Can lateral mobility be restored along a highly domesticated low-energy gravel-bed river?

Fluvial engineering works such as weirs, rip-rap, groynes, and dykes have constrained for decades and more the lateral mobility of rivers, one of the key drivers of aquatic and riparian diversity. Preserving or restoring a sufficient space for river mobility has therefore become a major river management focus. Because the success and relevance of management actions are conditioned by the level of energy and sediment supply of rivers, such actions are generally considered unsuitable for low-energy rivers. However, some low-energy rivers have numerous ancient engineering works along their length, especially bank protections, suggesting a potential capacity for bed migration. In this context, it is essential to determine to what extent planform dynamics is disturbed, and if lateral mobility can be restored. Herein, a case study was done on a 146 km stretch of the low-energy meandering gravel-bed Cher River (France). The goal of the study was to estimate the remnant shifting capacity, identify the factors controlling the location and intensity of lateral erosion, determine the potential for preserving and restoring lateral mobility, and examine management measures that could be implemented to this end. For that, field surveys, analysis of existing databases, aerial photographs, and laser imaging detection and ranging digital elevation model (LiDAR DEM) data were combined. The study revealed a strong longitudinal fragmentation of the river, with most of it laterally constrained due to the presence of anthropogenic structures such as bank protections, former gravel pits in the alluvial plain, bridges, and weirs. The river is now composed of a string of constrained and unconstrained reaches, and the space available for river shifting has been dramatically reduced. Due to these fluvial engineering works and anthropogenic legacies, the potential for lateral movement of the riverbed, and, therefore, diversification of riparian and aquatic habitats, is limited. Furthermore, lateral mobility could be preserved or restored only for very short sections of the river. It is therefore highly unlikely that good ecological status could be achieved on the entire river corridor through removal of bank protections. Nevertheless, a possible solution could be combining bank protection removals with a series of gravel augmentations close to each other.

Multi time scale influence of dams on bedload transport.

Dams are ones of the main sources of anthropogenic disturbance to the ecology and geomorphology of rivers. The aim of the present study is to understand the mechanisms underlying their influence on downstream bedload transport in three gravel-bed rivers in the Morvan massif, France. The hydrological disturbance caused by four dams is examined at a short (2.4-2.7 years) and longer (21-28 year) time scale. At the short time scale, bedload displacement was monitored (RFID) at 8 study sites around the dams. Morpho-sedimentary characterization of the bed substrate was performed at the study sites and combined with analyses of the long profile evolution and the current cross profile. The flood regime has been to a varying extent durably reduced by the dams depending on their size and purpose: the mean annual maximum flood was reduced by 9 to 40% and the number of flood events by 27 to 73.5% over the 21-28 years period. Sediment availability and loose structures were found above the dams and below medium-sized dams (<10 m) with a null or moderate influence on the flood regime (configuration I). Sediment deficit, consolidated structures, bed coarsening and vegetation encroachment were observed within 20 km downstream of large dams (>15 m) influencing strongly or moderately the flood regime (configuration II). These morpho-sedimentary features significantly affect the current bedload dynamics, creating conditions more or less favorable for the mobility of the present and incoming bedload. The cumulative mean bedload distances of RFID tracers in configuration II are significantly lower (6.8-45 m) than in configuration I (78-315 m). The current flow management of the dams has only a moderate effect on the bedload distances recorded, as shown by the mean virtual bedload velocities, which confirm the different dynamics (0.42-0.91 m/d, and 0.62-6.44 m/d, for II and I respectively). Our results demonstrate how modifications of dams on flow and bedload discharge altered the downstream morphology, but also that this inherited morphology may now be the main controlling factor of bedload transport. These findings invite further discussion about the most appropriate ways to restore rivers downstream of dams when dealing with multi-decadal inherited morphological features.

Morpho-sedimentary dynamics associated to dam removal. The Pierre Glissotte dam (central France).

The paper emphasizes the main lessons learned from hydromorphological monitoring following the removal of a medium-sized dam (7.29 m) located on a medium energy gravel bed river over a four year period (2015-2019). The Pierre Glissotte dam was previously located on the upper Yonne river (Morvan massif), where it was an obstacle to sediment continuity and was almost completely filled with sand and silts. The dam was removed in two steps, the first in July 2015 and the second in October 2017. Several methods were used (topographical surveys, SFM photogrammetry, RFID tracking, hydrological monitoring) to characterize river adjustments, i.e. the nature of the morpho-sedimentary dynamics, their rates, their temporal and spatial variations, and their control mechanisms. The results highlight the complex and nonlinear response of the Yonne river and the relevance of a regular prolonged monitoring. The changing patterns in space and over time, underline the vast range of uncertainties surrounding this type of restoration and the difficulty involved in predicting post-removal hydromorphology around the dam (return to pre-dam functioning, no changes, new equilibrium conditions). For instance, up to now, the study shows that intense morpho-sedimentary dynamics in the reservoir and effective restoration of bedload continuity do not necessarily lead to changes in the downstream conditions (bed mobility and morphological configuration) previously shaped under the influence of the dam, thus mitigating the success of the river restoration operation.

Fifty-year dynamics of the Lena River islands (Russia): Spatio-temporal pattern of large periglacial anabranching river and influence of climate change.

The Lena, a large river that drains the northern coldest region of the Northern Hemisphere, is deeply influenced by the continuous permafrost and degradation of the frozen ground has been shown to be the main cause of the marked increase in water discharge. The first objective of this study conducted on the middle Lena was to analyze the island dynamics for the last 50 years (1967 to 2017). Several morphological parameters were surveyed using a GIS on seven series of aerial photographs and satellite images of a 100 km-long reach: island size, eroded and deposited areas, position and morphology of the islands. This approach enabled the identification of evolutionary models. Our second objective was to evaluate the potential impact of ongoing climate change. We analyzed morphological parameters with respect to two main factors: efficient discharge (bar-full, bankfull and flood discharges) and water temperature. A potential erosion index (PEI) was calculated by coupling the duration of discharge exceeding the bar-full level and water temperature. The results identified several morphological changes that occurred at the end of the 20th century: an increase in the number of islands, greater eroded surfaces and accelerated migration of islands. Comparing the dynamics of islands with and without permafrost is a good indicator of their sensitivity to climate change. A major change was observed concerning the erosion and migration of islands with and without permafrost. This evolution seems to be linked both with the duration of the discharge that exceeds the bar-full level and with the number of flood peaks. The water temperature in May and August have a major influence on permafrost islands that become increasingly destabilized. Thus, as large rivers are assumed to slowly react to climate change, the recent changes in the Lena River prove that the global change deeply impacts periglacial rivers.