Genetic instabilities of (CCTG).(CAGG) and (ATTCT).(AGAAT) disease-associated repeats reveal multiple pathways for repeat deletion.

The DNA repeats (CTG).(CAG), (CGG).(CCG), (GAA).(TTC), (ATTCT).(AGAAT), and (CCTG).(CAGG), undergo expansion in humans leading to neurodegenerative disease. A genetic assay for repeat instability has revealed that the activities of RecA and RecB during replication restart are involved in a high rate of deletion of (CTG).(CAG) repeats in E. coli. This assay has been applied to (CCTG).(CAGG) repeats associated with myotonic dystrophy type 2 (DM2) that expand to 11 000 copies and to spinocerebellar ataxia type 10 (SCA10) (ATTCT).(AGAAT) repeats that expand to 4500 copies in affected individuals. DM2 (CCTG).(CAGG) repeats show a moderate rate of instability, less than that observed for the myotonic dystrophy type 1 (CTG).(CAG) repeats, while the SCA10 (ATTCT).(AGAAT) repeats were remarkably stable in E. coli. In contrast to (CTG).(CAG) repeats, deletions of the DM2 and SCA10 repeats were not dependent on RecA and RecB, suggesting that replication restart may not be a predominant mechanism by which these repeats undergo deletion. These results suggest that different molecular mechanisms, or pathways, are responsible for the instability of different disease-associated DNA repeats in E. coli. These pathways involve simple replication slippage and various sister strand exchange events leading to deletions or expansions, often associated with plasmid dimerization. The differences in the mechanisms of repeat deletion may result from the differential propensity of these repeats to form various DNA secondary structures and their differential proclivity for primer-template misalignment during replication.

Chemotherapeutic deletion of CTG repeats in lymphoblast cells from DM1 patients.

Myotonic dystrophy type 1 (DM1) is caused by the expansion of a (CTG).(CAG) repeat in the DMPK gene on chromosome 19q13.3. At least 17 neurological diseases have similar genetic mutations, the expansion of DNA repeats. In most of these disorders, the disease severity is related to the length of the repeat expansion, and in DM1 the expanded repeat undergoes further elongation in somatic and germline tissues. At present, in this class of diseases, no therapeutic approach exists to prevent or slow the repeat expansion and thereby reduce disease severity or delay disease onset. We present initial results testing the hypothesis that repeat deletion may be mediated by various chemotherapeutic agents. Three lymphoblast cell lines derived from two DM1 patients treated with either ethylmethanesulfonate (EMS), mitomycin C, mitoxantrone or doxorubicin, at therapeutic concentrations, accumulated deletions following treatment. Treatment with EMS frequently prevented the repeat expansion observed during growth in culture. A significant reduction of CTG repeat length by 100-350 (CTG).(CAG) repeats often occurred in the cell population following treatment with these drugs. Potential mechanisms of drug-induced deletion are presented.

Unpaired structures in SCA10 (ATTCT)n.(AGAAT)n repeats.

A number of human hereditary diseases have been associated with the instability of DNA repeats in the genome. Recently, spinocerebellar ataxia type 10 has been associated with expansion of the pentanucleotide repeat (ATTCT)(n).(AGAAT)(n) from a normal range of ten to 22 to as many as 4500 copies. The structural properties of this repeat cloned in circular plasmids were studied by a variety of methods. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and atomic force microscopy detected local DNA unpairing in supercoiled plasmids. Chemical probing analysis indicated that, at moderate superhelical densities, the (ATTCT)(n).(AGAAT)(n) repeat forms an unpaired region, which further extends into adjacent A+T-rich flanking sequences at higher superhelical densities. The superhelical energy required to initiate duplex unpairing is essentially length-independent from eight to 46 repeats. In plasmids containing five repeats, minimal unpairing of (ATTCT)(5).(AGAAT)(5) occurred while 2D gel analysis and chemical probing indicate greater unpairing in A+T-rich sequences in other regions of the plasmid. The observed experimental results are consistent with a statistical mechanical, computational analysis of these supercoiled plasmids. For plasmids containing 29 repeats, which is just above the normal human size range, flanked by an A+T-rich sequence, atomic force microscopy detected the formation of a locally condensed structure at high superhelical densities. However, even at high superhelical densities, DNA strands within the presumably compact A+T-rich region were accessible to small chemicals and oligonucleotide hybridization. Thus, DNA strands in this "collapsed structure" remain unpaired and accessible for interaction with other molecules. The unpaired DNA structure functioned as an aberrant replication origin, in that it supported complete plasmid replication in a HeLa cell extract. A model is proposed in which unscheduled or aberrant DNA replication is a critical step in the expansion mutation.

Duplications between direct repeats stabilized by DNA secondary structure occur preferentially in the leading strand during DNA replication.

To ascertain a leading or lagging strand preference for duplication mutations, several short DNA sequences, i.e. mutation inserts, were designed that should demonstrate an asymmetric propensity for duplication mutations in the two complementary DNA strands during replication. The design of the mutation insert involved a 7-bp quasi inverted repeat that forms a remarkably stable hairpin in one DNA strand, but not the other. The inverted repeat is asymmetrically placed between flanking direct repeats. This sequence was cloned into a modified chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene containing a -1 frameshift mutation. Duplication of the mutation insert restores the reading frame of the CAT gene resulting in a chloramphenicol resistant phenotype. The mutation insert showed greater than a 200-fold preference for duplication mutations during leading strand, compared with lagging strand, replication. This result suggests that misalignment stabilized by DNA secondary structure, leading to duplication between direct repeats, occurred preferentially during leading strand synthesis.

