-4-fold those found in SLF was central to a debate initiated by advocates of SLF procedures. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: Two experimental set-ups were applied. The objective of a first study was to determine the ICCP at the end of the exposure steps to the CP solutions with our VIT protocol (n = 31). The goal of the second investigation was to compare the ICCP between VIT (n = 30) and SLF (n = 30). All experiments were performed in triplicates using mouse zygotes. The study took place at the GIGA-Research Institute of the University of Liège. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Cell volume is modified by changes in extracellular osmolarity. Hence, we estimated the final ICCP after the incubation steps in the VIT solutions by exposing the cells to sucrose (SUC) solutions with defined molarities. The ICCP was calculated from the SUC concentration that produced no change in cell volume, i.e. when intra- and extracellular osmolarities were equivalent. Cell volume was monitored by microscopic cinematography. ICCP was compared between SLF and VIT based on the principle that a high ICCP lowers the probability of (re)crystallization during warming but increases the probability of over-swelling of the cell due to fast inflow of water. The survival rates of mouse zygotes after SLF or VIT were compared using either (i) various warming rates or (ii) various concentrations of SUC in the warming dilution medium. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: The ICCP in mouse zygotes during the VIT procedure prior to plunging them in liquid nitrogen was ∼2.14 M, i.e. one-third of the concentration in the VIT solution. After SLF, the warming rate did not affect the zygote survival rate. In contrast, only 3/30 vitrified zygotes survived when warmed slowly but as many as 30/30 zygotes survived when warming was fast (>20 000°C/min). Vitrified zygotes showed significantly higher survival rates than slow-frozen zygotes when they were placed directly in the culture medium or in solutions containing low concentrations of SUC (P < 0.01). These two experiments demonstrate a lower ICCP after VIT than after SLF. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: The results should not be directly extrapolated to other stages of development or to other species due to possible differences in membrane permeability to water and CPs. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: The low ICCP we observed after VIT removes the concern about high ICCP after VIT, at least in murine zygotes and helps to explain the observed efficiency and lack of toxicity of VIT. STUDY FUNDING / COMPETING INTEREST(S): The study was funded by the FNRS (National Funds for Scientific Research). The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Cryopreservation of chicken primordial germ cells by vitrification and slow freezing: A comparative study.

In the present study, we compare a classical slow freezing (SLF) method and an aseptic vitrification (Vitrif) technique to cryopreserve a stable primordial germ cell (PGCs) line issued from the Ardennaise chicken breed. Viability immediately after warming was close to 80% and did not differ between the two cryopreservation methods. Proliferation tended to be slower for both cryopreservation methods compared with controls, but the difference was significant only for Vitrif. No difference was found between the two methods after flow cytometry analysis of stage-specific embryonic antigen-1 expression and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction on several factors related to PGC phenotype. After 1 week in culture, all cryopreserved cells reached controls' main morphologic and expanding (viability/proliferation) features. However, SLF generated more unwanted cells clusters than Vitrif. After injection of the PGCs into recipient embryos, vitrified PGCs reported a clear, yet not significant, tendency to colonize the gonad at a higher rate than slow frozen PGCs. SLF in cryovials remains simple, inexpensive, and less technically demanding than Vitrif. Nevertheless, the intrinsic advantages of our aseptic Vitrif method and the present study suggest that this should be considered as safer than classical SLF for cryopreserving chicken PGCs.

Nuclear transplantation using bovine primordial germ cells from male fetuses.

The developmental potential of nuclei of bovine gonial cells was investigated by nuclear transfer. Gonial cells were collected from male fetuses at about 175 days post coitum (p.c.). They were fused with enucleated oocytes; reconstituted embryos were cultured in vitro for 7 days. Embryos reaching the compacted morula or blastocyst stage were either fixed for cell counting or transferred into recipients. Out of 115 oocyte-gonia fusions, 101 (87.8%) gave rise to cleaved embryos at Day 3 and 26 (22.6%) had reached the 8-cell stage. At Day 7, 1 (1%) developed to the morula stage and 5 (4%) reached the blastocyst stage. Three blastocysts were fixed and showed normal cell numbers (135; 90; 76 cells). Three blastocysts and one morula were transferred in four recipients; two recipients were pregnant at Day 21 but only one was positive at Day 35 p.c.; this last one aborted around Day 40 p.c. No conceptus was collected. These results indicate that gonial cell nuclei can be partially reprogrammed; they are able to develop into blastocysts and to initiate gestation. However, more experiments will be necessary to prove the nuclear totipotency of bovine gonial cells.

Some factors affecting successful vitrification of mouse blastocysts.

