Medical Malpractice in Pediatric Orthopaedics: A Systematic Review of US Case Law.

BACKGROUND: Compared with other orthopaedic subspecialties, pediatric orthopaedic surgeons are thought to be at greater risk for malpractice claims; however, there is scant research on this topic. The purpose of our study was to characterize publicly available malpractice cases pertaining to pediatric orthopaedics to determine the (1) most common specialties of the physicians implicated, (2) most common diagnoses involved, (3) rate of verdicts in favor of the plaintiff, (4) amount of indemnity payments resulting from all verdicts versus verdicts in which only an orthopaedic surgeon was involved, and (5) outcomes of cases that were appealed. METHODS: The Westlaw legal database was queried for jury verdicts, settlements, and appellate cases using the search terms "pediatric" AND "orthopaedic" from December 31, 1984, to January 1, 2016, yielding 176 appellate court cases and 189 jury reports/settlements. After excluding duplicate cases and those involving patients aged 21 years or older, 36 appellate and 84 jury reports/settlement cases remained for analysis. RESULTS: Lawsuits against orthopaedic surgeons and pediatricians were most common, in cases involving fracture diagnosis and misdiagnosis of developmental dysplasia of the hip, respectively. Of the 84 cases, 43 rulings favored the plaintiffs. The median (interquartile range) indemnity payment was $900,000 ($1.9 million), and for cases in which only the orthopaedic surgeon was named as the defendant, the median (interquartile range) indemnity payment was $675,000 ($827,000). Of the 34 appellate cases, 16 cases initially ruled in favor of the defendant were upheld and 13 were reversed/remanded. Five cases initially ruled in favor of the plaintiff were upheld, and none was reversed/remanded. CONCLUSIONS: Malpractice lawsuits named orthopaedic surgeons and pediatricians more often than physicians in other specialties. Orthopaedic surgeons were sued most often for management of fractures and pediatricians for mismanagement of developmental dysplasia of the hip. Nearly 51% of malpractice cases were ruled in favor of the plaintiff, with high indemnity payments. However, when cases that were ruled in favor of the physician were appealed, most verdicts were upheld. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV.

Walking Out of the Curve: Thoracolumbar Kyphosis in Achondroplasia.

BACKGROUND: Thoracolumbar kyphosis (TLK) is common in infants with achondroplasia. Our goals were to examine the natural history of TLK and identify factors associated with persistent TLK. METHODS: We reviewed records of patients with achondroplasia seen by a board-certified orthopaedic surgeon at a tertiary care medical center between 1997 and 2013. Inclusion criteria were minimum 2-year follow-up and radiographs taken at time of presentation, within 6 months of walking age, and within 6 months of the first anniversary of walking age. We defined TLK as kyphosis of ≥20 degrees centered at T12 and L1. We assessed patient demographic characteristics, radiographic parameters (Cobb angle, apical vertebral translation, and apical vertebral wedging for vertebral height and width), and clinical parameters (developmental motor delay, hydrocephalus, presence of a ventriculoperitoneal shunt, and foramen magnum decompression). Developmental motor delay was defined as the inability to sit or ambulate independently by age 14 or 30 months, respectively. Associations between these factors and persistent TLK (ie, unresolved at final follow-up) were evaluated using logistic regression and χ, Fisher exact, and independent t tests. Significance was set at P<0.05. RESULTS: A total of 60 patients were included. Mean values were as follows: age at presentation, 10.9±7.0 months; length of follow-up, 5.7±3.6 years; initial curve, 43.8±11.0 degrees; independent sitting age, 12.6±5.5 months; and independent walking age, 21.1±7.8 months. At walking age and 1 year after walking age, 15% and 58% of patients, respectively, had spontaneous TLK resolution. In total, 30% of patients had persistent TLK at final follow-up. Apical vertebral translation (P=0.001), percentage of apical vertebral wedging for vertebral height (P=0.031), and developmental motor delay (P=0.043) were associated with unresolved TLK. CONCLUSIONS: In patients with achondroplasia, TLK resolved at walking age in 15% of patients and after a year of walking in 58% of patients. Earlier bracing may slow TLK progression in patients with achondroplasia and developmental motor delay. Patients with kyphotic curves between 20 and 40 degrees should be examined intermittently for progressive deformity or worsening symptoms of spinal cord compression. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II.

Stress-Induced, Aseptic Osteolysis of the Mid-Tibia in a Revision Hinged Total Knee Arthroplasty Mimicking Infection.

