Identification of a novel lipoic acid biosynthesis pathway reveals the complex evolution of lipoate assembly in prokaryotes.

Lipoic acid is an essential biomolecule found in all domains of life and is involved in central carbon metabolism and dissimilatory sulfur oxidation. The machineries for lipoate assembly in mitochondria and chloroplasts of higher eukaryotes, as well as in the apicoplasts of some protozoa, are all of prokaryotic origin. Here, we provide experimental evidence for a novel lipoate assembly pathway in bacteria based on a sLpl(AB) lipoate:protein ligase, which attaches octanoate or lipoate to apo-proteins, and 2 radical SAM proteins, LipS1 and LipS2, which work together as lipoyl synthase and insert 2 sulfur atoms. Extensive homology searches combined with genomic context analyses allowed us to precisely distinguish between the new and established pathways and map them on the tree of life. This not only revealed a much wider distribution of lipoate biogenesis systems than expected, in particular, the novel sLpl(AB)-LipS1/S2 pathway, and indicated a highly modular nature of the enzymes involved, with unforeseen combinations, but also provided a new framework for the evolution of lipoate assembly. Our results show that dedicated machineries for both de novo lipoate biogenesis and scavenging from the environment were implemented early in evolution and that their distribution in the 2 prokaryotic domains was shaped by a complex network of horizontal gene transfers, acquisition of additional genes, fusions, and losses. Our large-scale phylogenetic analyses identify the bipartite archaeal LplAB ligase as the ancestor of the bacterial sLpl(AB) proteins, which were obtained by horizontal gene transfer. LipS1/S2 have a more complex evolutionary history with multiple of such events but probably also originated in the domain archaea.

A metabolic puzzle: Consumption of C1 compounds and thiosulfate in Hyphomicrobium denitrificans XT.

Many obligately heterotrophic methylotrophs oxidize thiosulfate as an additional electron source during growth on C1 compounds. Although two different pathways of thiosulfate oxidation are implemented in Hyphomicrobium denitrificans XT, a pronounced negative effect on growth rate is observed when it is cultured in the simultaneous presence of methanol and thiosulfate. In this model organism, periplasmic thiosulfate dehydrogenase TsdA catalyzes formation of the dead-end product tetrathionate. By reverse genetics we verified the second pathway that also starts in the periplasm where SoxXA catalyzes the oxidative fusion of thiosulfate to SoxYZ, from which sulfate is released by SoxB. Sulfane sulfur is then further oxidized in the cytoplasm by the sulfur-oxidizing heterodisulfide reductase-like system (sHdr) which is produced constitutively in a strain lacking the transcriptional repressor sHdrR. When exposed to thiosulfate, the ΔshdrR strain exhibited a strongly reduced growth rate even without thiosulfate in the pre-cultures. When grown on methanol, cells exhibit significantly increased NAD+/NADH ratios in the presence of thiosulfate. In contrast, thiosulfate did not exert any negative effect on growth rate or increase NAD+ levels during growth on formate. On both C1 substrates, excretion of up to 0.5 mM sulfite as an intermediate of thiosulfate (2 mM) oxidation was recorded. Sulfite is known to form adducts with pyrroloquinoline quinone, the cofactor of periplasmic methanol dehydrogenase. We rationalize that this causes specific inhibition of methanol degradation in the presence of thiosulfate while formate metabolism in the cytoplasm remains unaffected.