The effects of temperature and exposure time to vitrification solutions on In vitro survival of mouse blastocysts were investigated. Blastocysts were first exposed for 10 min to vitrification Solution 1 (VS1) containing 10% glycerol-20% 1,2 propanediol in phosphate buffered saline (PBS), then to vitrification Solution 2 (VS2) with 25 % glycerol-25% 1,2 propanediol for various periods either at room temperature or at 4 degrees C. At room temperature survival dropped quickly, while at 4 degrees C an increase in survival was observed. It is concluded that the viability of mouse blastocyts after vitrification is dependent on the temperature and duration of equilibration in vitrification solutions.

Cytogenetic study of bovine oocytes matured in vitro.

Described in the present paper is a cytogenetic study of bovine oocytes matured in vitro. The cumulus-oocyte complexes (COC), punctured from ovaries recovered in a local slaughterhouse, were classified into 3 groups according to follicular diameter 1 to 4mm, 5 to 8mm and 9 to 13 mm. Metaphases available for observation were classified as metaphase I, haploid and diploid metaphase II. High levels of haploid metaphases II (90.6, 86.9 and 94.4 %) among the 3 groups of follicular sizes indicated successful meiotic resumption during in vitro maturation and suggested that cytoplasmic maturation may be responsible for low developmental rate after IVM, IVF and in vitro development (IVD).

Assessment of nuclear totipotency of fetal bovine diploid germ cells by nuclear transfer.

Nuclear transfer was used to study nuclear reprogramming of fetal diploid bovine germ cells collected at two stages of the fetal development. In the first case, germ cells of both sexes were collected during their period of intragonadal mitotic multiplication at 48 days post coïtum (d.p.c.). In the second case, only male germ cells were collected after this period, between 105 and 185 d.p.c. Isolated germ cells were fused with enucleated oocytes. Reconstituted embryos were cultured in vitro and those reaching the compacted morula or blastocyst stage were transferred into synchronous recipient heifers. Of 511 reconstituted embryos with 48 d.p.c. germ cells (309 males and 202 females), 48% (247/511 ) cleaved; 2.7% (14/511 ) reached the compacted morula stage and 8 of them the blastocyst stage (1.6%). No difference was observed between sexes. All 14 compacted morulae/blastocysts were transferred into 6 recipients and one pregnancy was initiated. This recipient was slaughtered at Day 35 and an abnormal conceptus (extended trophectoderm and degenerated embryo) was collected. Its male sex, genetically determined, corresponded to that of donor fetus. Of 380 reconstituted embryos with male 105 to 185 d.p.c. germ cells, 72.1% (274/380 ) cleaved, 2.1% (8 380 ) reached the compact morula stage and 7 of these the blastocyst stage (1.8%). Three blastocysts and one morula were transferred into 4 recipients. Two became pregnant at Day 21 but only one at Day 35 which aborted around Day 40. Our results show that the nucleus of diploid bovine germ cells of both sexes can be reprogrammed. However, in the absence of further development of these reconstituted embryos, nuclear totipotency of bovine diploid germ cells remains to be evidenced.

Preservation of oocyte and granulosa cell morphology in bovine preantral follicles cultured in vitro.

Described in the present paper is a culture system that preserves oocyte and granulosa cell morphology in bovine preantral follicles during 5 d in vitro. The effects of additional hypoxanthine and energy substrata (i.e., pyruvate and glutamine) on the morphology of cultured preantral follicles were investigated. It was shown that addition of a mixture of pyruvate, glutamine and hypoxantine to the culture medium increased the percentage of follicles with an intact oocyte from 29.4 to 78.6%. Morphological criteria are described to discriminate between normal and degenerated preantral follicles during culture by inverted microscopy. In addition, the importance of histological evaluation to judge the quality of oocyte and granulosa cells is demonstrated.

Development of a combined new mechanical and enzymatic method for the isolation of intact preantral follicles from fetal, calf and adult bovine ovaries.

The isolation of preantral follicles from the ovaries of bovine fetuses, calves and adult cows was performed using a simple, rapid mechanical and enzyme method. The ovaries were cut into small pieces with a tissue chopper. Then, the suspension was filtered successively through 500 and 100 mum nylon mesh filters. This simple mechanical procedure resulted in large numbers of isolated preantral follicles: 2,142 +/- 254; 512 +/- 92 and 298 +/- 54 from the ovaries of bovine fetuses, calves and cows, respectively. In addition, the ovarian fragments between 100 and 500 mum were suspended in 10 ml of M199 Hepes medium plus 5% FCS and divided into 2 equal parts: one portion was used for collagenase treatment (200 U/ml) for 20 minutes, while the other served as a control. Collagenase treatment resulted in 841 +/- 161; 216 +/- 51 and 52 +/- 17 preantral follicles from fetuses, calves and cows, respectively, compared with 312 +/- 86; 52 +/- 15 and 10 +/- 2 in the control group. The use of collagenase with ovarian fragments selected by filtration as a method for increasing the rate of recovery of preantral follicles is described here.