Chemotherapeutically induced deletion of expanded triplet repeats.

The number of neurodegenerative disorders associated with the expansion of DNA repeats, currently about 18, continues to increase as additional diseases caused by this novel type of mutation are identified. Typically, expanded repeats are biased toward further expansion upon intergenerational transmission, and disease symptoms show an earlier age of onset and greater severity as the length of the triplet repeat tract increases. Most diseases exhibit progressive neurological and/or muscular degeneration that can lead to total disability and death. As yet, no treatment exists for the genetic basis of any repeat disease. Given that the severity of these diseases is related to repeat tract length, reducing repeat lengths might delay the onset and reduce disease severity. Here, we test the hypothesis that the introduction of damage into DNA, which results in subsequent repair events, can lead to an increased rate of repeat deletion. Applying a sensitive genetic assay in Escherichia coli [Mut. Res. 502 (2002) 25], we demonstrate that certain DNA damaging agents, including EMS, ENU, UV light, and anticancer agents mitomycin C, cisplatin, and X-rays increase the rate of deletion of (CTG).(CAG) repeats in a length and orientation dependent fashion. In addition, oxidative damage to DNA also increases the deletion rate of repeats. These results suggest that a chemotherapeutic approach to the reduction in triplet repeat length may provide one possible rationale to slow, stop, or reverse the progression of these diseases.

Genetic recombination destabilizes (CTG)n.(CAG)n repeats in E. coli.

The expansion of trinucleotide repeats has been implicated in 17 neurological diseases to date. Factors leading to the instability of trinucleotide repeat sequences have thus been an area of intense interest. Certain genes involved in mismatch repair, recombination, nucleotide excision repair, and replication influence the instability of trinucleotide repeats in both Escherichia coli and yeast. Using a genetic assay for repeat deletion in E. coli, the effect of mutations in the recA, recB, and lexA genes on the rate of deletion of (CTG)n.(CAG)n repeats of varying lengths were examined. The results indicate that mutations in recA and recB, which decrease the rate of recombination, had a stabilizing effect on (CAG)n.(CTG)n repeats decreasing the high rates of deletion seen in recombination proficient cells. Thus, recombination proficiency correlates with high rates of genetic instability in triplet repeats. Induction of the SOS system, however, did not appear to play a significant role in repeat instability, nor did the presence of triplet repeats in cells turn on the SOS response. A model is suggested where deletion during exponential growth may result from attempts to restart replication when paused at triplet repeats.

Genetic assays for measuring rates of (CAG).(CTG) repeat instability in Escherichia coli.

Genetic selection assays were developed to measure rates of deletion of one or more (CAG).(CTG) repeats, or an entire repeat tract, in Escherichia coli. In-frame insertions of >or=25 repeats in the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene of pBR325 resulted in a chloramphenicol-sensitive (Cm(s)) phenotype. When (CAG)25 comprised the leading template strand, deletion of one or more repeats resulted in a chloramphenicol resistant (Cm(r)) phenotype at a rate of 4 x 10(-2) revertants per cell per generation. The mutation rates for plasmids containing (CAG)43 or (CAG)79 decreased significantly. When (CTG)n comprised the leading template strand the Cm(r) mutation rates were 100-1000 lower than for the opposite orientation. As an initial application of this assay, the effects of mutations influencing mismatch repair and recombination were examined. The methyl directed mismatch repair system increased repeat stability only when (CTG)n comprised the leading template strand. Replication errors made with the opposite repeat orientation were apparently not recognized. For the (CAG)n leading strand orientation, mutation rates were reduced as much as 3000-fold in a recA- strain. In a second assay, out-of-frame mutation inserts underwent complete deletion at rates ranging from about 5 x 10(-9) to 1 x 10(-7) per cell per generation. These assays allow careful quantitation of triplet repeat instability in E. coli and provide a way to examine the effects of mutations in replication, repair, and recombination on repeat instability.

Instability of repeated DNAs during transformation in Escherichia coli.

Escherichia coli has provided an important model system for understanding the molecular basis for genetic instabilities associated with repeated DNA. Changes in triplet repeat length during growth following transformation in E. coli have been used as a measure of repeat instability. However, very little is known about the molecular and biological changes that may occur on transformation. Since only a small proportion of viable cells become competent, uncertainty exists regarding the nature of these transformed cells. To establish whether the process of transformation can be inherently mutagenic for certain DNA sequences, we used a genetic assay in E. coli to compare the frequency of genetic instabilities associated with transformation with those occurring in plasmid maintained in E. coli. Our results indicate that, for certain DNA sequences, bacterial transformation can be highly mutagenic. The deletion frequency of a 106 bp perfect inverted repeat is increased by as much as a factor of 2 x 10(5) following transformation. The high frequency of instability was not observed when cells stably harboring plasmid were rendered competent. Thus, the process of transformation was required to observe the instability. Instabilities of (CAG).(CTG) repeats are also dramatically elevated upon transformation. The magnitude of the instability is dependent on the nature and length of the repeat. Differences in the methylation status of plasmid used for transformation and the methylation and restriction/modification systems present in the bacterial strain used must also be considered in repeat instability measurements. Moreover, different E. coli genetic backgrounds show different levels of instability during transformation.