Allometric-kinetic model predictions of radionuclide dynamics across turtle taxa.

Chelonians (turtles, tortoises, and sea turtles; hereafter, turtles) inhabit a wide variety of ecosystems that are currently, or have the potential in the future to become, radioactively contaminated. Because they are long-lived, turtles may uniquely accumulate significant amounts of the radionuclides, especially those with long half-lives and are less environmentally mobile. Further, turtle shells are covered by scutes made of keratin. For many turtle taxa, each year, keratin grows sequentially creating annual growth rings or layers. Theoretically, analysis of these scute layers for radionuclides could provide a history of the radioactivity levels in the environment, yet there are few previously published studies focused on the dynamics of radionuclide intake in turtles. Using established biochemical and ecological principles, we developed an allometric-kinetic model to establish relationships between the radionuclide concentrations in turtles and the environment they inhabit. Specifically, we calculated Concentration Ratios (CRs - ratio of radionuclide concentration in the turtle divided by the concentration in the soil, sediment, or water) for long-lived radionuclides of uranium and plutonium for freshwater turtles, tortoises, and sea turtles. These CRs allowed prediction of environmental concentrations based on measured concentrations within turtles or vice-versa. We validated model-calculated CR values through comparison with published CR values for representative organisms, and the uncertainty in each of the model parameters was propagated through the CR calculation using Monte Carlo techniques. Results show an accuracy within a factor of three for most CR comparisons though the difference for plutonium was larger with a CR ratio of about 200 times for sea turtles, driven largely by the uncertainty of the solubility of plutonium in sea water.

Allometric-kinetic model predictions of concentration ratios for anthropogenic radionuclides across animal classes and food selection.

Protection of the environment from radiation fundamentally relies on dose assessments for non-human biota. Many of these dose assessments use measured or predicted concentrations of radionuclides in soil or water combined with Concentration Ratios (CRs) to estimate whole body concentrations in animals and plants, yet there is a paucity of CR data relative to the vast number of potential taxa and radioactive contaminants in the environment and their taxon-specific ecosystems. Because there are many taxa each having very different behaviors and biology, and there are many possible bioavailable radionuclides, CRs have the potential to vary by orders-of-magnitude, as often seen in published data. Given the diversity of taxa, the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) has selected 12 non-human biota as reference animals and plants (RAPs), while the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) uses the non-taxon specific categories of terrestrial, riparian, and aquatic animals. The question we examine here, in part, is: are these RAPs and categorizations sufficient to adequately protect all species given the broad diversity of animals in a region? To explore this question, we utilize an Allometric-Kinetic (A-K) model to calculate radionuclide-specific CRs for common animal classes, which are then further subcategorized into herbivores, omnivores, carnivores, and invertebrate detritivores. Comparisons in CRs among animal classes exhibited only small differences, but there was order of magnitude differences between herbivores, carnivores, and especially detritivores, for many radionuclides of interest. These findings suggest that the ICRP RAPs and the DOE categories are reasonable, but their accuracy could be improved by including sub-categories related to animal dietary ecology and biology. Finally, comparisons of A-K model predicted CR values to published CRs show order-of-magnitude variations, providing justification for additional studies of animal assimilation across radionuclides, environmental conditions, and animal classes.

Anthropogenic uranium signatures in turtles, tortoises, and sea turtles from nuclear sites.

Chelonians (turtles, tortoises, and sea turtles) grow scute keratin in sequential layers over time. Once formed, scute keratin acts as an inert reservoir of environmental information. For chelonians inhabiting areas with legacy or modern nuclear activities, their scute has the potential to act as a time-stamped record of radionuclide contamination in the environment. Here, we measure bulk (i.e. homogenized scute) and sequential samples of chelonian scute from the Republic of the Marshall Islands and throughout the United States of America, including at the Barry M. Goldwater Air Force Range, southwestern Utah, the Savannah River Site, and the Oak Ridge Reservation. We identify legacy uranium (235U and 236U) contamination in bulk and sequential chelonian scute that matches known nuclear histories at these locations during the 20th century. Our results confirm that chelonians bioaccumulate uranium radionuclides and do so sequentially over time. This technique provides both a time series approach for reconstructing nuclear histories from significant past and present contexts throughout the world and the ability to use chelonians for long-term environmental monitoring programs (e.g. sea turtles at Enewetok and Bikini Atolls in the Republic of the Marshall Islands and in Japan near the Fukushima Daiichi reactors).