Viability of cloned bovine embryos after one or two cycles of nuclear transfer and in vitro culture.

We described an exclusively in vitro procedure for cloning and recloning bovine embryos. Embryos obtained by IVM/IVF/IVC developed to the morula stage were used as blastomere donors in cunjunction with IVM recipient oocytes. Reconstructed embryos were developed in vitro in co-culture using bovine oviductal epithelial cells. The resulting morulae were used as donors for recloning under the same experimental conditions. No significant difference was observed between cloning and recloning in terms of development (rates of blastocysts: 12.9 versus 14.9%), in the number of nuclei per blastocyst (63.8 versus 49.1), or in pregnancy rates (35.7 versus 33.3%). The high variability observed between replicates and the correlation between results in first and second cycle nuclear transfer may suggest an inherant potential of individual donor embryos to support development by cloning.

[Cloning using nuclear transfer in bovine species: results and perspectives]. / Le clonage par transfert de noyau dans l'espèce bovine: résultats et perspectives.

A all in vitro cloning technique was developed in which the reconstituted embryos from the first cycle nuclear transfer (cloning) were used as blastomere donor for the second cycle nuclear transfer (recloning). Such method permitted to produce 14.5% of morulae and 14.9% of blastocysts after the first and second cycles of nuclear transfer, respectively. The rates of birth obtained after transfer of such embryos were 21.4% et 20.8% for first and second cycles respectively, corresponding to 6 et 5 calves for 28 et 24 transferred embryos. Unfortunately, gestation pathologies and an increase of birth weights were observed. It seems that the in vitro presence of gametes and/or embryos may be responsible of an alteration in the control of gene expression.

[Cloning using nuclear transfer in bovine species: initial results]. / Le clonage par transfert de noyau dans l'espèce bovine: premiers résultats.

In 1987, Prather et al. have performed the first embryo cloning by nuclear transfer in the bovine species. Since, many researchers try to develop and to apply the technique. While the enucleation of the recipient oocyte, the injection of the donor blastomere and the fusion procedure are now well controlled, on the other hand, maturation and activation as the development and freezing of the cloned embryos need to be more investigated. The cloned embryo is more fragile. An increase in embryonic mortality is observed after transfer in a recipient cow.

[Genetic mechanism of human sex differentiation]. / Le déterminisme génétique de la différenciation sexuelle humaine.

The genetic mechanism controlling sexual differentiation had remained unknown for a long time. Karyotype analysis of sex-inverted patients or individuals with ambiguous sexual differentiation has enabled the localization and identification of genes involved. It is currently known that the SRY gene is responsible for the initiation of a cascade reaction leading to male differentiation of the primitive gonad. SRY is a +/- 820 base pairs gene located on the small arm of the Y chromosome, more precisely within the 1A1 alpha sub-segment. Although a few other genes are known to be involved in the downstream regulation of SRY, their precise mode of action is yet unknown.

Relationship of human follicular diameter with oocyte fertilization and development after in-vitro fertilization or intracytoplasmic sperm injection.

The aim of this work was to evaluate the relationship between follicular size at the time of oocyte retrieval, and the subsequent oocyte competence to be fertilized and to develop in vitro. All the obtained oocytes were classified according to the corresponding volume of aspirated follicular fluid. Aspirated volume of follicular fluid <2 ml corresponded to a follicular diameter <16 mm and constituted the small size group. Volume of follicular fluid from 2 to 6 ml corresponded to a diameter from 16 to 23 mm and constituted the medium size group. The large size group contained follicles with diameter >23 mm and corresponded to an aspirated volume of follicular fluid of >6 ml. A progressive and significant increase in the rates of oocytes with a first polar body was observed from the small size group to the other groups and from the medium to the large size group: 75.3, 85.9 and 95.3% respectively. After classical in-vitro fertilization (IVF), significantly better rates of fertilization and development were obtained in the medium size group compared to the two other groups. Moreover, a positive relationship was observed between follicular diameter and rates of embryos scored as 'good' when oocytes were fertilized by intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). These results demonstrated that follicular size is positively related to the oocyte ability to be fertilized and to develop. Although oocytes from small follicles gave lower percentages of development probably due to partial oocyte incompetence, they allowed an increase in the total number of embryos scored as 'good'.