In this report, we present the case of an 80-year-old female with pain located over the tip of her cemented tibial stem in a revision hinge total knee arthroplasty with localized osteolysis that looked suspicious for infection. A thorough workup was negative for infection. We postulate that the osteolysis at the end of her tibial stem was initiated by a modulus of elasticity mismatch at the stem tip, which generated a focal area of increased sagittal bone bending and microparticle generation. She was treated with lesional exploration, debridement, synthetic bone grafting, and tibial plating to distribute stress loads away from the tibial stem tip. Histologic analysis identified no organisms or neoplasm. Her pain ultimately resolved, and the patient returned to her customary activities.

Occlusion of an Aortobifemoral Graft after Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty.

With the aging population, the demand for total hip arthroplasty is rising. Improvements in arthroplasty techniques and design allow for total hip arthroplasty to be increasingly performed in older patients and those with multiple comorbidities. Complications are rare in young and healthy patients; however, there is greater risk in patients with multiple medical comorbidities and those who have had prior revision procedures. Large-vessel thrombosis is an especially rare, but potentially devastating, complication, particularly in patients with existing major-vessel bypass grafts. Only 3 case reports of major-vessel graft occlusion after total hip arthroplasty have been reported in the literature, and none after revision. In this article, we report a case of occlusion of an aortobifemoral graft after revision total hip arthroplasty for periprosthetic joint infection.

Predicting the need for surgical intervention prior to first encounter for individuals with shoulder complaints: a unique approach.

BACKGROUND: Increasing demand for musculoskeletal care necessitates efficient scheduling and matching of patients with the appropriate provider. However, up to 47% to 60% of orthopedic visits are made without formal triage. The purpose of this study was to develop a method to identify, prior to the initial office visit, the probability that a patient with shoulder symptoms will need surgery so that he or she can be appropriately matched with an operative or nonoperative provider. We hypothesized that patients who had an injury, previously saw an orthopedic provider, or previously underwent magnetic resonance imaging on the affected shoulder would be more likely to undergo surgery. METHODS: Drawing from expert opinion on potential risk factors (which could be identified prior to the initial office visit) for requiring operative intervention for a chief complaint of shoulder symptoms, we developed a branching-logic questionnaire that required a maximum of 7 responses from the patient during the scheduling process. We administered the questionnaire to patients calling with a chief complaint of shoulder symptoms at the time of initial appointment scheduling in a sports health network. A chart review was later completed to determine the ultimate treatment (operative vs. nonoperative) of each patient's complaint. A multivariate predictive model was then developed to determine the characteristics of patients with a higher surgical risk. RESULTS: We successfully developed a model capable of determining surgical risk from 7% to 90% based on patient sex, previous magnetic resonance imaging status, and injury status. CONCLUSIONS: Our predictive model can aid in patient clinical scheduling and ensure optimal matching of a patient with the best provider for the patient's care. Decreased wait times and appropriate matching may lead to increased patient satisfaction, superior outcomes, and more efficient use of health care resources.

Effectiveness of surgical and non-surgical management of crouch gait in cerebral palsy: A systematic review.

BACKGROUND: Cerebral palsy (CP) is a prevalent group of neuromotor disorders caused by early injury to brain regions or pathways that control movement. Patients with CP exhibit a range of functional motor disabilities and pathologic gait patterns. Crouch gait, characterized by increased knee flexion throughout stance, is a common gait pattern in CP that increases energy costs of walking and contributes to ambulatory decline. Our aim was to perform the first systematic literature review on the effectiveness of interventions utilized to ameliorate crouch gait in CP. METHODS: Comprehensive searches of five medical databases yielded 38 papers with 30 focused on orthopaedic management. RESULTS: Evidence supports the use of initial hamstring lengthenings and rectus femoris transfers, where indicated, for improving objective gait measures with limited data on improving gait speed or gross motor function. In contrast, evidence argues against hamstring transfers and revision hamstring lengthening, with recent interest in more technically demanding corrective procedures. Only eight studies evaluated alternatives to surgery, specifically strength training, botulinum toxin or orthoses, with inconsistent and/or short-lived results. CONCLUSIONS: Although crouch in CP is recognized clinically as a complex multi-joint, multi-planar gait disorder, this review largely failed to identify interventions beyond those which directly address sagittal plane knee motion, indicating a major knowledge gap. Quality of existing data was notably weak, with few studies properly controlled or adequately sized. Outcomes from specific procedures are confounded by multilevel surgeries. Successful longer term strategies to prevent worsening of crouch and subsequent functional decline are needed. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Systematic review.